Watchdog objects to demolition of building for student flats
The application has been lodged with the City of Edinburgh Council.
The Cockburn Association, the city's heritage watchdog, has submitted an objection on the grounds it 'appears to fail to comply with key policies'.
The association said: 'While the site is appropriate for redevelopment in principle, the proposal's excessive scale, poor design quality, and loss of distinctive existing buildings raise serious concerns.
'The five-storey frontage block is too tall for its context, and the overall massing, especially in conjunction with adjacent proposals, risks overwhelming the surrounding townscape and conservation areas.
'The design lacks architectural distinction and fails to respond meaningfully to its setting. Internally, the proposed rooms require careful assessment with respect to daylighting standards, and external amenity space is limited and heavily overshadowed.'
READ MORE:
The developer's statement currently being considered by planners said: 'A Heritage Statement is included as part of this application, for which an in-depth assessment of the existing buildings can be found.
'The building on Ratcliffe Terrace is the former Causewayside Lads Institute and has been assessed to be of low importance.
'A report of valuation was also commissioned by the client which concludes that the building is in poor condition with a market value of nil in the current market, and therefore unsuitable for a loan in its current condition.'
It added: 'The report concludes that the state of repair is very poor, both internally and externally, including brickwork, windows and roof. There is also structural cracking on the south elevation.
'In terms of marketability, the report states that there is very limited demand in the location for the use class of property, with excessive capital expenditure required and extended marketing period to secure a purchaser.'
A council archaeologist said: "The site occurs on the one of the main medieval routes into Edinburgh's medieval town from the South via Liberton and entering Edinburgh via the medieval Portsburgh suburb and Bristo Port.
"This area began to be developed during the 18th century with Kirkwood's 1817 map showing the site occupied by a Georgian property owned by a Mr Christie. This building survives into the fourth quarter of the 19th century when it is replaced by what appear to be small workshops/ industrial units coinciding with the expansion of Victorian industry."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
2 days ago
- Scotsman
Inside the Scottish auction of rare treasures, from a Culloden cannonball to £12,000 frock
Every year, the Scotland Collected auction at Lyon & Turnbull offers buyers the chance to own some of the country's finest treasure. This year is no exception. On August 20 and 21, with a public viewing at their 33 Broughton Place premises from August 17 to 20, they'll be selling over 700 incredible lots. You could end up being the proud owner of, among many other things, an Edwardian sporran, a Victorian style antler settee, a Flying Scotsman train set, a bust of Robert Louis Stevenson, or a bottle of rare whisky. We spoke to head of sales John Mackie, and a few of the other specialists, about the forthcoming sale. Are the Scotland Collected auctions especially popular? As Scotland's oldest auctioneers, we are proud to hold our annual Scotland Collected auctions. This sale attracts buyers from all over the world, particularly those with Scottish lineage or those with an interest in our history and its craft. Are your buyers usually from abroad, or from here in Scotland? We have a mix of collectors, those who are based in the UK and those in countries like the USA, Canada and Australia with a strong Scottish connection. However, it is always surprising to see what wide and varied quarters the bidders come from. What particularly interesting lots do you have in the sale? Following on from the record-breaking Cairncross Collection auction in August 2025, we are excited to announce the largest private collection of Scottish freshwater pearl jewellery ever to come to market. Carefully collected over a number of years with the assistance of Cairncross of Perth, this collection was amassed by a private connoisseur who hopes their enthusiasm can now be passed on to a new generation of collectors. It is a remarkable opportunity to see, not only a comprehensive record of the renowned Perthshire jewellers designs celebrating the flora of Scotland, including designs rarely found at auction, such as the Timorous Beasties' brooch and a horse-chestnut design; but also a vast array of of Scottish freshwater pearls, showcasing the wide range of colours, shapes and lustres this magical Scottish gem can take. This year's auction is particularly varied with a range of Wemyss Ware, provincial and Scottish silverware, hardstone jewellery, Jacobite works of art and collections formed by individuals and families over many years. It also includes one of the largest collections of Scottish pistols to come to the open market in perhaps decades. These and other weapons link closely to