French court to rule on surgeon who abused children for decades
Joel Le Scouarnec, 74, is already in prison after being sentenced in 2020 to 15 years for raping and sexually assaulting four children, including two of his nieces.
In this trial, which began in February, he has admitted sexually assaulting or raping 299 patients -- 256 of them under 15 -- in hospitals in western France between 1989 and 2014, many while they were under anaesthesia or waking up after operations.
Le Scouarnec is charged with 111 rapes and 189 sexual assaults and is set to emerge as one of the most prolific convicted sex predators in France's history.
The victims have been represented by around 60 lawyers.
"I hope the verdict will be commensurate with the horrors he committed," Amelie Leveque, one of the victims, told AFP.
"But I don't believe it very much."
Victims and child rights advocates say the surgeon's case highlights systemic shortcomings that allowed Le Scouarnec to repeatedly commit sexual crimes.
Prosecutor Stephane Kellenberger has requested the maximum 20-year sentence for the retired surgeon and also made the rare demand that he should be held in a centre for treatment and supervision even after any release due to his "dangerousness".
In France, sentences are not added together, unlike in the United States where Le Scouarnec would have been jailed for "2,000 years", said the prosecutor.
- 'Major pervert' -
"I am not asking the court for leniency," Le Scouarnec said in his closing statement in Vannes in the western region of Brittany on Monday.
"Simply grant me the right to become a better person," he said.
The verdict, which will be handed down by presiding judge Aude Buresi, is expected to be announced from 2:30 pm (1230 GMT).
One of the lawyers, Maxime Tessier, has asked the court to take into account the "exceptional" nature of Le Scouarnec's confession when he admitted all the charges against him in March.
The retired surgeon also said he considered himself "responsible" for the death of two of his victims -- Mathis Vinet, who died after an overdose in 2021 in what his family says was suicide, and another man who was found dead in 2020.
Le Scouarnec documented his crimes, noting his victims' names, ages, addresses and the nature of the abuse.
In his notes, the doctor described himself as a "major pervert" and a "paedophile".
"And I am very happy about it," he recorded.
- 'Never again' -
While Le Scouarnec has asked his victims for forgiveness, many of them have questioned the sincerity of his apologies, which he repeated almost mechanically over the weeks of the trial, sometimes word for word.
"You are the worst mass paedophile who ever lived," said one of the lawyers representing the victims, Thomas Delaby, describing Le Scouarnec as an "atomic bomb of paedophilia".
The victims "will never forgive you. Never," Delaby told the defendant.
"Who are you trying to convince that you've changed?" said another lawyer, Delphine Caro.
"Admitting everything is admitting nothing," added a third lawyer, Giovanni Bertho-Briand.
The surgeon practised for decades until his retirement in 2017 despite a 2005 sentence for owning sexually abusive images of children and colleagues raising their concerns.
Le Scouarnec might stand trial again in the future, the public prosecutor said.
Prosecutors opened two investigations, one of which concerns unidentified or newly reported victims of Le Scouarnec.
There has been frustration among some that the trial has not had the impact in France they hoped for.
The case has not won the attention given to the case of Dominique Pelicot, who was jailed last year for recruiting dozens of strangers to rape his now ex-wife Gisele.
But Health Minister Yannick Neuder said on Wednesday he would work with Justice Minister Gerald Darmanin to ensure that "never again will we find ourselves in a situation where patients and vulnerable children" are exposed to predators.
A collective of the survivors is set to meet with Neuder in June.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
7 hours ago
- ABC News
Jury in Matt Wright trial hears celebrity croc wrangler told injured pilot to 'delete, delete, delete' items from phone
The jury in the Northern Territory Supreme Court trial of Matt Wright has heard the celebrity crocodile wrangler told an injured pilot to "delete, delete, delete" items off his mobile phone during a visit to his hospital room following the crash. Family members of helicopter pilot Sebastian Robinson and a property caretaker gave evidence at the celebrity crocodile wrangler's trial on Tuesday. Mr Wright has pleaded not guilty to three counts of attempting to pervert the course of justice following a fatal chopper crash in remote Arnhem Land on February 28, 2022. Mr Wright's close friend and co-star Chris "Willow" Wilson was killed in the accident and Mr Robinson, the pilot, was seriously injured. The charges against Mr Wright relate to events that allegedly took place in the days, weeks and months after the accident. If you missed yesterday's live coverage of the trial, catch up here. To stay up to date with this story, subscribe to ABC News.
