THE LOWDOWN: Are Sonia Gandhi, Rahul in trouble in the National Herald case?
News: The Enforcement Directorate has told a Delhi court that a prima facie case of money laundering was made out against senior Congress leaders Sonia Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi in the National Herald case. On May 2, notices were issued to the accused, including Young Indian.The National Herald case is an ongoing investigation involving allegations of financial irregularities, money laundering, and related offences against Sonia Gandhi, her son Rahul Gandhi, and other Congress leaders. The case originated from a private complaint filed in 2012 by BJP leader Subramanian Swamy in a Delhi court.advertisementSwamy accused Sonia and Rahul Gandhi of cheating, criminal misappropriation, and breach of trust in the acquisition of Associated Journals Limited (AJL) by Young Indian Limited (YIL).The Enforcement Directorate (ED) intensified its money laundering probe in November 2023, attaching assets worth Rs 751.9 crore linked to AJL and YIL.
What is the National Herald?The National Herald newspaper was founded in 1938 by Jawaharlal Nehru and others to support India's independence movement.The newspaper was published by Associated Journals Limited (AJL), a not-for-profit company incorporated in 1937, which also published Qaumi Awaz (Urdu) and Navjeevan (Hindi).In 2008, AJL ceased publication of the National Herald and its sister publications due to financial difficulties, including significant debt.What are the roles of Sonia and Rahul Gandhi?In November 2010, Young Indian Limited (YIL), a not-for-profit company, was incorporated with Sonia Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi as majority shareholders, each holding 38% of the shares (totalling 76%). The paid-up capital of YIL was Rs 5 lakh.advertisementAJL owed Rs 90.25 crore to the All India Congress Committee (AICC) as an interest-free loan to sustain its operations.In 2010, the AICC assigned this loan to YIL for Rs 50 lakh. AJL issued 9.02 crore equity shares (face value Rs 10 each) to YIL, making YIL the majority shareholder with 99% ownership of AJL. While AJL legally remained an independent entity, YIL effectively controlled it.Why did the AICC transfer the loan for Rs 50 lakh?The AICC stated that AJL was unable to repay the Rs 90.25 crore loan. The AICC agreed to write off the loan after receiving Rs 50 lakh from YIL, treating it as a settlement due to AJL's financial distress.Is such a transfer of debt and conversion to equity a normal practice?Debt assignment or conversion to equity is a common practice in corporate restructurings. However, such transactions typically occur under regulatory oversight, such as by the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) in India. The AICC's transfer of the loan to YIL was not supervised by any regulatory body.Did the Congress lose money in the deal?The Congress claims the AICC did not incur a financial loss, as the loan to AJL was interest-free and intended to support a not-for-profit venture aligned with the National Herald's ideological goals, not to generate profit.advertisementDid Young Indian pay Rs 50 lakh for a bankrupt company?AJL was not bankrupt but had significant debt and ceased newspaper publication in 2008. AJL owned high-value real estate assets in cities like Delhi, Mumbai, Lucknow, and others. By acquiring 99% of AJL's shares, YIL gained control over these assets, which can generate revenue through leasing or other means.Subramanian Swamy alleged in his 2012 complaint that AJL's assets were worth over Rs 2,000 crore.Are the asset valuations accurate?In November 2023, the ED attached AJL assets valued at Rs 751.9 crore, including immovable properties (Rs 661.69 crore).Herald House, Delhi: A multi-story building on Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg.Bandra Property, Mumbai: A nine-story building with two basements, approximately 15,000 square meters.Lucknow Building: A property on Bisheshwar Nath Road.Panchkula Plot, Haryana: A 3,360-square-meter plot allotted in 1982 and re-allotted in 2005.Additional properties exist in cities like Patna and Indore.Separately, the ED has attached equity shares worth Rs 90.2 crore.The Congress disputes the ED's valuation, claiming the assets are worth approximately Rs 350 crore.What are the allegations against the Gandhis?advertisementThe ED, in its 2023 attachment order and April 2025 chargesheet, alleges that the loan transfer and equity conversion constituted a money-laundering scheme.The agency claims AICC funds (including public donations) were used to fraudulently transfer control of AJL's assets to YIL, beneficially owned by Sonia and Rahul