It's time for the UK to recognise Palestine
Keir Starmer has an opportunity to act now. Britain must follow France and recognise a state of Palestine while there is still a Palestine to recognise.
The position of the United Kingdom has long been that the only acceptable settlement is the two-state solution. Yet we only recognise one of those states.
The recognition of Palestine has been Labour policy since I was shadow foreign secretary. It was in the manifesto on which we were elected last year. And immediate recognition is supported by the majority of the Foreign Affairs Committee, which I chair, and which publishes a report into the Israel-Palestine conflict today.
When I ask the government when it will happen, they tell me they will recognise at the moment of maximum impact.
But we cannot wait forever for a perfect moment that may never come. I can think of many opportunities when recognition might have had a significant effect, had we taken that step.
We cannot let another opportunity pass us by.
On Monday, the long-awaited French-Saudi conference on the two-state solution will take place in New York. Ahead of it, President Macron has announced that he will recognise a Palestinian state in September.
It is no secret that Macron has been pushing the UK government to recognise Palestine alongside the French. He told Parliament as much when he addressed us last week.
He is right. A unified move by the signatories to the secret Sykes-Picot agreement which carved up the Middle East more than a century ago would demonstrate our sincere commitment to a two-state solution.
The leaders' meeting at the UN in September offers that opportunity.
Of course, the most urgent need is for an immediate ceasefire and for UN-administered aid to flood into Gaza. Recognition does not secure peace on its own.
But it should be the start of a renewed commitment by Britain to engage with our allies, particularly Gulf and Arab states, to build a plan for a sustainable peace. It would signal that our engagement is sustained and sincere.
And it would show the Israeli government that the UK is prepared to take the kind of decisive action promised in the Foreign Secretary's statement alongside 27 allies on Monday.
That must include tough and direct action on violent extremist settlers and the companies who facilitate settlements. Their behaviour imperils the two-state solution by taking over the very land which should be Palestinian. My committee's report argues that the UK must extend sanctions against them and prevent the import of settlement goods.
The natural reaction of the British public to the scenes of starvation and death in Gaza is to call on their politicians to do something.
The challenge for politicians is to ensure that what they do makes a real difference.
The recognition of Palestine as part of a renewed commitment by the UK to work with others to build a peace process would be just that.
Britain has said it wants to work with France when it comes to the recognition of Palestine. Now that France has said it will recognise in September, is it not fair to expect the government to join them?
I, my committee, and the British public will be watching with anticipation.
Emily Thornberry is Labour MP for Islington South and Finsbury and chair of the Foreign Affairs Select Committee
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
a few seconds ago
- Telegraph
Trump: wind farms are a ‘con job'
President Donald Trump branded wind power a 'con job' after playing golf in Scotland, describing how turbines ruined the view from the 18th hole of his Turnberry course. The president said wind farms spoiled the landscape and sucked in expensive subsidies in comments likely to complicate a meeting with Sir Keir Starmer on Monday. 'The whole thing is a con job. It's very expensive,' he added as he announced a trade deal with the EU. The deal includes the EU buying billions of dollars of American energy, including natural gas. Mr Trump spent Sunday morning playing golf with his son Eric and club members before sitting down for crucial European trade talks. 'Today I'm playing the best course, I think, in the world, Turnberry,' he said, in front of a giant picture window looking out on its fairways, dunes and the sea beyond. 'It's probably the best course in the world. And I look over the horizon and I see nine windmills at the end of the 18th. I said, 'Isn't that a shame?'' Mr Trump's Scotland visit is centred around his two golf clubs. On Friday, engulfed in the Epstein scandal at home, he issued an eleventh-hour invitation to Ursula von der Leyen, the European Commission president, to come to his Ayrshire golf club to try to agree a trade deal before crippling tariffs come into force on August 1. He announced a trade deal shortly after the meeting at Turnberry, and dismissed the idea the deal was a useful distraction from the Epstein accusations. 'We have reached a deal. It's a good deal for everybody,' he told reporters, confirming 15 per cent tariffs on all goods. Ms von der Leyen also hailed it as a 'good deal'. Mr Trump's comments on wind energy, however, are likely to complicate Mr Trump's meeting on Monday with Sir Keir, who has staked Britain's future energy supply on wind. In its manifesto last year, Labour promised to work with the private sector to double Britain's onshore wind power capacity by 2030. That meant ending the de facto ban on new onshore wind farms in England and, by declaring them nationally significant infrastructure projects, stripping councils of their power to block giant onshore wind farm developments. The policy, drawn up by Ed Miliband, the Energy Secretary, and condemned by critics as a 'power grab', cleared the way for a raft of new wind farms with turbines predicted to exceed 800ft in height. In Scotland on Sunday, Mr Trump pushed back on any suggestion that his 'beautiful' morning of golf had put him in a good mood. 