Bombay HC refuses relief to L&T in tender process for tunnel, elevated road projects connecting Thane with Mira-Bhayandar
A vacation bench of Justices Kamal R Khata and Arif S Doctor passed a verdict on two pleas by L&T, which claimed that it had not received any intimation about the status of its bids, while the other bidders had received the same.
In the case of a plea against the opening of financial bids for an elevated road, the HC refused to continue the stay on the opening of bids and said it was rejecting L&T's request for further stay. In the case of the tunnel project, the HC dismissed L&T's plea stating that it had approached the court with 'suppressed' material.
The HC, however, said the price bids submitted electronically by L&T for both the projects should be preserved in a sealed cover for two weeks to enable it to approach the Supreme Court. The bench said the MMRDA shall communicate the decision related to the tender award as per the Instructions to Bidders (ITB).
The two projects link Thane and Mira-Bhayandar through a tunnel from Gaimukh to Fountain Hotel junction at Shilphata, and an elevated creek road bridge will connect Bhayandar to Ghodbunder Road in Thane.
MMRDA invited tenders for the project in July 2024, and on October 8, responding to a separate plea by L&T, the Authority had said that it would extend by 60 days the last date of submission of bids for the project.
Senior advocates Abhishek Manu Singhvi and Janak Dwarkadas, representing L&T, informed the HC that the technical and financial bids were submitted on December 30, 2024, and MMRDA opened the technical bids on January 1 and were being evaluated, however, the petitioner firm had not received any communication related to the same.
The firm said that without such information about the evaluation result, MMRDA had scheduled the opening of financial bids for the project on May 13. However, it said some other bidders had received an intimation about the opening of financial bids. Therefore, it approached the HC seeking an urgent stay on the same. The firm argued that if the financial bids were opened by excluding it, the same would be contrary to a fair and transparent tender process and against well-established legal norms or principles.
L&T's bid unresponsive before opening financial bids: MMRDA
Solicitor General Tushar Mehta and senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi for MMRDA, however, argued that it was not required to intimate L&T that the firm's bid was found to be unresponsive before opening the financial bids.
The Authority claimed that since the project was in public interest, it was entitled to open the financial bids and communicate the outcome of the technical evaluation without informing L&T. It added that of the five bidders, others were also found unresponsive for both projects at the technical stage and will be informed once the final bidder is selected.
The firm termed it 'discriminatory and arbitrary' and against principles of natural justice.
Earlier, on May 13, the court directed MMRDA not to open financial bids till it hears the plea. On May 15, while concluding the hearing and reserving its order, the bench extended the said arrangement till its decision on May 20.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
UP sanctions Rs 97cr for uninterrupted power supply to Noida
Noida: Power minister AK Sharma has directed officials to ensure uninterrupted electricity supply in Noida at a recent review meeting. Earlier, UPPCL approved Rs 97 crore for the district's infrastructure upgrade for the 2025–26 financial year. Separately, under the Rs 1,313-crore Central govt's revamped distribution sector scheme (RDSS), L&T has been commissioned for SCADA work, while another company is expected to be finalised in the first week of Aug. While the RDSS focuses on building new substations and strengthening distribution networks, parallel projects will replace ageing transformers, poles, and cables; particularly in Noida's newer sectors and older areas with poor infrastructure. You Can Also Check: Noida AQI | Weather in Noida | Bank Holidays in Noida | Public Holidays in Noida The business plan was submitted in March this year, but the sanction has come through now. For the 2024-25 financial year, Rs 125 crore had been approved, of which 80% of the work is already complete. "The remaining 20% will be completed by the end of Aug," said Sanjay Kumar Jain chief engineer Noida power department, PVVNL. Meanwhile, long-term infrastructure upgrades under the Centre's Rs 1,313-crore revamped distribution sector scheme (RDSS) are set to begin soon. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like New Container Houses Indonesia (Prices May Surprise You) Container House | Search ads Undo L&T has been awarded the contract for SCADA (supervisory control and data acquisition) work, while another company is likely to be finalised by Aug 6 or 7 for the remaining works. Jain said the SCADA system will enable real-time monitoring and automation of the power distribution network, improving efficiency, reliability, and sustainability. It will involve data collection from substations and integration of smart systems to manage load and distribution. Planned RDSS works include building over 20 substations in phases across residential, institutional, and industrial sectors. Five substations—two in Dadri, two in Jewar, and one in Rabupura—are among the initial projects. Additionally, around 300km of aerial bundled cables (ABC) will be laid in areas experiencing line losses. Traditional lines will be replaced with ABC cables first, followed by underground cable laying in other zones. The capacity and number of transformers will also be increased as part of network strengthening. While the RDSS and SCADA projects will run parallel to the annual maintenance and repair works, officials said the overall objective is to address Noida's growing power demand and upgrade the city's ageing infrastructure. "The RDSS works are planned for the 2025-27 period and are crucial for future load management and system modernisation," Jain told TOI.