Gandhi.The ED further alleges that AJL, YIL, and AICC cheated AJL's original shareholders and Congress donors by transferring assets to YIL.Do Young Indian Ltd and the Gandhis own these assets?The Congress maintains that AJL retains ownership of its assets, and YIL, as a not-for-profit company, was created to revive the National Herald, not to acquire assets for financial gain. YIL cannot pay dividends, and the Gandhis derive no direct financial benefit.What happens if the charges are proven?If convicted under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA), the accused could face imprisonment of up to seven years.Are the Gandhis in trouble?The acquisition of AJL's shares by YIL for Rs 50 lakh raises questions about the transaction's propriety, including the lack of regulatory oversight.The Congress has to explain why the ownership of AJL was given to a company in which the Gandhis have a 76 per cent stake.advertisementThere are many other questions: What was the process for selecting Young India Ltd for the debt buy-out? Why was the approval of the original shareholders of AJL not taken?But, does this qualify as a case of money laundering? The ED's case relies on circumstantial evidence, such as shareholding patterns and loan conversions, rather than direct proof of the Gandhis siphoning funds. Courts often require concrete evidence of intent and personal gain in cases of alleged money laundering. The Gandhis' defense that they derived no financial benefit could test the prosecution's case.Tune InMust Watch
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
12 minutes ago
- India Today
Zohran Mamdani turns New York City mayoral race into Bollywood blockbuster
When Zohran Kwame Mamdani announced his candidacy for New York City mayor last October, he was seen as a long shot. But an affordability-centred messaging and social media-driven campaign sprinkled with Bollywood tadka has propelled the 33-year-old assemblyman to the forefront of the Democratic primary to Ugandan academic Mahmood Mamdani and acclaimed Indian-American filmmaker Mira Nair, Zohran Mamdani has leaned into his South Asian heritage and captured the attention of younger, immigrant, and working-class New Yorkers with his populist platform and savvy use of Hindi film week, Mamdani dropped a campaign video on X peppered with classic Bollywood film scenes and music. Speaking in Hindi, he explains the voting process, makes the case for affordability, and takes aim at his main rival: former New York governor Andrew Cuomo, who is backed by US President Donald Trump. A democratic socialist, Mamdani framed the race as a choice between a people-powered movement and billionaire-backed 2-minute, 23-second video features the iconic scene from Deewar, where Amitabh Bachchan's character Vijay boasts, "Aaj mere paas buildingein hain, property hai, bangla hai, bank balance hai, gaadi hai. Tumhare paas kya hai? (Today I have buildings, property, a bungalow, a bank balance, and a car. What do you have?)."A beat later, Mamdani appears on screen, arms spread in Shah Rukh Khan's signature pose, responding simply: "Aap" (I have the people).Billionaires ke paas already sab kuchh hai. Ab, aapka time already have everything. Now, your time has come. Zohran Kwame Mamdani (@ZohranKMamdani) June 4, 2025advertisementThe message is clear: Mamdani is positioning himself as the candidate of the people, against Cuomo, whom he portrays as emblematic of elite privilege and establishment explain New York's ranked choice voting system, Mamdani borrows Kishore Kumar's voice from Karz and uses glasses of lassi as props: "Hey, have you ever voted for anyone? Have you ever ranked anyone?"This is not your typical New York City mayoral has fused desi pop culture with policy to communicate a progressive vision: free city buses, controlling apartment rents, city-run grocery stores, and a $10 billion tax hike on the ultra-wealthy to pay for it all.'We can guarantee cheaper groceries, we can raise the minimum wage, we can freeze the rent for more than 2 million tenants, and build more than 200,000 affordable homes. We are done settling for less,' he declares in another ad—rooted in the spirit of Roti, Kapda aur Makaan, the 1974 Bachchan-starrer that named the three most basic human ad starts airing are done settling for less. Zohran Kwame Mamdani (@ZohranKMamdani) June 11, 2025With a short-lived career as a hip-hop artist, Mamdani now calls himself the Kendrick Lamar of affordability—intent on sticking to a message that speaks to working-class ke paas already sab kuchh hai. Ab, aapka time aageya (Billionaires already have everything. Now, your time has come)," he says in his video, a callback to the