Madrid judge shuts down 10 tourist lets for ‘illicit and unsanitary activities'
The family, who have two children and who have not been named, said they had suffered stress, anxiety and sleep deprivation because of the loud, drunken, destructive and lewd behaviour of guests, which included vandalism, vomiting and having sex in the block's communal areas.
The ruling, which has just been made public, comes amid continuing protests over the social and economic consequences of overtourism and the lack of affordable housing.
The family live in a block of 60 flats near the Spanish capital's Plaza Mayor, 75% of which are run as tourist rentals. Two years ago, they engaged a lawyer to represent them after efforts to address the problem with the city council and the owners of the rentals came to nothing.
'The family have one tourist flat above them, another below them, and more tourist flats near their bedrooms,' said their lawyer, Miguel Ángel Rubio.
'The family came to me and told me that they'd been to the police who'd come with a decibel metre and had fined the owners €16,000. But the problem is that [the companies that own these flats and others] can make more than €150,000 in rents in a single weekend, so a €16,000 fine is nothing for them. So I had to bring a case on the grounds that the family's fundamental rights were being violated – and it succeeded.'
Rubio said the case was groundbreaking as at stake was not whether the flats themselves were illegal or unlicensed, but whether the activities in and around them were severely damaging the family's basic rights and quality of life.
The judge, in her ruling, said ample evidence had been provided of the stresses and strains that the family had suffered.
'The constant noise, the breaking of shared fixtures, the filling of the lobby with suitcases at all hours and the presence of shopping trolleys filled with towels and other cleaning times for the multiple tourist-use flats, thus impeding the movements of neighbours, have been duly proven and are not isolated incidents,' she noted.
Sign up to This is Europe
The most pressing stories and debates for Europeans – from identity to economics to the environment
after newsletter promotion
Also proven were 'guests using the common areas for sexual relations', multiple police visits, 'vomiting in the courtyards' and broken mailboxes and lift fittings. At one point, the judge said, things had got so bad that a security guard was hired.
The judge rejected the rental owners' claims that the family was merely experiencing the kind day-to-day disruption any neighbour could expect, adding: 'The actions were not merely irritating but also unsanitary, indecent and even illegal.'
After finding that the family's 'fundamental right to personal and family privacy' had been violated, the judge ordered 10 of the flats in the block to close and awarded the family damages of almost €39,000 (£33,700).
Rubio said: 'The family are very happy and very positive because the judge has ordered the flats to stop operating and has ordered the owners to pay them damages.' He said he had been inundated with calls from people in similar situations since news of the case emerged on Monday.
In recent years, increasing overtourism has exposed the scale of Spain's housing crisis and prompted nationwide protests. The shortage of housing stock has been exacerbated by the boom in tourist rental flats.
Rents have increased 80% over the past decade, outpacing wage rises, and a recent Bank of Spain report estimated that almost half of tenants spend 40% of their income on rent and utility bills, compared with an EU average of 27%.
Last year, the mayor of Barcelona, Jaume Collboni, said he would end apartment rentals to tourists by 2028 by scrapping the licences of the 10,101 flats currently approved as short-term rentals.
Although the Spanish government recently ordered Airbnb to take down more than 65,000 illegal adverts, a recent study by the consumer and social rights ministry found that more than 15,200 tourist flats in Madrid are operating without the necessary licences.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Public prosecutor wants Real Madrid's Raul Asencio jailed for two-and-a-half years for allegedly sharing child sex tape
A PUBLIC prosecutor wants Real Madrid defender Raul Asencio jailed for two-and-a-half years, according to reports. Asencio, 22, is alleged to have shared a sex tape involving a minor. 1 In February it was revealed that Asencio would stand trial in the Canary Islands after being accused of disseminating images and a video of a minor and another girl. According to The Athletic, Spain's Public Prosecutor's Office has alleged that two former Real Madrid academy players, not Asencio, had consensual sex with the two girls, including the minor. They are accused of photographing the incident without the minor, and another involved girl's, consent. Asencio is then alleged to have asked to be sent videos of the incident, before then showing them to someone else. This would mean that he committed two breaches of Article 77 of the Spanish Criminal Code, relating to privacy, if guilty. The Spain international is one of four Real Madrid academy products involved in the ongoing case, but the only one still at the club. Ferran Ruiz has since moved to Girona, while Juan Rodriguez, and Andres Garcia have signed for teams in the Spanish lower leagues. The Spanish Public Prosecutor's Office has called for all four players to be jailed. Both girls are claimed to be suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder. They are said to want Asencio to pay them each €5,000 (£4,350) for his alleged role in their ordeals. Earlier this year, Asencio released a statement strongly denying any wrongdoing. It began: "I have not participated in any behaviour that violates the sexual freedom of any woman, much less minors." Asencio also said the "presumption of innocence must continue to prevail." He added: "Should charges ultimately be filed and a trial commence, I will continue to defend myself before the Courts and Tribunals, in which I have full confidence, reaffirming my innocence of any criminal conduct. "All of this is without prejudice to the utmost respect for the conduct of the judicial proceedings as a whole, including those of the other persons under investigation. "I want to reiterate, once again, my absolute respect for the rights to sexual freedom and privacy of all women." Allegations made against Asencio did not stop him from being selected by Real Madrid last season. Having made his senior debut last November, Asencio was a regular throughout the rest of the campaign under Carlo Ancelotti. He also featured in four of Real Madrid's six Club World Cup games under Ancelotti's successor Xabi Alonso. In addition to making 46 senior appearances for Real to date, Asencio received his first Spain call up in March, although he did not get on from the bench to earn his maiden cap.
