logo
Man who beat his ‘free spirit' friend to death sentenced to life

Man who beat his ‘free spirit' friend to death sentenced to life

Irish Times12-05-2025

A 'remorseless' killer beat his friend to death with a hammer and left him wrapped in carpet underlay in a dog pen in his back garden, the
Central Criminal Court
has heard.
When gardaí found Shane Knott's body in the back garden of Padraig Delaney's home, the deceased was unrecognisable and had to be identified through his DNA.
A jury in Tullamore found Delaney (44) guilty of murder earlier this year, rejecting his claim that he acted in self-defence.
Delaney, of The Lane, Eustace Demesne, Naas, Co Kildare had pleaded not guilty to the murder of Shane Knott (37) at Delaney's home between April 3rd and April 14th, 2024.
READ MORE
The trial heard that Delaney's brother, Tadhg Delaney, was murdered in Tallaght in November 2023. Nobody has been charged with his murder, and the investigation is ongoing.
Delaney told gardaí that he believed the Kinahan crime organisation was involved in his brother's murder and had sent Mr Knott to kill him.
Sentencing Delaney (44) to life imprisonment on Monday, Mr Justice Paul Burns described Delaney's claims that he acted in self-defence as a 'self-serving fabrication' which was rightly rejected by the jury.
In a victim impact statement, the deceased's mother, Catherine Fitzsimons, said her son was subjected to 'deliberate and devastating violence at the hands of a man he once called his friend.'
She said she had twice reported her son missing in April 2023, not knowing he was already dead. He was, she said: 'Left alone, hidden away, denied dignity even in death.'
She said she first heard confirmation that the body found at Delaney's home was her son through a media report. 'Not from a knock on the door or a phone call but from a news article; that moment was indescribably cruel,' she said.
Her son's injuries were so severe that she was not allowed to see his face. Denied the right to say goodbye, she said she will never forget holding her son's 'cold hand' while the rest of his body was covered with a body bag.
She said Delaney has offered no apology or sign of remorse and put the family through the pain of a trial in which they had to relive her son's final hours 'moment by moment'.
Mr Knott, she said, was 'far from perfect', but he was deeply loved and a 'free spirit' who dreamed of starting his life over in America. The family attended his cremation on what should have been his 37th birthday.
Ms Fitzsimons said she no longer lives, but survives. 'Each day begins with silence and sorrow, and I ask the questions that will never be answered: Did he know he was alone? Did he feel afraid? Did he suffer? These thoughts are with me every day, they do not fade.'
Inspector Paul O'Reilly told prosecution counsel Seoirse Ó Dúnlaing SC that Mr Knott lived a 'transient life' and on April 3rd, 2024 had been detained at Naas Garda station for a robbery offence. He received station bail and went to Delaney's house, where he would stay occasionally.
Four days later, Mr Knott's mother reported her son missing. On April 14th, Delaney told his father there was a body in his back garden. He claimed he had defended himself after Mr Knott attacked him with a pair of scissors.
Delaney's father alerted gardaí, and they found Mr Knott's body in the back garden in a dog pen wrapped in carpet underlay. A pathologist's report confirmed that he suffered multiple head and brain injuries consistent with a violent and sustained attack with a blunt weapon, such as a hammer.
'The entire left side of his face was crushed', Inspector O'Reilly said.
In Garda interviews, Delaney said he and Mr Knott had been drinking and playing chess on the Tuesday evening and fell asleep. The next morning at about 10 o'clock, he claimed Mr Knott 'came at' him with scissors and said: 'I'm going to do what I came here for.'
He said he struck Mr Knott in the head with a claw hammer three or four times in self-defence. Inspector O'Reilly said there was no basis for Delaney's claim that a 'high-ranking member of the Kinahan organisation' had sent Mr Knott to kill him.
He said there was also no link between the murder of Delaney's brother, Tadhg, and Mr Knott's murder.
Inspector O'Reilly said Delaney is originally from Clondalkin and trained as a cabinet maker. He was homeless for a time and had a history of alcohol and substance abuse. He has previous convictions for intoxication in public, common assault and criminal damage.
Before passing sentence, Mr Justice Burns said Delaney's accounts of what happened were a 'self-serving fabrication' that a jury had rejected. 'This was not self-defence, but was murder,' the judge said.
The killing was 'particularly brutal' and the treatment of Mr Knott's body was 'callous and disrespectful'.
The judge said Mr Knott was clearly loved and he expressed his condolences to the family.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Sacked financial adviser wins €48,000 at WRC
Sacked financial adviser wins €48,000 at WRC

