
Man who beat his ‘free spirit' friend to death sentenced to life
A 'remorseless' killer beat his friend to death with a hammer and left him wrapped in carpet underlay in a dog pen in his back garden, the
Central Criminal Court
has heard.
When gardaí found Shane Knott's body in the back garden of Padraig Delaney's home, the deceased was unrecognisable and had to be identified through his DNA.
A jury in Tullamore found Delaney (44) guilty of murder earlier this year, rejecting his claim that he acted in self-defence.
Delaney, of The Lane, Eustace Demesne, Naas, Co Kildare had pleaded not guilty to the murder of Shane Knott (37) at Delaney's home between April 3rd and April 14th, 2024.
READ MORE
The trial heard that Delaney's brother, Tadhg Delaney, was murdered in Tallaght in November 2023. Nobody has been charged with his murder, and the investigation is ongoing.
Delaney told gardaí that he believed the Kinahan crime organisation was involved in his brother's murder and had sent Mr Knott to kill him.
Sentencing Delaney (44) to life imprisonment on Monday, Mr Justice Paul Burns described Delaney's claims that he acted in self-defence as a 'self-serving fabrication' which was rightly rejected by the jury.
In a victim impact statement, the deceased's mother, Catherine Fitzsimons, said her son was subjected to 'deliberate and devastating violence at the hands of a man he once called his friend.'
She said she had twice reported her son missing in April 2023, not knowing he was already dead. He was, she said: 'Left alone, hidden away, denied dignity even in death.'
She said she first heard confirmation that the body found at Delaney's home was her son through a media report. 'Not from a knock on the door or a phone call but from a news article; that moment was indescribably cruel,' she said.
Her son's injuries were so severe that she was not allowed to see his face. Denied the right to say goodbye, she said she will never forget holding her son's 'cold hand' while the rest of his body was covered with a body bag.
She said Delaney has offered no apology or sign of remorse and put the family through the pain of a trial in which they had to relive her son's final hours 'moment by moment'.
Mr Knott, she said, was 'far from perfect', but he was deeply loved and a 'free spirit' who dreamed of starting his life over in America. The family attended his cremation on what should have been his 37th birthday.
Ms Fitzsimons said she no longer lives, but survives. 'Each day begins with silence and sorrow, and I ask the questions that will never be answered: Did he know he was alone? Did he feel afraid? Did he suffer? These thoughts are with me every day, they do not fade.'
Inspector Paul O'Reilly told prosecution counsel Seoirse Ó Dúnlaing SC that Mr Knott lived a 'transient life' and on April 3rd, 2024 had been detained at Naas Garda station for a robbery offence. He received station bail and went to Delaney's house, where he would stay occasionally.
Four days later, Mr Knott's mother reported her son missing. On April 14th, Delaney told his father there was a body in his back garden. He claimed he had defended himself after Mr Knott attacked him with a pair of scissors.
Delaney's father alerted gardaí, and they found Mr Knott's body in the back garden in a dog pen wrapped in carpet underlay. A pathologist's report confirmed that he suffered multiple head and brain injuries consistent with a violent and sustained attack with a blunt weapon, such as a hammer.
'The entire left side of his face was crushed', Inspector O'Reilly said.
In Garda interviews, Delaney said he and Mr Knott had been drinking and playing chess on the Tuesday evening and fell asleep. The next morning at about 10 o'clock, he claimed Mr Knott 'came at' him with scissors and said: 'I'm going to do what I came here for.'
He said he struck Mr Knott in the head with a claw hammer three or four times in self-defence. Inspector O'Reilly said there was no basis for Delaney's claim that a 'high-ranking member of the Kinahan organisation' had sent Mr Knott to kill him.
He said there was also no link between the murder of Delaney's brother, Tadhg, and Mr Knott's murder.
Inspector O'Reilly said Delaney is originally from Clondalkin and trained as a cabinet maker. He was homeless for a time and had a history of alcohol and substance abuse. He has previous convictions for intoxication in public, common assault and criminal damage.
Before passing sentence, Mr Justice Burns said Delaney's accounts of what happened were a 'self-serving fabrication' that a jury had rejected. 'This was not self-defence, but was murder,' the judge said.
The killing was 'particularly brutal' and the treatment of Mr Knott's body was 'callous and disrespectful'.
