Police admit arrest of anti-monarchy heckler in Oxford was unlawful
Police have admitted acting unlawfully in arresting a trainee Baptist minister who called out 'Who elected him?' at a local proclamation of the accession of King Charles III.
After a two-and-a-half-year battle, Symon Hill, 47, has been paid £2,500 in compensation from Thames Valley police over his arrest in September 2022.
Hill had been returning home from his church in Oxford on a Sunday morning, three days after the death of Queen Elizabeth II, when he found his way blocked by a procession to proclaim King Charles.
He asked local police officers how he could avoid the crowds and mentioned in conversation that he disagreed with the veneration of an unelected head of state.
'They got a bit defensive about it,' said Hill. 'One asked, 'Why are you here if you don't agree with it?' I was just going home.'
Charles was then declared our 'only' king and 'rightful liege lord'.
'Who elected him?' Hill called out from the back of the crowd.
A couple of people told Hill to shut up and he responded that a head of state was being imposed without the country's explicit consent.
Three security guards appeared and ordered Hill to be quiet. He said he argued back at which point a number of police officers 'swooped in'.
Hill was handcuffed and led away, as strangers challenged the right of the police to detain someone for voicing an opinion even if it was one with which they disagreed.
In police body-worn camera footage shared during the legal challenge, officers are heard saying: 'But we do need to fine or de-arrest as we will get a complaint off the back of this.'
Hill was subsequently released but later asked to voluntarily attend a police station. 'I was made aware then that it wasn't so voluntary so I did go to the police station,' he said.
He was ultimately charged under the Public Order Act with 'threatening or abusive words or behaviour'.
The charges were dropped on 5 January 2023 by the Crown Prosecution Service due to insufficient evidence.
Hill, who is a chaplain at Aston University in Birmingham, said he had been 'surprised' by the entire affair and by the two-and-a-half years it had taken for the police to admit their mistake.
Sign up to First Edition
Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters
after newsletter promotion
He said: 'Opposing the monarchy is not a crime. I'm very conscious that most people who are wrongly arrested are not able to take legal action.
'This is not just about me. It never has been. It is about the rights of all people to dissent, to express their views, to refuse to bow down, to assert the dignity and equality of all human beings.
'With the vague anti-protest laws as they are, anybody could face arrest for expressing an opinion in a public space. The law must be changed and the police must be held to account.'
Hill, who has a history of peace activism and protest, was supported in his legal action by the National Council for Civil Liberties, also known as Liberty.
Katy Watts, a lawyer at Liberty, said: 'We must be able to raise our voices on the issues that matter to us. A functioning democracy relies on the ability to voice different opinions and discuss them in public spaces. Symon's wrongful arrest shows how broad anti-protest laws are shutting down people's freedom of expression.
'We must urgently see a review of the broad anti-protest legislation to ensure that what happened to Symon cannot be allowed to happen again.'
Thames Valley police's deputy chief constable, Ben Snuggs, said: 'Thames Valley police has settled a claim with Mr Hill and has accepted that the grounds of the offence for which he was arrested were unlawful.
'Public order and public safety operations are a key part of policing and it's important we use these circumstances to help shape our future response.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Sussex Police officer charged with sexually assaulting four women
A Sussex Police officer has been charged with sexually assaulting four an investigation, the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) authorised that PC Ryan Busby, 25, be charged with four counts of sexual assault by touching, police incidents are alleged to have happened with four women known to him on 20 December 2024 while Mr Busy was off will appear at Guildford Magistrates' Court on 8 July. The force says Mr Busy is suspended from Police explained that the matter was referred to the Independent Office of Police Conduct, which instructed that a local investigation by the force's professional standards department should be carried out.
