Route-and-branch transit overhaul maps city's devolution
10 Wolseley. 11 Portage. 12 William. 14 Ellice. 15 Mountain. 16 Osborne. 17 MacGregor. 18 Corydon. 19 Notre Dame. 20 Academy…
Until this week, I hadn't realized I could recite just about the full set of Winnipeg Transit routes and numbers by memory.
Alas, this newly discovered party trick is destined to go unused as we bury these routes with the streetcar tracks they were originally designed to follow, the veins through a city that are remnants of a time when a much more closely-packed citizenry all needed the same things, and all of which were available in the heart of the city.
JOHN WOODS / FREE PRESS FILES
The revamped routes seek to deliver better commute times and less waiting to transfer in an effort to draw more users, but the Transit overhaul fails to give dedicated car users reason to get out of their vehicles.
I have mixed feelings about this evolution.
Obviously, changes are needed to transit. Declining ridership and rising safety issues are clear indicators that it's not fulfilling its role of getting us where we need to go. But the days of jumping on the bus for all of our needs are behind us. Even if we wanted to go shopping downtown, we largely couldn't, as there's nowhere left to shop.
A short walk down Portage or Graham will yield empty shopfront after empty shopfront. The mammoth department stores of two generations ago are gone, and many of the destinations that would have drawn us are now parking lots haunted by the ghosts of Winnipeggers past and the cars of Winnipeg present.
I'm worried our transit overhaul reflects our devolution, instead of our evolution, as a city. It seems to be a reflection and acceptance of our problematic sprawl.
With nothing to bump into on the outside margins of our town, we have nothing stopping us from expanding ever outward, trenching new sewer lines and paving new roads while the older ones rot and crumble, building new houses while addresses in older neighbourhoods are left as burnt skeletons or piles of rubble for months on end.
Transit has been slow to extend service into newer areas, and inhabitants have been slow to adopt transit as a way to get around.
While in some ways this redesign feels like an admission of defeat, a commitment to a future of further sprawl, it does give hope that somewhere in Winnipeg, someone involved in planning is acknowledging we cannot go on just waiting for our boomtown days to come back while more and more of our citizenry are making homes along river banks.
Transit has been slow to extend service into newer areas, and inhabitants have been slow to adopt transit as a way to get around.
In a rare example of cross-sector co-ordination, there are a few examples of this novel forward-thinking mindset.
The city is looking at adding housing along the new 'spine' routes, even incorporating residential units into transit infrastructure.
The lofty plans for Graham Avenue — a pedestrian mall and shopping district — promise to bring people downtown to socialize, shop and dine. The new routes promise quicker commutes, better coverage and short waits for transfers — all good reasons to pull someone onto the bus who hasn't considered it in some time.
All in all, it's a noble effort to make a rare and radical change to Winnipeg's public services in an effort to actually serve the needs of the citizenry.
But it's not going to work.
These noble 'pull' reasons to take the bus will fail if there aren't balanced and co-ordinated 'push' incentives to get people out of their cars.
Wednesdays
Columnist Jen Zoratti looks at what's next in arts, life and pop culture.
We cannot simply emphasize the perks of taking the bus without also making driving more unattractive, and we are a woefully car-committed city.
We cannot simply emphasize the perks of taking the bus without also making driving more unattractive, and we are a woefully car-committed city.
The fact we're still entertaining the thought of widening Kenaston Boulevard is clear communication from the city itself that we don't believe in public transit to move people. No, we must make way for more cars instead. It's cars that move people in Winnipeg. And it's cars that occupy the ever-expanding network of surface parking lots in our downtown: cheap, plentiful spaces have made driving to work easy and comfortable. Why would anyone take the bus where there is very little advantage?
Transit is not just failing because the product itself isn't working well. It's failing because our city has planned for it to fail. There is no outcome for transit, in the current design of this city, that will strengthen its utility and usage, because we haven't considered factors beyond the service itself.
It's clear the reliability and safety of transit must be improved, and some of that will be addressed by the changes that go into effect tomorrow, but until the infrastructure surrounding car use makes it preferable, I can't imagine I'll be memorizing many new route numbers.
rebecca.chambers@freepress.mb.ca
Rebecca Chambers
Rebecca explores what it means to be a Winnipegger by layering experiences and reactions to current events upon our unique and sometimes contentious history and culture. Her column appears alternating Saturdays.
