Was Sanjay proving too wild even for Indira Gandhi: Former PM's principal secretary in book
NEW DELHI: As principal secretary to Indira Gandhi in the run up to the Emergency and during her authoritarian regime of 21 months, P N Dhar had a rare insight into the goings-on of the period, and one central character who gets the most unflattering portrayal in his otherwise sober account of the era is the former prime minister's younger son Sanjay Gandhi.
In his book, Indira Gandhi, the Emergency, and Indian Democracy, Dhar says the PMH (Prime Minister's Home) became a hive of "extra-constitutional" activities as leaders junior in the Congress hierarchy but having the ears of an increasingly distrustful prime minister and another set of functionaries loyal to her son undermined the PMS (Prime Minister's Secretariat).
Critical of the power centralised in the PMS, Morarji Desai reduced its strength and rechristened it as Prime Minister's Office, a moniker which has continued, after replacing Indira Gandhi.
Sanjay Gandhi and his loyalists like Haryana leader Bansi Lal gained ascendency in the Congress during the era.
Even the prime minister was left alarmed by their move to have state assemblies pass resolutions in support of forming a constituent assembly for sweeping changes in the Constitution.
Aware of her obsessive love for Sanjay Gandhi, Dhar said in the book published in 2000 that he would normally have attributed all this to temporary annoyance.
"But it was more than a passing mood this time. I knew how carefully she had kept Sanjay out of all discussions on constitutional reforms. I also knew how much she had resented the passage of the constituent assembly resolutions by the three assemblies without her knowledge, but with Sanjay's approval. Was Sanjay proving too wild even for her?" he wondered.
He said the main purpose of the constituent assembly appeared to be continuing the Emergency regime and postponing elections.
Bansi Lal told Dhar that it would be to make "behan ji" (Indira Gandhi) president for life.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Print
28 minutes ago
- The Print
People rejected both BJP & Congress in bypolls: Kejriwal
AAP candidate Sanjeev Arora appears to be heading for a victory from the Ludhiana West assembly seat in Punjab leading with a margin of over 7,000 votes against his nearest rival and Congress candidate Bharat Bhushan Ashu, according to initial trends. AAP leader Gopal Italia won the Visavadar seat, while BJP's Rajendra Chavda bagged the Kadi seat on Monday, as counting for bypolls to the two constituencies in Gujarat concluded, officials said. New Delhi: AAP national convener Arvind Kejriwal on Monday said people are fed up with the BJP in Gujarat and stressed that people had rejected both Congress and BJP in the bypolls. Kejriwal said the results of Ludhiana West show that the people of Punjab are very happy with the work of the government and they have given more votes as compared to 2022. 'The people of Gujarat are now fed up with BJP and they are seeing hope in Aam Aadmi Party,' he said in a post on X in Hindi. Thanking the people of Punjab and Gujarat, Kejriwal said people had rejected both BJP and Congress in these bypolls. 'Many congratulations to all of you on the splendid victory of Aam Aadmi Party in Visavadar seat of Gujarat and Ludhiana West seat of Punjab. Many congratulations and many thanks to the people of Gujarat and Punjab. In both the places, the victory margin has been almost double as compared to the last election,' Kejriwal said in a post on X in Hindi. 'Both the parties, Congress and BJP, contested the elections together in both the places. Both of them had the same objective – to defeat AAP. But people rejected both these parties in both the places,' he claimed in the post. Celebrations erupted at the AAP headquarters in Delhi here with party workers distributing laddoos to celebrate the twin victories. PTI SLB HIG This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content. Also Read: Bypoll boost for AAP after Delhi debacle, Kerala brings cheer to Congress & TMC retains edge in Bengal
The Print
28 minutes ago
- The Print
New twist in Congress-Tharoor saga—PMO shares Kerala MP's article on Op Sindoor global outreach
