'Look, 40% of the southeast have Norman names': Browne defends William the Conqueror millennium
A plan to commemorate the first Norman king of England William the Conqueror in 2027, one thousand years after his birth, was
proposed to cabinet this week by Browne
and was sharply met with dismay from Sinn Féin.
The year-long commemoration were
labelled 'offensive' by Sinn Féin TD Aengus Ó Snodaigh
.
He said it beggared belief, given the 'legacy of William's successors invading and subjugating Ireland in the name of his English crown'.
Asked about the criticism today, Browne told
The Journal
that the events were about 'respectfully commemorating a historical event that hugely influenced Ireland's future'.
'Look, around 15% of the population in this country are Norman heritage. When you go down to the southeast, up to 40% of surnames are Norman heritage.'
The Normans, who landed in Wexford's Bannow Bay in 1169, were responsible for the foundation of many Irish towns.
They also built castles, abbeys and cathedrals that are still standing today. These include St Patrick's Cathedral and Christ Church Cathedral.
The first Norman king of England, William the Conquerer, began his reign after he won the Battle of Hastings in 1066, defeating King Harold's English army.
Advertisement
Following a cabinet meeting on Tuesday, Browne said the Normans 'left their mark in monumental ways' and he wants this new initiative to leave a lasting legacy, by promoting tourism and boosting the economy.
Heritage Minister James Browne clarified that the events were not celebrating any particular person.
Muiris Ó Cearbhaill / The Journal
Muiris Ó Cearbhaill / The Journal / The Journal
Today, he clarified that the events were about commemorating – not celebrating – a group of people who arrived to Ireland and 'ended up with a tagline of being more Irish than the Irish themselves'.
'They adopted Gaelic culture, they married into Gaelic families, and they fought for Irish freedom on many, many occasions. So we're right to commemorate it. We're not celebrating anybody, so we're not.'
Ó Snodaigh this week slammed Browne's plan as amounting to 'scraping the barrel of colonialism, imperialism and English royalism' for the sake of 'themed tourism'.
He said we should 'take pride in the rich architectural, cultural, and literary heritage' of Anglo-Norman Ireland, but that his party draws the line at focusing the commemoration around England's first Norman king.
Asked about Ó Snodaigh's remarks, Browne told
The Journal
: 'I'm a little bit worried that Sinn Féin have increasingly taken any opportunity to hint at nativism. I think, you know, we really have to be very careful with this type of language.'
The 'European Year of the Normans' will consist of multidisciplinary events, such as exhibitions, live performances, cross-border artistic residencies, re-enactments, student exchanges, sports, research and more.
It will also involve partners from Normandy, the Channel Islands, Italy, the United Kingdom, Norway, and Denmark. The events will take place from March to October 2027.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
2 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Displaced Ukrainians who fled war zone for Alaska give opinion on Vladimir Putin visit to adopted home
The couple haven't seen each other since she and her son Mark (15) fled Ukraine after Russia launched a full-scale invasion more than three years ago and missiles struck near her hometown near Dnipro. She and her son managed to find refuge 7,500km away in Alaska under a Joe Biden-era programme offering Ukrainians a safe haven in the US. But Ms Pokidcenko fears she could lose her husband any day, as she has lost friends and relatives fighting on the front lines. 'It is my biggest pain, and this is what my tears are all about,' Ms Pokidcenko told The Telegraph. 'All I want to have is my husband back and to be with him and be together, every birthday my son wishes for his dad to be with us, and unfortunately I cannot fulfil his birthday wish.' Tomorrow, she will come the closest she ever has been to the man responsible for her family's devastation when Vladimir Putin arrives in Anchorage − the city she fled to. His meeting with Donald Trump, which marks the first time Putin has visited the US in a decade, has sparked fears across Europe that the two world leaders will carve up Ukraine while Volodymyr Zelensky is frozen out. I have to believe that this will be the beginning of an agreement But rather than feel frustration and anger that Putin is coming to town, Ms Pokidcenko is optimistic it could mark the beginning of the end of the war. 'I have to be very hopeful that this will be something that then moves the world,' she said. 'I can't trust him [Putin], and I can't believe everything that he says, but I have to believe that this will be the beginning of an agreement.' Ms Pokidcenko's hope is echoed by several of the 1,000 Ukrainian refugees who fled to Alaska since 2022 with the help of New Chance, a Russian-language church. Ms Pokidcenko moved to Alaska with her friend Olena Demchenko, and her two children, Aleksander (15) and seven-year-old Sofia. She now works in a care home in Anchorage. Ms Demchenko (38) can remember waking up to the sounds of bombs blowing up when Russia invaded. Her family boarded a train to Poland, where they stayed for several months, before Zori Opanasevych, who works with New Chance, messaged them on Facebook saying she could help evacuate them to Alaska. 