Groenewald calls for corporal punishment for those who can't afford bail
PA MP Marlon Daniels argued the death penalty would be more suitable for those sentenced for murder.
'Corporal punishment is mildly put. Bring back the death penalty. You kill someone, be prepared to be killed.'
Rise Mzansi MP Makashule Gana said alternative rehabilitation methods should be introduced.
'We need to be innovative. It's not corporal punishment we need; it's community service,' Gana said.
'There are many inmates housed in correctional service facilities who shouldn't be there. Let's send them to work in communities for free instead of introducing corporal punishment. Let them clean the streets and pay for the crimes they committed.'
Groenewald has previously said some inmates serving life sentences could be denied parole despite completing all required rehabilitation programmes.
He said: 'The parolees I work with are lifers. You can have a parolee or applicant for parole who went through all the rehabilitation courses and the whole process, but then you get a psychologist's report and a criminologist's report and in the reports it is determined what is the risk of the applicant reoffending.'
TimesLIVE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald
12 hours ago
- The Herald
Alleged hitman linked to Prasa regional manager's death appears in court
A KwaZulu-Natal man who is alleged to have carried out a hit on Passenger Rail Agency (Prasa) regional manager Jacob Khoaele on January 22 made a brief appearance in the Durban magistrate's court on Monday. Khoaele, 53, died in a hail of bullets in his vehicle on Shelbourne Avenue, La Lucia. KwaZulu-Natal police spokesperson Col Robert Netshiunda said on Saturday detectives had made a breakthrough in the case when they arrested a fourth suspect in connection with Khoaele's death. Mthandeni Cele, 24, was arrested at the Scottburgh magistrate's court where he was appearing in an unrelated case of house robbery and attempted murder involving a homeowner who was shot and his vehicle stolen on November 11 2024. He faces charges of conspiracy to commit murder and murder. He told the court he plans to enlist his own private legal representative. Netshiunda said the murder investigation was handed to provincial serious and violent crime, murder and robbery detectives who cracked the case and arrested twins Vukani and Vukile Mchunu aged 35 on July 27. Investigations also pointed to Sandile Sakhile Ngcobo, 38, as the alleged mastermind behind the killing. Ngcobo made his first appearance on August 4 and is also an accused in a triple murder and attempted murder case in which he allegedly shot dead three people accused of murder in Msinsini in 2021. 'The three had just appeared in court when they were shot dead in a vehicle in Hibberdene on June 27 2024. A passer-by also sustained a gunshot wound during the incident,' said Netshiunda. Magistrate Ashwin Singh rolled the matter over to Tuesday and urged Cele to have his lawyer present. TimesLIVE
Mail & Guardian
12 hours ago
- Mail & Guardian
DA slams R700m national dialogue as pricey ‘talk shop'
Democratic Alliance leader John Steenhuisen. (Delwyn Verasamy/M&G) The The 'The fact that others are now withdrawing from the national dialogue shows that it is an illegitimate talk shop. South Africans do not need more dialogue; they need real delivery. The DA will relentlessly use our influence inside the GNU and parliament to push for these reforms. It is time for urgent action. We must create economic growth and jobs,' he said. His comments came days after several legacy organisations announced they would not participate in the dialogue or the work of its preparatory task team. These include the Steve Biko, Thabo Mbeki, Chief Albert Luthuli, Desmond and Leah Tutu Legacy, FW de Klerk and Oliver and Adelaide Tambo foundations, as well as the Strategic Dialogue Group. The organisations cited insufficient funds and not enough time to prepare for the first national convention and a shift towards government control of the programme. 'We feel the organisation of the matter was not entirely honest as to where the funds will be directed. This is due to our belief that core principles meant to underpin the whole National Dialogue have been violated in the rush to host a gathering on 15 August,' they said in a joint statement. President Cyril Ramaphosa first publicly Last month National Dialogue steering committee chairperson Nkosinathi Biko Besides the DA, other critics have also slammed the proposed R700 million plus budget for the initiative, with labour federation Cosatu said the idea, pushed by a few officials, was 'imprudent and insensitive' amid deep public frustration, with workers already facing spending cuts on health, education, policing and home affairs services, as well as rising living costs and an economy crippled by unemployment, poverty and inequality. Following the