Court rejects developer's bid to turn Sydney boarding house into luxury apartments
In the wake of the court's decision the mayor, Clover Moore, has also called on the Minns government to allow significant loss of individual homes as a ground for rejecting development applications.
Developer LFD Homes took the City of Sydney to court over its decision to block its application to turn a boarding house – which housed 28 mostly elderly men on Selwyn Street in Paddington – into four dwellings.
In findings handed down on Thursday, the NSW land and environment court sided with the City of Sydney on the grounds of social impact and the loss of affordable housing, finding that the 32-room building should be retained because the proposal 'would result in the unacceptable loss of affordable rental boarding house accommodation in the local area'.
The decision followed a protracted community campaign from residents and their neighbours to retain it.
But it came too late for the 28 men living there, who were handed eviction notices last October and have all since left.
Jeff Elliott was one of the 28 men who were evicted. The 61-year-old, who works as a postman, had lived in the boarding house for more than 20 years. He left just a few weeks ago.
'It was a family,' he said of the bond he had with the other men living there. 'We barbecued together, we shared Christmas together, we did everything together.'
'I haven't seen them since we left.'
Mike Mannix, one of the neighbours who started the community campaign, said the court's decision was bittersweet and he felt as if they had failed the men.
'They were our friends and we didn't want to see them go from our community,' he said. 'At least this very dark cloud has a silver lining and hopefully we can set a precedent for the future.'
Moore also acknowledged the decision had come too late for the men who had to leave their homes.
Last year, in an unprecedented move for the council, it offered to buy the boarding home from the developer after a successful motion moved by the Greens. The NSW government also agreed to pitch in a portion of the cost to buy it.
The council said the developer has not yet indicated a willingness to sell. It remains unclear what the developer will do with the building after the court's decision.
'Sydney should not simply be an enclave for the rich,' Moore said. 'We need more housing, not less. That's why stories like this are so confronting and why the city rejected this development application in the first place,' she said.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
'We are hopeful the decision will set a valuable precedent that stops the loss of affordable and diverse forms of accommodation to private residential development across the state.'
Moore said there were about 4,000 rooms in boarding houses across the City of Sydney's local area, but that number was shrinking because there was 'greater profit in converting these buildings into a small number of luxury residences'.
'The NSW government needs to urgently implement the recommendations from the statutory review of the Boarding Houses Act and consider significant loss of individual homes as grounds for rejecting development applications to avoid this devastation in the future,' she said.
The recommendations of the boarding house review – which was handed down in 2020 – include establishing minimum standards for 'reasonable notice' to evict a boarding house tenant. Boarding house residents are not protected under the same tenancy laws as renters, which now include provisions to protect renters from no-grounds evictions.
Elliott has been living at his sister-in-law's home in Redfern. He said he has been offered to move into another boarding house, but he has rejected the offer because he now feared the insecurity.
Mannix said the men were relocated in 'record time' and have been relocated across the city, including in the inner west, Penrith and Malabar.
Sylvie Ellsmore, the Greens councillor who moved the motion for the boarding house to be bought by the council, said the court's decision was 'historically unprecedented' and reflected how dire the housing crisis is.
'Five or 10 years ago, we probably wouldn't have got this decision, but the scale of the housing crisis has changed,' she said.
Ellsmore called for the NSW state government to buy boarding houses – which are privately owned – and turn them into public housing.
'This is quite a dense type of housing that already exists that can provide housing for lots of people,' she said.
