Tynwald rejects majority of proposed Legislative Council reforms
The majority of of proposed reforms to Legislative Council election procedures have been rejected by Tynwald members.Julie Edge MHK had suggested changes including MLCs serving for a maximum of two terms and not being permitted to take on roles in government departments.She said her proposals would improve "transparency", but only one measure - which would see candidates declare their interests before elections - was backed.Newly elected council member Gary Clueit described the motion as "flawed", and said the parliament had "far more urgent matters" to focus on, such as housing and health.
The Legislative Council is primarily a revising chamber for new laws made on the island and its members are voted in by the House of Keys.Edge's motion also suggested candidates should need the support of at least 20 members of the public to be proposed and serving MLCs should be required to step down before seeking election to the House of Keys.She said argued the proposals would bring the MLC election process "more closely in line with how an MHK has to be elected".
Public comment
During the two hour debate, Clueit said he believed MHK's workloads would increase "appreciably" if MLCs were not allowed to serve on government departments.He also said any reduction of the duties of an MLC "would surely also lead to additional public comment and speculation" on the role and its basic annual salary of £71,659.Fellow MLC Paul Craine asked why full use would not be made of the "wealth of qualifications, knowledge and extensive experience" of council members elected by MHKsThe parliament chose to throw out most of the suggested measures but agreed candidates should be required to declare their interests before a council election takes place.Edge said she saw this move as "a big step forward and win for transparency". The Clerk of Tynwald said the implementation of the change was now "a matter for the House of Keys Standing Orders Committee to consider".
Read more stories from the Isle of Man on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Isle of Man on Facebook and X.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
02-06-2025
- BBC News
Opportunity to comment on Douglas and Onchan 20mph proposals
Detailed plans for the latest round of a scheme to introduce lower speed limits in residential areas have been put out for consultation. The move, brought forward by the Department of Infrastructure, will see the 20mph (32km) limits implemented in built up areas across the island over the next 18 living in Douglas and Onchan have been given until 4 July to submit feedback on the proposals for those areas ahead of the continuation of the Minister Michelle Haywood said her department was not to asking "whether there would be reduced speed limits, but which roads should be included". Last month Tynwald approved the Department of Infrastructure's plan for the scheme, which outlined increased public involvement and how the project would be put in said her department was "probably running one of the biggest consultation exercises that has ever been done", as the team aimed to engage with every local authority area over the coming months. 'Local knowledge' Maps have been made available to view at Onchan Commissioners' office, Onchan Library, Douglas City Hall, Douglas City Library and the Sea detailed maps have also been made available in an online portal, which allows people to leave feedback by selecting the road they wish to comment can also be sent by email to the traffic regulation order said Tynwald members had now approved the move three times, meaning she now needed to "deliver something that is the best for each residential area". "Our proposals are there, and they can contract or expand depending on local knowledge," she said while the department's engineers knew "what the road looks like in terms of highway designs", local residents were best place to comment on "how people use the road and how the traffic flows through the area".Roads near schools, hospitals and care homes, along with places "where we know there is an increased probability of people who are vulnerable", would be prioritised under the scheme, Haywood the department had gathered views and adjusted the proposals accordingly, the department would "feel we have the green light" to implement the reduced speed limits, she added. Read more stories from the Isle of Man on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Isle of Man on Facebook and X.
BBC News
21-05-2025
- BBC News
Call for 'gaslighting' remark withdrawal rejected by Tynwald
A committee's call for the Manx chief minister to withdraw comments that accused the former health minister of "gaslighting" has been rejected by the Cannan said Lawrie Hooper's resignation speech on 15 October was a "fabrication" of facts and accused him of "gaslighting" the Council of Ministers and the public over Manx Care's funding.A Tynwald Standards and Members' Interests Committee report found Cannan's language to be "unacceptable" and called for the remarks to be that recommendation, and a second that would have seen politicians given training on parliamentary language, were voted down by Tynwald members. When delivering his resignation statement in October, Hooper said he believed Cannan had an "ultimate aim to try and privatise our health service".A day later, when Hooper was not present, Cannan said the statement was a "fabrication" describing it as a "falsehood and a slur on the Council of Ministers".The remarks were reported to the committee by Hooper, which also considered comments from a failed motion of no confidence in the chief minister in the House of Keys on 29 that debate several members criticised Cannan's remarks about Hooper. In its latest report the committee concluded Cannan's language had been "unacceptable" and said it was "not acceptable parliamentary practice for one member to characterise what another member has said as fabrication, falsehood or gaslighting".It also suggested training should be undertaken by all members "in the principles of parliamentary language and debate".During the debate on the findings in the Manx parliament, Rob Callister MHK said he believed the "entire situation should never have escalated to a stage requiring reporting and recommendations".Julie Edge MHK said: "We need to stop pretending that we need training camps and start demanding basic decency." Committee chairman Juan Watterson SHK told members he thought they were "capable of making their point in debate without impugning character or using inappropriate language".He said it would be "right that we do as much as we can to learn from this episode and reduce the risk of any similar difficulties arising in future".However, the motion failed to gain enough voted in after the session, Watterson said, by not supporting the recommendations, they had "passed a motion that will allow acceptable standards of behaviour in our national parliament to be far lower". Read more stories from the Isle of Man on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Isle of Man on Facebook and X.
The Independent
13-05-2025
- The Independent
Hong Kong rushes to tighten domestic version of national security law
The Hong Kong administration has fast-tracked the enactment of new legislation under its domestic security law to include a maximum of seven years of jail term for disclosing ongoing investigations by Beijing. The new legislation appears to be enacted to consolidate Beijing's control over the financial hub, which has witnessed a steady clampdown on dissent. The Safeguarding National Security Regulation was enforced on Tuesday, just a day after the government proposed the subsidiary legislations in a meeting at the Legislative Council. The city authorities on Monday announced the new legislative changes to amend the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance to provide better "clarity" and support to Beijing's national security office. Hong Kong authorities last year imposed the domestic security law, also known as Article 23, despite growing international criticism that it could erode freedoms in the city. The subsidiary laws were tabled before a Legislative Council panel on Tuesday and enacted through a 'negative vetting procedure" which allows the law to be first published before being reviewed by lawmakers. A government spokesperson said the subsidiary law was enacted "against the increasingly turbulent global geopolitical landscape, national security risks to which the HKSAR [Hong Kong Special Administrative Region] is exposed can arise all of a sudden", according to Hong Kong Free Press. 'The two pieces of subsidiary legislation are essential from the perspective of protection in respect of the OSNS's [Beijing's Office for Safeguarding National Security] effective performance of its mandate under the requirements" of the city's national security legislation, the spokesperson added. The spokesperson claimed the subsidiary legislation will not affect the lives of the general public, nor hinder the operations of any institutions and organisations. The new legislation will facilitate the work of Beijing's national security office in the city, which includes investigating cases that it exercises jurisdiction over. The law includes designating premises linked to Beijing's national security offices, known as the Office for Safeguarding National Security (OSNS), as "prohibited places". Anyone who discloses information related to Beijing's OSNS investigations will face a fine of up to HK$500,000 or up to seven years, the law states. Those found guilty of providing false or misleading information to Beijing will also be punished with a maximum fine of HK$500,000 and a jail sentence of up to seven years. The legislation was gazetted and signed by acting chief executive Eric Chan due to city leader John Lee 's current trip to Kuwait.
