Italy cuts ties with Israeli spyware firm Paragon amid surveillance scandal
Italy has terminated its contracts with Israeli spyware company Paragon, after revelations that the surveillance technology was used against critics of the government – including journalists and migrant rescue workers – prompted political uproar and calls for a full investigation.
The move was confirmed in a parliamentary report released on Monday by the intelligence oversight committee COPASIR, which found that Italy's intelligence services had initially paused, then cancelled their use of Paragon's spyware.
The timeline of the contract's end remains unclear, especially since Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni's government had told parliament in February that the deal was still active.
Both the Italian government and Paragon confirmed the termination, but offered diverging narratives.
The controversy has provoked condemnation from opposition parties and media freedom advocates. Italy's journalists' union, FNSI, urged prosecutors to determine whether state surveillance laws were broken.
Paragon's software was allegedly used to target individuals in Italy, including a journalist and members of the migrant rescue organisation Mediterranea, which has frequently criticised Meloni's right-wing government.
Meta-owned WhatsApp revealed in January that the spyware had been deployed against dozens of users globally — including some in Italy.
The government has admitted that seven Italians were targeted, but maintains that any surveillance was lawful and overseen by a public prosecutor. It denied engaging in illicit spying and said it had tasked the National Cybersecurity Agency with reviewing the matter.
One of those allegedly targeted, Francesco Cancellato, editor of investigative outlet Fanpage, had claimed to the Reuters news agency and others that he was placed under surveillance.
But COPASIR said it found no evidence supporting the claim. Paragon, in a statement to Fanpage, said it halted services to Italy once Cancellato's case came to light and claimed the Italian government refused a joint probe into the matter.
Meloni's office has declined to comment. Meanwhile, opposition lawmakers are demanding that the government explain its role in parliament.
The report also revealed that Italy's intelligence services had authorised the use of Paragon's spyware in 2023 and 2024 to monitor a small number of individuals in connection with criminal investigations, including suspected 'terrorism', people smuggling and espionage.
COPASIR defended the surveillance of Mediterranea members Luca Casarini and Beppe Caccia, saying it was not due to their activism but their suspected links to irregular migration. The spyware's use on them was approved by Undersecretary Alfredo Mantovano, Meloni's top intelligence adviser, on September 5, 2024.
Mantovano did not respond to requests for comment.
Last month, a Sicilian court ordered Casarini, Caccia and four others to stand trial for allegedly aiding irregular immigration – a case widely seen as a test of Italy's approach to migrant rescues. All deny the charges.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Qatar Tribune
6 hours ago
- Qatar Tribune
Italian referendums on citizenship, labour law fail over low turnout
dpa Rome A series of referendums on immigration and labour law have failed in Italy after turnout fell far short of the required 50% of the eligible population after two days of voting, in a win for right-wing Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni. Preliminary figures from the Interior Ministry showed that only 29% of voters had cast a ballot by the time polling station closed at 3pm (1300 GMT) on Monday. The referendums focused heavily on labour law, with votes on better protection against dismissal, higher severance payments, the abolition of fixed-term contracts and liability in the event of accidents at work. The fifth issue involved deciding whether people from countries outside the EU could be granted citizenship after five years. Currently, this takes at least 10 years. The final results will only be published after the end of the count. According to preliminary figures, there were clear majorities in favour of the measures, but they will not pass due to the low turnout. The failure was widely expected after only 22% of voters participated in the election on Sunday, when voting was open until 11pm. Of the 78 referendums held in Italy since the end of World War II, many have failed due to low turnout. The latest vote was initiated by trade unions and the left-wing opposition. The right-wing coalition government under Prime Minister Meloni advised its supporters not to participate. Meloni herself went to her polling station but did not cast her vote.
Al Jazeera
8 hours ago
- Al Jazeera
Injured Palestinian Journalist vows to keep working despite losses
NewsFeed Injured Palestinian Journalist vows to keep working despite losses Duha al-Saify, a Palestinian journalist and mother, has vowed to continue reporting on the genocide in Gaza, despite losing three of her children in Israeli attacks and suffering severe facial injuries.
Al Jazeera
10 hours ago
- Al Jazeera
Italy cuts ties with Israeli spyware firm Paragon amid surveillance scandal
Italy has terminated its contracts with Israeli spyware company Paragon, after revelations that the surveillance technology was used against critics of the government – including journalists and migrant rescue workers – prompted political uproar and calls for a full investigation. The move was confirmed in a parliamentary report released on Monday by the intelligence oversight committee COPASIR, which found that Italy's intelligence services had initially paused, then cancelled their use of Paragon's spyware. The timeline of the contract's end remains unclear, especially since Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni's government had told parliament in February that the deal was still active. Both the Italian government and Paragon confirmed the termination, but offered diverging narratives. The controversy has provoked condemnation from opposition parties and media freedom advocates. Italy's journalists' union, FNSI, urged prosecutors to determine whether state surveillance laws were broken. Paragon's software was allegedly used to target individuals in Italy, including a journalist and members of the migrant rescue organisation Mediterranea, which has frequently criticised Meloni's right-wing government. Meta-owned WhatsApp revealed in January that the spyware had been deployed against dozens of users globally — including some in Italy. The government has admitted that seven Italians were targeted, but maintains that any surveillance was lawful and overseen by a public prosecutor. It denied engaging in illicit spying and said it had tasked the National Cybersecurity Agency with reviewing the matter. One of those allegedly targeted, Francesco Cancellato, editor of investigative outlet Fanpage, had claimed to the Reuters news agency and others that he was placed under surveillance. But COPASIR said it found no evidence supporting the claim. Paragon, in a statement to Fanpage, said it halted services to Italy once Cancellato's case came to light and claimed the Italian government refused a joint probe into the matter. Meloni's office has declined to comment. Meanwhile, opposition lawmakers are demanding that the government explain its role in parliament. The report also revealed that Italy's intelligence services had authorised the use of Paragon's spyware in 2023 and 2024 to monitor a small number of individuals in connection with criminal investigations, including suspected 'terrorism', people smuggling and espionage. COPASIR defended the surveillance of Mediterranea members Luca Casarini and Beppe Caccia, saying it was not due to their activism but their suspected links to irregular migration. The spyware's use on them was approved by Undersecretary Alfredo Mantovano, Meloni's top intelligence adviser, on September 5, 2024. Mantovano did not respond to requests for comment. Last month, a Sicilian court ordered Casarini, Caccia and four others to stand trial for allegedly aiding irregular immigration – a case widely seen as a test of Italy's approach to migrant rescues. All deny the charges.