Read full biography
Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.
Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
6 days ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Some introspection can help break strife-sex cycle
Opinion DEAR MISS LONELYHEARTS: I know why my girlfriend won't see me face-to-face anymore. It's because we can't help but be sexual — both her weakness and mine — and we never end up working out the problems between us. Even after we can't agree on anything at all and have had a big fight, it's ended up with great sex. That's how we are. (We are both women, by the way.) Last week it seemed to really fall apart. She told me she'd had enough of my nonsense and has moved out to her cabin on Lake Winnipeg for the rest of the summer. She says she's working remotely. Do I even believe that? I really need to see her and look into her eyes, to find out. She's not even picking up her phone regularly. I asked her if I could visit, so we could finish talking things over, and she said no because it was too soon. I was shocked. This relationship is just wearing me out, but I can't seem to move on. When things are good, we have the hottest physical connection, but we still fight too much. — Sick of Fighting, Wolseley Dear Sick of Fighting: This fighting dynamic is burning your relationship out. Your mate is telling you in every way she can that she's had enough. It's time to use a different tactic — accept that you do need to keep your distance and consider seeing a relationship counsellor or a psychologist for a few visits. Your mate will be curious to know what's being discussed. Let her do most of the phoning or messaging to you until she comes back to the city. Let her have time to miss you and think about what's going on. Be a little mysterious. It can be lonely at the lake, especially in August when people are heading home to get kids ready for school, so give yourself time to get your head straightened out and see if you still want her back in your life. It's time to stop apologizing and take back some of your power. Dear Miss Lonelyhearts: I have somehow ended up in a romantic mess at the restaurant where I work and I really need to keep this great part-time job after the summer. I never should have started dating someone from work, but it was kind of a thrill. And then, I dated a second employee. Now both relationships are over and we are all still working together — and I am feeling pretty awkward. Help please. — Balancing Act, downtown Winnipeg Dear Balancing Act: These little workplace romances have been just a summertime adventure for you, but you want to keep your job, so you must get over yourself. Be extra respectful and stay friendly with both co-workers. They may be moving on to heavy workloads at school or something else this fall, but they too may want to keep on working there. Let's hope you were just a summer diversion to them as well, and they are fine staying friendly co-workers with you. It's all about co-operation and helping one another when you're working for tips. Please send your questions and comments to lovecoach@ or Miss Lonelyhearts c/o the Winnipeg Free Press, 1355 Mountain Ave., Winnipeg, MB, R2X 3B6. Maureen ScurfieldAdvice columnist Maureen Scurfield writes the Miss Lonelyhearts advice column. Read full biography Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Winnipeg Free Press
28-07-2025
- Winnipeg Free Press
Difficult situations, moving experiences
As a volunteer recruiter, Tyler Omichinski has found that Winnipeggers are eager to pitch in. Omichinski is the operations manager for the local chapter of Shelter Movers, a national charitable organization that provides moving and storage services at no cost to individuals and families fleeing abuse. More than 70 Winnipeggers have signed up to volunteer with the chapter since it was established last summer. That response is impressive, Omichinski says. 'I've been kind of blown away (by) how much that delightful stereotype of us in Winnipeg being people who volunteer (and) people who give to charity holds true,' he says. 'We've had a relatively easy time finding folks to help out, which has been fantastic.' Shelley Madden is one of those people. The Charleswood resident has a long history of giving her time to organizations that serve marginalized people. She discovered Shelter Movers late last summer, shortly after giving a list of resources to a woman who was fleeing an abusive situation. ''This is stellar, this is absolutely amazing. This is the kind of resource that was missing when I gave those referrals to that woman,'' Madden recalls thinking after she learned about the organization on Volunteer Manitoba's website. The 56-year-old educational assistant was looking for somewhere to volunteer and so she applied immediately. Since then, she's served as an online orientation facilitator, training volunteers on the organization's protocols and how they can take a trauma-informed approach to their work. More recently, she's volunteered as a mover. Shelter Movers collaborates with local businesses and community services who refer clients — primarily women and their children — who have decided to leave an abuser and have a safer place to go. Movers and drivers are the backbone of the organization. Working in groups of two to seven people, and guided by a detailed itinerary, volunteers load the clients' belongings into a vehicle and transport them and their items to a predetermined location. The