logo
Windblown review – haunting elegy for a felled 200-year-old natural wonder

Windblown review – haunting elegy for a felled 200-year-old natural wonder

The Guardiana day ago
If you thought there could not be a more Edinburgh-centric show than James Graham's Make It Happen, with its appearances from Adam Smith and figures from the city's once great banks, well think again. In Windblown, Karine Polwart commemorates an Edinburgh institution of similar longevity. And she does it exquisitely.
Her focus is the sabal palm that stood in the Royal Botanic Garden for more than 200 years and, even before that, grew in the original gardens at the top of Leith Walk. It outgrew the original glass house within decades and towered over generations of visitors until, in 2021, this oldest living specimen in the collection had to be chopped down.
You might have expected a protectionist response from Polwart, but she does not question the necessity of the renovations to the Victorian palm houses that are now under way as part of the Edinburgh Biomes project, designed to secure the future of the collection's 13,500 plant species. Rather, her tone is elegiac, not least because this is also a lockdown-era story, haunted by loss and the need for reflection.
Following the format of her equally sublime Wind Resistance, she blends songs, poetry and spoken word, all delivered in soothing, honeyed tones, to celebrate the wondrous natural beauty of the tree and to praise the generations of keepers who ensured its survival. With co-composer Pippa Murphy, Polwart was artist in residence at the Botanics, and in Windblown she draws on conversations with staff whose dedication to the plants is as personal as it is professional.
One observes that on the day his dog was due to be put down, he still gave it a treat in the morning. The palm commands similar dedication and respect until the very end. 'For the time is nearly over,' goes Polwart's repeated refrain, set to an appropriately timeless folk melody.
Accompanied by Dave Milligan on grand piano, she stands beneath a wild feathery arrangement of fronds designed by Neil Haynes and lit in ever-changing colours by Lizzie Powell, as Jamie Wardrop's sparkling watery video projections suggest the epic journey from Bermuda (and its colonialist implications). Through it all, Polwart attributes to generations of Edinburgh citizens an enterprise of everyday love, care and attention.
At Queen's Hall, Edinburgh, until 13 August
All our Edinburgh festival reviews
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Alex Kingston is the third celebrity contestant announced for Strictly Come Dancing 2025
Alex Kingston is the third celebrity contestant announced for Strictly Come Dancing 2025

BBC News

time31 minutes ago

  • BBC News

Alex Kingston is the third celebrity contestant announced for Strictly Come Dancing 2025

Doctor Who and ER star Alex Kingston has been announced as the second celebrity taking part in the new series of Strictly Come Dancing. The multi-award-winning entertainment show, produced by BBC Studios, will return to BBC One and BBC iPlayer for its new series this September. Alex Kingston has been a star of stage and screen for more than four decades, gaining international fame as Dr Elizabeth Corday in the global hit TV drama ER for eight years, winning a SAG award in the process. She is known to millions of Doctor Who fans as the iconic River Song, aka The Doctor's Wife, a role she has played opposite three Doctors on screen and continues in audio adventure and novel form. Other television work includes a BAFTA-nominated performance as Moll Flanders, plus roles in Douglas Is Cancelled, Treason, Gilmore Girls, Boudica, Lost in Austen, Dodger, A Discovery of Witches, Law & Order: Special Victims Unit, and Arrow. Her extensive theatre roles range from playing Lady Macbeth, to Nurse Ratchet in One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest, Prospero for the Royal Shakespeare Company, and many many more. More: Strictly Come Dancing 2025 - find out everything you need to know about the new series Meet the new Professional Dancers joining the Strictly family in 2025 Watch Strictly Come Dancing on BBC iPlayer and add to your Watchlist On joining Strictly Come Dancing, Alex Kingston says: 'Aaaaagghhh!!!!!!' The news was revealed on The One Show on Monday 11 August. The remaining celebrity contestants joining the new series will be announced in due course. Strictly Come Dancing is a BBC Studios Entertainment production for BBC One and BBC iPlayer and was commissioned by Kalpna Patel-Knight, Head of Entertainment at the BBC. The Executive Producer is Sarah James, the Series Editors are Nicola Fitzgerald and Jack Gledhill. The Commissioning Editor for the BBC is Jo Wallace. Strictly Come Dancing will return to BBC One and BBC iPlayer this September. Add Strictly to your watchlist on BBC iPlayer now. GK