'I'm actually not in a great mood,' he said at the press conference with Ms von der Leyen, to laughter from his team. Mr Trump may be on British soil, but he is meeting foreign leaders on home territory. The vast ballroom at Turnberry was set out like the Oval Office, scene of so many televised showdowns. The president took the seat on the right, just as he would at the White House, with his five advisers in seats beside him, arranged as if on the familiar couches, facing their counterparts no more than four feet away. A small group of guests, including his sons Donald Jr and Eric, were seated to one side, with a close-up view of the spectacle. But for all the important issues at stake, Mr Trump could not resist returning to golf and the presence of wind turbines. He was visiting Turnberry for the first time since Kirk Hill wind farm began producing energy from eight turbines that rise more than 300 ft into the air. 'The whole thing is a con job,' he said. 'It's very expensive, and in all fairness, Germany tried it and wind doesn't work.' He said it made no sense to subsidise energy projects such as wind farms. 'With energy, you make money, you don't lose money. But more important than that is it ruins the landscape,' he said. 'It kills the birds.' He also said that 'windmills' were driving whales 'loco'. Long-running battle over turbines Mr Trump's hatred of turbines stems from a long-planning battle he had with Scottish authorities. He opposed plans for a major North Sea wind power development that he complained could be seen from his Aberdeenshire course but lost the case. On Monday, Sir Keir is expected to push Mr Trump for his help in securing a ceasefire in Gaza. The president promised more aid for Gaza but indicated that he had run out of patience with Hamas, accusing the terror group of toughening its line on returning the last remaining Israeli hostages. 'They don't want to give them back, and so Israel's going to have to make a decision,' he said. His US negotiators left Qatar, which is mediating talks, on Thursday as talks collapsed. In the press conference, Mr Trump also called Iran 'stupid' for continuing to enrich uranium in the wake of US air strikes on its nuclear facilities. He said Iran had been 'beaten up very badly, for good reason'. 'I think Iran has been very nasty, with their words, with their mouth. I think they've been very nasty. They got the hell knocked out of them and I don't think they know it,' he added. 'You've just come out of something that's so bad and they talk about: we want to continue enrichment … How stupid can you be to say that?'
Telegraph
a few seconds ago
- Telegraph
Essex police boss demands to meet Yvette Cooper over migrant hotel
A police boss has demanded an urgent meeting with Yvette Cooper on Monday to seek the closure of the Epping asylum hotel at the centre of recent protests. Roger Hirst, the police and crime commissioner for Essex, said The Bell Hotel was an inappropriate location for asylum seekers and was costing his force 'hundreds of thousands of pounds' in officer overtime to police the protests. Hundreds of officers from Essex, the Metropolitan Police and forces across England were deployed on Sunday to police about 1,000 protesters who converged on the hotel. Essex imposed restrictions on the protests that required pro and anti-migrant groups to be separated on designated sites and banned anyone from wearing face coverings. A dispersal order runs from 12pm on Sunday until 8am on Monday, covering Epping town centre and nearby transport hubs. It gives officers the power to remove anyone suspected of anti-social behaviour. The Bell has become a target for protests after a resident Ethiopian asylum seeker was charged with sexually assaulting a 14-year-old schoolgirl days after arriving in the UK. Ten people have been arrested after violence flared 10 days ago. Mr Hirst said: 'The Bell is not the right place for a hotel for asylum seekers. It's in the middle of a home counties market town and these are people who have a very different life experience arriving there. There are schools in the vicinity as well. It is not the right place. 'It's costing hundreds of thousands of pounds. It's a lot of police overtime. This is not what we need to be happening on a regular basis in the town. It's a diversion of resources from what police officers should be doing.' It follows similar calls for the hotel's closure from Kemi Badenoch, the Tory leader and Essex MP, and Chris Whitbread, the Epping council leader, who said it had become a 'focus and battleground' for extremist groups. Tommy Robinson, the political activist whose real name is Stephen Yaxley-Lennon, said on his X account on July 20 that he was 'coming to Epping next Sunday ... and bringing thousands more with me', but did not make the journey. Around 400 anti-migrant protesters were the first to gather outside the hotel before counter-demonstrators comprising pro-Palestine groups, unions and anti-racism campaigners arrived around an hour later at 3pm and were directed to a field nearby. Officers from as many as 30 police forces are believed to have been involved including Merseyside, Surrey, Lancashire, the City of London and Sussex were in attendance. The counter-demonstrators signs included: 'Don't let the far-Right divide us with their hatred, ' while anti-migrant protesters chanted: 'Protect our kids,' and 'Keir Starmer is a w-----.' Sarah White, 40, one of the protest organisers, said she would continue demonstrations until the hotel closed. The mother of three said: 'We won't stop. Today has been a great opportunity for our voices to be heard. 