The judge said Mr Knott was clearly loved and he expressed his condolences to the family.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Australian accused in mushroom murders trial disputes accounts of fatal lunch
An Australian woman accused of the murder of three elderly relatives of her estranged husband by feeding them poisonous mushrooms has disputed accounts of the fatal lunch given by other witnesses, a court heard. Erin Patterson (50), is charged with the July 2023 murders of her mother-in-law Gail Patterson, father-in-law Donald Patterson and Gail's sister, Heather Wilkinson, along with the attempted murder of Ian Wilkinson, Heather's husband. The prosecution accuses her of knowingly serving the guests death cap mushrooms as part of a Beef Wellington at her home in Leongatha, a town of about 6,000 people some 135km from Melbourne. She denies the charges, which carry a life sentence, with her defence calling the deaths a 'terrible accident'. READ MORE On Ms Patterson's third day of cross-examination, prosecution lawyer Nanette Rogers asked whether she had lied about serving herself on a plate of a different colour from those of her guests, which the prosecution says she did to avoid the poison. 'I suggest that this description that you gave to the jury of the plates you used at the lunch is a lie. Correct or incorrect?' Ms Rogers said. 'Incorrect,' the accused replied. In his evidence, Ian Wilkinson, the sole surviving guest from the lunch, whose recovery took months in hospital, had said Ms Patterson served herself on a plate of a different colour. Ms Patterson's estranged husband, Simon Patterson, previously testified that Heather Wilkinson had remarked on the different coloured plates before she died. Erin Patterson also disputed an account by her son, who said in his evidence he had not seen her repeatedly visit the bathroom as a result of also becoming sick after the meal. The defence's decision to call Erin Patterson as a witness has re-ignited interest in the trial that began in late April. Media have descended on the town of Morwell where the trial is being held, about two hours east of Melbourne. State broadcaster ABC's daily podcast on the trial is currently Australia's most popular, while many domestic newspapers have run live blogs. Ms Patterson is currently in her sixth day of giving evidence and her third day of cross-examination by Ms Rogers. The prosecution rested its case on June 2nd after a month of evidence from relatives and medical, forensic and mushroom experts. The trial, expected to conclude this month, continues. (c) Copyright Thomson Reuters 2025


Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Death of Garda Kevin Flatley a ‘stark' reminder of risks facing members of force
The death of Garda Kevin Flatley was a 'stark' reminder of the risks gardaí face while on duty, Garda Commissioner Drew Harris will tell the Oireachtas justice committee later. Mr Harris, who is due to brief TDs and senators about the force's operations, community policing and road safety, will use an appearance before an Oireachtas committee to 'reiterate the importance of responsible driver behaviour'. Garda Flatley, a 49-year-old father of two, was killed on duty last month while policing a speed checkpoint duty near Swords, Dublin. Izzet Can Berber, the motorcyclist involved in the collision in which Garda Flatley was fatally injured, died in hospital last week from his injuries . READ MORE 'The recent loss of our colleague Garda Kevin Flatley served as a stark reminder of the risks our gardaí face while on duty, but also put into sharp focus the dangers that exist on our roads today,' Mr Harris will tell the committee. He will note that despite 'significant roads policing enforcement', there had been 70 road deaths so far this year as of June 5th. 'And so, I want to reiterate the importance of responsible driver behaviour,' he will say. 'I appeal to all road users – in the interest of their safety and those around them – that they slow down, never drive under the influence of an intoxicant, wear a safety belt, and never use a mobile phone while driving.' The committee will also hear the commissioner defend the staff retention rate in An Garda Síochána . He will argue that the rate of resignations from the force is below those in the UK and some European police forces. Mr Harris will also stress that the Garda's new operating model, the first time the structure of the force has changed since the 1920s, has been a success – particularly for survivors of domestic violence. He will also tell the committee that there have so far been 12 prosecutions under a stalking law enacted last year.