Some call the Sussexes' Netflix deal a demotion - but the company still sees them as a power couple
Some call the Sussexes' Netflix deal a demotion - but the company still sees them as a power couple

Sky News

time41 minutes ago

  • Sky News

Some call the Sussexes' Netflix deal a demotion - but the company still sees them as a power couple

While we're all desperate to know what this new deal is really worth in dollars and pounds, one thing I can tell you for certain is that Prince Harry and Meghan want us to know they're delighted that Netflix again wanted to get a deal done. "Absolutely over the moon" is how it was described to me. But they'll also be aware of the attention it'll attract as we all try to pick apart what it means. Image: Meghan, Duchess of Sussex. Pic: Jake Rosenberg/Netflix Firstly because of that ongoing fascination in how they're making money since stepping away from royal life and losing financial support from the King, but also because of the recent reports that Netflix were intending to cut ties. Yes this is a different type of deal from their original one in 2020. Some have argued that a "first look deal" looks like a demotion from what they previously signed up to. With no real clarity on how much their original deal was worth, and no numbers being publicly thrown around this time, that is hard to judge. But talking to those who know something about these kinds of deals you do get a sense it could potentially be more lucrative than it looks on face value. With first look deals, yes there is often financial commitments from the likes of Netflix to get that first exclusive look at projects and first refusal. Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player 2:22 Harry claims: War of words continues But there could be other significant monetary incentives for the Sussexes to sign. For example, when the Obamas signed a first look deal with Netflix, the streaming service agreed to pay the operational costs for their production company "Higher Ground". Could it be that Netflix are also now covering the costs of Archewell Productions? Follow the World Listen to The World with Richard Engel and Yalda Hakim every Wednesday Tap to follow It's stating the obvious to say that Harry and Meghan continue to divide opinions, some wanting to watch their programmes from a place of respect and fondness, others as a reason to grumble about them. But signing on this latest dotted line shows Netflix still sees them as a power couple, who attract significant attention and are worthy of investment, whatever that really adds up to.

The Burns Project review – Scotland's national poet in all his glory and contradictions
The Burns Project review – Scotland's national poet in all his glory and contradictions

The Guardian

time42 minutes ago

  • The Guardian

The Burns Project review – Scotland's national poet in all his glory and contradictions

We are sitting around a table in the sedate surroundings of the Georgian House, the Robert Adam-designed townhouse run by the National Trust for Scotland. James Clements, playing the part of Robert Burns, says something about the weather, and suddenly a streak of lightning cuts down the length of the table top. It has a gash down the middle for that very purpose. It is a sign of the attention to detail in Cora Bissett's excellent production. What could have been a by-the-numbers tribute to Scotland's national poet is altogether more subtle, imaginative and contentious. The long, undulating table, designed by Jenny Booth and cleverly lit by Elle Taylor, continues to play an unexpected part: Clements appears from beneath a domed plate cover in a scene of hungover contrition, while a cutlery boat sets sail under its own steam towards the West Indies. Oh yes, the West Indies. One of the inconvenient truths about this people's poet, the man who wrote the egalitarian A Man's a Man for a' That, is that it was only his newfound career as a published writer that stopped him heading to Jamaica to work in the slave trade. Clements's script, drawing on private letters and recently digitised historical archival material, plus the voices of modern commentators, does not gloss over this, nor the poet's womanising. Rather, it presents a rounded picture of a contradictory man who could write tender verse one minute and abandon a pregnant woman the next. Burns is embodied with gusto and rounded Ayrshire vowels by Clements, accompanied by Lisa Rigby, singing sweet renditions of favourites such as Ae Fond Kiss on guitar and shruti box. It works as both a primer to the short life of this farmer turned celebrity and a knotty study of his politics, compromises, artistic enthusiasms and colourful love life. At the Georgian House, Edinburgh, until 16 August All our Edinburgh festival reviews

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store