Hong Kong court hears appeals by jailed democracy campaigners
They were among 45 opposition figures, including some of Hong Kong's best-known democracy activists, who were sentenced in November over a 2020 informal primary election that authorities deemed a subversive plot.
Critics including the United States, Britain and the European Union said the case showed how a Beijing-imposed national security law has eroded freedoms and quashed peaceful opposition in Hong Kong.
Ex-lawmakers "Long Hair" Leung Kwok-hung, Lam Cheuk-ting, Helena Wong and Raymond Chan are among those contesting their convictions and sentences in hearings that are scheduled to last 10 days.
Owen Chow, a 28-year-old activist who was sentenced to seven years and nine months in jail - the harshest penalty among the dozen - has also lodged an appeal.
Former district councillor Michael Pang withdrew his appeal application on Monday morning, leaving a total of 12 appellants.
Some of them have already spent more than four years behind bars.
The activists were accused of organising or taking part in an unofficial primary election that aimed to improve the pro-democracy camp's chances of winning a majority in the legislature.
They had hoped, once a majority was secured, to force the government to accede to demands such as universal suffrage by threatening to indiscriminately veto the budget - a plan that trial judges said would have caused a "constitutional crisis".
Defence lawyer Erik Shum said that vetoing the budget was a form of "check and balance" built into Hong Kong's mini-constitution that lawmakers could deploy as a last resort.
"In order to check the unpopular exercise of powers by the executive, one of the important measures is to tie the purse," he told the court.
Shum said lawmakers should not be answerable to the courts over how they vote because of the separation of powers.
PROSECUTORS SEEK REVERSAL
Prosecutors also challenged the acquittal of lawyer Lawrence Lau, one of two people found not guilty in May 2024 from an original group of 47 accused.
Lau's "overall conduct" showed that he was party to the conspiracy and he should be tried again because the lower court made the wrong factual finding, the prosecution said.
Lau, representing himself, said the trial court's findings should not be "casually interfered" with.
"I have never advocated for the resignation of the chief executive, I have never advocated the indiscriminate vetoing of the financial budget," Lau told the court, referring to core tenets of the alleged conspiracy.
Beijing has remoulded Hong Kong in its authoritarian image after imposing a sweeping national security law in 2020 following months of huge, and sometimes violent, demonstrations.
Authorities arrested figures from a broad cross-section of the city's opposition in morning raids in 2021, the group later being dubbed the "Hong Kong 47".
Aged between 27 and 69, they included democratically elected lawmakers and district councillors, as well as unionists, academics and others ranging from modest reformists to radical localists.
Dozens of police officers were deployed outside the West Kowloon court building on Monday morning as people queued to attend the hearing.
"They made a sacrifice ... I hope they understand that Hongkongers have not forgotten them," said a public hospital worker in his thirties surnamed Chow.
Amnesty International's China director Sarah Brooks said the appeal would be a "pivotal test" for free expression in the Chinese finance hub.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNA
4 hours ago
- CNA
Thailand's foreign ministry spokesman on whether there can be a ceasefire with Cambodia yet
Scroll up for the next video X Thailand's foreign ministry spokesman on whether there can be a ceasefire with Cambodia yet
CNA
5 hours ago
- CNA
Singapore could be ‘most perfect example' of a country that needs nuclear energy: IAEA chief
SINGAPORE: Singapore could be the 'most perfect example' of a country that needs nuclear energy given its territorial limitations, energy requirements, technological base and institutional maturity, said the director general of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Rafael Mariano Grossi on Friday (Jul 25). The chief of the United Nations' nuclear watchdog was in Singapore as part of the SR Nathan Fellowship, a high-level programme for foreign leaders and prominent individuals to visit the country. The country on Friday also renewed its agreement with the IAEA to help train experts from developing countries in nuclear research. Speaking during a lecture and question-and-answer session hosted by the newly launched Singapore Nuclear Research and Safety Institute at the National University of Singapore, Mr Grossi said that Singapore is prepared to host nuclear power 'relatively soon'. The Singapore government is looking at alternatives to gas, and nuclear energy stands out as one, he added, noting that Singapore has limitations when it comes to producing renewable energy. The country cannot produce hydropower and lacks the territory to produce enough wind or solar energy to meet its energy needs, he said. 'In my opinion, and in the opinion of many experts, in terms of the options, perhaps Singapore could rightly figure as the most perfect example of a country that needs nuclear energy, because with a very small nuclear power plant, you can have a level of energy density and production that you cannot match with anything else,' he said. Mr Grossi's impression is that Singapore will see its first nuclear power plant 'within a few years'. This may be a cooperative effort with the rest of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), he said. All the ASEAN countries are also looking into nuclear energy, though they are all looking into it in different ways since they have different systems and economies, he noted. 