withdrawal of the foundations from the preparatory task team last week, a new convention organising committee, including representatives from civil society, National Economic Development and Labour Council (Nedlac), the University of South Africa (Unisa) and the presidency, has taken over preparations. The convention organisers confirmed the first national convention of the National Dialogue will take place on 15 and 16 August at Unisa's main campus. It will host 1 000 delegates from more than 30 sectors, with special weighting for marginalised groups including youth, women and LGBTQI+ people. Some 557 participants from 28 sectors have confirmed attendance. Costs have been reduced through in-kind contributions, national convention spokesperson Zwoitwaho Nevhutalu said, adding: 'Unisa is providing venues, catering, audio-visual services, printing and other logistics free of charge. 'Additional support includes donated transport and a digital platform for the dialogue. The main expenses are being covered from Nedlac and presidency budgets, in line with the Public Finance Management Act.' The plan is to hold at least three dialogues in each of the country's 4,300 wards, supplemented by sectoral discussions and the media, Nevhutalu said. A mobile app will allow the public to contribute and track outcomes. 'The outcomes framework of the public dialogues will focus on radical change, rapid response and rebuilding the nation. We must not allow any grouping to control a process that should truly belong to citizens,' he said. For the DA, the time for talking has passed. 'It is now time for the majority of South Africans to taste the freedom of a new democracy through a job, not jobs and tenders only for the politically elite,' Steenhuisen told journalists. He argued that dismantling the Broad-based Black Economic Empowerment Act (broad-based BEE), the Employment Equity Act and the Expropriation Act, alongside taking a stronger stance against corruption, would open the economy to more meaningful growth. 'These laws were intended to advance transformation, but they have increasingly entrenched elite enrichment, deterred investment, and blocked small businesses from accessing opportunities,' he said. But last week ANC secretary general Fikile Mbalula said the party 'would not be coerced' into reversing its 'progressive transformation laws', echoing a position stated by Ramaphosa earlier this year. The president told parliament that the coalition government's commitment to broad-based BEE remained 'steadfast' and aligned with the Constitution's equality clause, which allows for measures to advance those disadvantaged by unfair discrimination. 'If the privileged class tried to fight back against economic redress, that would be unconstitutional,' he said. ActionSA has also signalled it may withdraw from the dialogue, citing public dissatisfaction and the withdrawal of respected foundations. 'We are not prepared to lend credibility to what many already believe to be a window-dressing exercise that risks becoming a government-directed platform,' the party's Athol Trollip said, describing the process as 'crumbling' and losing credibility.
The Herald
15 hours ago
- The Herald
Malema wants prostitution legalised
EFF leader Julius Malema has called on the government to decriminalise prostitution. Speaking to party supporters at a Women's Day rally in Mpumalanga, Malema said sex workers deserved access to protection by law enforcement agencies, including being able to open cases against rapists or other types of abusers without disrespect from police. 'The government must legalise prostitution. Prostitution is the oldest profession in the world. You may be a Christian; whether you like it or not, prostitution is a job and there are people who work in it. Respect those people, they too must have protection and workers' rights,' he said. There has been an ongoing debate about legalising prostitution to enhance health and safety for sex workers and protect their rights. In 2022, the cabinet approved the publication of the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences and Related Matters) Amendment Bill regarding the decriminalisation of sex work for public comment. The passage of the bill has since stalled. Malema said all women should be protected from being victims of abuse. 'We must ensure we protect our women in every space we occupy. Women get raped in churches, schools, workplaces and social places. They do not rape themselves — they are raped by men. Men have to stand up and by standing up you don't have to do anything — just stop raping women.' He called on men to take a stand against gender-based violence, saying: 'We don't want men who are cowards, who are scared of people their age and gender and go and exercise their power over powerless women. No man should lay a hand on a woman. We must protect them, respect them and provide for them.' TimesLIVE
