Thai gallery removes China-focused artworks after 'pressure' from Beijing, Asia News
In what the artists called the latest attempt by Beijing to silence critics overseas, the Bangkok Arts and Cultural Centre changed multiple works by artists in exile in the exhibit on authoritarian governments collaborating across borders.
When Reuters visited on Thursday (Aug 7), some works previously advertised and photographed had been removed, including a multimedia installation by a Tibetan artist, while other pieces had been altered, with the words "Hong Kong", "Tibet" and "Uyghur" redacted, along with the names of the artists.
Three days after the show, Constellation of Complicity: Visualising the Global Machinery of Authoritarian Solidarity, opened on July 24, Chinese embassy staff, accompanied by Bangkok city officials, "entered the exhibition and demanded its shutdown", said the exhibit's co-curator, Sai, a Myanmar artist who goes by one name.
In a July 30 email seen by Reuters, the gallery said: "Due to pressure from the Chinese Embassy - transmitted through the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and particularly the Bangkok Metropolitan Administration, our main supporter - we have been warned that the exhibition may risk creating diplomatic tensions between Thailand and China."
The email said the gallery had "no choice but to make certain adjustments", including obscuring the names of the Hong Kong, Tibetan and Uyghur artists.
Several days later, Sai told Reuters, the embassy demanded further removals.
The Chinese embassy in Bangkok and foreign ministry in Beijing, and Thailand's foreign ministry did not respond to multiple requests for comment.
The Bangkok Metropolitan Administration referred Reuters to the gallery, which did not respond to an email seeking comment. A gallery representative at the exhibit said the team had agreed not to comment on the issue. 'Authoritarian pressure'
Rights groups say China carries out a sophisticated campaign of harassment against critics overseas that has often extended into the art world, allegations Beijing has denied.
Sai, co-founder of Myanmar Peace Museum, the organisation that put together the exhibition, said the removed pieces included Tibetan and Uyghur flags and postcards featuring Chinese President Xi Jinping, as well as a postcard depicting links between China and Israel.
"It is tragically ironic that an exhibition on authoritarian co-operation has been censored under authoritarian pressure," he said. "Thailand has long been a refuge for dissidents. This is a chilling signal to all exiled artists and activists in the region."
Sai said he was speaking from overseas, where he had fled after Thai police sought to find him. The superintendent of Pathumwan Police Station, who oversees the gallery's Bangkok neighbourhood, told Reuters he had received no reports of such an incident.
Thailand this year returned to China 40 Uyghurs, members of a mainly Muslim ethnic minority numbering about 10 million in China's far western region of Xinjiang, in a secretive deportation. UN experts had warned they would be at risk of torture, ill-treatment and "irreparable harm". China denies abusing Uyghurs.
The Bangkok exhibition also features works by artists in exile from Xinjiang as well as Russia, Iran and Syria.
China has been steadily increasing its influence in Southeast Asia, where governments are balancing co-operation with the regional giant against concerns over sovereignty.
Beijing recently sought unsuccessfully to block screenings in New Zealand of a Philippine documentary on that country's struggles in contested parts of the South China Sea amid alleged harassment from the Chinese coast guard and maritime militia, local media reported. It was pulled from a film festival in the Philippines in March due to "external factors", the filmmakers said. Black screen
Chinese officials returned to the Bangkok gallery on Wednesday, asked to remove another flyer and reiterated "enforcement of the One China policy", Sai said, citing updates from contacts.
That policy, observed by governments that have relations with Beijing, acknowledges Beijing's position that the People's Republic of China is the sole legitimate government representing all of China, including Taiwan. China has never renounced the use of force over the self-governed island. Taiwan's government says only Taiwan's people can decide their future.
Foreign governments refer to Tibet and Xinjiang as part of China.
Works withdrawn from the Bangkok exhibit by Tibetan artist Tenzin Mingyur Paldron included video of Tibetans carrying Palestinian flags while calling for accountability for genocide and a film titled Listen to Indigenous People.
The works were previously advertised, and Sai shared images of them previously on display with Reuters.
"By forcing (the gallery) to remove significant parts of my work, the Chinese government has once again demonstrated that it desperately wishes to cut Tibetans off from the rest of the world," said Paldron, adding that China did not "want its complicity in other colonialisms and genocides to be recognised".
"Who are museums for?" he said. "They should be for the people, not dictators of any ideology."