LFD Homes was approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
5 hours ago
- Daily Mail
California's cheapest place to live looks beautiful and an average home is $286,500 but there's a big drawback
It looks like it offers an idyllic lifestyle with beautiful scenery, small-town living, and rock-bottom prices - but the enclave recently named the most affordable place to buy in California comes with one major caveat. Lassen County, with a population of nearly 30,000, has officially been ranked the cheapest housing market in the state, according to the California Association of Realtors' latest report. The median price for an existing single-family home in Lassen was just $286,500 in June 2025 - a fraction of the $899,560 statewide median and the $1.4 million average seen across the Bay Area. While Lassen offers striking high desert landscapes and unbeatable value, some buyers may be surprised to learn that the local economy has long been tied to the state correctional system. 'There's a large prison there,' said Billy Taylor, a real estate agent based in neighboring Plumas County, 30 minutes from Lassen County. 'A lot of the locals work as prison guards, and others move there to be closer to incarcerated loved ones.' The facility - High Desert State Prison - has been one of the region's largest employers since it opened in 1995. But long before the prison arrived, Lassen County was known for something else entirely. 'It's a very rural town known for cattle ranching and timber harvesting,' Taylor said. 'That's what it was built on - it was strictly ranching before the prison came in.' It's also a draw for outdoor enthusiasts, he added, with 'world-class hunting and fishing,' including large mule deer and the famous Eagle Lake trout, a prized species unique to the area. Susanville, the county seat, has a population of nearly 10,000 and still reflects that rugged, frontier identity - one that may appeal to buyers looking for space, affordability, and access to nature. Taylor emphasized that Lassen County offers exceptional value, particularly for those priced out of more populated markets. 'You can't build a house for what existing homes are selling for,' he said, noting that buyers can find ranchettes with acreage and 'elbow space' at prices rarely seen elsewhere in California. Most homes, he added, are selling below asking price, typically within 5 to 10 percent of list. Known for its high desert terrain and mountain ranges, Lassen County attracts outdoor enthusiasts and budget-conscious buyers alike Lassen isn't the only county offering relative bargains – four others also posted median home prices well below the statewide average, according to the Realtors' report. Lake County at $301,380; Trinity County at $311,000; Siskiyou County at $315,000; and Plumas County at $328,750 are the most affordable in the state. Plumas, in particular, is attracting buyers from Nevada and the greater Reno area, thanks to its mountain views, small–town feel, and access to Lake Almanor – a quiet resort community locals call 'what Tahoe was 30 years ago.' According to Zillow, California's average 30–year fixed mortgage rate stood at 6.88 percent as of July 18. But in Lassen and other rural areas, sellers are showing more flexibility. Jordan Levine, senior vice president of the California Association of Realtors, said homes are staying on the market longer, and sellers are more open to negotiation. 'Amid stabilizing home prices and a greater availability of homes for sale, California's housing market rebounded in June, but remained below year-ago levels,' the Realtors Group said in a news release. Heather Ozur, California Association of Realtors president, added: 'With more properties on the market and price growth flattening, conditions have become more favorable for prospective buyers who have been waiting on the sidelines to re-enter the market and take advantage of increased negotiating power.' With scenic terrain, low prices, and a slower pace of life, Lassen County may offer an appealing alternative for budget–conscious buyers – as long as they're not deterred by its prison–town identity.
Daily Mail
6 hours ago
- Daily Mail
How Albanese's 1.2million housing policy failure and record immigration has created a new category of Aussies with nowhere to go
Australia's housing emergency is now so dire nurses are living in cars while thousands of mothers and their children are sleeping rough or crammed into crisis accommodation with no path out. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese promised to fix the housing crisis but Australia today is home to some of the most expensive real estate in the world, with near record low rentals available and the worst levels of homelessness in living memory. Recent data by Homelessness Australia reveals the number of people accessing their services each month has grown by 10 per cent since the Albanese government came into power in May 2022. The situation is even more dire for women and girls, with an increase of 14 per cent. But while women and children go without a roof over their heads, immigration is booming, which experts say is putting unprecedented strain on the local property market. Australian Bureau of Statistics figures show in the year to May, 1.1million permanent and long-term arrivals hit Australian shores, including international students and skilled workers. In cities soaking up the bulk of the arrivals like Sydney, Melbourne, Perth and increasingly Brisbane, the competition for rentals is fierce, sending rents and house prices soaring. Australian Population Research Institute president Bob Birrell blamed the housing crisis on record overseas migration, which meant working Australians were being pushed out of the market, unable to buy or rent. 