the nation's turbulent past but are made with such quality they are works of art in their own right. These connect in with our wider Jacobite section which is always a very popular area to collectors. The collection spans early 17th century examples, which are extremely rare, to the iconic silver and steel Doune pistols. We are also delighted to present a collection from the former Earls of Airlie - a lineage stretching to Robert the Bruce and King James VI of Scotland and II of England. The Ogilvy family was established with lands in Angus as early as the 15th century, with Airlie Castle's foundations laid in 1432. For successive centuries, they have always had a close relationship to the monarchy; raising armies during the Jacobite rebellions to more recently, Lord Ogilvy 13th (8th) Earl of Airlie (1926-2023), who, acting as Lord Chamberlain to Queen Elizabeth II, saw him oversee many significant Royal events. Which items do you expect to do particularly well? A wonderful lot in the sale is a dress worn by Lady Margaret Ogilvy, the Countess of Airlie, which reputedly was worn when she was a guest at Holyrood Palace in 1745, where Bonnie Prince Charlie was in attendance. Lady Ogilvy and her husband, David Ogilvy, 6th Earl of Airlie, were prominent Jacobites and supporters of Bonnie Prince Charlie in Scotland. Eighteenth-century Scottish clothing with provenance is rare, but to have a piece connected to such a remarkable original owner, and one who may even have danced with the Prince himself, sets the imagination alight. Do the staff have any personal favourites? Kier Alexander, silver specialist: 'We usually offer a fine selection of work by the Scottish silversmith Graham Stewart,and this year is no exception, featuring his iconic honeycomb candlesticks, a beautifully engraved bowl, and a remarkably large centrepiece.' John Mackie, head of sales: 'At this time of year with the countryside in full abundance just looking at a hedgerow with its dog roses, buttercups and other wildflowers reminds me of the myriad patterns that inspired the well-known and collectable Fife pottery Wemyss Ware. Personally, I am very fond of the small pigs that the factory produced from the late 19th century onwards – the early examples are well-modelled and their slightly bewildered expressions are very engaging!' Colin Fraser, specialist: 'It has to be the 18th century invalid feeder, made by Hugh Clark of Perth. Not only is he a particularly rare maker, but invalid cups are seldom seen. This appears to be the only known example from Perth. Although it looks just like a rather odd cream jug this would have been essential to making sure a patient received food and most likely medicine from their carer.' Anything that's particularly rare? Colin Fraser: 'Rare items include a cannonball recovered from the battlefield of Culloden which is a wonderful example of a Scottish relic with an incredible story and provenance back to a family closely connected with the cause. Having been in an exhibition previously this is the first time it has ever been offered for sale.' Any items that are very collectable? Wemyss Ware was developed in the late 19th century as a more sophisticated, decorated range to complement the standard transfer-printed and other wares produced at the Fife Pottery. In many ways Wemyss is perfect for collectors, with its myriad range of patterns and shapes, each hand-painted by a particular artist and, by and large, identified by a maker's mark. It is an instantly recognisable aesthetic: the brightly coloured decoration on a stark white background, drawing inspiration from the Fife countryside. For more information, see
Scotsman
2 days ago
- Scotsman
Dundee named in top 2 UK cities with the quickest home sales, according to new study
Selling your home can feel like a waiting game and often a frustrating one. But where you live in the UK can make all the difference in how long your property sits on the market. Factors like local demand, population growth, commuter connections and housing stock all play a part in how quickly that 'for sale' sign turns into 'sold'. But have you ever wondered which UK cities are seeing homes snapped up at lightning speed in 2025? From gorgeous Georgian town houses to jaw-dropping penthouses, converted campervans to bargain boltholes. Take a peek at the finest homes across the UK. Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... A new study by has analysed housing data across 100 towns and cities in the UK to reveal where homes are selling the fastest. The findings shed light on some expected hotspots, but also a few under-the-radar surprises. To rank the cities, the study focused on median selling times: the number of days it typically takes for a property to go under offer once listed. Unlike average (mean) times, which can be skewed by a few sluggish sales, the median offers a more realistic snapshot of what sellers can expect. Still, the study also looked at mean selling times to highlight how consistent (or inconsistent) each market really is. The data was sourced from Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Dundee ranks in second place, with a