SMRT Trains fined $240,000 over accident that killed technical officer
SMRT technical officer Muhammad Afiq Senawi was killed after rod weighing nearly 3kg hit his face in 2020. PHOTO: ST FILE
SINGAPORE – Rail operator SMRT Trains was fined $240,000 on May 5 over an accident at Bishan Depot in March 2020 that killed one of its technical officers.
The company was convicted of an offence under the Workplace Safety and Health Act, as it had failed to take reasonable measures to ensure its employees' safety at the depot in Bishan Road.
On March 23, 2020, Mr Muhammad Afiq Senawi, 30, and a colleague were using a hydraulic press machine (HPM) to replace some train-related components.
Mr Afiq had placed a component into the machine, and activated the piston to carry out the task.
However, he had failed to remove a similar older component. Due to a pressure build-up, a spacer rod that weighed nearly 3kg flew out of the machine, broke through the fencing gate near the machine, and struck his face.
Mr Afiq was rushed to Tan Tock Seng Hospital, where he died of face and chest injuries at around 10.15am that day.
Coroner Christopher Goh later ruled his death to be an unfortunate misadventure.
Among other things, an investigation later revealed that SMRT Trains had failed to install a pressure gauge for the HPM after dismantling it for repairs.
On May 5, Ministry of Manpower prosecutor Kimberly Boo told the court that the spacer rod had not been secured to any other component, adding: 'There was thus a hazard of the spacer rod displacing from its position and shooting out during operations.'
She also said that a maintenance work record dated June 11, 2018, stated that the hydraulic pressure gauge was damaged.
As a result, there was no indication of the pressure of the HPM available when it was in operation.
The damage was reported to an engineering maintenance manager, who instructed for the gauge to be dismantled. However, he later overlooked its reinstallation.
Another work record dated Dec 16 that year stated that the pressure gauge was sent for calibration.
Court documents stated that the most recent maintenance of the HPM prior to the tragedy was carried out on Jan 2, 2020. The gauge was still not installed then.
Ms Boo said: '(SMRT Trains) had failed to ensure that a pressure gauge, which was a safety measure identified in the HPM operation manual, was installed for the HPM. Once the activating lever was pulled by the operator, the piston would continually move downwards to generate a downward push motion.
'Even though HPM operators were not required to monitor the exact pressure involved in the operation, the presence of a pressure gauge would provide an indication to operators on whether the force applied in any installation or removal had increased disproportionately.'
SMRT Trains had also failed to limit the pressure setting of the HPM, which would reduce operators' exposure to a force far beyond what was necessary for its intended use, thus lowering the risks of harm the operators are exposed to.
SMRT Trains was charged in court in 2023.
Shaffiq Alkhatib is The Straits Times' court correspondent, covering mainly criminal cases heard at the State Courts.
Join ST's WhatsApp Channel and get the latest news and must-reads.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
a day ago
- Straits Times
Singaporean man arrested in Johor for alleged involvement in road rage incident
Videos of the incident went viral on social media. PHOTO: ST FILE Singaporean man arrested in Johor for alleged involvement in road rage incident The Malaysian police have arrested a Singaporean man after he was allegedly involved in a road rage incident in Johor on June 7. The 40-year-old man was arrested at 6.20pm on June 8 by a team of officers from the Criminal Investigation Division of the Johor Bahru North police headquarters. The police also seized several items, said Johor Bahru North police chief Balveer Singh Mahindar Singh in a June 8 statement. Mr Balveer said a 31-year-old Malaysian man had lodged a police report over the June 7 incident, claiming that on that day, he was honked by a Singapore-registered Toyota Altis car. He said the Singaporean was dissatisfied that the man's BMW had allegedly blocked his path in the Taman Tun Aminah area. 'An argument took place and the suspect allegedly kicked the complainant's car, causing damage. However, the complainant did not suffer any injuries,' he said. Videos of the incident went viral on social media. Mr Balveer said checks on the Singaporean revealed that he has no prior criminal record, and that he tested negative for drugs. The Singaporean will be taken to a court in Johor Bahru on June 9 for a remand application under Section 426 of the Penal Code (for mischief and damage of property) and Section 509 of the Penal Code (utterance of insult). Join ST's WhatsApp Channel and get the latest news and must-reads.