Irish Times

time41 minutes ago

  • Irish Times

Sacked financial adviser wins €48,000 at WRC

A financial adviser who said she 'never made' purported remarks that her employer called an 'instantly sackable offence' and was not given a chance to address the claims has won over €48,000 for unfair dismissal. A Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) adjudicator found the employee was denied any opportunity to 'challenge her accusers' on serious bullying allegations when she was sacked in July 2024 without being given the precise details of what was alleged against her. The employee, Caitriona Nic Aodha, secured the sum on foot of complaints under the Unfair Dismissals Act 1977 and the Minimum Notice and Terms of Employment Act 1973 against AFS Wealth Management and Insurance Advisers Ltd, which trades as Abbey Wealth. Ms Nic Aodha had worked at the company as a financial adviser earning €45,000 per annum plus commission for around three and a half years when it was bought out by new management in February 2022, the WRC heard. READ MORE On Wednesday 24th January 2024, she arranged for a meeting human resources the following day with a view to file a grievance alleging 'bullying' by Vesper France, the chief executive officer's (CEO) wife and office manager, she said. At 8.59am the following morning, she told the WRC, she received an email from the company's CEO, Victor France, and found herself locked out of the company systems two minutes later. Mr France gave evidence that he received a phone call from an employee identified only as 'Ms E'. This worker told him about alleged remarks by Ms Nic Aodha to the effect that the business would 'go bust', Mr France said. He said Ms E also recounted an allegedly 'disturbing conversation' with Ms Nic Aodha about a medical issue suffered by Ms E, which Ms E was upset about. Mr France said he was 'very angry' about this and considered it an 'instantly sackable offence' – and decided to suspend Ms Nic Aodha on full pay after consulting with his HR advisers. Ms E's complaint 'led to a number of other complaints' from other employees, he added. The tribunal heard that Ms France, the CEO's wife, filed a human resources (HR) complaint of her own against Ms Nic Aodha on 7 February 2024, alleging the complainant was 'hostile' with her, 'mimicked' her in one meeting, and had made a 'demand' for €25,000 'in her bank account by the end of the week as a loyalty reward'. After nearly six months on suspension with no apparent progress, Ms Nic Aodha wrote to Mr France on 17th June. She told him she had made 'countless attempts' to engage with him and that the CEO had been 'rude and abrupt' in response. She wrote that on the date of her correspondence he had told her: 'I'm not in the mood for this,' and hung up on her. Mr France dismissed her by email a month later, telling her the company investigation had concluded she had committed gross misconduct. Mr France's initial evidence to the WRC was that it was his understanding that Ms Nic Aodha spoke to an investigator before her sacking. At a later point in the proceedings, the tribunal noted, he said he wished to 'correct the record' and said he was 'incorrect' in this belief and accepted he had 'no knowledge' of what happened, the decision recorded. When Mr France's evidence about her purported remarks was put to Ms Nic Aodha, she said she 'never made the alleged comments'. Questioned on her efforts to find new work after her dismissal, Ms Nic Aodha said she had applied for 'approximately 2,000 jobs' between August 2024 and the WRC hearings this spring. She said that she was putting six or seven hours a day into looking for work in the financial services sector and beyond, and had attended 30 interviews to no avail. Ms Nic Aodha's evidence was that when she was asked about leaving her old employment in the course of her job search, she had answered with the truth, that she was 'dismissed for gross misconduct'. She told the commission the effort was 'becoming soul-destroying' and that she 'eased off' on the job hunt between November 2024 and January 2025. Adjudication officer John Harraghy wrote in his decision that anyone facing a disciplinary process had the right to a 'full and fair opportunity to state his or her case' and to 'challenge his or her accusers'. Mr Harraghy wrote that Ms Nic Aodha's had approached her job search with the required 'resolve' in the circumstances of the case and had eased off at points because it was 'strenuous and futile'. These rights 'cannot be ignored' with a worker facing dismissal as a sanction, but had been denied to Ms Nic Aodha, he wrote. She was sacked without notice without being given the specifics of the allegations against her or involving her in either an investigation or a disciplinary process, he noted. He rejected Ms Murphy's argument that the 2,000 job applications in the period were not enough and wrote that the manner of the claimant's dismissal created 'difficulties' in finding new work, though it had not been a 'complete barrier'. Upholding her complaint under the Unfair Dismissals Act 1977, he directed the company to pay her €45,000 in compensation. The award for unfair dismissal reflected a loss of earnings of €35,465 during the period Ms Nic Aodha spent out of work, a further €7,500 for the loss of statutory redundancy entitlements, and a further €2,500 relating to pension benefits. The WRC also directed the payment of a further €3,460, four weeks' salary, for the notice pay denied to Ms Nic Aodha when the company purported to terminate her for gross misconduct. Nicola Murphy of Peninsula Business Services appeared for the company before the WRC, while Ms Nic Aodha represented herself as a lay litigant.

