Autonomous vehicles make Arizona roads safer. That's no accident
It's become such a part of our everyday lives that you need to look closely to realize there's no one behind the wheel of some cars gliding down streets like Camelback Road and navigating the intricacies of Phoenix traffic at rush hour.
While many other states remain paralyzed by the thought of reconciling technology with older infrastructure, Arizona has done something remarkable: It has embraced rather than shunned self-driving car technology, creating a model rooted in innovation, regulatory humility and the principles of freedom.
This was no accident.
It came from deliberate leadership, according to a new report from the Goldwater Institute, where I work. In 2015, then-Gov. Doug Ducey issued an executive order launching Arizona's experiment in what's been labeled permissionless innovation — the idea that regulatory frameworks should default to openness, transparency and stability.
Rather than allowing bureaucrats to imagine dangers for them to act against, the order required regulators to demonstrate tangible harm before intervening.
The Arizona model — now codified into law — has positioned our state as a leader in innovation while keeping our communities safe by mandating that autonomous vehicle companies meet federal safety standards, respond intelligently to system failures, and maintain full compliance with traffic laws and insurance requirements.
Yet it avoids the reflexive overreach that has plagued other states, where layers of local and state mandates often unintentionally work together to render innovation nearly impossible.
In Arizona, regulatory authority is streamlined at the state level, ensuring safety while avoiding the policy fragmentation that too often creates complicated webs of regulation that stops companies from deploying new technologies before they can even start.
The results speak for themselves.
As of 2024, 13 companies are actively testing and deploying autonomous vehicles across Arizona's roads. Waymo alone has logged more than 20 million autonomous miles in the Phoenix metro area, with peer-reviewed data revealing a dramatic reduction in crashes.
That includes 81% fewer airbag deployments and 78% fewer injury-causing collisions compared to human drivers over the same distance, Waymo reports.
But autonomous vehicles do more than reduce risk on the roads.
Opinion: AI fights fires and drives cars. Soon, it'll do our jobs
For older adults, people who are blind and those with other disabilities, these vehicles can offer long-overdue freedom and independence. When designed with accessibility in mind — and through strategic partnerships with organizations such as the National Federation of the Blind — companies like Waymo are engineering vehicles that do more than drive: they communicate, accommodate and adapt to meet riders where they are.
A freedom once dependent on others can now be self-directed.
Arizona has earned this success by doing the opposite of our neighbors to the west in California, where multiple government agencies impose broad but fragmented permitting regimes and operational limits.
While caution has its place, the way autonomous vehicles will reshape infrastructure, labor markets and public safety cannot be overstated.
According to economist Jim Rounds, Arizona is likely to attract $6.1 billion in research and development related to autonomous vehicles, creating 39,000 direct jobs and potentially $4.3 billion in economic output.
Rounds also estimates, conservatively, that the industry could generate up to $500 million in tax revenue by 2030 if Arizona's supportive regulatory environment remains intact.
If we want to stay ahead of the pack, the impulse to regulate must be disciplined by humility and trust.
Regulation must remain retrospective — based on demonstrable harm — and must continue to be standardized at the state level.
Embracing a freedom-based model for technology will continue to make our lives better. As other states scramble to rewrite regulations for autonomous vehicles at the municipal level, Arizonans can look toward the future, trusting that our framework embraces both innovation and safety on our roads.
And in doing so, it invites the nation to follow our lead by putting on display the success to back it up.
Brian Norman is director of state affairs at the Goldwater Institute, where he leads the institute's nationwide government affairs strategy. Reach him at bnorman@goldwaterinstitute.org.