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
Road project: HC nixes Margao man's plea against acquisition of his land
Panaji: The high court has dismissed a petition filed by a Margao resident challenging the acquisition of his land at Sirvodem, Margao, for the rehabilitation of hutments to fix the missing link of the ring road in Margao. The HC said that the acquisition proceedings were completed by state govt and that the man objected to the acquisition of his land at the final stage of the proceedings. The division bench, comprising justices Bharati Dangre and Nivedita Mehta, said that the acquisition of the land for the public purpose of fixing the missing link of the ring road is a matter of policy and not of law. It said state govt is the authority that must carry out the plan for which the land was acquired and govt is in the best position to judge which land can be exempted from acquisition. The court held that it cannot exercise the power of writ under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution. The petitioner stated that he couldn't file objections under the Land Acquisition Act as he was out of India during the relevant time. In the meantime, the land acquisition officer conducted an inquiry and inspection and found that hutments were coming up on the proposed ring road site. Hence, the acquisition was proposed for rehabilitating the hutments that had existed for many years. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Gold Is Surging in 2025 — Smart Traders Are Already In IC Markets Learn More Undo The petitioner stated that if his residential house was acquired, it would deprive him of his permanent place of residence in Goa. He stated that hutment dwellers could easily be accommodated on lands belonging to govt of Goa, such as in Margao (Sonsoddo), Davorlim, and Verna near the industrial estate, many of which are barren and uninhabited. He also told the court that there is a plot at Loutolim measuring 5,000sqm, which was acquired by the Goa Industrial Development Corporation and allotted to govt of Goa, for the implementation of a housing scheme. This plot can be utilised for the rehabilitation of slum dwellers who illegally reside on the land reserved for dealing with the missing link of the road, he said. He requested that his property be dropped from the proposed acquisition proceedings.
News18
7 hours ago
- News18
BEST Using Leased Electric Cars Without Fitness Certificates, Insurance; Alleges Labour Union
Last Updated: All 142 Tata Xpres-T EVs hired by the civic-run BEST for its officials and staff before March 2023 were plying without fitness certificates and valid insurance as of Monday. The Brihanmumbai Electric Supply and Transport (BEST) undertaking which provides electricity as well as public bus service in Mumbai has been using leased electric cars without valid fitness certificates and insurance, sources have claimed. All 142 Tata Xpres-T EVs hired by the civic-run BEST for its officials and staff before March 2023 were plying without fitness certificates and valid insurance as of Monday, they alleged. Senior officials of the BEST did not respond to the claims, while a regional transport officer told PTI that the RTO will issue a show-cause notice to the concerned company, though it had reportedly brought the first lot of 30 cars for fitness certificate renewal. BEST said in a written reply that obtaining these certificates was the responsibility of the private firm which has leased out the vehicles. The fitness certificate or insurance of some of the leased cars expired eight months ago and the same was the case of insurance of several cars, sources in the undertaking claimed. The cars are being used for ferrying employees and officers of BEST's traffic and electricity wing. Shashank Rao, leader of a union of BEST employees, said on Tuesday that the undertaking was playing with the lives of its employees. 'If tomorrow any untoward incident happens due to these cars, concerned BEST officials should be held responsible," Rao told PTI. A BEST employee who did not wish to be named said he and hundreds of his colleagues use these EVs for official work such as attending to power line faults, but now they are scared to use them. 'Everyone knows the financial condition of BEST. Hence we are scared to use EV cars, because in case of any accident the occupants won't even get compensation," the employee said. As per BEST's written reply to PTI's query, the 142 electric sedans have been hired from Nagpur-based Sargo Overseas Private Limited. As per the contract, it is the responsibility of the company to renew the fitness certificates and insurance of these cars, BEST said. The cars have been hired for 15 years, and for each car BEST is annually paying Rs 5,08,800 or Rs 42,400 per month to Sargo Overseas at present. For the period of first 10 years, BEST is supposed to pay Rs 42,400 to the company per car per month, and Rs 28,407 for the remaining five years. As per RTO records, these electric cars were registered between November 2022 to July 2023. Shrinivas Rao, BEST's additional general manager (transport) who is responsible for these cars, did not respond to calls and messages seeking his comment. Additional transport commissioner Bharat Kalaskar, who is also in-charge of Tardeo RTO, said they will issue a show-cause notice to the company if the vehicles were running without fitness certificates, but he had learnt from his office that the company produced a lot of 30 cars for renewal of fitness certificates earlier in the day. As per rule 62 of the Central Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989, fitness certificates are mandatory for all commercial vehicles including EVs. Under section 146 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, motor vehicles plying on roads must have insurance policy covering third party risks. Driving a car without a valid fitness certificate can result in fines ranging from Rs 2,000 to Rs 5,000 for a first-time offense. Subsequent offenses can lead to fines up to Rs 10,000 and even imprisonment . For driving an uninsured vehicle, the fine is Rs 2,000 for the first offence, and Rs 4,000 for every subsequent offence. There is also a provision of imprisonment for the violation of the rule. (This story has not been edited by News18 staff and is published from a syndicated news agency feed - PTI) About the Author Shahrukh Shah Shahrukh Shah, Sub-Editor at News18, loves to write about everything that moves on wheels. With years of experience and the required skill sets, he is contributing to the auto section, where he let people know ...Read More First Published: Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