'I told my mum, and she said, 'no, I oppose this very strongly. It's colder, there's polar bears, you're going to freeze there, you're not going to survive'. All we knew about Alaska, but what we knew was, it was snow-covered mountains with Eskimos,' Ms Demchenko said. They arrived in 'an unbelievable place where the sky was so close to us', she said. Her children enrolled in school and learnt English and she found a job as a supermarket cashier. But when asked about how she feels about Putin's upcoming visit to Alaska, she told The Telegraph: 'This may sound strange, but when I heard this, I had hope that this meeting will be a period or a dot for this terrible, long war.' Ms Opanasevych said while some Ukrainians have expressed 'anger' at Putin's upcoming visit and have said they will protest, the majority are choosing to keep their distance as they can't bear the pain of revisiting those emotions. Amid the backdrop of this meeting, refugees like Ms Demchenko live in fear that they will not be granted permission to remain in the US. The Trump administration has slowed granting extensions to a halt, leaving many families in limbo. At least a dozen Ukrainian refugee families have already left Alaska after a lapse in their status granted under the Uniting for Ukraine programme, Ms Opanasevych said. 'It just feels like we're being pressured, and the strongest ones will survive and kind of not crack under this,' Ms Opanasevych said. Ms Demchenko said she worries her parole will not be renewed to remain in the US next year. She tries not to think about Russia increasing its presence on the Bering Strait, which separates the US and Russia. 'It does not make me happy, I just would never want the same thing to happen to us, to repeat that story,' she said. It is very, very stressful. It is something I think about every day, and all day Ukrainian refugee Tetiana Kuznitsova's legal status to remain in the US expires next week. Ms Kuznitsova (50) said finding refuge in the country allowed her 'to breathe in relief' and feel safe. Shortly after moving to Alaska she met her fiance, John Tull (58), a US citizen, but she wants to enjoy the engagement and does not wish to rush the wedding. 'It is very, very stressful. It is something I think about every day, and all day,' she said. Zoya Koval is also hopeful some progress can be made. She and her husband Vitalii Koval had just spent four years renovating their dream home, which had a sprawling garden with apple trees and flowers, when they fled their hometown Okhtyrka, which is close to the front line, with their three sons. On the night of Russia's invasion, Ms Koval said she saw explosions in the distance while her husband went to get petrol to flee the city. Mr Koval (37), who works in construction, was able to leave the country with the family as he had three children, and they moved to Poland for six months before relocating to Alaska with the help of New Chance. Of Putin's upcoming visit, Ms Koval said: 'I really hope that this brings a purpose to this meeting, so that it would end the war, and not just for a little short while, but end the war.'
Irish Independent
2 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Letters: Let's keep fingers crossed that Donald Trump's meeting with Vladimir Putin will prove fruitful
With the exception of Hungary, all the EU leaders backed the statement, saying that meaningful negotiations can only take place in the context of a ceasefire or a reduction of hostilities. US president Donald Trump is due to meet his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin in Alaska tomorrow to discuss bringing an end to the war. As things stand, there's no invitation for the country the Russian leader invaded, nor for the continent it sits in. It would be true to say that European allies of Ukraine have been burnt before regarding Russian ceasefires. In the past, Russia has made promises that haven't been honoured. I would imagine that the EU will especially be anxious about any possible demands by Russia that Ukraine gives up its quest to join Nato or the EU. One has to be concerned that the outcome of tomorrow's meeting could leave the people of Ukraine extremely unhappy. Of course, the meeting could fall apart without and progress or breakthrough. Perish the thought. John O'Brien, Clonmel, Co Tipperary As Gazan people continue to suffer, at what point are we going to say 'No more'? I fully agree with your editorial that the intentional assassination of journalists in Gaza was intended to stifle the truth in the middle of the genocide and starvation ('Israel's attempt to silence journalists must be condemned', August 12). Journalists, health-care personnel, children, women, the sick, the infirm and the disabled, along with others, have paid far too high a price in this senseless war. They have witnessed unimaginable death, destruction and famine. Sadly, the international community has become desensitised to images of demolished hospitals, mutilated bodies, weeping women and starving children. When will we say 'No more' to these horrors of war? Dr Munjed Farid Al Qutob, London Vile attacks on our Indian neighbours must not be tolerated in Irish society The abhorrent hate crimes perpetrated against members of the Indian community in Ireland violate our nation's values of inclusion and equality. They endanger a community that has given so much to our country through its contributions to health care and the economy. These hate crimes become even more abhorrent when you consider the powerful historical ties between our nations, something that has been highlighted recently by politicians and other influential figures and must continue to be propagated to help foster tolerance in those who support xenophobia. When you read about our histories, you realise there are potent parallels to be found. To those Irish people who would defend the ill-treatment of the Indian community, there are questions that I feel they must strongly consider. Did you know Ireland and India have a shared history of colonialism? Did you know we have a historical longing for self-determination and nationhood? Did you know we have a shared trauma of famine, conflict and partition within our nations? Did you know that during the Irish Famine of the 1840s, wealthy Hindus, princes and those of lesser financial means donated thousands of pounds to relief efforts for our ancestors? Wouldn't all of this justify a strong bond and affinity between our people, and not the bigotry manifested in the recent hate crimes? I hope this cancer in our society can be