median of 18 days and a mean of 44. This relatively narrow gap between median and mean suggests that homes across the board, not just the best-kept or most centrally located, are selling swiftly. With its ongoing regeneration projects and growing reputation as a cultural and tech hub, Dundee's property appeal is clearly on the rise. Dundee named in top 2 UK cities with the quickest home sales Meanwhile, Glasgow takes the crown with a median selling time of just 14 days and a mean of 37, the fastest in the UK. Edinburgh claims third place with a median of 24 days, though its mean time of 95 days shows more market variability. Belfast is next in fourth, where homes typically go under offer in 28 days and average out at 82. Newcastle follows closely in fifth, boasting a 30-day median and a 75-day mean. Sheffield ranks sixth, where homes take a median of 31 days and mean of 69 to sell. In seventh place, Redditch, Stockport, and Sunderland all tie with a 33-day median. Their mean selling times differ: 90 for Redditch, 73 for Stockport, and 78 for Sunderland. Crawley and Warrington complete the top ten in joint tenth, each with a 34-day median and mean times of 72 and 71 respectively. While the top ten may be speeding through house sales, not every city is quite so brisk. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Leeds, for instance, came in 25th with a median of 40 days and a mean of 98. Bristol and Derby tied in 30th place with a median of 41 days; Bristol's mean is 76, while Derby is slightly slower at 80. Liverpool landed in 44th with a median of 46 days, and Birmingham came in 48th at 47 days. York ranked 63rd (51 days), and Nottingham was 70th (53 days). Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Even London, with all its market activity, lagged in 84th with a median of 59 days, proof that a busy market doesn't always mean a fast one. At the other end of the table, Slough was the slowest of them all, with a median selling time of 81 days. Brentwood, Canterbury, Worthing, and Bournemouth rounded out the bottom five, all taking between 64 and 77 days. Whether it's higher prices, more selective buyers, or just local market quirks, selling a home there requires a bit more patience. Top 20 list of UK cities with the fastest home sales in 2025:
Scotsman
3 days ago
- Scotsman
New homes released at East Lothian's Longniddry Village
Cruden is offering a limited-time package of huge savings on the apartments with £5,000 cashback and a further £5,000 options voucher to make a new house at Longniddry a dream home. From gorgeous Georgian town houses to jaw-dropping penthouses, converted campervans to bargain boltholes. Take a peek at the finest homes across the UK. Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to Edinburgh News, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Five-star Scottish housebuilder Cruden Homes has released more homes for sale at its multi-award-winning Longniddry Village development in East Lothian with prices from £290,000. The latest release is across five plots, namely three two-bedroom apartments, available to move in from November and two four-bedroom properties which will be complete by early 2026. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad To further entice buyers, Cruden is offering a limited-time package of huge savings on the apartments with £5,000 cashback and a further £5,000 options voucher to make a new house at Longniddry a dream home. Longniddry Village development in East Lothian Longniddry Village takes inspiration from the characterful architecture and appeal of quaint East Lothian villages and towns. Its local vernacular and carefully considered landscape design seamlessly extends into the existing vibrant village community. The traditionally inspired architecture includes period-style features such as sash windows, chimneys and high ceilings. Meanwhile, the interior accommodation is spacious and airy, complete with high-quality fixtures and fittings that include designer German kitchens with integrated Siemens appliances, built-in wardrobes, stylish bathrooms and fibre broadband. When complete, the development will include several features for residents to enjoy, including a play park, sports pitch, restored mill pond and wildflower meadow. New owners will also benefit from the neighbouring steadings restoration, which will be a hub for several amenities including an independent coffee outlet, a luxury convenience store and salon. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Hazel Davies, Sales and Marketing Director of Cruden Homes, said:'It's great to extend the new home options available to discerning buyers at our Longniddry Village development, whether they're taking their first step on the property ladder or looking for more space to grow. The added incentives for our range of apartments make now the perfect time to move. Cruden's multi-award-winning Longniddry Village development in East Lothian 'This has been an incredibly popular development, with previous launches selling out ahead of plan. We would advise potential home buyers to book a viewing as soon as possible to avoid disappointment."