'The Albanese government is completely irresponsible on this issue,' he said. Freelancer CEO Matt Barrie (pictured) said the Great Australian dream of home ownership is out of reach for many now and he places the blame on record migration 'They have neglected it ever since they got back into power in 2022, they've just let immigration rip. 'We've had enormous levels of migrants, which is just unprecedented, and irresponsible in the context of the housing crisis.' Dr Birrell said part of the problem is the skilled migration program recruits hardly any tradespeople, especially for the beleaguered building industry. 'Migration is not adding to the supply of those important trades at all,' he said. 'Although a lot of temporary migrants who are adrift in Melbourne and Sydney would probably like to take up an apprenticeship in these areas, they can't, because they're temporaries.' Freelancer CEO Matt Barrie said the Albanese government had created a system so perverse doctors were living in share houses and nurses were sleeping in their cars. 'The Great Australian Dream is now mathematically impossible for the average Australian,' he said. 'In Sydney it now takes 46 years just to save a house deposit. Think about that, for a child born in Sydney today, their retirement party will come before they've saved enough for a house deposit.' Mr Barrie said the housing crisis had been 'engineered' by the government which has flooded the country with the largest immigration wave in history. 'Why, in a cost of living crisis, would they allow nearly one million international student enrolments? 'Why, in a cost of living crisis, would they allow 2.46million people on temporary visas into a country of 27million when there's only 36,000 rental vacancies?' Refuge workers and frontline services are also sounding the alarm on the crisis which is leaving women and children behind. As politicians returned to Canberra for the first sitting week of the new term, Everybody's Home spokeswoman Maiy Azize said the Albanese government has a chance to deliver a lasting legacy on housing or risk being remembered for letting it slip away. It comes after the public release of a written warning to Treasurer Jim Chalmers that the Albanese government could not meet its commitment of supplying 1.2million homes by 2029. 'This is a national crisis that is now pricing out everyday people right across the country,' she said. 'The government can't ignore the increasing number of Australians who are sleeping on streets and couches, forgoing food and medicine to pay rent, and living in unsafe and makeshift housing.' Ms Azize said warnings the government is unlikely to meet its ambitious housing target are further proof that relying on the private market alone won't work. The organisation said social housing has declined to around 4 per cent of all homes, down from 4.7 per cent in 2013. 'To reach six per cent social housing Australia must build more than 36,000 additional social housing dwellings every year for the next decade,' she said. 'If we want one in ten homes to be social housing, we need to build an extra 54,000 social homes every year for 20 years. 'Whichever way you look at it, the scale dwarfs current government commitments and lays bare both the enormous demand and decades of chronic underinvestment.' During Question Time on Wednesday, Opposition leader Sussan Ley pushed Mr Albanese on whether he would abandon his failing policies to tackle the housing crisis. In his defence, Albanese said Labor had 'inherited a decade of neglect' and it would take time to catch up. One Nation Senator Pauline Hanson said Australian cities were full, housing is unaffordable, and services are stretched to breaking point. She said One Nation will cut permanent and temporary migration and restore the population to a level the country can support. 'This isn't extreme. It's common sense,' she said. 'Mass migration must stop. The system is broken. Let's fix it and give our people the chance to thrive.' For many it is too late. Shocking new data from Homelessness Australia reveals a record surge in families stuck in temporary refuges, with thousands of mothers and children sleeping rough or crammed into crisis accommodation. CEO Kate Colvin said one reason for the dramatic deterioration in families and women being pushed further into crisis is rising rents, with Labor's investment in social housing failing to keep pace with demand. Ms Colvin said many were one health tragedy away from losing a stable roof over their heads. 'It's heartbreaking when you meet people who have cancer and due to the number of hospital visits they attend they can no longer work. They lose their home and end up living in their car because you can't afford rent on income support payments,' she said. 'I've spoken to lots of young people who have been in and out of refuges for years, slept in parks or are couch-surfing with dubious people. 'There's always someone who'll offer a 16-year-old girl a bed but it comes with obligations.' Ms Colvin said homelessness is increasing for all, but women and girls are copping the brunt of this crisis. 'The Prime Minister talks about leaving no one behind but the harsh reality is that with 45 per cent of women and girls seeking homelessness support having experienced domestic and family violence, more women and girls are returning to violent homes.' Housing and Homelessness Minister Clare O'Neil said the government has invested more than $1.2billion in crisis and transitional housing. 'We're acutely aware of just how complex the challenge of homelessness is, which is why we continue to listen to people with first-hand knowledge right across the homelessness sector,' she told the ABC.