'All of them are saying, we want nuclear energy. How can we get it?' he said. 'And of course, Singapore with its technological base, with its institutional maturity, is ideally, I would say, prepared to host nuclear power relatively soon.' Mr Grossi highlighted one scenario where Singapore could collaborate with a neighbouring country on a nuclear power project. 'We have traditional, big nuclear power plants. Is this a good fit for Singapore? Perhaps Singapore in combination or in cooperation with another country in ASEAN, it's not impossible,' said Mr Grossi. Raising the example of the Krsko power plant in Slovenia that supplies energy to both Slovenia and Croatia, Mr Grossi noted that citizens from both countries work at the plant. 'It's a beautiful example of confidence building, good neighbourhood and intelligence applied to energy,' he said. Singapore and a few other neighbouring nations have made it clear that no decision has been made on whether to adopt nuclear energy, but the idea is being studied alongside other possible sustainable energy options. There are no nuclear-powered nations in ASEAN yet. GLOBAL NUCLEAR ENERGY TRENDS A new trend in nuclear energy is small modular reactors. While most are not in operation yet, these reactors are being licensed in many countries, including the United States, France, the United Kingdom and Argentina, said the IAEA's chief. 'They seem to be a very interesting option here,' he noted, adding that Africa also has 'enormous interest' in such reactors, since its grids are smaller or weaker and do not need big nuclear power plants. Climate scientists and experts have recognised that, in terms of climate change, decarbonisation without nuclear energy is 'practically utopian'. Subtracting the nuclear energy factor for big industrial economies that are heavily reliant on coal or fossil fuels will create a situation that is 'almost impossible to manage' if the world wants to achieve the emissions levels agreed upon in the Paris agreement, said Mr Grossi. He urged the audience to recognise nuclear energy's contribution to gradual decarbonisation, which the world is embarking on. 'Because we all know that this is a process that will take time. A quick phase-out of fossil fuel is impossible, as we know,' he added. Responding to a question about the cost of nuclear energy, Mr Grossi noted that nuclear energy is very capital-intensive at the beginning. This is why analysts say it is too expensive compared to solar or wind energy generators, he added. 'But when it comes to energy, cost is one factor. It is not the defining factor overall,' said Mr Grossi. For example, a country like Singapore has less space for solar energy farms, and big economies like the US will not be able to sustain themselves on only renewable energy, he noted. There are also political factors when it comes to cost, said the IAEA's chief, highlighting that it is important to subsidise clean energy. 'But nuclear energy has never benefited from any subsidy. So you need levelised cost of energy before you start making calculations,' he said. SAFETY CONCERNS AND GEOPOLITICS Mr Grossi also addressed the safety concerns that came with nuclear technology and nuclear energy. Responding to a question about Russia targeting nuclear power plants in Ukraine and whether the IAEA is concerned about similar scenarios in the future, Mr Grossi said: 'Of course, the fact that a nuclear power plant is caught in the middle of a war or a conflict is something that greatly concerns us.' This is why the UN Security Council established principles about how nuclear power plants should not be attacked or become military bases, indicating clearly that both sides should exercise 'maximum restraint', he added. 'Whether this is a trend or not, I suppose not. I think the problem here is the war, it's not the technology,' said Mr Grossi. Inviting the audience to think about this 'in military terms', he stressed that a power plant – a big piece of infrastructure – has an impact on the economy of the countries involved. 'It's like in law, you establish jurisprudence, precedent … Thanks to the example we have in the Zaporizhzhia crisis, if in the future we have a similar situation, we will have the authority and the capacity to intervene, because we did it once and because it worked,' he said. The Zaporizhzhia Nuclear Power Plant in southeastern Ukraine, which is Europe's largest nuclear power plant, was captured by Russian forces in March 2022. Mr Grossi also addressed a question from Israel's Ambassador to Singapore Eli Vered Hazan about how a nuclear Iran can be prevented. This boils down to the inspection regime that should be put in place for parties to the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT), said the IAEA's chief. Iran is a party to the treaty, though it has threatened to pull out before. Noting that Israel is not a party to the treaty, Mr Grossi said that all the countries that signed the agreement subject their facilities to a 'very stringent regime of inspections'. In Iran's case, the IAEA has been doing this with 'some successes and some failures', Mr Grossi said, adding that there were areas that were 'not entirely clear' for 'quite some time'. Reiterating what he said in June, Mr Grossi stressed that Iran does not have nuclear weapons and does not have a programme aimed at having nuclear weapons. 