'We've got the message out there that we don't want these hotels. This I think has been the biggest and there's more to come. We need to feel safe, we don't currently. It's shocking. We won't stop until that hotel is closed.' Maureen Chapman, 73, who has lived in Epping for 50 years, said she felt 'under threat'. She said: 'I have grandchildren living locally. We want this closed and we won't stop until it is. It's shocking.' Police said three people were arrested: a 52 year-old man on suspicion of a public order offence; a 53 year-old woman for racially aggravated abuse; and a 27 year-old woman on suspicion of criminal damage and a public order offence. In Canary Wharf, around 150 protesters gathered on Sunday near the Britannia International Hotel in London's financial district, to which the Home Office plans to send asylum seekers. The 'silent protest' had been scheduled to start near the four-star hotel at 3pm, with online graphics reading: 'Save our kids, stop the boats,' and 'Everyone welcome. Stand in unity, make your voice heard – silently.' Two men have been charged with public order offences after a protest outside a hotel in Diss, Norfolk Constabulary has said. They were arrested on Saturday after police reviewed footage from both sides of a protest that took place on Denmark Street on Monday, the force said. James Harvey, 22, of Linden Drive, Hethersett, has been charged with a racially aggravated public order offence. Luke Sharman, 23, of Harcourt Close, Norwich, has been charged with a racially aggravated public order offence and possession of cannabis.
Times
24 minutes ago
- Times
Kemi Badenoch says Tories would ban doctors from going on strike
Kemi Badenoch has pledged to ban doctors from striking as she insisted Britain needed to cut spending to 'live within our means'. The Conservative leader said she would extend rules that prevent police officers and soldiers from striking to deal with what she called the increasingly 'militant' British Medical Association (BMA). Labour is scrapping Tory rules that would have allowed ministers to set out minimum levels of service staff would have to provide during strike action in the NHS and other public services. Badenoch said she would restore these for other NHS staff and go even further on doctors. 'The BMA has become militant. These strikes are going too far and it is time for action,' she said. Describing the measures as 'common-sense proposals to protect patients and the public finances', Badenoch said: 'These strikes will have a significant economic effect, but they will also mean cancelled operations, worry for families of the sick and suffering for those who are unwell. We know that previous strike action by doctors even led to some patients losing their lives.' She again praised Argentina's chainsaw-wielding President Milei, citing him as an inspiration for a future Conservative government. Badenoch has said she will not 'literally use a chainsaw' to cut spending but said that Britain was borrowing too much, adding: 'We need to start thinking about the next generation.' While seeking to distinguish herself from Nigel Farage, the Reform leader, with a tough line on public spending, Badenoch last week said she aimed to imitate Milei, who won power after brandishing a chainsaw to illustrate his approach to slashing state spending. He has balanced the budget and reduced inflation through deep cuts to public expenditure, such as pensions, which have provoked widespread protest. • The WhatsApp group: Kemi Badenoch revs up her cost-cutting chainsaw* 'I wouldn't literally use a chainsaw, but it was a very, very visual story that he told about making sure that Argentina lived within its means,' Badenoch said. She admitted Britain had 'a different set-up' to Argentina but told Sunday Morning with Trevor Phillips on Sky News: 'We need to start thinking about the next generation. We are borrowing our children's money to pay for today, to pay for welfare. We're paying £100 billion on debt interest. That's just not fair.' Badenoch previously pledged to stop people with milder mental health problems from claiming disability benefits. The government was forced to abandon plans to cut eligibility for welfare after a revolt by Labour backbenchers. While cuts in other areas are likely to be far more contentious for a Tory party heavily dependent on older voters, Badenoch insisted 'we need to live within our means' as a country. Farage has pledged to remove the two-child benefit cap as he seeks to win over cultural conservative voters who often want more public spending. Rachel Reeves, the chancellor, is expected to raise taxes in the autumn to cover the cost of retreats on cuts to welfare and pensioners' winter fuel payments, along with deteriorating economic forecasts and the rising cost of borrowing.