The Guardian
9 hours ago
- The Guardian
On a roll: Who Gives a Crap toilet paper co-founder aims for ‘world domination'
It has been ubiquitous in middle class British bathrooms since a flush of growth during the Covid pandemic. Now Who Gives a Crap is aiming to wipe out the Andrex puppy, Cushelle's koala and Little Duck's little duck with a more ethical version of toilet roll. Its product, made from recycled paper or bamboo and wrapped in colourful paper, has risen rapidly to become the UK's third biggest non-supermarket brand. Now, the company – which claims to be the first ever online specialist loo roll maker – is aiming for 'world domination' with a rollout into Tesco supermarkets, and beyond. The Australian brand gives 50% of its profits to clean water and sanitation projects, and raising money for good causes is a key part of the company's purpose, according to its co-founder, Simon Griffiths. After experiments with a 'click to give' donations website and then a bar that sold beer and wine from developing countries, he settled on the idea of linking philanthropy to an everyday product that could reach every household. Griffiths says a trip to the loo inspired a 'quarter-second epiphany' on what that product could be, alongside the company's risque name and its mission to raise funds to provide access to clean water and sanitation in developing countries via partners including WaterAid. From the beginning, the company promised to donate half its profits to sanitation projects and as sales around the world have rapidly grown, it has raised close to £10m so far for projects such as eco-friendly waterless toilets in Kenya and school toilet blocks in Timor-Leste. Sales at its UK arm rose 17% to £45.5m in 2024 when operating profits more than doubled to £2.8m, according to the most recent figures available at Companies House. The company does not reveal international profits, but it donated £2.43m to sanitation projects last year, suggesting they have hit almost £5m. The brand is aiming to more than double donations to A$50m (£24m) by 2028 and within a decade collect 'hundreds of millions' of donations by adding new products and new countries. 'The reason why we exist is because there's still 2 billion people without access to adequate sanitation today, globally,' Griffiths says. 'If you're going to solve that problem that affects billions of people, you need to eventually be everywhere. That's not something we plan to do in the next 12 months. In 30 years' time, I think we will want to be in every supermarket in the UK.' The brand, which began online, is already in more than half of Australian supermarkets and went on to Tesco shelves earlier this month in the UK after launching in Whole Foods Market and Waitrose in 2023 . However, further expansion may be tough during a cost of living squeeze and the imposition of US tariffs on Chinese-made goods which is pushing up prices in what is now its biggest market – just ahead of the UK. Even in the UK, the ethical stance comes at a price for shoppers, with its 100% recycled rolls priced at 39p for 100 sheets for a six-pack at Tesco – on a par with Cushelle's six-pack but a considerable mark-up on the 16p for the supermarket's recycled own-brand and ahead of the 32p for 100 sheets for Andrex's 'family soft' nine-roll pack. He cheerfully admits that its success so far is down partly to the colourful paper wraps on its loo rolls, which people like to show off in their bathrooms, as much as its environmental and ethical considerations. Sign up to Business Today Get set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morning after newsletter promotion From the outset the plan was to provide a stylish and ethical counterpoint to 'this sea of white and purple and different colours and pictures of puppies and pillows and feathers and things that were entirely unrelated to toilet paper' on supermarket shelves, Griffiths says. He has said the company might be only a fifth of the size it is today if it wasn't for the wrapping. Having started with 100% recycled loo roll made using waste – such as old letters and cardboard boxes – it now also sells a version made from bamboo. Other products include recycled tissues and, perhaps more controversially, recycled plastic bin bags and dog poo bags. The group is also expanding geographically including entering Canada this year – taking it to 37 countries in total. It is a long way from the toilet seat where Griffiths sat for 50 hours as part of a 2012 crowdfunding campaign that raised A$50,000 to back the first order and where it also signed up the brand's first 1,000 customers. Expansion today is underpinned by A$41.5m in 2021 from investors including Verlinvest, the Belgian investment company behind the oat milk Oatly and the fair trade chocolate brand Tony's Chocolonely. So far, a rising number of shoppers seem persuaded that the product is worth paying more for than bog-standard rivals and Griffiths insists it is more than a passing fad with every decision based on 'trying to do the right thing'. 'We've been around now for about 12 years in Australia. I don't think there's a risk of us kind of going out of fashion in the same way that you might see with clothing,' he says.
