2 Deadly Shootings in 2 Days Highlight Dangers of Aid Distribution in Gaza
In an incident on Saturday, Israeli soldiers opened fire on civilians moving chaotically toward food distribution sites run by Israel-backed private contractors in Israeli-controlled areas. In another incident on Sunday, Israeli soldiers opened fire on civilians rushing to seize aid from a convoy of food trucks sent by the United Nations toward areas controlled by Hamas.
Supporters of the Israel-backed system used the episode on Sunday to highlight the failures of the U.N.-led system. Those favoring the U.N. system said the killings on Saturday illustrated the failures of Israel's approach.
Israel says it is necessary to put food distribution sites in areas beyond Hamas's control in order to make it harder for both fighters from the militant group and civilian looters to steal supplies. Critics of that approach say it forces hungry civilians to cross Israeli military lines, putting them at greater risk.
Three broader dynamics highlight the problems associated with both approaches.
In both incidents over the weekend, the Israeli military used live fire to contain unrest, instead of using nonlethal forms of crowd control.
Civilians are also ready to risk death by Israeli gunfire to avoid death by starvation in Gaza, where food is scarce following Israel's 80-day blockade between March and May.
In addition, after 22 months of war, there is no functional governing system in most of Gaza, with Hamas no longer providing social services or law enforcement in most of the territory.
Israel has decapitated Hamas's leadership, demolished many government buildings and controls the majority of the land. But Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel has repeatedly decided against creating a system of transitional governance — whether through formal military occupation or the empowerment of Palestinian alternatives to Hamas.
'There's a blame game and everyone is looking at the technical details and about how the aid is distributed,' said Shira Efron, an expert on aid systems in Gaza at Israel Policy Forum, a New York-based research group.
'But the bigger issue is the lawlessness and the breakdown of governance,' she added. 'After 22 months of war, it's anarchy in Gaza. And without addressing the core issue of what should happen next in Gaza, there won't be a solution.'
Responding to such criticism, Mr. Netanyahu has said that Hamas must be completely defeated before detailed postwar plans can begin. But his critics, including many in Israel, say that it is harder to defeat Hamas without planning for its replacement.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
7 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Scenes of starving people in Gaza ‘deplorable', says Reeves
Scenes of starving people in Gaza are 'deplorable', Chancellor Rachel Reeves has said. In recent days, multiple images have come from the territory of people – including children – visibly starving, along with reports of Israeli military attacks on those seeking to access aid. The UK Government has resisted calls to immediately recognise Palestinian statehood despite pressure being ramped up by France becoming the first G7 country to do so. Speaking to journalists on a visit to a Rolls Royce factory near Glasgow, Ms Reeves said the immediate priority for the UK Government would be to ensure enough aid is allowed in to Gaza. 'We believe that a two-state solution is the only way to having enduring peace in the Middle East – a safe and secure Israel alongside a viable and peaceful Palestinian state,' she said. 'The immediate priority, though, is to get aid in. 'We've all seen the scenes unfolding in Gaza, it is incredibly depressing and deplorable what is happening there. 'And to avoid a further humanitarian crisis, we must get that food, those medical supplies and aid in to Gaza.' The Chancellor added that the Prime Minister was meeting European leaders about the issue on Friday. 'Prime Minister Starmer will be talking to the Chancellor of Germany and the President of France later today to see what more we can do to get that much-needed aid in to the country.' But Scottish First Minister John Swinney urged the UK Government to recognise Palestine, saying he believed it to be the only way to work towards a two-state solution in the region. 'I've been calling for the recognition of Palestine as a sovereign, independent state since the general election campaign last year because it is, for me, the only way in which there can be movement towards a two-state solution, which is the only way there can be peace in the Middle East,' he said. The First Minister said he 'very much welcomed' the move from President Emmanuel Macron, adding: 'Anyone looking at the suffering of the people of Palestine at this particular moment, the horrendous suffering, the starvation that is going on within Palestine, must come to the conclusion that an immediate solution is required, which is a ceasefire and the flow of humanitarian aid. 'But the solution also is the movement towards a two-state solution, which involves the recognition of an independent Palestinian state. 'That is the route to peace in the Middle East, that's what should be followed and that's what I encourage the United Kingdom Government to do.'
Yahoo
7 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Israel allows foreign countries to parachute aid into Gaza
Israel has said foreign countries can drop aid into Gaza from today. A senior IDF official told Sky News on Friday: "Starting today, Israel will allow foreign countries to parachute aid into . "Starting this afternoon, the WCK organisation began reactivating its kitchens."Humanitarian aid organisation World Central Kitchen in Gaza in November after a number of its workers were killed in an Israeli airstrike last year. Aid workers in Gaza - who help provide food, medicine and shelter for the millions displaced there - have been affected by the ongoing conflict between Israel and Hamas. The Gaza Humanitarian Foundation - an Israel and US-backed organisation - has been distributing food packages in Gaza since the end of May, after Israel eased its 11-week blockade of aid into the territory. Read more:Recognise Palestine, Starmer urged More than 1,000 people have reportedly been killed while trying to receive food aid since then, according to the UN, with the territory facing a starvation crisis. On Friday the UN warned the enclave was running out of specialised therapeutic foods to treat malnourished children. Israel has been at war with Hamas in Gaza after the Palestinian militant group , on 7 October 2023. This breaking news story is being updated and more details will be published shortly. Please refresh the page for the fullest version. You can receive Breaking News alerts on a smartphone or tablet via the Sky News App. You can also follow @SkyNews on X or subscribe to our YouTube channel to keep up with the latest news.