Straits Times
4 days ago
- Straits Times
MOM investigating alleged misuse of work passes meant for foreign students and trainees
MOM said some of the probes surrounding breaches of the pass requirements have already been completed with more to come. PHOTO: ST FILE SINGAPORE – Investigations are underway into what a support group for migrant workers brands a 'job scam' centred on misuse of work passes. Training Employment Passes give foreign students and intra-corporate trainees the right to work here for three months, but they have allegedly been used to employ foreign workers in lower-skilled roles that are not allowed under the pass. Some of the probes surrounding breaches of the pass requirements have already been completed with more to come, noted the Ministry of Manpower (MOM) on June 6. It did not disclose how many reports it had received. The pass allows foreign students or trainees from a company's overseas office or subsidiary to undergo practical training for professional, managerial, executive or specialist jobs here for up to three months. Trainees must earn a minimum fixed salary of $3,000 a month. The work attachment f or student applicants must be tied to their studies. T hey must either be studying in an 'acceptable institution' or earning at least $3,000 a month. The investigation comes after 13 TEP holders sought help in recent months from advocacy group Transient Workers Count Too (TWC2). They were hired by employers to take up various roles with a lower skill level than the pass appears to allow. Five of the 13 were put to work in a food and beverage establishment, five in a warehouse, two in cleaning companies while one ended up in a 'tour coach agency',TWC2 said on its website last month. The 13 people had turned to TWC2 over a period of about five months starting in December 2024. 'We have never before seen so many workers on this kind of work pass in such a short time,' TWC2 said. The group added that nearly all the 13 complained about salary irregularities, including being paid below the $3,000 stated minimum, though at least one found long working hours to be the biggest problem. 'However, when we found out more about the circumstances which led to their working in Singapore, we could see the contours of a rapidly widening job scam,' TWC2 noted. The workers had been designated as 'management executives' despite performing menial tasks such as washing dishes, it added. They were often not sent to the MOM to have their TEP issued until nearly 30 days after arrival, effectively meaning they worked an additional fourth month without a pass being issued. TWC2 executive director Ethan Guo told The Straits Times that a common feature was that most of the workers were coming to work for the first time in Singapore and had arrived relatively recently. 'This showed that these were young, impressionable and vulnerable foreigners with little or no knowledge of employment laws in Singapore,' Mr Guo noted. He added that the group could not confirm if there has been a sudden uptick in the number of TEP holders reporting salary irregularities. 'What has happened of late was a concerted effort by TWC2 to educate migrant workers on the correct payment of their salaries, and this could have resulted in more workers with such problems coming forward to seek help from us,' he said. They may have been many more victims in the past who did not realise they have been scammed, or did not have an avenue for assistance. Mr Guo said TWC2's concern lies with workers who have been misled into jobs they paid huge sums to agents for and then put into 'legal jeopardy once they agree'. He noted that the attempts to dodge the TEP requirements may have arisen as a work-around for industries 'desperate for cheap foreign labour'. 'A more holistic response would be a review of work permit quotas for these industry sectors like logistics, cleaning and food and beverage.' However, Mr Guo added that TWC2 is not advocating a massive liberalisation in foreign workforce policy, as making cheap labour too easily available could blunt the incentive for employers to pursue automation and productivity improvements. The MOM also said it performs additional checks and audits on selected TEP applications, such as requesting proof of training programmes and foreign offices or subsidiaries. It noted that it will take action against errant employers, including suspending their work pass privileges, imposing financial penalties or even prosecution. The ministry also encouraged affected workers to reach out for assistance. Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Straits Times
5 days ago
- Straits Times
New Zealand PM floats privacy laws after staffer accused of filming women
Senior aide Michael Forbes resigned after a local news outlet alleged he covertly recorded audio of sessions with sex workers and secretly photographed women at the gym. PHOTO: ST FILE New Zealand PM floats privacy laws after staffer accused of filming women New Zealand's prime minister floated new privacy laws on June 5 after his own press secretary was allegedly caught taping sex workers without consent. Senior aide Michael Forbes resigned after a local news outlet alleged he covertly recorded audio of sessions with sex workers and secretly photographed women at the gym. Prime Minister Christopher Luxon said he was 'shocked' – but it was unclear whether Mr Forbes had broken the law. 'If you're a New Zealander you ask quite legitimate questions about how does this behaviour happen, and is it legal or illegal,' he told reporters on June 5 . 'I have that same reaction to it as well.' Mr Luxon flagged new privacy laws that could be drafted to clear up the legal grey area. Forbes – who was Mr Luxon's deputy chief press secretary – apologised in a statement sent to media. 'I want to offer my sincerest apologies to the women I have harmed,' he said. The scandal came to light after a sex worker noticed Mr Forbes's phone was recording audio while he took a shower, according to an investigation published on June 4 by New Zealand news outlet Stuff. Mr Forbes phone was then found to contain photos of women in compromising positions at the gym, and a video shot through a window showing women getting dressed at night, Stuff reported. 'In the past, I was in a downward spiral due to unresolved trauma and stress, and when confronted with the impacts of my behaviour a year ago, I sought professional help, which is something I wish I had done much earlier,' Mr Forbes said in a statement. 'What I failed to do then was make a genuine attempt to apologise.' AFP Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