'But at the same time, they need to be accountable for everything they do because their programme is extremely big and very ambitious,' he added, noting that this increases the level of Iran's responsibilities. Iran has been found in breach of their obligations before, Mr Grossi added, noting that the IAEA is insisting that its inspectors return to Iran as soon as possible. 'This is what created a situation of concern, sometimes doubts about what was really going on in Iran. And most importantly, because we cannot undo the past, what happened happened, what we need now is to prevent further attacks or violence or situations like this,' he said. Noting that Iran has indicated that they will be ready to restart some conversations 'at a technical level', Mr Grossi added: 'I think we need to reengage in a normal relationship. It's not a matter of confidence or anything else. This is an obligation for as long as you are a party to the NPT.' DEALING WITH NUCLEAR WASTE Mr Grossi also responded to a question from the High Commissioner of South Africa to Singapore Charlotte Lobe about the disposal of radioactive waste and how to deal with the environmental impact of using nuclear energy. Highlighting that countries have been using nuclear power for more than 50 years, the IAEA's chief said: 'There has never been an accident or a problem with the nuclear waste.' This means that the world has technologically apt solutions for dealing with nuclear waste, he added. 'Important to be considered is that no country can have a nuclear power programme without a very clearly defined and agreed plan for the waste. You cannot simply start a nuclear power plant and then I will see what I do when the fuel has been burned and I have to put it somewhere,' said Mr Grossi. There are very clear methodologies to deal with nuclear waste that are used to 'great success'. Debates have been more centred around the long-term disposal of nuclear waste, which will hold a certain degree of radiation for hundreds or thousands of years, the IAEA chief noted. The amount of nuclear waste is 'extremely low', he stressed. 'We are not creating a mountain of nuclear waste that cannot be handled.' What countries normally do is they look for a place with a 'very stable geological situation' and then the waste is put in a container until it is no longer dangerous, said Mr Grossi. 'More important, we even check and inspect. We are the only industry that checks the rubbish,' he added, to laughter from the audience. Nuclear waste is inspected to ensure that it is not a radiation hazard and that it complies with nuclear non-proliferation measures, said Mr Grossi, who added that it is important to explain decisions to the public and to be accountable for them.
Straits Times
6 hours ago
- Straits Times
China must strike delicate balance in its approach towards Thai-Cambodian conflict, say analysts
Smoke is pictured in the air as a multi-rocket launcher is fired near the Cambodia-Thailand border in Oddar Meanchey province, on July 25. CHONGQING – China faces a delicate balancing act as it decides what role it should play in the ongoing border hostilities between Thailand and Cambodia, two Southeast-Asian nations that are its close neighbours and which it wields strong influence over. Analysts told The Straits Times that while the clash, which began on July 24 and has so far reportedly left at least 16 dead, could present an opportunity for China to showcase its leadership in the region, the world's second-largest economy is likely to keep to its traditional approach of having the two countries resolve the matter on their own. It is also likely to first look to Asean as it assesses how it can best help the process along. But that does not mean that China will not attempt to bring both countries to the negotiating table as the conflict is happening in its neighbourhood, said Professor Fan Lei, an expert on China-Asean relations at China's Charhar Institute, a international relations thinktank. Asean is China's largest trading partner, representing 16.6 per cent of the world's second-largest economy's overall foreign trade. Total trade between Asean and China reached 1.71 trillion yuan (S$306.26 billion) in 2024, up 7.1 per cent from 2023. Analysts pointed to how China can play a bigger role in the dispute between Thailand and Cambodia, given that China is both countries' top trading partner, and thus wields strong economic influence over both states. Thailand relies on Chinese imports such as machinery, electronics and vehicles. Chinese visitors are also Thailand's top source of foreign tourists. