Bengal govt questions contempt petition in teacher recruitment case in high court
Kolkata: A Calcutta high court division bench hearing the contempt petition by state-appointed schoolteachers in the bribe-for-job case on Wednesday allotted more time for hearing after the West Bengal government questioned the validity of the petition, lawyers present at the hearing said.
The contempt petition was filed by a section of the 25,752 teachers and non-teaching staff appointed in 2016. On April 3, the Supreme Court upheld the high court's April 2024 order and cancelled all these appointments saying there was no way to differentiate between tainted and non-tainted appointments. On an appeal by the state, the top court directed on April 17 that non-tainted teachers may continue in service until December 31 and ordered the state to start a fresh recruitment process.
'Counsels for the state and the West Bengal School Service Commission (WBSSC) told the division bench of justices Debangsu Basak and Shabbar Rashidi that the contempt petition, alleging that the 2024 high court order had been violated, was not maintainable because portions of that order were modified by the Supreme Court on April 3,' a lawyer for the state government said.
'The lawyers argued that a contempt petition can be moved only before the Supreme Court since the latter modified some of the directions of the high court,' the lawyer added.
The division bench will hear the matter again on April 28.
Claiming to be eligible appointees, the petitioners alleged that WBSSC and the state government violated the high court's April 2024 order by not publishing the optical mark recognition (OMR) sheets of the candidates who appeared for the selection test in 2016.
The state told the court in 2024 that the original OMR sheets were destroyed a year after the appointments following standard procedure.
The petitioners have claimed that soft copies of the OMR sheets are available on three hard disks that the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) recovered after it started probing the alleged appointment scam following the high court's 2022 order.
Eligible and tainted appointees could be detected only if the OMR sheets were made public, the petition has said. The teachers have started a fresh agitation outside the WBSSC office since Monday with this demand.
On Tuesday, chief minister Mamata Banerjee appealed to them to return to work saying her government would file a review petition before the Supreme Court.
'Please go home. We are filing a review petition. Let the government do its job. You are getting your salary. Have faith in the government. Don't be misled,' Banerjee said at an administrative meeting in East Midnapore district.
Her appeal, however, had no effect on the agitators. The agitation continued on Wednesday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
36 minutes ago
- India Today
NEET UG 2025: 12.37 lakh qualify, no perfect 720 scores this year
The NEET-UG 2025 results have been declared, revealing a significant shift in trends—most notably, the absence of any perfect scores and a lower overall top score compared to previous Kumar from Rajasthan emerged as the sole topper, securing a percentile of 99.9999547. He was closely followed by Madhya Pradesh's Utkarsh Awadhiya, who scored a percentile of 99.9999095. TThe top score this year dropped to 686, with no candidate securing a full In contrast, last year saw 17 students achieve a perfect 720, although this figure was later revised to 61 after a Supreme Court intervention over grace marks and answer key discrepancies. This time, the NTA has not released individual scores for the top 50 candidates, breaking from earlier MARKS DROP AS TOP SCORE FAILSWith the top scores dipping, the cut-off marks have followed suit. For the general category, the qualifying range was between 686 and 144. This is a drop from last year's range of 720–162, and 720–137 in 2023.A total of 73 candidates scored within the 651–686 marks range this year, according to the official results. The sharp decline in top scores may be reflective of the stricter monitoring and tighter evaluation process that was in place for the 2025 12 LAKH CANDIDATES QUALIFYadvertisementOut of 22.09 lakh students who appeared for NEET UG this year, 12.37 lakh have cleared the examination—indicating a qualifying rate of over 56%. The participation numbers dipped slightly from last year's 23.33 candidates continued to dominate the results, making up over half of all test-takers and accounting for nearly 58% (7.22 lakh) of those who BREAKUPUttar Pradesh led the tally with the highest number of qualified candidates (1,70,684), followed by Maharashtra (1,25,727), Rajasthan (1,19,865), Karnataka (83,582), and Bihar (80,954). Amongst the top 20 rankers, Rajasthan and Delhi each produced four candidates.-----After a controversy surrounding a paper leak in 2024, the NEET UG 2025 exam was conducted under heightened security and surveillance. The Ministry of Education set up a committee last year to recommend improved protocols, and both state and central agencies worked to ensure smooth and fair conduct of the exam in May this the medical entrance test continues to be a high-stakes gateway for lakhs of aspirants, this year's results underscore a renewed focus on exam integrity and Watch
The Hindu
42 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Protesting teachers in Bengal go on hunger strike ‘till government meets demands'
Protesting teachers in West Bengal, whose appointments were cancelled after the Supreme Court order, have gone on a hunger strike, demanding that the government pause fresh recruitments until their review petition yields a result. Ten protesting teachers — Mita Sarkar, Chinmoy Mondal, Koushik Sarkar, Balaram Biswas, Sukumar Soren, Bikash Roy, Manik Majumder, Kishore Kumar Roy, Anirban Saha, and Achinta Das — started 'fasting unto death' from 1 am on June 13. As of going to press, they would have completed nearly 48 hours of their hunger strike. 'We lost our livelihoods for no fault of ours, but because of the government's corruption. So we have been forced to take this extreme step. We will not end our hunger strike till our demands are met, or till our bodies give in,' fasting teacher Mr Mondal said. This development follows months of protests after a Supreme Court order on April 3 invalidated nearly 26,000 teaching and non-teaching job appointments from the recruitment panel published by the West Bengal School Service Commission (SSC) in 2016, citing a 'vitiated and tainted' hiring process. Following a consequent order by the Supreme Court, the West Bengal government published the rules and notification for fresh recruitments to fill 44,203 vacancies for the position of assistant teachers. Meanwhile, the State and the SSC have also filed review petitions at the Supreme Court. 