cured and that the Indian community in Ireland will feel welcomed and respected. Tadhg Mulvey, Co Meath Ireland should look to its history to learn how to assimilate immigrants As an Irish immigrant in Canada, I have watched from afar how Ireland deals with the issue of racism. Without going into details Ireland needs to look inward. It is long forgotten that it took about 12 generations (1200 to 1450) for the Normans and Gaels to assimilate, but eventually we all became one happy race. Hopefully with that behind us, the Irish can do better. Gerard Walsh, Port Elgin, Ontario Pesky minor headaches that build up to an all-out war as I go about my life Small annoyances have a knack for stealing our patience, especially after a long day. The fly that landed on my head last night while I was trying to sleep ranks high, as does the classic sock that stubbornly slips down inside the shoe. There's the phone screen that refuses to unlock on the first try, traffic lights turning red just as you approach and the dreaded single hair lurking in your dinner. Then there's public wifi that fails every five minutes, the last stubborn blob of toothpaste that won't come out and the remote control dying mid-show. Add to that the loud chewing in a quiet auditorium, misplaced keys when you're already late and the beer that foams over before you've even poured a proper glass. And, in solidarity with Tom Gilsenan, there's the state-service queue where you are always 12th in line (Letters, August 13). He called a public body at 1.30pm and again at 4pm, still stuck behind the same 11th caller who must have been reciting his or her memoirs. I'm sure I'm not the only one who has these issues, and I'm equally sure there are others I haven't listed. Enda Cullen, Tullysaran Road, Armagh Gaeltacht colleges keep Irish language alive and are integral to education Áine Ní Bhreisleáin writes about the challenges facing Irish colleges in the Gaeltacht regions, where last year 25,480 students attended courses ('Exodus of mná tí could lead to end of Gaeltacht tradition for Irish teens', Irish Independent, August 12). Not only does an influx of students contribute to the economies of these regions, but the students themselves immerse themselves in an environment where Irish is the everyday language of the ordinary people living there. For most students this is the only time during their school years when they experience our native language outside of school. The 'coláistí samhraidh' need greater supports because their importance in fostering a 'grá don teanga' in the next generation cannot be over-estimated,
Irish Examiner
8 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Ireland must fix infrastructure gaps urgently to secure foreign direct investment
Ireland must address infrastructure gaps with 'great urgency' if it is to successfully attract and grow foreign direct investment (FDI) into the country particularly in light of the new tariff regime coming out of the US, the American Chamber of Commerce Ireland has warned. In its pre-budget submission, the Chamber makes a number of recommendations for the Government to focus in order to make the country a more appealing location for investment. Chief executive of the American Chamber of Commerce Ireland Paul Sweetman said with the current 'challenging environment' with tariffs, prompted by US president Donald Trump, competition for investment and talent ' is continuing to increase'. According to the Chamber, 90% of its members surveyed said their corporate headquarters have a positive view of Ireland as an investment location, and 68% said their headquarters already have plans to invest in Ireland over the next five years. It also found that 96% of members said believe the ability to meet climate targets is critical in preserving Ireland's competitiveness, while the same number of respondents expressed concern over the impact that reaching full capacity at Irish airports and ports would have for growth and investment. Mr Sweetman warned that 'infrastructural gaps in key areas including housing, energy and transport are a challenge to Ireland's competitiveness'. The recently announced revised National Development Plan commits to strong investment across a number areas, but it is vital Ireland addresses infrastructure gaps with great urgency. "This can position the country for continued success in attracting and growing foreign direct investment into the future.' On the infrastructure gap, the Chamber said that along with delivering housing, 'critical transport connectivity projects including MetroLink and Dart+' are also needed along with funding to Uisce Éireann to support long-term development projects. The Chamber survey of members found that 98% indicated the availability of housing is a challenge for their employees. In this area it also called for enhancing the electricity grid capacity while supporting renewable energy growth. In the area of taxation, the Chamber has called for tax credits in the areas of digitalisation and decarbonisation as well as the extension of current income tax exemptions and reducing personal tax burdens on employees to support the attraction and retention of talent. The Chamber also called for policies around attracting and retaining talent which includes 'advancing measures to address skills gaps and further support apprenticeships, expanding roles eligible for employment permits and providing an annual budget to support innovation'. Mr Sweetman said that the budget should focus on 'economic levels' within the Government's control. 'Our pre-budget submission outlines smart investment and policy decisions that will best prepare Ireland to leverage opportunities in talent attraction, research and development, digital solutions and energy over the years to come,' he said. 'Winning the next wave of FDI is achievable if Ireland builds upon its existing strengths. This, in turn, will support the growth of the 970 US operations in Ireland, directly employing 210,000 people and a further 169,000 people indirectly.'