rap anthem from Ranveer Singh and Alia Bhatt-starrer Gully Mamdani's rise has not come without controversy. His vocal criticism of Israel and advocacy for Palestinian rights have earned him a fair share of has also been branded anti-Hindu for calling Prime Minister Narendra Modi a "war criminal" with reference to the latter's alleged role in the 2002 Gujarat riots. PM Modi was given a clean chit by a Supreme Court-appointed probe."Narendra Modi helped to orchestrate what was a mass slaughter of Muslims in Gujarat to the extent that [people] don't even believe there are Gujarat Muslims anymore," Mamdani recently said at a forum. "This is someone we should view in the same manner we do Benjamin Netanyahu. This is a war criminal."His Muslim heritage has also drawn vitriol, but Mamdani has turned the attacks into campaign fodder."When you're the first Muslim elected official to run for mayor, people say some pretty wild things," he quipped in a New York City—America's largest metropolis—grappling with a cost-of-living crisis, housing shortages, transit issues, and deep inequality, the next mayor faces enormous challenges. Mamdani, powered by Bollywood swagger and socialist fire, has cast himself as the underdog hero standing up for the little guy.
India Today
12 minutes ago
- India Today
Can India's middle class invest where Dubai's billionaires buy homes?
For a long time, Dubai looked like a rich person's dream, shiny buildings, luxury cars, no income tax, and homes that looked like something out of a felt like a place only for billionaires, Bollywood stars, and big business families. But things are changing now as more and more salaried Indians are asking the same question: Can I also buy a home in Dubai?advertisementRitu Kant Ojha, CEO of Proact Luxury Real Estate, said that the interest from Indian buyers has expanded beyond just high-net-worth individuals.'We're witnessing a strong inclination among Indian buyers for a diverse range of properties in Dubai. Apartments remain highly sought after, particularly those in well-connected areas with solid infrastructure,' he said. Demand is also rising for villas and townhouses in gated communities, especially among families looking for space and lifestyle COST: NOT CHEAP, BUT POSSIBLEFor most salaried Indians, the first concern is cost, and understandably so. While Dubai is often portrayed as a high-end real estate market, there are entry points that may suit higher-income middle-class explains that mid-range apartments in decent neighbourhoods often fall in the AED 1 million to AED 3 million range, or roughly Rs 1.5 crore to Rs 3 crore, depending on the location and such properties, a buyer usually needs to put down around 20% as down payment, plus 4% for the Dubai Land Department's registration fee. That means an Indian buyer would need to have around Rs 35–50 lakh in liquid savings to enter the market.'This is not for everyone,' Ojha cautions, 'but for dual-income families or professionals with long-term savings and financial discipline, it is doable.'FINANCING OPTIONS ARE OPENING UPWhile paying the full amount upfront is rare, Dubai's property market does offer multiple financing says, 'Non-resident Indians can explore mortgage options from banks operating in the UAE. Typically, these require proof of income and a valid passport. The loan-to-value ratio for NRIs ranges between 50% and 80%, depending on the buyer's financial profile.'An increasingly popular option is to go for developer-backed payment plans. These allow buyers to make staggered payments linked to construction milestones, or even continue paying in instalments has made Dubai more accessible to salaried Indians who may not have a large lump sum ready, but can commit to monthly Ojha warns that all payment plans should be studied carefully. "The terms can vary widely. Some look attractive on paper but have hidden conditions. A good advisor will break it down for you.'HIGHER RETURNS COMPARED TO TIER-2 INDIAN CITIESadvertisementWhile the upfront investment is certainly higher than, say, buying a flat in Lucknow or Jaipur, the returns in Dubai are significantly better, Ojha explains.'In Tier-2 cities in India, you typically earn 2% to 2.5% annual rental yield. In Dubai, even mid-range apartments fetch 7% to 10%, especially in expat-driven neighbourhoods. Capital appreciation is also strong—15% to 20% annually, and sometimes more depending on the area and market cycle,' he is also no personal income tax in the UAE, so investors don't have to worry about rental income or capital gains tax eating into their buyers must go in with open eyes. Apart from the down payment, buyers are responsible for several additional