This article originally appeared on Arizona Republic: Waymo put Phoenix innovation on the map. That was the point | Opinion
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Elon Musk Loses $12 Billion In Wealth Overnight As Tesla Bets Future On Robotaxis
In Tesla's earning call Wednesday the company's CEO Elon Musk admitted things look pretty dire. Tesla's earnings dropped for a second straight quarter by a staggering 16% — the largest quarterly drop for the company in a decade. Musk said that, thanks to tariffs and regulatory changes brought on by a president he himself championed, Tesla likely has a few more rough quarters ahead. But it's not as bad as it all seems. There is a glimmer on the horizon — according to Musk, the company's infant robotaxi service, which recently began operations in Austin, Texas, will cause an avalanche of profits late next year when Tesla robotaxis will fully reach half of Americans. Well, not to defecate in anyone's decaf, but that ain't happening. Of all of Elon Musk's pie in the sky promises, this one rings the most hollow. Tesla's stock price following the disastrous call reflects that maybe, just maybe, the market finally knows Musk is in a corner, and out of ideas. Read more: Buy One Of These Electric Pickup Trucks Instead Of Humiliating Yourself With A Tesla Cybertruck Let's Check In With Waymo, Shall We? Companies that have been running robotaxis for years are still burning money at an alarming rate. Waymo said in May that the company is giving 250,000 paid trips a week to a large customer base in four major American cities, with three more — Atlanta, Miami, and Washington, D.C. — planned to launch in 2026. It's by far one of the most successful companies to step into the emerging robotaxi model. Waymo's been offering driver-free rides to the public since 2018, and despite some growing pains it has proven safe and effective. Waymo is literally the best to have ever done it up to this point. So, how much money is this titan of self-driving making each year? Unfortunately, it's clear Waymo is costing its parent company, Alphabet, billions in financial losses every year. Forbes didn't mince words in a recent report: "While Google does not break down Waymo's financials, its Other Bets segment, which includes the robotaxi startup, posted a $4.4 billion loss over the last fiscal year. The cost base is high. Waymo owns the vehicles it operates, a contrast to ride hailing players such as Uber. Then, there are the costs tied to vehicle retrofitting, mapping, and fleet management. This means that Waymo has yet to demonstrate a path to profitability, even at the relatively large scale it is currently operating at. Waymo still loses money on every ride it delivers. This has meant that Waymo is burning through cash and remains dependent on external funding." Self-Driving Predictions Of Quarters Past It's not just Waymo feeling the pinch; many self-driving taxi services have come and gone, buckling under the weight of profit loss or bad publicity. The $3 trillion-endowed HSBC bank predicted just this week that it could take up to eight years for self-driving operators to break even on robotaxis. Last year, on the Q2 earnings call, Musk said he'd be surprised if Tesla didn't have "Full-Self Driving" this year. Instead, a full year later, the company is battling in court over its allegedly misleadingly named "Autopilot" and "Full-Self Driving" causing customer's deaths. With just a handful of robotaxis offering free rides in a small slide of Austin to via invite only and with a human minder in the passenger seat, you have to wonder if this is just another out-of-pocket promise is the kind of "corporate fluffery" that Tesla has engaged in in the past. The Market Says No Now it seems Musk's promises are hitting less hard than they used to. The normal stock market price bump the automaker usually experiences after Musk makes big quarterly meeting promises hasn't happened. In fact, Tesla's shareprice dropped nine percent as of this writing, wiping out $12 billion in wealth from Elon Musk's net worth, according to the Economic Times. But hey, maybe Tesla will finally build that affordable vehicle its been—oh, what? It'll just be a cheaper Model Y? Since the Model Y is already the brand's best-seller, I guess the plan is to sell more Model Ys, but these will likely be decontented models, and therefore less desirable. Cool. It's not like EV customers can look to the radically depreciated used EV market for a vehicle that is both affordable and heavy on features. In the meantime, sales in foreign markets like Canada and Europe have dropped to a trickle. And none of this even calls in the sales disaster of the Cybertruck! Tesla is in quite a pinch and the path through doesn't look too bright. Will the meme stock that started meme stocks survive under this onslaught? Want more like this? Join the Jalopnik newsletter to get the latest auto news sent straight to your inbox... Read the original article on Jalopnik.
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
As Tesla Launches Ride-Hailing in San Francisco, How Should You Play TSLA Stock Here?