The Independent
4 hours ago
- The Independent
Spending review in six charts: Where Rachel Reeves cuts and pay boosts will land
Chancellor Rachel Reeves unveiled the government 's 2025 spending review, laying out government and departmental spending over the next four years. Overall, budgets will grow by 2.3 per cent a year - a more modest sum compared to 3.8 per cent annually at the 2021 spending review under Boris Johnson's Conservative government. There was a record boost for the NHS, amounting to an extra £29 bn a year, as well as extra funds for policing and prisons. But budgets were squeezed elsewhere. Here, the Independent looks at the headline figures from the chancellor's speech. Which departments will benefit? Most departments will see their budgets rise, to varying degrees. The biggest percentage increase was for the Department of Energy Security and Net Zero, which will see a 16 per cent real-terms boost to its budget each year, doubling from £5.6bn this year to £11.4bn in 2025/6. Ed Miliband's department will also see £14.2bn for the new Sizewell C nuclear power station over the next five years. The Suffolk plant will power around six million homes, will be completed in the next decade. The Business and Trade, MHCLG Local Government, and Law Officers' departments will also see more moderate real-terms growth in their budgets. Over £3bn for the Department of Business and trade will be for advanced manufacturing in the net-zero transition, such as zero-emission vehicles and aircraft. The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) will also receive record levels of funding at £1bn in 2028/9, increasing capacity for prosecuting criminal cases. In real terms, the Health and Social Care budget, which already represents the biggest proportion of government spending, will increase the most, with £58.2bn more in 2028/9 compared to 2023/4. The defence budget, which is protected and cannot be cut, will grow £19.6bn larger by 2028/9, to £73.5bn. This is part of Sir Keir Starmer's commitment to boost defence spending to 2.7 per cent of GDP from 2027, and 3 per cent by the next parliament, following pressure from Donald Trump and Nato to ramp up spending in response to global threats, such as Russia. However, the uplift has led to the foreign aid budget being slashed. As a result, the Foreign Office will see the sharpest drop in funding - with a 5 per cent real-terms cut per year. The Home Office will also see a 2.2 per cent shrinkage in real-terms growth, while the Culture, Media and Sport, Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, and the Cabinet Office will see real-terms depreciation. Most of these real-terms losses are due to inflation, meaning that budgets are growing at a slower pace than costs are rising, if at all. Several departments whose funding is not protected from cuts are set to see their budgets shrink. £20m for selected regions The government also announced 25 new 'trailblazer neighbourhoods' which will receive long-term investment over the next decade. The majority of these are in England, with five across Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland. Each area will receive up to £20 million over the next decade, in locations including Brinnington (Stockport) and Birkenhead Central (Wirral). Police and prisons clampdown Law enforcement was also a key focus in the spending review. The chancellor announced that police spending power would increase by 2.3 per cent per year on average, as part of the government's commitment to add 13,000 police officers and staff to neighbourhood policing. But police chiefs hit out, saying the increase was a 'huge blow' that would leave forces struggling to meet their pledges, including halving violence against women and girls and fulfilling their recruitment targets. Ms Reeves also committed £7bn over the next five years to build 14,000 new prison places, alongside investment in the probation system. Prisons across England and Wales are currently 98.9 per cent full, according to government figures; with jails dangerously close to their overall 89,000 capacity. The investment follows an open letter from senior police and security chiefs, warning that plans to release prisoners early could cause 'net detriment to public safety' without further spending to bolster police forces. The increase comes after fraught talks with Home Secretary Yvette Cooper, who was the last minister to agree a spending deal with the Treasury. In the end, Ms Reeves imposed a settlement on the department, with a Whitehall sources telling The Times 'Yvette pushed very hard but was told that there simply isn't the money for it.' NHS digitisation and repairs The NHS will receive a £29bn real-terms increase in annual day-to-day spending, from 2023/4 to 2028/9. Ms Reeves said that the government would invest £10bn to further digitise the NHS, with a focus on the NHS app; in addition to £30bn over the next five years for maintenance and repair across NHS buildings. Ms Reeves claimed that significant progress had been made in the NHS since the Labour government came into power last summer. In that time, the NHS has recruited 1,700 new GPs and cut waiting lists by over 200,000, to 7.4 million, she said. But there are concerns that the increase will also need to fund pay rises for doctors - who are threatening strike action if they don't get a 29 per cent rise.
Telegraph
12 hours ago
- Telegraph
Householders who racially abuse police at home to face prosecution
People who racially abuse police making house calls will be prosecuted under plans to close a legal loophole. Offenders will face up to two years in jail if they are found guilty of directing religious or racial abuse at emergency service workers who enter their homes. The Public Order Act of 1986 made it illegal to racially or religiously abuse anyone in public but did not cover behaviour within a private home. The legislation was designed to let police keep public spaces free from abuse but not overstep into conversations held in private. But the Home Office said this left police and other emergency workers vulnerable and unprotected from racial and religious harassment during house calls, and meant they could not bring perpetrators to account. Home Office officials said ministers had decided to close the loophole because of an increase in reports of emergency workers being abused for their race or religion while in private homes. 'They should not have to tolerate abuse' A Home Office spokesman said: 'By closing the loophole in the Public Order Act 1986, the Government is making clear that racially or religiously motivated abuse and threats towards our emergency workers will never be tolerated, regardless of where it takes place.' Dame Diana Johnson, the policing minister, said: 'Our emergency workers put themselves in harm's way every day to keep us safe and they should never have to tolerate abuse due to their race or religion while simply doing their job. 'By closing this loophole, we're sending a clear message that racial and religious abuse directed towards those who serve our communities will not be tolerated.' The changes will be introduced through amendments to Labour's Crime and Policing Bill, which will also extend police powers to enter homes to seize knives and mobile phones. At present, the law only allows officers to seize blades that are on the banned list, such as 'zombie' knives and machetes, and ministers said police were hamstrung when they raided suspects' homes. They are not allowed to take weapons such as kitchen knives, which are not on the list, even if they suspect they will be used in crimes. Police will also be able to enter homes and search for stolen mobile phones without a warrant, if the devices have been electronically tracked to that location. Wes Streeting, the Health Secretary, said the law change would enable emergency workers to save lives free from violence or intimidation. 'Anyone who violates this core principle brings shame on themselves and will feel the full force of the law, wherever they are,' he said. 'I will not stand any health worker being subjected to abuse and take a zero-tolerance approach, and these new measures will crack down on perpetrators.'