Senior gardaí warn Kinahan cartel members of ‘serious life choices' ahead
Senior gardaí warn Kinahan cartel members of ‘serious life choices' ahead

Irish Times

timean hour ago

  • Irish Times

Senior gardaí warn Kinahan cartel members of ‘serious life choices' ahead

Senior figures in the Kinahan cartel who remain at large, mainly in Dubai, are in a 'perilous position' as the State has already secured significant policing results that 'people said couldn't be done', Garda Commissioner Drew Harris has said. Deputy Commissioner Justin Kelly, who is in charge of security-related policing including organised crime, said senior and junior cartel members had 'significant life choices' to make in the months ahead. Rewards amounting to $15 million (€13 million) from US law enforcement remain available for information that would lead to the arrest and conviction of cartel founder Christy Kinahan and his sons, Daniel and Christopher Jnr Many people linked to them needed to now carefully consider their options, gardaí said. READ MORE Mr Harris and Mr Kelly were speaking just over a week after the wanted cartel figure, Seán McGovern , was extradited from the United Arab Emirates (UAE) to Ireland to face charges over alleged crimes linked to the Kinahan-Hutch feud. The charges include murder, directing a crime gang and enhancing the capabilities of a crime gang. McGovern last October became the first cartel member to be arrested in Dubai. He is the first Irish person ever extradited from the UAE to the Republic. His extradition became possible after a once-off agreement was reached between the UAE and Ireland. A permanent extradition agreement between the two states came into force for future cases last month. An Air Corp plane carrying Sean McGovern lands at Baldonnell in Dublin last week after his extradition from Dubai. Photograph: Alan Betson Mr Harris said the relationship the Garda had built with Dubai Police was strong and had resulted in Dubai aiding the extradition and 'providing us with information' about cartel members. He and Mr Kelly stressed that even minor players in the cartel's activities had information that could secure the US reward money. 'I want to remind others in the Kinahan organised crime gang of the perilous position that they're now in,' said Mr Harris told reporters in Dublin on Monday. 'Ourselves and other law enforcement are fixed on them, fixed on bringing them to justice, all of them to justice. 'So all of them should be worried and they should be thinking of the choices, serious life choices, that are now ahead of them in respect of what they do over the coming months.' A poster offering rewards for information that would lead to the conviction of any of the three Kinahans or for significant information that could degrade the cartel Almost two years ago, The Irish Times revealed a Garda investigation had been concluded into the alleged activities in Ireland of the cartel's leadership team based in Dubai, with a file sent to the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP). Some of the leadership figures were also investigated for their alleged roles in the 2016 Kinahan-Hutch feud murder of Eddie Hutch. He was the brother of Gerry Hutch, known as The Monk, who was named in Garda evidence to the High Court as the main protagonist in the feud on the Hutch side. However, when asked whether any directions on criminal charges had been received from the DPP relating to those investigations, Mr Harris said he could not provide a running commentary on such matters. Mr Kelly said he had previously made clear the Garda would be 'relentless in our pursuit' of cartel members and others involved in organised crime. Going to another country, even one with no extradition agreement in place, did not offer them safety, he added. 'It doesn't matter where in the world they are,' he said. 'We've absolutely dismantled two of the organised crime groups here in Dublin. At one stage we had 47 members of one group in jail,' Mr Kelly added, in reference to the Byrne organised crime group, which ran the cartel's operation in Ireland, though he did not name them. Deputy Garda Commissioner Justin Kelly, who is in charge of security-related policing including organised crime. Photograph: Colin Keegan/Collins Anyone who was involved in organised crime, or was just becoming involved, needed to be aware of the response they would be met with. 'The reality facing you is the full force of the State against you; investigations by specialist investigators, prosecutions, many of these cases in the Special Criminal Court. And there's been numerous lengthy sentences handed out for drugs, firearms,' Mr Kelly said. 'We now have substantial legislation around organised crime; directing and facilitating organised crime. So there's a huge range of powers we have.' For many of those jailed in recent years, the Criminal Assets Bureau (Cab) had followed up by seizing their homes and other assets. The 'events of the last week' – a reference to the McGovern extradition – offered a clear demonstration of 'the absolute relentlessness' of the approach now being pursued by the Garda, he added.