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore SMRT to pay lower fine of $2.4m for EWL disruption; must invest at least $600k to boost reliability Singapore MRT service changes needed to modify 3 East-West Line stations on Changi Airport stretch: LTA Asia Live: Thailand-Cambodia border clashes continue for second day Singapore Lung damage, poor brain development, addiction: What vaping does to the body Life 'Do you kill children?': Even before independence, S'pore has always loved its over-the-top campaigns Singapore S'pore could have nuclear energy 'within a few years', if it decides on it: UN nuclear watchdog chief Singapore Fine for couple whose catering companies owed $432,000 in salaries to 103 employees Singapore Kopi, care and conversation: How this 20-year-old helps improve the well-being of the elderly Meanwhile, bilateral trade between Cambodia and China grew 26.9 per cent in the first six months of 2025, compared with the same period in 2024, official data from Cambodia showed. China is a major investor in both Thailand and Cambodia in sectors such as electric vehicles, infrastructure and real estate. China also conducts separate military exercises with Cambodia and Thailand. In April, Chinese-sponsored upgrades to Ream Naval Base in Cambodia raised concerns about China's growing footprint in South-east Asia. But China has to tread a delicate balance. On the one hand, 'China may feel that it should not just sit idly by and do nothing if such military conflict is in its neighbourhood', said Associate Professor Li Mingjiang, an expert on Chinese foreign policy and regional security at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies. On the other hand, it has to be mindful not to 'leave the impression it is disregarding Asean', said Professor Zhu Feng, dean at the School of International Studies at Nanjing University. Already, countries in South-east Asia are wary of China's expanding influence in the region – and its clashes with the Philippines over maritime territorial claims – as they navigate an increasingly complex geopolitical landscape amid intense US-China rivalry. That is why China is most likely to conduct 'quiet and informal mediation', Prof Li said, adding that he believes 'Chinese diplomats may already be involved in discussions with Cambodia and Thailand, urging them to de-escalate and engage in talks'. Professor Gu Jiayun, vice-dean at the School of Asian Studies at Beijing Foreign Studies University, said: 'It is in China's interest to keep the peace among its neighbours, given that conflict can hurt the region's as well as its own development prospects.' Prof Gu said that both Thailand and Cambodia have 'shown restraint in the clash so far, so they might be looking for an out to start negotiations'. Publicly, Thailand has rejected mediation efforts from third countries to end the ongoing conflict. However, it has signalled that the door will be kept open for Asean to facilitate a return to bilateral negotiations with Cambodia. Phnom Penh has written to the United Nations for help – the first time in more than a decade that an Asean member state has made such a request. The latest border dispute escalated sharply on July 24 after a Thai F-16 fighter jet bombed targets in Cambodia on July 24. Tensions between Thailand and Cambodia have been steaming since May, when a Cambodian soldier was killed during a brief exchange of gunfire near the border in north-eastern Thailand. Both countries – which share a long history of border disputes that date back to France's occupation of Cambodia until 1953 – have blamed each other for the latest escalation, and downgraded their diplomatic ties on July 23. During a meeting between Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi and Asean secretary-general Kao Kim Hourn in Beijing on July 25, Mr Wang said that China 'stands ready to continue playing a constructive role in easing tensions (between Thailand and Cambodia) and de-escalating the situation in an impartial and fair manner'. Calling the latest deadly clash 'distressing and concerning', Mr Wang added: 'China appreciates and supports the proactive mediation efforts of the Asean Chair and encourages the 'Asean Way' to promote dialogue and political resolution.' Asean's fundamental principles include mutual respect for the sovereignty of all nations, non-interference in the internal affairs of member states, peaceful settlement of disputes, and renunciation of the threat or use of force. On July 24, a Chinese foreign ministry spokesman told reporters at a regular briefing that 'China has and will continue to promote talks (between the two Asean states) for peace in its own way and play a constructive role in promoting de-escalation'. Prof Fan said that China is likely to draw Cambodia and Thailand into negotiations with economic ways. This would be in line with the Chinese government's emphasis on cooperative win-win partnerships and non-interference principles regarding foreign diplomacy that are part of China's Three Global Initiatives, he added. 'It is also a possibility that China might encourage Thailand and Cambodia to resolve their dispute at Hong Kong's new international mediation body,' Prof Fan said. China signed on May 30 a convention to set up an international organisation for mediation in Hong Kong to resolve cross-border disputes among countries and international companies that Beijing hopes can match up to the UN's International Court of Justice. Analysts noted that China's actions will be a test of its diplomatic strength in the region. Prof Li said that China has been signalling that 'it does want to gradually play a slightly larger role in the region' that goes beyond traditional security issues. President Xi's first overseas trip in 2025 amid growing trade tensions with the US was to South-east Asia, where he visited Malaysia, Cambodia and Vietnam for a week in April. Prof Li said: 'The conflict between Cambodia and Thailand could be an opportunity for China to try out its limited role so far in addressing the security issues in the Mekong region, cautiously, quietly and informally, of course.'