When Reuters visited, video monitors showed a black screen. A film by a Uyghur artist played, but there was a black mark where her name had been.
[[nid:720084]]
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
26 minutes ago
- Straits Times
Costa Rica to start building massive El Salvador-inspired prison
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Wardens in anti-riot gear take part in a practice, during a tour in the \"Terrorism Confinement Center\" (CECOT) complex, which according to El Salvador's President, Nayib Bukele, is designed to hold 40,000 inmates, in Tecoluca, El Salvador October 12, 2023. REUTERS/Jose Cabezas/File Photo SAN JOSE - Costa Rica will begin construction this year on a new maximum-security prison inspired by the El Salvador mega-prison at the center of that country's crackdown on crime, Costa Rica's Justice Minister Gerald Campos said on Wednesday. Costa Rica, long considered to be the safest nation in Central America, is grappling with a wave of homicides that have been attributed to drug gang violence. In 2023, it registered its highest-ever homicide rate, and opinion polls rank insecurity as the public's top concern, positioning the issue as a central theme for national elections coming in 2026. The Salvadoran government is providing technical assistance for the project, Campos said. The new prison is necessary because current facilities are nearly 30% overpopulated, creating conditions that allow incarcerated leaders to continue running criminal enterprises, he said. "If we don't do this, the system is going to collapse, and we risk internal conflicts, hostage taking, and riots," Campos told a congressional committee. The new facility, named the Center for High Containment of Organized Crime (CACCO), has been designed to hold 5,100 inmates, increasing Costa Rica's prison capacity by 40%. The government has budgeted the project at $35 million, with Campos saying El Salvador collaborated on blueprints and security technology. Specific details of the project have been declared confidential. The model for the new prison, El Salvador's 40,000-inmate Terrorism Confinement Center (CECOT), is the centerpiece of Salvadoran President Nayib Bukele's war on gangs. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Asia India, Singapore ministers discuss deeper tie-ups in digitalisation, skills, industrial parks Business More seniors remain employed after retirement and re-employment ages raised in 2022: MOM study Singapore askST: Public bidding possible if assets seized in $3b money laundering case are sold at auction Singapore 2 dead after fire in Jalan Bukit Merah flat, about 60 evacuated Sport PSG beat Tottenham on penalties to win Uefa Super Cup Singapore TB screenings at two pre-schools after staff member diagnosed in July Business Haidilao to close Clarke Quay outlet on Aug 31; exit follows 3 earlier outlet closures Opinion How to train a drone warrior, with lessons from Ukraine While Bukele's crackdown is credited with a sharp drop in El Salvador's murder rate, human rights organizations report abuses within CECOT, describing inhumane conditions and deaths within the prison. El Salvador's government denies those allegations. REUTERS
Business Times
2 hours ago
- Business Times
Oil hits two-month low as US, IEA supply guidance weighs
[NEW YORK] Oil prices fell to over two-month lows on Wednesday after bearish supply guidance from the US government and the International Energy Agency, while investors eyed US President Donald Trump's threat of 'severe consequences' if Russia's Vladimir Putin blocked peace in Ukraine. Brent crude futures settled down 49 cents, or 0.7 per cent, to US$65.63 a barrel. During the session it dropped to US$65.01 a barrel, the lowest since June 6. US West Texas Intermediate crude futures fell 52 cents, or 0.8 per cent, to US$62.65 a barrel. The contract fell to US$61.94 a barrel, the lowest since June 2. US crude stocks rose by 3 million barrels to 426.7 million barrels, the Energy Information Administration said on Wednesday. Analysts in a Reuters poll had expected a 275,000-barrel draw. Net US crude imports rose last week by 699,000 barrels per day, EIA said. 'These crude exports remain subpar from what we got used to, falling due to tariff pushback,' said John Kilduff, partner at Again Capital in New York, adding continued lower exports could weigh on prices. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up The International Energy Agency on Wednesday raised its forecast for oil supply growth this year but lowered its demand forecast. Trump is expected to meet with Putin in Alaska on Friday to discuss ending Russia's war in Ukraine, which has shaken oil markets since February 2022. When asked whether Russia would face any consequences if Putin does not agree to stop the war after Friday's meeting, Trump responded on Wednesday: 'Yes, they will.' Asked if those consequences would be sanctions or tariffs, Trump told reporters: 'I don't have to say, there will be very severe consequences.' Trump also said a meeting between the pair could swiftly be followed by a second that included the leader of Ukraine. Meanwhile, in its monthly report on Tuesday, Opec+ raised its global oil demand forecast for next year and trimmed estimates of supply growth from the United States and other producers outside the wider group, pointing to a tighter market. 'Were we to take an aggregate of the respective IEA and Opec oil demand growth projections for 2025 at their respective bearish and bullish ends, even a modest middle figure, say just north of 1 million bpd, can easily be serviced by non-Opec supply growth alone at the moment,' said independent energy analyst Gaurav Sharma. 'So, I don't see a bullish case for oil over the near-term horizon.' REUTERS
