Kennedy's Vaccine Hypocrisy Is Unsustainable
Any hopes that Mr. Kennedy's noxious views on vaccines would moderate with responsibility were always wishful thinking. It may be impossible to change his course, but that doesn't mean those in positions of leadership shouldn't try.
As health secretary, Mr. Kennedy has failed to help control the measles outbreak in and around Texas, which has ballooned to more than 500 cases and now includes the deaths of two children. This lamentable outcome is unsurprising, given that he is a longtime critic of the measles shot and in 2021 dismissed measles outbreaks as 'fabricated to create fear.' For these reasons, many doctors, including me, were opposed to his nomination as leader of our health care system.
Mr. Kennedy's best chance at stopping the deadly measles outbreak and preventing other ones is by improving vaccination rates. Yet doing so would alienate him from the anti-vaccine community. He recently attended the funeral of one of the children who died, an 8-year-old girl in Texas, and reportedly questioned the safety of vaccines to her family members. But in his public comments about the visit, he wrote that 'the most effective way to prevent the spread of measles is the MMR vaccine.' That tepid statement made headlines and drew praise from Senator Bill Cassidy, a Republican and a physician who reluctantly provided a key vote for Mr. Kennedy's confirmation.
Mr. Kennedy's supporters, however, saw the public comment as a betrayal. 'What on earth is going on with Bobby Kennedy,' wrote Liz Wheeler, a conservative media personality, adding that the Make America Healthy Again community 'fought for Bobby Kennedy because he was unafraid to name the dangers of the MMR vaccine.'
Del Bigtree, one of Mr. Kennedy's collaborators in the anti-vaccine movement, struggled to explain his apparent turnaround. 'I have worked with Bobby for many years and I can confidently say that he has a heart that is incapable of compromise,' Mr. Bigtree wrote on X. 'I also recognize that he is at a poker table with the slyest serpents in the world and the stakes are nothing less than the lives of our children and the future of our species.'
Thank you for your patience while we verify access. If you are in Reader mode please exit and log into your Times account, or subscribe for all of The Times.
Thank you for your patience while we verify access.
Already a subscriber? Log in.
Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
UPI
3 hours ago
- UPI
Vaccination rates of U.S. kindergartners down, measles cases up
A MMR vaccine information packet is seen at City of Lubbock Health Department in Lubbock, Texas, in March. According to an update from the Texas Department of State Health Services on Friday, there was was an outbreak of measles in the South Plains region of Texas where 146 cases were identified as of late January. New CDC data shows that vaccination rates are down in the United States. Photo by Annie Rice/EPA-EFE July 31 (UPI) -- Vaccination rates among U.S. kindergarten students decreased during the 2024-2025 school year, according to data released Thursday by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the District of Columbia. Rates ranged from 92.1% for diphtheria, tetanus and pertussis to 92.5% for measles, mumps and rubella. Vaccination rates for polio and varicella dropped in more than half of the states compared to a year prior, the data show. "The number of kindergarteners attending school without documentation of completing the MMR vaccine series was about 286,000 during the 2024-2025 school year," the report said. Overall, the number of kindergartners exempt from one or more vaccines during the 2024-2025 school year reached nearly 138,000, the data showed. The drop in vaccination rates comes amid an uptick in the number of measles cases in the United States. There have been 29 reported outbreaks in 2025, compared with 16 in 2024. Of 1,156 cases reported so far this year, 87% of them have been confirmed, compared to 198 of 285 confirmed cases, or 69%, in 2024.
Bloomberg
5 hours ago
- Bloomberg
CDC Cuts Experts Out of Panels That Develop Vaccine Policy
The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention told physician groups, public health professionals and infectious disease experts that they will no longer be invited to help review vaccine data and develop recommendations, according to an email viewed by Bloomberg. The move marks an escalation in Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s efforts to assert control over the CDC's vaccine advisory process. Under the change, external experts will be excluded from the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices' working groups — subcommittees that review data and develop policy recommendations — but they will still be able to participate in open public meetings.