The Independent
23-07-2025
- The Independent
American convicted of triple murder in Spain now free in US after Venezuela prisoner swap
Donald Trump's administration hailed a prisoner exchange with Venezuela as a diplomatic success that brought home 10 Americans who were 'wrongfully detained" there. The men there were 'hostages,' according to a statement from the Senate Foreign Relations Committee shared by Secretary of State Marco Rubio. Those Americans are 'now free and back in our homeland,' Rubio said. But one of those men is an American-Venezuelan dual citizen who was convicted of murdering three people in Spain in 2016, according to Venezuelan court records and statements from officials in Madrid. Dahud Hanid Ortiz, 55, was sentenced in Venezuela in January 2024 to 30 years in prison after he was convicted of killing three people in Madrid in 2016. He was accused of escaping to his home country, where he was arrested and prosecuted in 2018. Venezuela prohibits the extradition of its citizens, and Venezuelans can be tried for crimes committed outside the country. Images shared by the U.S. State Department show Ortiz with other Americans who were imprisoned in Venezuela smiling together and waving small American flags as they returned to America on July 18. A spokesperson for the State Department refused to confirm his identity. 'The United States had the opportunity to secure the release of all Americans detained in Venezuela, many of whom reported being subjected to torture and other harsh conditions,' the spokesperson said in a statement to The Independent. 'For privacy reasons, I won't get into the details of any specific case.' Ortiz, a former U.S. Marine who served in the Iraq War, reportedly killed three people in Usera, a working-class district in the south of the Spanish capital in 2016. His alleged target was Víctor Salas, a lawyer who was in a relationship with his ex-wife who he had threatened to kill, according to records reviewed by El Pais. Ortiz is accused of killing two female employees at the firm and a client he mistakenly believed was Salas. According to Argentinian outlet Infobae, Ortiz used a combat knife and an iron bar to stab and bludgeon the victims, then set the lawyer's office on fire. Following their deaths, Ortiz returned to Germany, where he was living at the time, and then travelled to Latin America, where he was arrested. 'We all feel like we've been deceived, betrayed and let down,' Salas told Spanish program Vamos a Ver on Tuesday. 'We feel deceived because Dahud Hanid Ortiz was never a political prisoner. He was a murderer who was convicted and sentenced by the Venezuelan authorities. The case record makes it quite clear that he's a criminal.' He told TeleMadrid that 'the governments of Donald Trump and Maduro have just handed a killer his freedom — someone who's a real danger to society — without anyone bothering to provide a real explanation.' The prisoner exchange also saw the release of dozens of Venezuelans that the Trump administration had deported to a brutal prison in El Salvador after accusing them of being 'alien enemies' deployed by that country's government to 'invade' the U.S. Under the deal, 252 Venezuelans — including men who were accused of being Tren de Aragua gang members and summarily deported to El Salvador's Terrorism Confinement Center, or CECOT — were returned to their home country. Those deportees were imprisoned at the facility for more than four months. Trump officials had labelled those men the 'worst of the worst' criminals, and 'alien enemies' who committed 'warfare' on U.S. soil — yet they were released in Venezuela, and could be brought back to the United States under court orders.
The Guardian
18-07-2025
- The Guardian
Spain's People's party hit by alleged multimillion cash-for-favours scandal
Just when Spain's opposition People's party thought it had the socialist government of Pedro Sánchez on the ropes over a series of corruption scandals, it has been hit by a controversy of its own over alleged trafficking of influences by Cristóbal Montoro, the former finance minister. It's alleged that Montoro established the so-called 'economic team', a lawyer's office linked to the finance ministry, which took kickbacks from gas and other energy companies in return for favourable government policy. It's claimed that between 2008 and 2015 Montoro and 27 other accused, among them senior treasury officials, were paid at least €11m (£9.5m) by major energy companies. According to the police investigation led by the judge Rubén Rus 'the economic team received large commissions in return for its capacity to influence legislative and executive powers' under the government of the then president, Mariano Rajoy, adding that 'the office was merely a vehicle to access the finance ministry'. In his report the judge comments that gas companies 'tried to influence legislation in accordance with their interests by using various lobbies but without success' and were only successful when the go-between was Montoro's economic team. 'Within a short period of time and for no apparent reason they obtained the desired legislative reforms,' principally in the form of lower tax liabilities, it concluded. It's also alleged that Montoro personally accessed the confidential tax records of political rivals in his own party, among them Esperanza Aguirre, the former president of Madrid, as well as several journalists and celebrities, including tennis star Rafa Nadal, the art collector and socialite Carmen Thyssen and Jordi Pujol Ferrusola, the son of former Catalan president Jordi Pujol, who was under investigation for corruption. It is said that Rajoy was warned about Montoro's activities but no action was taken. Montoro resigned from the PP on Thursday, and issued a statement saying 'there is no proof of any of the accusations'. The allegations are a blow to the strategy of PP leader Alberto Feijóo which has consisted of a relentless attack on Sánchez whose party is being investigated over a series of corruption charges. Feijóo said the revelations don't change his view that corruption must be rooted out, whoever is involved. 'What needs to be investigated must be investigated,' he said. 'This gives Sánchez a breathing space but it's not the end of it as more is likely to emerge from the judicial investigations,' said Pablo Simón, a political scientist at the Universidad Carlos III in Madrid. 'This levels the playing field and it's also a blow to Feijóo's strategy as it puts him on the defensive.' Simón said the latest scandal would reinforce the view of many voters that Spain's political parties, both left and right, were irredeemably corrupt. The only beneficiaries, he said, would be the far-right Vox party which, having never been in power, could claim to have clean hands. 'It's analogous to what happened in Portugal after the scandals involving the socialist and then the conservative governments which benefited the far-right party there,' Simón said.