Tharoor also praised Prime Minister Narendra Modi in the piece and called the diplomatic outreach a moment of national resolve and effective communication. In the piece published by The Hindu, Tharoor—who led a nine-member delegation to the United States, Panama, Guyana, Brazil and Colombia—lauded the government's initiative, saying it was 'vital in shaping global perceptions and consolidating international support'. New Delhi: At a time when Thiruvananthapuram MP Shashi Tharoor's rift with the Congress leadership has become pronounced, the Prime Minister's Office Monday shared an opinion piece by him on the success of Operation Sindoor's global outreach achieved through the visits of multi-party delegations. 'Prime Minister Narendra Modi's energy, dynamism and willingness to engage remains a prime asset for India on the global stage, but deserves greater backing…The lessons learned—the power of unity, the efficacy of clear communication, the strategic value of soft power, and the imperative of sustained public diplomacy—will undoubtedly serve as guiding principles as India navigates an increasingly complex international landscape,' wrote Tharoor. Lok Sabha MP and former Union Minister Dr. @shashitharoor writes- Lessons from Operation Sindoor's global via NaMo App — PMO India (@PMOIndia) June 23, 2025 The PMO's social media post came as fresh fodder for Tharoor's detractors in the party. His ties with the Congress first took a hit earlier this year after he praised the Left-led Kerala government's new industrial policy in a newspaper column. As leaders of the Kerala Congress attacked him over the piece, Tharoor defended himself, saying while he does not believe that the overall industrial climate of the state has changed 'when something good emerges, even if only in one area, it is petty not to acknowledge it'. Matters came to a head when Tharoor dismissed US President Donald Trump's claim that his administration brokered a truce between India and Pakistan after a military conflict broke out between the two following India's airstrikes on terror bases in Pakistan 7 May. The Congress, at that point, wanted to corner the Modi government over Trump's claims. Subsequently, Tharoor accepted the Centre's invitation to lead a multi-party delegation to world capitals to garner support for India's Operation Sindoor and its fight against Congress leadership claimed he did so without consulting the party, which had nominated other leaders to join the delegations. Nevertheless, Tharoor did not just lead one delegation, but also stirred the pot further by saying that India crossed the Line of Control to carry out surgical strikes on a terror base 'for the first time' under the Narendra Modi government in 2016. Last week, Tharoor acknowledged his differences of opinion with the 'current Congress leadership'. Tharoor also said he was not invited to campaign for the party in the Nilambur bypolls. 'I do not go where I am not invited,' he told reporters. However, on being asked whether he was going to leave the party, he said he was 'not going anywhere'. 'I am a member of the Congress party. Let the party decide what it thinks about me,' he said. (Edited by Ajeet Tiwari) Also Read: Excluded by Congress, Shashi Tharoor says 'honoured' by govt's invitation to join all-party delegation
Indian Express
41 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Best MLA award winner, party's Dalit face: All about Shailesh Parmar, Congress's ‘interim' in-charge in Gujarat
Though tendering their resignation by owning moral responsibility for electoral defeats is nothing new for party chiefs, as a norm, the post-holders would wait for a word from the top leadership before relinquishing charge. In what can be seen as departure from the rule, Gujarat Pradesh Congress Committee (GPCC) president Shaktisinh Gohil chose to leave the top job in the state party unit on his own on Monday by 'appointing' Shailesh Parmar, the party's Dalit MLA from the reserved Danilimda constituency in Ahmedabad city, as the in-charge of the party 'till the AICC appoints a new president'. This comes in the backdrop of the Congress's dismal performance in the Kadi and Visavadar bypolls. Gohil's decision has put Shailesh Parmar, 56, under renewed spotlight. Among the seniormost MLAs in the Gujarat Assembly, Shailesh Parmar has been winning the seat since 2012. Politics runs in the legislator's family as his father, the late Manharbhai (Manubhai) Parmar, was a formidable Dalit leader in Gujarat and a state minister in a previous Congress-run government. Before Danilimda, Shailesh Parmar also represented Shaher Kotda constituency, which was represented by his father till 1998. Though the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) won the seat in 2002, Shailesh Parmar wrested it back in 2007. In the last Assembly elections, Shailesh Parmar defeated the BJP's Naresh Vyas by a margin of over 13,000 votes. Shailesh Parmar is the party's deputy leader in the Assembly where the Congress's numbers have shrunk to 12. Shailesh Parmar has completed his Bachelor of Education from Hindi Sahitya Sammelan, Prayag, in Uttar Pradesh. By vocation, he is a farmer who is also involved in construction business. In the last Gujarat Assembly, Shailesh Parmar won the Best MLA award along with the BJP's Jitu Sukhadia. Shailesh Parmar had recently accompanied the team that represented Gujarat in the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association meeting held at Sydney in November 2024. Besides Shailesh Parmar, Anirudh Dave from the BJP joined Speaker Shankar Chaudhary as observers.