Chicago Tribune
8 hours ago
- Chicago Tribune
How a program that gives new mothers cash could serve as a model
A procession of mothers wearing red sashes, pushing strollers and tending to toddlers made their way Friday to a little festival in Flint, Michigan, where families received diapers and kids played. It was called a 'baby parade.' The sashes indicated the women were participants of a growing program in Michigan that helps pregnant women and new moms by giving them cash over the first year of their children's lives. Launched in 2024, the program comes at a time when many voters worry over high child care costs and President Donald Trump's administration floats policy to reverse the declining birth rate. Backed by a mix of state, local and philanthropic money, Rx Kids gives mothers of newborns up to $7,500, with no income requirements and no rules for how the money is spent. Supporters believe the program could be a model for mitigating the high cost of having children in the U.S. 'There's all kinds of reasons, no matter what your political affiliation or ideology is, to support this,' said state Sen. John Damoose, a Republican and ardent supporter of the program. To qualify, women need to prove they live in a participating location and that they are pregnant, but don't have to share details about their income. It's designed to be simple. Pregnant women receive $1,500 before delivery and $500 every month for the first six to 12 months of their babies' lives, depending on the program location. Dr. Mona Hanna, a pediatrician, associate dean for public health at Michigan State University College of Human Medicine and the program's founding director, said that window is a time of great economic vulnerability for new parents — and a critical developmental period for babies. Most participants need diapers, formula, breast feeding supplies and baby clothes but every family's needs are different. The monthly payment can also help buy food and cover rent, utilities and transportation. For some moms, the extra cash allows them to afford child care and return to work. For others, it allows them to stay home longer. The program so far is available in Flint, Pontiac, Kalamazoo and five counties in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan. By fall, it will expand to a rural central Michigan county and several cities near Detroit. Hanna said the main piece of feedback she hears is that the program should be bigger. She's heard from lawmakers and others hoping to start similar programs in other states. Hanna said the program's data shows nearly all pregnant women in Flint have signed up since it became available. The locations were designed to target low-income families, though there is no income requirement. Luke Shaefer, a professor of public policy at the University of Michigan and a co-founder of Rx Kids, said they wanted to eliminate any stigma or barriers that discourage people from signing up. The founders also want mothers to feel celebrated, hence the parade Friday. 'For so long moms have been vilified and not supported,' Hanna said. Friends told Angela Sintery, 44, about Rx Kids when she found out she was pregnant with her second child. She's a preschool teacher who spread the word to other parents. Sintery had her first daughter 19 years before her second and had to buy all new baby supplies. She said the cash provided by Rx Kids would have been helpful when she had her first child at age 24, before she went to college. 'So this time around, I didn't have to stress about anything. I just had to worry about my baby,' she said. Celeste Lord-Timlin, a Flint resident and program participant, attended the baby parade with her husband and 13-month-old daughter by her side. She said the deposits helped her pay for graduate school while she was pregnant. 'It allowed us to really enjoy being new parents,' she said. The program relies heavily on philanthropic donations but Hanna's long-term goal is for the government to be the main provider. 'I see philanthropy as the doula of this program, they are helping birth it,' she said. 'They are helping us prove that this is possible.' Democrats in Michigan's state Senate introduced legislation in February that would make the program available to any pregnant woman in the state and it has bipartisan support. But with a divided Legislature only able to pass six bills total this year, it's unlikely the program will yet expand statewide soon. Even Damoose, among the program's top backers, said he doesn't think Michigan can afford statewide expansion yet. But the lawmaker who represents parts of the Upper Peninsula of Michigan does want to keep growing it. For fellow Republicans who oppose abortion as he does, the approach is a 'no brainer' way to help pregnant women, Damoose said. 'We've been accused for years and years, and not without cause, of being pro-birth, but not pro-life,' he said. 'And this is a way for us to put our money where our mouth is.' A new movement of pro-natalist political figures, including Vice President JD Vance, Elon Musk and other members of Trump's periphery, have harped on the country's declining birth rate. But a recent Associated Press-NORC poll found that most Americans want the government to focus on the high costs of child care — not just the number of babies being born here. Under Trump's tax and spending bill that Congress passed in July, the child tax credit is boosted from $2,000 child tax credit to $2,200. But millions of families at lower income levels will not get the full credit. The bill will also create a new children's saving program, called Trump Accounts, with a potential $1,000 deposit from the Treasury. That's not available until children grow up and is more focused on building wealth rather than immediate relief, Hanna said. 'We don't have that social infrastructure to invest in our families,' Hanna said. 'No wonder people aren't having children and our birth rates are going down.' The Trump administration has also toyed with the idea of giving families one-time $5,000 'baby bonuses,' a policy similar to Rx Kids. Critics have rightly pointed out that doesn't come close to covering the cost of child care or other expenses. Defenders of a cash-in-hand approach, though, say any amount can help in those critical early months. 'I think it's part of a new narrative or the rekindling of an old narrative where we start to celebrate children and families,' said Damoose.