Irish Times
13 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘It's much bigger than football': Sligo Rovers launches coaching programme with prisoners at Loughan House
'Football brings everyone together,' says Conor O'Grady, the head of academy at Sligo Rovers Football Club and part-time coach at one of Ireland's two open prisons. Over the past month, on an AstroTurf pitch overlooking Cavan's share of Lough MacNean, O'Grady has been putting on weekly training sessions for prisoners at Loughan House. It is building up to a showpiece finale: a match played at Rovers' home stadium, the Showgrounds. 'No matter what your background is or where you are, everyone who plays football has that genuine love,' O'Grady adds. 'The majority of these lads have a real affection for football. You come down here and you're back to being an 11 or 12-year-old or whatever again.' There are no security checks as you drive into Co Cavan's Loughan House, an open prison holding up to 153 men who face minimal restrictions on movement and activities. READ MORE Lee, a prisoner at Loughan House Open Centre in Blacklion, Co Cavan, where Sligo Rovers are running coaching sessions. Photograph: Bryan O'Brien Visitors, often locals from the nearby village of Blacklion, are welcome to use the coffee shop, car wash and polytunnels, all of which are manned by prisoners. Many of the men in the centre have spent time in closed prisons and are coming to the end of their sentences. This is a place to readjust and regain some independence. 'Anyone can make a mistake and end up in prison,' says governor Mark Lydon. 'I could have a 19 or 20-year-old. Our job is to try to give people the skills, the ability, the knowledge and the confidence that when they're released, they can go into their community, get a job and start to live their life again. Hopefully, people leave here and they've got a chance.' Lee*, a prisoner, has always been involved in football – at schoolboys' level with Shelbourne and Bohemians, and as a coach with local sides as the years went on. He was one of the representatives for Loughan House at Sligo Rovers' integration tournament a few weeks ago, which featured a host of teams from marginalised communities. The prisoners won out handily, sparking this series of training sessions. Conor O'Grady (centre), head of academy at Sligo Rovers, with prisoners of Loughan House Open Centre in Blacklion, Co Cavan. Photograph: Bryan O'Brien Prisoners of Loughan House Open Centre with (from left) Conor O'Grady and Jamie Murphy of Sligo Rovers and prison officer Michael Slator. Photograph: Bryan O'Brien 'Some days in here can be long,' Lee says. 'Some days can be good and on your good days, it's all right. When you have something to look forward to each week, it makes things a lot easier. When things are competitive and they're done in the right way, it's really good football-wise. There's people going to the gym that normally wouldn't go to the gym because they want to get fit for games that are coming up. 'There's no tension in an open jail,' he adds. 'Everybody is getting ready to either get out or they're going to work. There's a lot of positivity. In a main jail, it's a lot different to that.' David*, a team-mate of Lee's in that integration tournament, also has a history of being involved with team sports and coaching. He describes himself as the elder statesman in a very strong squad. The coaches from Sligo Rovers agree that the standard of football among the prisoners is very high. Sport and exercise are central to a more autonomous lifestyle in Loughan House, but so too are the many opportunities prisoners are afforded to re-socialise and reskill in advance of release. There are accredited courses and workshops in construction, motor mechanics, cleaning and laundry. Educational units teach soft skills such as art, languages and maths. 'You can see it even when the guys land here,' David says. 'It takes a few weeks to adjust to that bit of extra freedom. Having that responsibility for yourself. To be back in when you need to be and you're not in behind the door which is the hardest part, as you can imagine, of prison.' David, a prisoner at Loughan House Open Centre. Photograph: Bryan O'Brien Loughan House in Blacklion, Co Cavan, where Sligo Rovers are running coaching sessions and disability in sport workshops with some of the prisoners. Photograph: Bryan O'Brien Jamie Murphy has been Sligo Rovers' football and social responsibility officer for about a year. As one of only two fully fan-owned clubs in the top tier of the League of Ireland, community programmes are central to its model. Murphy has been crucial in establishing refugee football, disability teams, a Down syndrome (DS) team and walking football for older people. A women's social football programme has just begun and is already at full capacity. 'A big part of the work we do is trying to make sure we create as many playing and non-playing opportunities for as many communities as we can, with a particular focus on groups that might be marginalised or have experienced exclusion of some type,' Murphy says. 'This is right in with what we're trying to do.' Attendances and interest around the League of Ireland have skyrocketed in recent years and a number of people are engaging with domestic club football here for the first time. Social inclusion initiatives can act as catalysts for communities to rally around their local clubs, both for those that are directly involved and for people who hear about positive work being done. 'The first thing Jamie set up was the DS team,' Conor O'Grady says. 'I spoke to a couple of parents [of players on the team], and they had never been inside the Showgrounds. They had no reason really for going to the Showgrounds, and now they don't miss a game. As well as all these things being community-based, we're actually bringing in new supporters to the club and we're engaging with a lot of different people from different backgrounds.' Conor O'Grady, Head of Academy at Sligo Rovers, with prisoners of Loughan House Open Centre in Blacklion, Co Cavan. Photograph: Bryan O'Brien Prisoners at Loughan House Open Centre in Blacklion, Co Cavan. Photograph: Bryan O'Brien There is an educational element to the project at Loughan House, with the programme also featuring a workshop on sport and disability. Murphy's work tends to take a long-term view, offering placements or work experience beyond participation in an initial course. Players from Rovers' refugee groups have regularly gone on to become volunteers or stewards at the club. 'Football sometimes is the hook that we use,' Murphy says. 'It's much bigger than football ... We're chatting to the players the last few weeks and we're finding out a bit about their background and what they've done in life. How much they have to contribute to society when they leave Loughan House. 'They've played at good levels in different sports. They've done coaching. They've achieved in different areas, and they have something positive to contribute once they leave. That's what this programme is about as well – trying to encourage them to do that.' *The identity of the prisoners has been protected