logo
Middle powers such as Australia relied on the rules-based order, but that's in doubt. Here's what we must do

Middle powers such as Australia relied on the rules-based order, but that's in doubt. Here's what we must do

The Guardian25-02-2025

The iconoclastic news whirlwind around Donald Trump points to a new US approach on the international stage: globalism and free trade are out. Spheres of influence are back in vogue. It's not isolationism, it's transactional mercantilism. But with Australia heavily invested in its US relationship we need to calmly undertake a net assessment: to weigh up what's at stake while looking to engage with our region more fully.
US globalism has been soured by the effects of catastrophic wars in the Middle East since 2001, coupled with the 2008 global financial crisis, a drug scourge, a surge of immigration, a sense of being taken advantage of and an undermining of faith in government. These echo in Australian society.
China's rapid growth and adversarial mercantilism helped. Russia's barbarous invasion of Ukraine added to the mix. Trump has supercharged the disruption with his sidelining of allies and favouring of autocrats. That leaves us at an inflection point.
For middle powers such as Australia, the rules-based order has been convenient, helping to enable global trade and enhanced prosperity. But it's also been flimsy and is now in doubt.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
The 2017 foreign policy white paper, issued shortly after Trump came to office last time, was effectively our 'Plan B'. In the face of a US transactional retreat from ideational leadership, the white paper talked up the alliance but mainly bolstered other connections to offset growing US disengagement. We emphasised the Association of South-east Asian Nations (Asean); the Pacific Islands Forum (Pif); the Indian Ocean Rim Association (Iora) and others.
The 2024 national defence strategy was written with China's adventurist mercantilism and military expansion in mind. But these two documents now need a significant rethink. A net assessment is in order, carefully re-examining Australian interests and regional obligations, and the best way to approach our exceptional friend, the US.
We came closer to European partners with our involvement in the war in Afghanistan, and because they too are concerned about reverberations at both ends of the Eurasian landmass.
The Quad also helped tie in the US, alongside Japan, India and Australia, working on regional economic, technical and human security projects.
Meanwhile, the Five Eyes intelligence-sharing arrangements, spawned in the second world war, prompted parallel defence, border security, policing and intelligence ties.
Today the Europeans, Quad and Five Eyes connections may have a newfound utility – for engaging with equally shocked erstwhile US allies and partners including friends in Asean, the Pif and Iora.
Take the Anzus alliance: it doesn't include an HQ, a commander, forces assigned or a mutual defence guarantee. It's an 800-word essay. To be sure, the security ties are now wide-ranging but, if the treatment of our strategic cousins in Canada is anything to go by, this pact offers no assurance. What mitigates this is the convenience of Australia as a suitable piece of real estate, for facilities at Pine Gap (intelligence), Tindal (air force), Darwin (marines) and Perth (navy and submarines).
Australia's one-punch boutique defence force and limited volunteer emergency services are structured for the unipolar moment and to make not much more than niche contributions far afield. This was for a more benign time.
The Aukus agreement for sharing advanced technology has been described as a waste of money that, with Trump's return, leaves Australia vulnerable to being dragged into another war. Yet Trump hasn't started wars and evidently seeks to avoid conflict over Taiwan, perhaps even making a deal with China.
So far Aukus retains broad bipartisan support in Australia and the US, including with Trump and the US submarine industrial base is being re-energised. While challenging, therefore, the concerns are still manageable.
Instead of conscription, we could consider introducing a voluntary but incentivised national and community service scheme – covering the armed forces and cyber force, along with state emergency, police, fire and national park services. We could also have a Peace Corps-like body to bolster regional engagement and delivery of aid and humanitarian assistance – and perhaps compensate in the Pacific for drastic cuts in USAid.
Strong and broad ties with Indonesia and Papua New Guinea are critical. These have been strengthened but need to go deeper across business, education, societal and security links. After all, when we last faced an existential crisis in 1942, it was there. Now, though, there are ways to sweeten the connections in collaboration with other neighbours.
We also need to boost offerings to Pif member states, facing looming environmental catastrophe, governance challenges and the buffeting from great power competition. We should propose a grand compact or a Pacific island federation. It could look like a cross between Asean, the European Union and the Pacific compact state arrangements. This way we would share some sovereignty and gain some collective security and bolster self-reliance.
Australians have a fear of abandonment matched by a lingering fear of entrapment. Those fears are more acute now than in ages.
John Blaxland is professor of international security and intelligence studies at the ANU's strategic and defence studies centre

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Trump reveals the advice he gave Barron about drugs and tattoos
Trump reveals the advice he gave Barron about drugs and tattoos