'The process of the review petition [before the Supreme Court] and fresh appointments will continue simultaneously,' Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee had said on May 27 this year. However, 'sacked and untainted' teachers have raised questions on why the application deadline for fresh recruitments is set before the Supreme Court can take a decision on the review petition. 'Our primary demand behind the hunger strike is for the government to postpone or put on hold fresh recruitments till the Supreme Court pronounces a judgement on the review petition. As of now, the deadline to apply for fresh recruitment closes before the Supreme Court is due to reopen after summer recess on July 14. We believe the government is not interested in pursuing the review petition earnestly,' Mehebub Mondal, a protesting teacher and leading voice of the Jogyo Shikkhok Shikkhika Adhikar Mancha (JSSAM), told The Hindu. He explained that the review petition is one of the last remaining hopes for 'untainted' teachers to have their job appointments reinstated without re-examination. 'We have proved our worth once and have worked diligently as teachers for seven years. We are innocent victims of the government's corruption. The SSC should publish a certified list of 'untainted candidates' and a fresh merit list for 2016 after re-evaluating our OMR sheets. That will help us retain our jobs, and the worthy waitlisted candidates can also find their deserved position in the merit list,' Mr Mondal said. He added that if the sacked teachers must reappear for fresh recruitments, they demand to be recruited through a separate notification and selection process, meant only for the affected teachers of the cancelled 2016 panel. Mr Mondal also claimed that the SSC chairperson, during his meeting with JSSAM representatives on June 12, did not accept any of the demands put forth by the protesting teachers.
Time of India
6 hours ago
- Time of India
Mosques cut down on loudspeakers' decibel levels
Azaan, or the Islamic call to prayers, lasts for a few minutes. However, the use of loudspeakers for azaan by mosques has been in the crosshairs of some members of other faiths for a long time. The controversy keeps hitting the headlines, with courts, the Supreme Court, and different high courts laying down guidelines for the use of loudspeakers for religious functions and ordering penalties for violation of the rules. As the latest round of controversy over loudspeakers in mosques rages, several mosques in the city and suburbs have voluntarily brought down the decibel levels to the permissible limit. According to the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB), the permissible noise levels in residential areas are 55 decibels for daytime and 45 decibels for the night. Much before BJP functionary and ex-MP Kirit Somaiya took it up and allegedly put pressure on the police stations to remove loudspeakers from mosques, in 2022, MNS chief Raj Thackeray aggressively opposed the use of loudspeakers for azaan. Jama Masjid Al Shams at Mira was among the first mosques in the Mumbai Metropolitan Region (MMR) to install the machine to keep the decibel levels of its loudspeakers under the permissible limit. "The machine hardly costs around Rs 1500. Our Masjid trust's office has kept the records of the decibel level of every azaan since the day we installed it in 2022. We were the first to follow the guidelines of the Supreme Court about the noise level. Many other mosques replicated the practice," informs Syed Muzaffar Husain, chief trustee of the Jama Masjid Al Shams and former MLC. Those opposing loudspeakers at religious places cite the January 2025 verdict of the Bombay High Court, which graded the punishment for violation of the guidelines. It mandated the cops to act against the violation in three stages: warning, penalty (Rs 5000 per day), and seizure of the loudspeakers. "Just the other day, the local police visited our mosque and asked us to remove the loudspeakers. We have told them we will follow the guidelines and are soon to set the decibel level to the permissible limit," says Abul Hassan Khan, trustee of Masjid Ajmeri and Madrasa Ali Hassan Ahle Sunnat at Sakinaka. It was at another meeting in Sakinaka again where former minister Arif Naseem Khan announced that a legal team headed by senior counsel Yusuf Muchchala will challenge the state Additional Director General of Police (ADGP) May 11, 2025, circular, which demands religious places to submit property cards and proof of the structures' registration with the Waqf board or charity commission while seeking permission to use the loudspeakers. Neither the Supreme Court nor the Bombay High Court has put this condition in its guidelines for granting permission for loudspeakers. Many have cautioned against the politicisation of the loudspeakers' issue and suggested pragmatism. Shoaib Khatib, trustee of the iconic Jama Masjid of Bombay near Crawford Market, says his mosque follows the permitted decibel level for its loudspeakers. "In any case, loudspeakers are used only for azaan four times a day as there is no use of loudspeakers between 10 pm and 6 am, and the morning azaan is given without the use of a loudspeaker," says Khatib. Businessman V R Sharif is against the use of loudspeakers. "I have told many mosque managements to avoid using loudspeakers, which are a nuisance. Today, everybody carries a mobile phone, which can be used to set the alarm for azaan. We live in a diverse society, and we should not do something which disturbs the peace of our neighbours," suggests Sharif. General Secretary of Mumbai Congress Asif Farooqui slams the tendency to add to the noise. "Everybody knows that loudspeakers add to noise pollution. Nowhere is it written that our prayers will not be accepted if azaan is not amplified through loudspeakers. Move ahead with the times and compete for education and employment, not in creating noise," says Farooqui. Follow more information on Air India plane crash in Ahmedabad here . Get real-time live updates on rescue operations and check full list of passengers onboard AI 171 .