Tesla ((TSLA) CEO Elon Musk says the electric vehicle giant has launched a ride-hailing service in the San Francisco Bay Area. Shares of the automaker are still inching down in morning trading on Friday. Expectations are for TSLA's announced offering to be a chauffeur-style service and not a robotaxi service given it doesn't yet have authorization for its driverless vehicles in California. More News from Barchart With UnitedHealth Under DOJ Investigation, Should You Buy, Sell, or Hold UNH Stock Now? Trump Won't Take Away Tesla's Subsidies. Does That Make TSLA Stock a Safe Buy Here? Can AMD Stock Hit $210 in 2025? Stop Missing Market Moves: Get the FREE Barchart Brief – your midday dose of stock movers, trending sectors, and actionable trade ideas, delivered right to your inbox. Sign Up Now! At the time of writing, Tesla stock is down more than 15% versus its high set in the final week of May. Why Is It Significant for Tesla Stock? TSLA's newly launched ride hailing service in the San Fracisco Bay Area marks a significant leap toward its long-term commitment to dominating the robotaxi space. While not yet autonomous because of regulatory constraints, it allows the electric vehicle company to test real-world logistics, gather user data, and build brand presence in a competitive market dominated by Uber (UBER) and Waymo. The rollout signals potential future revenue streams and operational scalability, laying groundwork for broader autonomous deployment once approvals are secured, which could drive TSLA share price upside in the long run. Is It a Strong Enough Reason to Buy TSLA Shares? According to Wolfe Research analysts, while some narratives sure are improving for Tesla shares, especially as management executes on its AI ambitions, the current setup is not attractive enough to warrant an investment. In its latest research note, the investment firm agreed that the company's auto segment challenges are being offset by strength in its energy business, but said near-term estimates are rather inflated. TSLA stock is currently going for a forward price-earnings (P/E) ratio of nearly 270x, which is not inexpensive by any stretch of the imagination. However, the electric vehicle giant has recently inked a multibillion-dollar chip supply agreement with Samsung Electronics, reinforcing a commitment to its AI future that could justify its premium valuation moving forward. How Wall Street Recommends Playing Tesla Despite Musk's AI commitment, other Wall Street firms also remain in the same league as Wolfe Research on Tesla stock for now. The consensus rating on TSLA shares currently sits at 'Hold' only with the mean target of about $299 indicating potential downside of more than 2% from here. On the date of publication, Wajeeh Khan did not have (either directly or indirectly) positions in any of the securities mentioned in this article. All information and data in this article is solely for informational purposes. This article was originally published on


Digital Trends
2 days ago
- Digital Trends
Tesla brings its robotaxi service to San Francisco (sort of)
Tesla has rolled out a ride-hailing service in San Francisco, but the lack of a permit to allow it to accept fares from passengers means that it can't yet call it a robotaxi service. The first Tesla Model 3 and Model Y cars hit the streets of San Francisco on Thursday, just over a month after the launch of its robotaxi service in Austin, Texas, where it does have the proper permits. Recommended Videos A video uploaded by a passenger to X shows a Tesla employee with his hands touching the steering wheel as the car drove along in FSD (Full self-driving) mode, Tesla's advanced driver-assist feature. The California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) stated recently that at the current time, Tesla has to have a safety driver behind the wheel for testing, as well as to transport members of the public, Reuters reported. The regulator added that the automaker has to undertake a pilot phase that imposes no charges on passengers before applying for full-autonomous permits, a process that Reuters says took competitors such as Waymo 'years' to complete. Tesla is inviting employees' friends and family, and select members of the public, to participate in the early stage of the service. In June, the automaker launched its first robotaxi service in Austin, with a safety monitor sitting in the front passenger seat, not the driver's seat. And unlike the Tesla's ride-hailing cars in San Francisco, Austin's Model Y vehicles have 'robotaxi' branding on the side. Musk said recently that Tesla is planning to get permits to launch its robotaxi service in a number of states, including not only California but also Nevada, Arizona, and Florida. In California, strict regulations have prevented Musk from experiencing the kind of rapid robotaxi rollout that was possible in Texas. Essentially, the San Francisco launch appears to be a strategic move by Tesla to maintain momentum in the autonomous-vehicle sector.