Kinahan cartel leaders 'should be worried' after extradition of senior lieutenant
Kinahan cartel leaders 'should be worried' after extradition of senior lieutenant

Irish Examiner

timean hour ago

  • Irish Examiner

Kinahan cartel leaders 'should be worried' after extradition of senior lieutenant

The Garda Commissioner said the leaders of the Kinahan cartel in Dubai 'should be worried' after senior lieutenant Sean McGovern was extradited from there to Ireland to face gangland charges. Drew Harris urged members, both junior and senior, in the cartel — who are either at large or in jail — to think about whether or not to help gardaí in their efforts to bring the leaders to justice. Mr Harris was commenting on the transfer over a week ago of McGovern — seen as the right-hand man of cartel leader Daniel Kinahan — by gardaí and military pilots from Dubai. He was brought to the Criminal Courts of Justice to be charged with directing and facilitating an organised crime group and with a Kinahan-Hutch feud murder. Speaking in Garda Headquarters in Phoenix Park, Mr Harris said the leaders, who are still in Dubai, should be in fear they will be next. 'Yes, they should be worried," he said. "They should have been worried now for a number of years because there's huge investigative effort and international investigative effort has gone into the Kinahan organised crime gang.' He said a lot of comments of what 'couldn't be done have been done' and a legal extradition had happened. Mr Harris said because of the cooperation of police in Dubai and legal authorities in the UAE, 'we've seen an individual extradited back to Ireland to face justice here'. Mr Harris reminded other members of the cartel they are in a bind, but there are options for them, in terms of cooperating with gardaí. He said: 'I'd also like to point out too, the other senior lieutenants in the Kinahan organised crime group, who are now facing justice or who are now imprisoned, the sanctions and the rewards still stand — there's $15m there of reward money through the federal law enforcement authorities of the US, so that is still in play. I just want to remind other members of the Kinahan organised crime gang the perilous position they are now in, that ourselves and other law enforcement are fixed on them and are fixed on bringing them, all of them, to justice. 'So, all of them should be worried and thinking about the choices, the serious life choices that are now ahead of them in respect of what to do over the coming months.' Deputy Commissioner, Security, Governance and Strategy, Justin Kelly said a couple of years ago, when he was Assistant Commissioner, Operations and Security, both he and the commissioner had said gardaí would be 'relentless', and the extradition of McGovern was 'absolute evidence' of that. He said the 'exact same' applied to other transnational crime gangs. Referring to the Kinahan cartel, he said at one point there were 47 members of it in jail. Mr Kelly also called on Kinahan lieutenants to have a 'really good think' about what choices they make in the coming months.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store