Daily Mail​

time17 minutes ago

  • Daily Mail​

Trump reveals the advice he gave Barron about drugs and tattoos

President Donald Trump revealed his 'formula for good parenting' as 19-year-old Barron wraps up his first year in college. 'I always said the same thing. I said: no drugs, no alcohol, no cigarettes. I also would say don't get tattoos, but I don't say it too strongly, because a lot of people have gotten tattoos, and that's what they choose to do,' Trump told The New York Post in a podcast interview released Wednesday. Many of the president's supporters at rallies sport tattoos and even some members of Trump's Cabinet, including Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. The 78-year-old president has made a point of not drinking, as his older brother, Fred Trump Jr., suffered from alcoholism and died young, at age 42. He boasted that his five children - Donald Trump Jr., Ivanka, Eric, Tiffany and Barron - were 'born smart.' 'Barron is great. He is very tall and good,' the president said of his youngest, his only child with first lady Melania Trump. The president also revealed the sad reason why Barron was drawn to studying at New York University - he thought his late grandmother would live nearby. 'He just wanted to be there,' Trump said. 'He wanted to be there because his grandmother was gonna stay and wait for him in an apartment near the school. And she passed away.' Barron Trump is spotted leaving class at New York University last month. President Donald Trump said his 'formula for good parenting' was to tell his broad to avoid alcohol, cigarettes, drugs and even tattoos Melania's mother Amalija Knavs died in January 2024 at the age of 78. 'She was fantastic. Melania's mother was a fantastic woman. And Melania is a fantastic mother, by the way. She loves Baron,' Trump said. 'He's very tall and he's a good-looking guy.' Barron started at NYU as a freshman later in the year. Trump said he warned his son 'a little bit' about 'all the lefty professors' at the school. During the 2024 cycle, Barron, at that point 18, popped his head up more on the campaign trail. He attended his first Trump rally at his father's Doral golf club in Miami in July - the rally the Republican nominee attended before the Butler, Pennsylvania event where he was nearly assassinated. Barron also pushed his father to appear on particular podcasts, which likely helped the president increase his strength among the young male vote - a bloc Democrats usually overwhelmingly win. Trump lauded his other children in the interview too. 'Eric has done a fantastic job,' the president said. 'Ivanka, you know Ivanka? Yes. Very well. She's so great,' he continued. 'And Tiffany has done really well,' he said. She went to a great law school and did very well. Always a good student.' Eric Trump, and brother Donald Trump Jr., have been inking deals as the heads of the Trump Organization, while Ivanka has stepped back from the political limelight, after working in the first Trump administration. She did travel with her father over the weekend. Tiffany Trump had her first child, a son, in May. But it's Donald Trump Jr. who's most often referenced when there's talk of a Trump dynasty. Trump wasn't sure if Don Jr. would ever run for president. 'I don't know. I mean, I don't know. I think all of them probably have a future in politics, frankly. And Don is very good. A good guy. He's an outdoorsman,' the president said.

Dan Bongino wants to move FBI training program from iconic Quantico HQ to Alabama: report
Dan Bongino wants to move FBI training program from iconic Quantico HQ to Alabama: report

The Independent

time25 minutes ago

  • The Independent

Dan Bongino wants to move FBI training program from iconic Quantico HQ to Alabama: report

Leaders in the FBI are reportedly pushing to move one of the bureau's training programs from its headquarters in Quantico, Virginia, to Huntsville, Alabama, as part of President Donald Trump's desire to move federal agencies out of the Washington D.C. area. Dan Bongino, the FBI deputy director, has preliminarily proposed moving the FBI National Academy, a 10-week training academy for 250 domestic and international law enforcement officers, to Huntsville, the Washington Post reported on Wednesday. The FBI's training program for new bureau hires and other parts of its facilities, including the laboratory division, would remain at Quantico, people familiar with the discussion told The Post. While the proposal is still in preliminary stages, it aligns with Trump's April deadline asking agencies to create plans to move their headquarters from Washington D.C., to separate areas of the country to ' be where the people are.' However, the push to move to Huntsville, the most populous city in Alabama, has drawn criticism from some personnel who believe the move could be unjustifiably costly, The Post reported. While the FBI has operated at Redstone Arsenal, a U.S. Army base near downtown Huntsville, for decades, some expressed concern that sending hundreds of staff and agents to set up the training facility would require upgrades. 'If you look at FBI field offices, for example, you'll see many that are not located in downtown areas given the highly specialized nature of these facilities and their security requirements,' Norman Dong, the former Public Buildings Service commissioner under the Obama administration, told Federal News Network in April. 'In places like Atlanta or Sacramento, these FBI offices are located far outside of the central city,' Dong added. The FBI Academy is currently located in Quantico, a town in Prince William County, Virginia, which is approximately 35 miles outside of D.C. A spokesperson for the FBI said that any relocation options were being evaluated to determine if it could save the bureau money while also serving as a sufficient facility. Since Trump took office in January, the bureau has undergone significant changes, beginning with its leadership. Trump nominated Kash Patel to serve as FBI director despite Patel having a history of taking controversial pro-Trump stances. The president then tapped Bongino, a former Secret Service agent who became a popular right-wing podcaster, as deputy director. After Patel was sworn in, he said he would relocate roughly 1,000 staff and agents out of the D.C. office and said he'd move 500 people to the Huntsville facility so the FBI could have more of a presence in other cities. Trump proposed moving federal buildings and agencies outside of D.C. during his first administration, but the plan did not have immense success, in part due to the Covid-19 pandemic. Trump moved the Bureau of Land Management's headquarters from D.C. to Grand Junction, Colorado in 2019 so it could be closer to the land it manages. However, a review by the Biden administration found that the move caused more than 80 percent of the agency's employees to leave. Eventually, the headquarters were restored back to Washington D.C.

Les Miserables actors drop out because Trump is attending show
Les Miserables actors drop out because Trump is attending show

The Independent

time25 minutes ago

  • The Independent

Les Miserables actors drop out because Trump is attending show

President Trump and Vice President Vance, along with their wives, will attend a performance of Les Misérables at the Kennedy Center, marking Trump 's first visit to the venue during his second term. Trump 's decision to assume control of the Kennedy Center, replacing previous leadership and vowing to eliminate 'woke' programming, has sparked controversy. In response to Trump 's involvement, some cast members of Les Misérables are expected to boycott the performance. Following Trump 's takeover, several high-profile performers and members resigned, and the center has experienced a significant drop in ticket sales, leading to canceled performances. Trump has expressed his fondness for Les Misérables, even suggesting the possibility of extending its run at the Kennedy Center, which is currently scheduled through July 13.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store