Kilkenny boss claims Munster final conclusion was unfair
Kilkenny's reward for a sixth Leinster hurling title in a row is a likely semi-final with Limerick – but Derek Lyng felt sympathy for the vanquished Munster giants after what he felt was an unfair end to the game.
Lyng's team overcame Galway in Croke Park on Sunday, winning by eight points in front of 37,503 spectators.
A largely subdued affair was in complete contrast to the drama that played out in Limerick the night before, when Cork won on penalties after extra time. Kilkenny manager Derek Lyng reacts during the GAA Hurling All-Ireland Senior Championship final match between Kilkenny and Limerick at Croke Park in Dublin. Pic: Brendan Moran/Sportsfile
The net result is a place in the quarter-finals for Limerick, and they will be unbackable favourites to win that, against one of Dublin and Kildare.
That would set them against Lyng's men in the last four. And the victorious Kilkenny manager suggested that a fairer way of deciding the match would have been a replay.
'I think it's hard on players,' he said of the penalty shoot-out.
'I know we have a new system in place and we're kind of caught for time but I just think we're a bit too caught at the minute.
'It made for a great spectacle, but I think to be fair to players, the replay would have been more fair to them.' 7 June 2025; Cork captain Robert Downey lifts the Mick Mackey Cup after his side' victory in the Munster GAA Hurling Senior Championship final match between Limerick and Cork at LIT Gaelic Grounds in Limerick. Photo by Piaras Ó Mídheach/Sportsfile
Limerick will be expected to put aside that disappointment and prevail not only against the winners of Dublin and Kildare, but also Kilkenny in a semi-final.
And the tepid nature of much of yesterday's Leinster decider in contrast to the pyrotechnics in the Gaelic Grounds will do nothing to temper that belief.
Lyng, though, was adamant that his players have been tested properly ahead of the expected challenge to come.
'I think it's probably taken for granted that we're going to go win these games, but a huge amount of work goes into it, particularly from the players,' he said. Walter Walsh in action for Kilkenny. Pic: Piaras Ó Mídheach/Sportsfile
'We lost to Wexford, and against Dublin we would have been disappointed with a spell in that game as well, and likewise today, so, regardless of who we were playing, we know we're going to have to find another gear or two for the next day, and that's the reality of it.'
Galway, meanwhile, look certain to face Tipperary in a last-eight tie with the Premier County facing Laois in a preliminary quarter-final before then.
Micheál Donoghue denied that the job facing him on his return to Galway is bigger than anticipated after a desperately flat display in which his side went 36 minutes without a score from play. 19 August 2018; Galway manager Micheál Donoghue and Joe Canning of Galway following the GAA Hurling All-Ireland Senior Championship Final match between Galway and Limerick at Croke Park in Dublin. Photo by Brendan Moran/Sportsfile
Donoghue feels they are not as far behind the leading teams as many believe.
'No, I wouldn't say it's a bigger job,' he said.
'Obviously, the disappointment of today and I suppose the narrative will be that it's probably similar to previous years and previous teams.
'But look, we know what we have in the squad and we'll try and take the positives out of it as we move forward.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
6 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Horan on Armagh's need to go full bore: The most dangerous thing is to ease off
Despite already securing a quarter-final spot, Armagh will approach their upcoming Sam Maguire series tie against Galway with full intent, according to former Mayo manager James Horan. The All-Ireland champions have already topped Group 4 ahead of their fixture at Kingspan Breffni this Saturday. Remarkably, it is the third consecutive year that Armagh have finished top of their group. In 2023 and 2024, the team who finished one place behind them was Galway. Speaking on the Irish Examiner's Gaelic football podcast, Horan said Kieran McGeeney's side will target another win to set them up for their trip to Croke Park in two weeks. 'There is no such thing as a game meaning nothing at this time of the year,' he said. 'In terms of development and growth, that is where Armagh are. Every game, we have talked about their consistency. Armagh I don't think will change a thing. They have momentum and their belief set is based on hard work and a way of playing. 'They have been doing that for years and years. Look at how much they've grown already. Do you think because they have qualified already, they are going to give away that initiative and momentum by dropping down the gears? It is not in their psyche.' Horan cited the example of Donegal, who started the National League with three victories in a row before winning one of their final four games. The Ulster champions now must defeat Mayo in their final Group 2 game and hope Tyrone lose out to Cavan. 'It is the most dangerous thing you can do as a manager. I think Donegal are trying to chase that momentum since the third round of the league. They started so well, this force of nature coming at us. I think it is such a dangerous strategy. 'I don't see them doing anything different. Maybe they will try one or two other players. They might test one different thing on the field, but ultimately it will be the Armagh we know and expect. There will be nothing easy.' Meanwhile, despite the recent drama, Horan believes the GAA are right to change the All-Ireland senior football championship format. A new format will be in place next season with the group phase abolished and replaced by a qualifier-style series. 'It is classic recency bias. This year it is brilliant, every group has something to play for and this weekend has so much to play for. All people want is a bit of drama where anything can happen,' he said. 'It is great this year. Everything seems to be working right this year, with rules and everything else. It is all combining and working out ok. Should we get rid of it? If you take this year on its own, you would say no but what were we saying this time last year or the year before that? Too many games etc. Overall, the sample size of one year isn't enough to make a decision. Changing it might be the right play.'