ABC News
8 hours ago
- ABC News
Police compiling hundreds of documents in case against Pheobe Bishop's accused murderers
The police brief of evidence for the case against the alleged murderers of 17-year-old Pheobe Bishop will include 155 exhibits, a court has been told. Tanika Bromley, 33, and James Wood, 34, are each charged with murder and interfering with a corpse. The pair did not appear when their matters were mentioned in the Bundaberg Magistrates Court on Tuesday. Pheobe went missing from Bundaberg in May, having failed to check in for a flight to Brisbane. Her disappearance sparked a major search and police found her remains in bushland in early June. Prosecutor Vicki Kennedy-Grills told the court police officers had been working "at length" to gather the brief of evidence, which included 135 statements. The brief will also include CCTV footage, telephone and message data, photographs and post-mortem documents. Sergeant Kennedy-Grills said there were delays preparing the brief as officers waited for DNA testing and a ballistics report and worked through the "sheer volume" of material and "multiple crime scenes". Pheobe's family was in court and protested when Ms Bromley's defence lawyer Nick Larter proposed adjourning the matters to October 27. That is the date of Pheobe's 18th birthday. The court heard her family would be unavailable on the day. The two cases have been adjourned until November 3. Ms Bromley and Mr Wood remain in custody.
News.com.au
9 hours ago
- News.com.au
Sex workers punched, hit, attacked in ‘appalling, violent' ordeal after refusing man's sexual advances
A man's violent assaults against two sex workers – who were hit in the face, punched and thrown into walls, all because they refused his sexual advances – has been laid bare in court. Dumitru Sebastian Erimescu walked free from Brisbane District Court on a suspended sentence more than a year after the horror ordeal, which unfolded after a drunken night out in Fortitude Valley when he invited two strip club workers back to his home. The 'appalling and terrible' affair earned the scorn of Judge Nicholas Andreatidis KC, who said Erimescu was 'fortunate' he was not going to jail. 'Do not underestimate just how lucky you are that you are not actually going to prison today,' Judge Andreatidis said on Tuesday. 'Next time you go drinking, stop. 'Stop before you get to that point you can't control yourself. Drinking is not an excuse for any level of misconduct, let alone this type of violence.' Erimescu was initially facing more serious charges of deprivation of liberty and torture, but these did not proceed to his sentencing. Instead, he pleaded guilty on Tuesday morning to five counts of common assault and one count of assault occasioning actual bodily harm. The court was told Erimescu, 27, had been out drinking at the Love & Rockets strip club on October 15, 2023, where he asked one of the 21-year-old dancers to come home with him for $2000. She declined, but later agreed while saying she 'couldn't do anything she wouldn't do at the club'. Crown prosecutor Rebecca Guppy-Coles said Erimescu transferred the 21-year-old $3500 while waiting for an Uber. Another sex worker, 28, also agreed to go back to Erimescu's home but both women indicated no sexual intercourse would occur. The court was told he behaved sexually towards the first complainant under the belief he had paid for sex. Ms Guppy-Coles said both women decided to leave, but Erimescu insisted he had 'paid for the transaction' and offered more money. Erimescu then assaulted both women – slapping and punching them, grabbing them in the neck and chest area, pushing one back into a walk-in wardrobe and another into a wall. 'Both complainants tried to push him away,' Ms Guppy-Coles said. Erimescu demanded his money back and at one point took one of the women's licences, but she was able to get it back. He later apologised and both women were allowed to leave. Ms Guppy-Coles said both women suffered some serious injuries – one being left with a fractured eye socket. 'It was unprovoked, it was an attack on two vulnerable complainants … fortunately for the defendant they escaped without permanent injuries,' she said. Neither of the victims attended court. Erimescu's offending was described as a complete departure from his otherwise good character and an 'isolated aberration'. Defence barrister Matthew Hynes said his client had lost his trucking business as a result of the charges being laid and subsequent media reporting of the torture charges before they were dropped. 'The torture charges which were initially brought by police, would never have withstood scrutiny,' Mr Hynes said. Numerous supporters joined Erimescu in court, including his sister who had delayed her wedding to support him. Character references – including some from his former partners – were submitted on his behalf. Mr Hynes said Erimescu had prepared a letter of apology and offered compensation to the victims. Judge Andreatidis ultimately imposed a wholly suspended sentence of 19 months, accepting the offending was out of character for Erimescu. He took into account Erimescu's lack of criminal history, his remorse and the stress the delay in the case sentencing had caused him. Erimescu was ordered to pay $3500 in compensation to the victims.