Yahoo
37 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Jewish Tacoma candidate opposed by PAC backing ‘interests of Jewish community'
With funding coming largely from outside Tacoma, a political action committee that backs candidates who 'support the interests of the Jewish community' is spending thousands of dollars to oppose a candidate in Tacoma's District 5 City Council race. The PAC, called Washingtonians for a Brighter Future, spent $15,000 on mail and postage to send flyers opposing Cook to voters of District 5, and another $1,000 on text messages with the same goal. The group, according to a substack article linked on its website, is endeavoring to 'oppose hate in all forms' by elevating or opposing candidates at the local level who could move up to national positions. It's modeled after a California-based PAC called California Against Hate, which in 2022 worked to oppose a city council candidate in San Diego who was 'anti-Israel,' according to the article. 'Many of the most dangerous people crop up in the small cities,' Jared Sclar, co-founder of the California-based PAC, said of the Washington PAC in the substack article. 'If there is someone problematic, we may not know. We may not know someone is going to sneak by and get on the city council, and then they're the next Ilhan Omar,' Sclar wrote of Omar, a Democratic U.S. representative from Minnesota. Cook said she wasn't surprised to see such opposition to her campaign. 'I think these are the kind of hurdles that are very common when it comes to trying to win people-powered campaigns against corporate interests,' Cook told The News Tribune. The mail campaign came around mid-July, ahead of the Aug. 5 primary election that will whittle the slate of three candidates for the District 5 race down to two. Cook has raised the most money in the race so far at $47,012.98. Incumbent Joe Bushnell raised $35,744.14, and candidate Brandon A. Vollmer raised $851.03. The PAC as of July 24 raised $32,768.09 this year, only $1,000 of which came from a donor with a Tacoma address. The rest came from donors in Washington cities like Mercer Island, Seattle and Medina. At least one contributor listed an address in Naples, Florida. According to the Washington Public Disclosure Commission, the PAC spent $18,076.61 by July 24, $16,000 of which paid for the campaign against Cook. The mailers that the PAC distributed depicted her standing in front of a building with broken windows with graffiti that reads 'don't burn' and 'ppl live upstairs' overlaid with text that stated, 'Zev Cook cooking up chaos for Tacoma.' It also implied that Cook supported defunding the police and stated that doing so would result in increased crime, gang violence and home invasions. Cook, a community organizer and activist, has the backing of groups like the Tacoma and Pierce County Democratic Socialists of America, United Food & Commercial Workers Local 3000, and the Washington Education Association's PAC. Incumbent Joe Bushnell, who is running for re-election, has the endorsement of several state representatives, current and former council members, and the Tacoma Police Union, International Union of Police Associations Local 6. Bushnell also has Washingtonians for a Better Future's endorsement. 'Council Member Bushnell is a friend of the Jewish community,' the PAC's website reads. Bushnell said he didn't solicit an endorsement from the PAC but said he wasn't surprised to see the group oppose Cook, given her support from the Democratic Socialists of America. 'The groups that are supporting my opponent have very public rhetoric that rubs a lot of folks the wrong way,' Bushnell told The News Tribune. Cook, who is Jewish, said she feels the group is going after her because of her vocal support of Palestine. 'I'm the only candidate running for city council this year that's made public comments in support of Palestine and against genocide, in alignment with my Jewish values of community repair and justice,' she told The News Tribune. 'I think this is very similar in some ways, but certainly at a smaller scale, to the attack ads that were run against Zohran [Mamdani] for being a pro-Palestine candidate that he is continuing to be,' she said of Mamdani, who recently won the Democratic primary in New York City's mayoral race. 'But like Zohran I'm intending to win by continuing to just focus on how we make life better for working people in our city.' Nevet Basker, the PAC's co-chair, told The News Tribune the group is seeking to combat antisemitism and said it was Cook's 'rhetoric against Zionism' that the PAC opposes. 'We believe that the rhetoric in some of these campaigns, including Zev Cook, creates a permission structure for antisemitism that results in issues in our own communities, in Tacoma, in this case, where the Jewish community feels unwelcome and sometimes unsafe,' Basker told The News Tribune. Basker said the PAC's concerns also go beyond those of the Jewish community, to what she described as Cook's support for abolishing the police and prisons. 'She's also a leader of an organization that advocates for abolishing prisons and all incarceration releasing, even violent criminals, murderers, rapists, back into our communities,' Basker said. 'We believe that that is unsafe for everyone.' Cook, according to her website, has served as an officer for the Tacoma Democratic Socialists of America. The group also endorsed her in the District 5 race. The Democratic Socialists of America's political platform calls for the 'abolition of the carceral state.' 'For all of the working class to achieve collective liberation we must constrain, diminish, and abolish the carceral forces of the state — from prisons and police themselves, to their manifestations in all forms throughout society,' the platform reads. Cook told The News Tribune that she doesn't think that defunding the police 'is a very good framework for understanding public policy' and instead supports specific policies like increasing funding for Tacoma's non-police crisis response team. 'Generally, I think that we as a community need to be focused more on not just addressing the symptoms, but addressing root causes when it comes to crime, which is why our platform is so focused on addressing income and housing inequality in our community,' Cook said. She said she wasn't surprised to see the PAC's efforts to oppose her campaign and said the group wouldn't have sent out the mailer if they didn't think Cook had a real shot at winning. Some commenters on Reddit said that the anti-Cook flyer made them want to vote for her even more. 'Getting an attack ad like this just tells me that they've seen how effective our campaign has been at mobilizing the support of working class Tacomans,' she added. 'It tells me that they're scared that we might win this year.' Solve the daily Crossword