following is a list of volunteer opportunities for Winnipeg and surrounding areas. For more information about these listings, contact the organization directly. Volunteer Manitoba does not place volunteers with organizations but can help people find opportunities. To learn more about its programs and services, go to or call 204-477-5180. The following is a list of volunteer opportunities for Winnipeg and surrounding areas. For more information about these listings, contact the organization directly. Volunteer Manitoba does not place volunteers with organizations but can help people find opportunities. To learn more about its programs and services, go to or call 204-477-5180. The Ecuadorian Association of Manitoba needs volunteers who speak Spanish or are passionate about the culture to help with events. The position is an opportunity to gain experience in event management. People are welcome to apply at any time, but to participate in events this summer and fall, they should apply at volunteer@ or in July and August. SuperWalk is Parkinson Canada's largest annual fundraiser, helping the organization provide support and advocacy, and funding research for people living with and impacted by the disease. Event-day volunteers are needed. Roles include event setup and takedown, registration, greeting, food services, entertainment support, checkpoint stations and cheering on walkers. Events are taking place across Canada — including in Winnipeg — on Sept. 6 and Sept. 7. The time commitment varies. Volunteers will be contacted before the event to confirm their shift time, role and event details. Apply online at by Sept. 5. Canada's largest volunteer-led event for breast cancer — the CIBC Run for the Cure, in support of the Canadian Cancer Society — returns Oct. 5. Volunteers are needed to help plan and lead events across the country. To explore available positions, go to The application deadline is the day of the event. Victoria Lifeline needs home service volunteers to travel to clients' homes and work directly with subscribers and caregivers to install, support and explain Lifeline. Volunteers should have demonstrated interpersonal and communication skills. English is required; additional languages are an asset. A driver's licence and vehicle are required. Must be able to work independently. Shifts are available between 9 a.m. and 4 p.m. weekdays. A minimum of one four-hour shift weekly is required. Apply at by Dec. 30. Com-Span needs someone with experience in basic repairs and general handiwork to help with odd jobs around the building. The work includes minor repairs, installing shelves, repairing and replacing damaged items and minor paint touch-ups. Shifts will work around the person's availability. A criminal record check is required, with the costs reimbursed. Email admin@ by Dec. 31. The College of Registered Nurses of Manitoba needs a public representative to fill a vacancy on the finance committee for a term starting in October. The committee is responsible for making recommendations on financial policies, financial conditions and the annual audit to the council. More information is available at Send a resumé and cover letter to appointments@ by Aug. 8. Mount Carmel Clinic needs volunteers for community programming support. Roles include setting up and cleaning programming spaces, organizing the refreshments area, greeting community members and providing event information. Volunteers help staff members with group activities and distribution of materials. Volunteers should be 16 or older and open to working from a place of non-judgment, open-mindedness and respect for people of all backgrounds and identities. The time commitment is two shifts monthly, and there is an orientation of approximately three hours. Shifts are 10 a.m. to 7 p.m. weekdays. Background checks are required, with costs reimbursed. Email volunteer@ by Aug. 31. The Canadian Red Cross Society needs volunteers in Manitoba for programs such as Smart Start and Disaster Risk Reduction. These roles involve leading sessions on climate change and emergency preparedness, and require effective communication skills and cultural sensitivity. Volunteers might also join the emergency responder and personal disaster assistance teams to help during disasters. Training and background checks are mandatory. This opportunity offers experience in public speaking and crisis management. Send a resumé to SmartStart@ by Dec. 31. Villa Cabrini needs someone with creative skills to make posters for various events. The necessary information for the projects will be provided each month. The role does not include printing responsibilities; completed files can be emailed. Volunteers must have computer and design skills and be 16 or older. The role involves flexible hours and can be done remotely. Apply at vcabrini@ by Jan. 1. Police or security personnel and language interpreters may also be present for the move to ensure the process is as safe and efficient as possible. 'You're helping someone get out of a very difficult situation,' Madden says, adding that it's rewarding work. 'The amount of gratitude and graciousness that comes from the women (is) just humbling.' Paul Diouf agrees. Diouf arrived in Winnipeg from Dakar, Senegal, last August to study business administration at Saint-Boniface University. He started volunteering as a mover last December so that he could get to know the city. He has since been trained as a driver. Diouf recalls one particular shift when a woman gathered her children after the move so that they could all thank the volunteers. 