CNA
2 hours ago
- CNA
Commentary: China is playing the long game on trade. It's working
SINGAPORE: President Donald Trump's trade war was meant to rebalance global power in America's favour. Instead, China is playing the long game, enduring short-term economic pain to shape any eventual deal to its advantage. The strategy appears to be working – for now. On Monday (Aug 11), Washington granted Beijing another 90-day reprieve, extending a pause on tariffs through Nov 10. China announced it would do the same. Markets welcomed the move, which offered some relief after months of tension. The delay will give President Xi Jinping's policymakers more time to plan their next move. Time is Xi's ally. So far, the clearest outcome of each round of talks has been a commitment to meet again. Despite Trump's insistence that China has taken significant steps to improve their trade relationship, Beijing has made no consequential concessions on any of his key concerns. (China has offered some small compromises, none on the scale of American demands.) The extension has come at a delicate time for the economy, which is plagued by sluggish domestic demand and a slowdown in the property sector. Bloomberg Economics says that China is among the few major nations without a clear timeline or terms for a deal, while others have struck agreements to secure lower tariffs. Even with this reprieve, it notes, Beijing faces average US tariffs of 40 per cent – almost 25 percentage points above the global average. This will hurt prospects for Chinese citizens, who have enjoyed more than three decades of near double-digit growth. The economy expanded by 5.2 per cent in April-June from a year earlier – enviable by global standards – but anxieties among the once-thriving middle class over the future for their children are rising. Youth unemployment remains stubbornly high, with joblessness at 14.5 per cent in June. That figure has improved in recent months, but analysts point to significant challenges: More than 12 million university students are set to graduate with hopes of joining the workforce. A LONG BATTLE Still, China is betting that despite these economic costs, it can fight this trade war to the end. Politically, Beijing is preparing the population for a long battle. State media editorials in recent months have lauded a Mao-era philosophy as a possible strategy to counter American pressure. They reference the former Chinese leader's 1938 essay On Protracted War, which laid out his approach to combating the invading Japanese between 1937 and 1945. During a series of lectures in May and June 1938, Mao spoke of how the 'contest of strength is not only a contest of military and economic power, but also a contest of human power and morale'. Scholars say the idea was to alert his fellow citizens that the war would be long and gruelling, but could be won through endurance and unity. Despite millions of Chinese dead, Mao refused to yield. The conflict only ended after Japan surrendered in World War II in 1945. (Mao's civil war with the Nationalists lasted another four years.) Xi appears to be heeding his predecessor's counsel: patience, at all costs – with the aim of shifting the odds in Beijing's favour. CHINA'S STRATEGY OF SELF-RELIANCE Domestically, Xi has the levers of the Chinese state at his disposal to help him craft a now well-worn narrative that the West is keeping China down. The trade war has fuelled those views, which play well with an already disgruntled citizenry. Internationally, Trump is doing much of the work for him. In contrast to Washington's chaos on everything from trade to international students' university admissions, Beijing is presenting itself as a champion of multilateralism – notwithstanding that it's also trying to reshape the world order to its advantage. China is happy to keep the talks going, but is unlikely to make any concessions, as William Yang, the International Crisis Group's senior North East Asia analyst, says in a note. 'China believes momentum is on its side because Trump has a stronger desire to sign a deal with Beijing so that he can claim victory and secure a summit with Xi in the fall.' But Washington's economic leverage is gradually eroding, as China pushes ahead with its strategy of self-reliance. Beijing wants to reduce dependence on US markets, and deepen control over critical supply chains, as a report from the RAND thinktank notes. China on Monday urged local firms to avoid using Nvidia's H20 processors, especially in government projects, following a White House directive requiring it and AMD to pay 15 per cent of Chinese AI chip sales to Washington.
