Day two of testimony underway for Shawn Cranston murder trial
On Tuesday, a state police forensic DNA analyst testified that the DNA found on that rubber-like material is 790 septillion times more likely to be Shawn Cranston's. That's 790 with 24 zeros after it. The DNA expert said anything over 1,000 is considered strong.
About 25 members of the Amish community filled the courtroom while only three people were sitting in the area designed for Craston's family and friends.
The most emotional testimony came from Julie Warner, Andy and Rebekah Byler's primary driver.
She testified that on February 26, she dropped Andy off at his home on Fish Flats Road just a little after noon. He went to his house, and she went to the barn to use the restroom.
Moments later, Warner said Andy came running to the barn, he was frantic, and said someone had killed his wife. He then ran to her truck and 'lost it.'
Warner told Andy he needed to go into the house and get the kids out, but he said he couldn't.
Warner knew she couldn't leave the kids in the house alone with their mother if she was dead or injured, so she was going to go in and get them. That's when she saw Rebekah's body and called 911.
That call was played for the jury — Warner was heard saying, 'She's lying on the floor. I don't know if she's alive. Should I go in and check on her?'
The dispatcher told Warner to go inside and see if she's beyond medical help. Warner is then heard saying, 'There's a big pool of blood. Blood coming out of her nose and ears and it looks like her throat was slit.'
The 911 dispatcher asked if Rebecka's body was cold. Warner said, 'I don't know, I didn't touch her.' Warner then touched her leg and said it 'was cold.'
While the 911 call was being played, many Amish sat in the courtroom, leaning forward with their heads in their hands. Some were crying and wiping away tears.
Meanwhile, Cranston sat at the defense table, showing no emotion.
Jurors also saw key pieces of evidence, like tires and shoes, that prosecutors said put Cranston at Byler's house the day of the murder.
The jury also saw efforts to allegedly destroy evidence at Shawn Cranstons' home. There was also expert testimony from a forensic DNA analyst, along with a forensic serologist, which is someone who studies blood and other body fluids.
Cranston is facing charges of criminal homicide, criminal homicide of an unborn child, burglary, and criminal trespass.
Testimony will continue on Wednesday,
Related Stories:
Trial begins for man accused of murdering pregnant Amish woman
Trial for man accused of killing pregnant Amish woman pushed to 2025
2024 Amish murder case transferred to Pennsylvania Attorney General's Office
New information takes center stage in Rebekah Byler murder trial
Daughter of arrested suspect reacts to pregnant Amish woman murder case
List of seized items released in pregnant Amish woman homicide case
Murdered Amish woman suffered injuries to head, neck: investigators
Community remains in shock following Amish woman's death, Corry man's arrest
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wall Street Journal
5 days ago
- Wall Street Journal
‘Smoke and Mirrors' Review: A Magician, a Murder and a Mystery
First impressions often hide the full story in 'Smoke & Mirrors,' a debut mystery novel for middle-grade readers by Rosalyn Ransaw. Andy, our 12-year-old narrator, has been blamed for accidentally burning down a barn with a firecracker. The residents of the small Midwestern town where he is spending the summer readily accept this version of events, but the truth is more complicated. Andy has taken the fall because, as the only black kid in town, he thinks no one will believe him that a white boy was actually responsible for the damage. As punishment Andy must help the barn's owner, the cantankerous Mr. Gilbert, repair a dilapidated old house that once belonged to the Red Knave, a famous magician of the 1960s. The secretive masked performer used to stage magic shows on the property, drawing crowds eager to witness his illusions—until a man was murdered following one of his performances. Afterward, the Red Knave vanished. Though the police always suspected he was responsible for the death, no one ever cracked the case. Andy knows there must be more to the story. 'If there was one thing people were good at,' he thinks, 'it was assuming people were guilty because it was easier than doing the work of figuring out the truth.' He decides to investigate the decades-old murder, even if it means accepting the help of a local boy he is not entirely sure he trusts. 'Smoke & Mirrors' leans heavily on a classic whodunit setup as Andy and his sidekick work their way through a list of suspects and motives. Readers might crave more detail as the book builds toward its rapid-fire conclusion—a big reveal about the Red Knave's identity is glossed over far too quickly. Ms. Ransaw focuses instead on Andy's private, more nuanced motives for solving the mystery of the Red Knave: curiosity, yes, but also a keen sense of injustice. His father is in prison awaiting his parole hearing, and after Andy's own run-in with the police, he feels that no one is giving his family a fair chance. By solving the Red Knave case, Andy hopes he can get people to reconsider their first impressions—of the magician, and also of himself.
USA Today
6 days ago
- USA Today
6 killed in crash involving Amish van after truck runs stop sign
Six people died in a two-vehicle crash in Tuscola County, Michigan, authorities say. The incident occurred at an intersection in Gilford Township just before 5 p.m. on Tuesday, Aug. 12, according to the Tuscola County Sheriff's Office. Authorities say a pickup truck occupied by three people collided with a "full-size van" after the truck went past a stop sign. Ten people were inside the van at the time of the crash. The sheriff's office stated that people from the van and pickup truck were ejected from the vehicles and that the accident could have been prevented: "Please keep those affected by this tragedy in your thoughts. These incidents are preventable and people need to slow down and obey traffic laws." More news: Robbie Brewer, veteran race car driver, dies after NC crash The majority of those killed in the crash were Amish The conditions of those who survived are unknown, officials said. CBS News and ABC 12 reported that the large van was carrying Amish people, and five of them were among the deceased. According to the outlets, the local Amish use a horse and buggy to get around but will ride in vehicles for extended trips. The other person who died was from the truck, ABC 12 reported, and at least six others were hospitalized. Gilford Township is about 118 miles from Detroit. A separate crash happened on the same day in Michigan A separate crash involving the Amish community also happened on Aug. 12 in Montcalm Township. According to the Michigan State Police, a pickup truck struck a buggy occupied by five children and two adults. A 4-month-old died while hospitalized. The other juveniles were also taken to the hospital, and two people were released, as of Wednesday, Aug. 13. One adult, identified as a 24-year-old female, was said to be in stable condition. Taylor Ardrey is a news reporter for USA TODAY. You can reach her at tardrey@
Epoch Times
6 days ago
- Epoch Times
6 Dead After Truck Crashes Into Van Carrying Members of Amish Group in Michigan
A pickup truck went through a stop sign in rural Michigan and crashed into a van carrying members of an Amish community, killing at least six people, authorities said. The crash occurred Tuesday afternoon in Tuscola County's Gilford Township, 100 miles north of Detroit.