'It was kind of awesome — it gave me chills,' says Diouf, 27. 'To me it (indicated that I) did something really important… I'll never forget that.' While Omichinski is pleased with the number of people who volunteer with Shelter Movers, he says the organization could always use more help. Monday Mornings The latest local business news and a lookahead to the coming week. The duration of each move varies, with an average length of about four hours. Volunteers receive training and can sign up for moves according to their availability. To get involved, apply online at or email volunteer@ 'We've (done) 35 moves already and we're really getting our feet under us locally (so) that number's going to keep growing drastically,' Omichinski says. Shelter Movers operates in 10 centres across Canada and relies on more than 1,000 volunteers, per its website. Since 2016, the organization has completed more than 8,500 moves. If you know a special volunteer, email Aaron EppReporter Aaron Epp reports on business for the Free Press. After freelancing for the paper for a decade, he joined the staff full-time in 2024. He was previously the associate editor at Canadian Mennonite. Read more about Aaron. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Winnipeg Free Press
21-07-2025
- Winnipeg Free Press
Encampments and personal responsibilities
Opinion Some parts of Winnipeg have a noxious problem on their hands. Among behaviours by the residents of homeless encampments causing consternation among other Winnipeggers near the sites, the act of burning cable and wires in order to cash in on the metallic components is, literally, a toxic one. It's a problem firefighters have had to contend with, and one local authorities seem ill-equipped to address. Wire burning poses serious short-term and long-term health risks; the burning wires release carcinogens into the atmosphere and those exposed are at a higher risk of developing cancer. BROOK JONES/FREE PRESS An encampment on the bank of the Red River along the North Winnipeg Parkway Winnipegger Howard Warren told the Free Press he has asked residents of an encampment near his home to cease burning wires, but says his requests have been rebuffed. Warren pointed out that, were he to do the same in his own yard, his neighbours would likely complain and he may face penalties under the law. He's right, and the double-standard reveals a major problem, one with which those sympathetic to the encampments will have to contend. In late June, this paper shed light on an element of encampment life which put to the test the common stereotype that residents of homeless encampments are there because they have no other choice. Some residents, the June 25 story revealed, prefer to live in encampments. 'These are the people I trust, instead of somebody I don't trust or don't know,' one encampment resident, identified as Joseph, told the Free Press. He was unimpressed by provincial plans to end homelessness by 2031. 'And why? We don't have to pay rent. Why would I pay $600 for someone to tell me how to live when I could pay nothing and live how I want to live?' It's a whimsical notion, and one easy to be sympathetic to. Modern life is fraught with high costs and irritating obligations. And some people are not well-equipped or inclined to take part in the 21st-century rat-race. So let's indulge that thought for just a moment, that encampments in the city could be treated as permanent settlements for those who are not calibrated to the 'ordinary,' way of living. And let's narrow the focus to those who do have the choice, and not those who live in encampments because mental health issues or addictions leave them little choice. What does this idealized arrangement demand of everybody involved? Wednesdays A weekly dispatch from the head of the Free Press newsroom. Without wanting to besmirch the character of the aforementioned Joseph, let's zoom in on one comment he made: why should he want to pay rent 'for someone to tell me how to live…?' That's the sticking point, here: for all the talk among some encampment residents and their advocates about how the encampments provide protective, tight-knit communities for their residents, there is a distinct antisocial streak within them, one which makes the encampments dangerous and antagonistic to the rest of the city around them. Even in a world without all of the expectations which come with modern living, there is still such a thing as the social contract — a set of expectations placed on the individual which, while varying between cultures, is a fact of life across human civilization. In the distant past, one might have been free to pitch one's tent wherever worked, but there remained a social requirement to behave in a way that was not burdensome or dangerous to everyone else. While encampments may be a preferred way of life for some, they cannot and should not be a way to opt out entirely from the social contract. Encampments are not going to be a sustainable reality for the people living in them if their establishment is followed by trash littering the area, unsafe and toxic fires burning through the night, and other disruptive or criminal activities. Some people may be willing to look at those choosing the encampment life and say 'live and let live,' — but it's not going to happen if encampment residents can't figure out how to be better neighbours.