Irish Examiner
7 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Huw Lawlor: TJ Reid's attitude and professionalism an example for Kilkenny players
Huw Lawlor has hailed the longevity of TJ Reid as the 37-year-old claimed his 14th Leinster SHC medal on Sunday. The seven-time All-Ireland winner and seven-time All Star was only second to Lawlor as Kilkenny's best player in the victory over Galway and the defender was generous in his praise for the elder stateman of the team. 'Sure, he's a class apart, you know what I mean? You can forget about his age or whatever. The example he sets there in terms of work-rate and stuff like that, it's phenomenal, so it is. 'He's such a professional in terms of the way he sets up and the way he goes at it. He's a super player, his attitude and his work rate is top class, and I think that's what drives it on for him.' Two-time All Star Lawlor himself is playing some of the best hurling of his career as much as he is keen to play it down. 'Look, that kind of thing comes in fits and starts, I suppose. You can go through in form and out of form and stuff. 'We're just trying to get through the 70 minutes in the full-back line and try and stop them scoring, and if we can set up our own scores as well, then we'll be happy enough.' It might have seemed like a fade-out by Kilkenny but Lawlor had anticipated Galway would have a period of dominance and it manifested itself in an unanswered 1-6 towards the end of the game before The Cats settled themselves to seal the win. 'I suppose for that 55 minutes we probably choked the game and we controlled it well. Look, they were always going to get a purple patch at some stage and we were trying to limit that, but I thought the boys worked very hard all throughout. 'It's something that's happened to us before and we probably need to manage the game a little bit better from that point of view. But look, we got the scores and we got the kind of few interceptions that we needed to get over the line there.' You won't hear the 29-year-old complaining about the four-week gap to their July 6 All-Ireland semi-final being too long. 'Four weeks now to get the bodies right and get loads of training in. It's been a very busy six, seven, eight weeks there so it's a good chance to get training and for different lads to try get on to the team.'
Irish Examiner
7 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Shane Kingston and Conor Lehane 'representing Cork the best way they know how'
'I suppose it's nothing I'm not used to at this stage,' offered Shane Kingston with a wry smile about trying to make an impact from the bench as he did on Saturday. Three points and a goal in the penalty shoot-out was fair clipping as was Conor Lehane's brace, the free he won that Darragh Fitzgibbon sent over in extra-time and of course one of the other two penalties converted by Cork. The pair continue to pack a punch as much as they have both had a quiet season up to the Munster final. A pulled hamstring impacted Kingston's starting chances last year. His galivanting solo earned Patrick Horgan the game-changing penalty goal against Limerick in Cork 13 months ago. He picked off two points from the bench in the All-Ireland final but had been brought on and replaced in the semi-final. This year, his ailment has been a groin issue whereas a dislocated shoulder in February's Division 1A draw with Limerick stopped Lehane in his tracks. Recalled to the panel in 2023, he might not be as acquainted with the cameo role as much as Kingston but is growing into it. 'Sure look, that's the nature of the game. You wouldn't be involved unless you didn't know that going into it. I have no issue. With the talent that's there, representing Cork the best way they know how. "They've done themselves justice numerous times. It's healthy competition.' Kingston's contribution had shades of his seven points coming off the bench against Kilkenny in the 2021 All-Ireland semi-final. "I was actually wearing the same number (23), so it's becoming a bit of a thing now. 'Any day you're not in the starting 15 is obviously disappointing. The management put out their best team on any given day, so you just have to stop feeling sorry for yourself and focus on getting the best out of yourself if you're fortunate to be called upon. 'It's just about coming on and running relentlessly, hoping you get on that ball. For the first five, 10 minutes I didn't touch anything and then I got a ball in from Robbie [O'Flynn] and I just said I'd take it on because the boys were after playing 65, 70 minutes so I knew they'd be tired." Cork 's Eoin Downey and Conor Lehane celebrate after the penalty shoot out against Limerick. Pic: Eddie O'Hare. Kingston's penalty hit wasn't the cleanest. But for it taking an unusual bounce in front of Nickie Quaid, it mightn't have passed the Limerick goalkeeper. 'It was a bad strike too but it went in, so I was lucky,' admitted the Douglas man. "I think Pat came up to me and said, 'Do you want to hit one?' and I said, 'Yeah, absolutely.' Obviously, the confidence was high so I just said I had nothing to lose so I just drove on. From then on, I was just thinking I was going to score and that was kind of it, really. 'I suppose if I wasn't playing well I probably would have been a bit more hesitant hitting it. But confidence was high at the time. As soon as I knew I was hitting one, I just focused on scoring it. I just got the pick and it went in then." Lehane sure felt the tension as he stood up to his strike. 'You'd rather not be in too many of those situations. But when it comes out the better end for you, it's the best feeling in the world. Hopefully it's the last I'll ever do as well. "It was nerve-wracking alright. Nearly got to zone in, hit it as hard as you can and hope for the best.' Both men are complimentary of the value the other gave to Cork at the weekend. 'Shane was unbelievable,' says 32-year-old Lehane of 27-year-old Kingston. 'He's lethal in general. Look, sometimes the ball will go for you and then other times the donkey work that someone might do that you mightn't see that has a huge impact on the game, can happen too.' Kingston remarked of his team-mate from Midleton: 'Lehane came on the last day (v Waterford) as well and got a lovely point. He was lifting there when he came on. He's been showing that in training as well. "Having trained well over the last couple of weeks, it's nice to get the recognition."