costs—4% registration fee, 2% brokerage commission, utility setup fees, and ongoing service charges which cover maintenance and building amenities. These costs can vary based on location, property size and factor is the exchange rate risk between the Indian Rupee and the UAE Dirham. Although the Dirham is pegged to the US dollar and stable, any weakening of the rupee can increase the overall cost of investment for Indian YOU PICK DUBAI OVER TIER-2 INDIA?Ojha says that for a buyer purely focused on returns, Dubai has clear advantages.'Dubai has better infrastructure, a safer legal environment, and much better rental yields. The 2040 Urban Master Plan also promises long-term development and stability," he explained. That said, he does not recommend jumping in without preparation. 'This is an overseas investment, and with that comes complexity. Currency risk, legal compliance under RBI's remittance rules, and property management need to be understood.'For first-time Indian investors from the middle class, Ojha offers simple but important advice: 'Find a trusted, RERA-certified advisor. Don't get carried away by glossy marketing. Start with a research-driven approach.'He recommends visiting Dubai in person if possible, choosing investment-focused properties with strong rental history, and being clear about your goals, rental income, capital gains, or future believes that for the right kind of salaried Indian, with savings, financial discipline, and a long-term view, Dubai is no longer out of reach.'Many of my clients start with one investment and come back for more,' he concluded. (Disclaimer: The views, opinions, recommendations, and suggestions expressed by experts/brokerages in this article are their own and do not reflect the views of the India Today Group. It is advisable to consult a qualified broker or financial advisor before making any actual investment or trading choices.)Must Watch
India Today
13 minutes ago
- India Today
EVs are not as clean as you think, says Akio Toyoda, Chairman of Toyota
Toyota claims that it has sold 27 million hybrids since it launched the first generation of the Toyota Prius in 1997. Akio Toyoda, Chairman of the Board of Directors, Toyota, claims that these 27 million cars are greener than nine million fully electric vehicles when adding battery and vehicle production into the equation. In an interview with Automotive News, he added that if these nine million EVs were built in Japan, it would not have been as green as Japan relies mostly on thermal to Toyoda, components required for the manufacture of batteries needed in EVs can have a negative environmental impact. Not to mention, the logistics involved in moving the raw material from the source to manufacturing facilities and then to OEM more he says that the generation of electricity is not exactly done via green methods, with most global economies still heavily reliant on thermal sources for power. He further said in an interview that the conversion of fleets to electric also involves exorbitant costs. Hence, EVs are not the viable choice for the future. To sum it up, then, Toyoda isn't just looking at the localised impact of electric vehicles limited to emissions but a more holistic look at the life cycle of the entire vehicle from production to the post life impact. On the other hand, Toyoda says that hybrid vehicles seem to be more apt for the future where it is a best of both world where self-charging hybrids prove to be a practical and greener way to drive. These days, Toyota offers a hybrid variant across nearly every Toyota model manufacturers have also shown a bit of a slowdown when it comes to electric vehicles. While General Motors has pushed back the plans for the GM Silverado EV, Ford has also acknowledged an unexpected decline in consumer demand for EVs. According to reports, even Elon Musk's Tesla too has been suffering. Sales declined in both the U.S. and China. Tesla sold 38,588 vehicles in China in May, a 30.11 per cent decrease from the 55,215 units sold in the same month last year, according to data released today by the China Passenger Car Association. In India, Toyota also relies heavily on hybrids rather than going full electric. It currently offers the Toyota Urban Cruiser Hyryder, which promises to offer 27.97kmpl thanks to it being a hybrid. The Hyryder is priced between Rs 17.68 lakh and Rs 27.97 lakh. Toyota also offers the Toyota Innova Hycross, which is once again a proper hybrid and is powered by the TNGA hybrid petrol engine with E-drive transmission. The Hycross is priced between Rs 27.78 lakh and Rs 34.70 lakh. Toyota also launched the Toyota Camry Hybrid in India recently and priced it at Rs 51.54 to Auto Today Magazine
