Tien not on board with MTR over need for shutdown
Tien not on board with MTR over need for shutdown
Michael Tien said he didn't think it was necessary to shut down the entire Tseung Kwan O line on Thursday. File photo: RTHK
A lawmaker has questioned why the MTR Corporation had to shut down the entire Tseung Kwan O line last Thursday, when power and signalling failures halted services for five hours starting from the evening rush hour.
Roundtable's Michael Tien quoted the railway company as telling him that it couldn't switch to manual operation and use the one available track for trains to go both ways because the section was still running on the old signalling system.
Tien, who chaired the Kowloon–Canton Railway Corporation before the merger of the two rail companies, said he didn't find the explanation acceptable.
"When you look at the past two, three years, service disruptions didn't affect the whole Tsuen Wan and Island lines – with both of them also running on the old signalling system," he told RTHK's In the Chamber programme.
"They just switched to manual.
"The design is that, once the automated system isn't safe enough, you can go manual so that the trains would go at a slower speed."
The government has said the MTR has to spend more than HK$19 million on passenger rebates because of the service disruption.
As a result of the Tseung Kwan O stoppage and two others earlier in February and April, the MTRC will be having a day of half-priced fares on a Saturday or Sunday.
Tien said he found it "a bit funny" that passengers across the entire network would benefit, when it was mostly those taking the Tseung Kwan O line trains that bore the brunt of the shutdown.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTHK
6 hours ago
- RTHK
Security risks put paid to communications tender
Security risks put paid to communications tender Chris Tang says tendering can still be adopted to procure items that don't have any national security implications. Photo: RTHK Secretary for Security Chris Tang said on Tuesday the government has decided to skip the tendering process in procuring a next-generation communications system for the police force after taking into consideration national security risks. The force began parallel tendering to select a service provider to upgrade its communication system with 5G capabilities two years ago. However, the open tender process has since been abandoned, with the force citing geopolitical risks affecting supply chains and concerns over information security. According to papers submitted to Legco, authorities said they opted to directly approach a "reliable" service provider of their choice. In a Legislative Council security panel meeting, Tang said the decision on next-generation communications does not mean that all police procurements will skip the tendering process. 'We believe national security considerations are necessary but they do not mean every procurement exercise has to place them as our top priority,' he said. 'For example, we would also have to procure stationery and other products. So as long as they don't have any national security implications, we believe we should still adopt the conventional method of putting procurements up for tender.' The project's estimated cost has also substantially reduced to HK$2 billion, a more than 60 percent decrease compared to the original estimate of HK$5.2 billion. Tang assured lawmakers that this would not affect the system's functionality. 'We have already enhanced the design," he said. "For example, initially we were supposed to have two sets of hardware, and now we can have one with built-in firewalls. "All these have been adopted without affecting our operational efficiency. Therefore it's now cheaper and still equally efficient.' The proposed system also adopts a hybrid model, whereby the government will build and operate the core network and base stations, which will be complemented by commercial services for broader coverage and cost-effectiveness. Tang said the police will have priority in using the 5G network in congested areas, such as during fireworks shows. Annual expenditure for the proposed system will be about HK$40 million higher than current costs, but Tang stressed the higher expenditure incurred in upgrading the system is necessary to enhance efficiency. Lawmakers agreed to allow the proposal to proceed to the finance committee stage this month.
RTHK
7 hours ago
- RTHK
Xi, Trump to have phone call this week: White House
Xi, Trump to have phone call this week: White House The Foreign Ministry says Beijing has "no information to provide" on White House claims that the leaders of China and the US would talk this week. File photo: RTHK President Xi Jinping and his US counterpart Donald Trump will likely hold a long-awaited call later this week, the White House said on Monday, as trade tensions between the world's two biggest economies ratchet back up. Asked about the matter on Tuesday, a spokesman for the Foreign Ministry said Beijing had "no information to provide." Trump re-ignited strains with China last week when he accused the world's second-biggest economy of violating a deal that had led both countries to temporarily reduce huge tit-for-tat tariffs. The Commerce Ministry hit back, saying Washington had seriously undermined the consensus reached during the China-US economic and trade talks in Geneva earlier. "The two leaders will likely talk this week," White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt told reporters outside the West Wing when asked whether Trump and Xi would speak. The presidents of China and the US have yet to have any confirmed contact more than five months since the Republican returned to power, despite frequent claims by the US president that a call is imminent. Trump even said in a Time Magazine interview in April that Xi had called him, but Beijing insisted that there had been no call recently. The US leader introduced in April sweeping worldwide tariffs that targeted China most heavily of all, accusing other countries of "ripping off" the United States and running trade imbalances. China has denounced the tariffs, calling them protectionist, and made it clear no one wins in a trade or tariff war. (AFP)
RTHK
7 hours ago
- RTHK
HK stocks end up, driven by rebound for carmakers
HK stocks end up, driven by rebound for carmakers The Hang Seng Index saw a fairly strong rise of 354.52 points, or 1.53 percent. File photo: RTHK Hong Kong and mainland shares ended higher on Tuesday as banking stocks hit record highs and automakers rebounded, though investors remained cautious ahead of key developments later in the week. In Hong Kong, the benchmark Hang Seng Index added 354.52 points, or 1.53 percent, to end the day at 23,512.49. The Hang Seng China Enterprises Index tracking mainland companies rose 1.9 percent to bounce back from a one-month low. Carmakers listed in the city bounced, taking a breather from the recent sell-off triggered by a price war on the mainland. The Hang Seng Automobile Index jumped 2.4 percent, with Li Auto surging 5.8 percent and BYD climbing 3.9 percent. Up north, Chinese stocks closed higher, with the benchmark Shanghai Composite Index up 0.43 percent to 3,361.98. The Shenzhen Component Index closed 0.16 percent higher at 10,057.17. The ChiNext Index, tracking China's Nasdaq-style board of growth enterprises, gained 0.48 percent to close at 2,002.70. Banking stocks led onshore markets higher, with the CSI Banks Index rallying 2 percent to a record high. Chip stocks also strengthened, with the CSI Semiconductor Index adding 1.4 percent. "A likely return of market volatility in June" is expected due to US tariff policy uncertainties and lingering fundamental headwinds seen in macroeconomic data, according to a China equity strategist at Daiwa Capital Markets Hong Kong. "We reiterate our cautious market views as a market rebound since mid-April may have already factored in a 'good outcome' of the trade war," he wrote in a note. Further afield, Australian shares ended higher, helped by banks as investors expectations for further rate cuts were strengthened after minutes from the central bank's May meeting showed it had considered an outsized cut. The S&P/ASX 200 index rose 0.6 percent to 8,466.70 at the close of trade. The benchmark remains a few points shy of the psychologically important 8,500-point level, last seen in mid-February. (Xinhua/Reuters)
