New English curriculum 'system racism' by omission says Auckland head teacher
Northcote College Head of English David Taylor says he won't teach the new English curriculum, which includes movies like Spirited Away.
Photo:
Studio Ghibli / Archives du 7eme Art / Photo12 via AFP
Auckland's Northcote College Head of English David Taylor says he will not teach the proposed new English curriculum and is urging others to boycott it too.
The curriculum features a list of suggested texts including Arthur Miller's play
The Crucible
, Edgar Allan Poe's
The Raven
,1984 by George Orwell and
Dubliners
by James Joyce, along with writing from Kiwi authors including Becky Manawatu, Oscar Kightley and Witi Ihimaera.
The document makes no mention of Te Mataiaho, a framework grounded in Te Tiriti o Waitangi.
Taylor, who wrote an opinion piece on why he will refuse to teach the curriculum, told
Checkpoint's
Lisa Owen he had three main concerns.
"The first would be lack of flexibility that this document offers for us to meet the diverse needs of our students and our communities, that's both in the texts that they'll study but also opportunities to express themselves," Taylor said.
"A second big concern is that it really doesn't seem like a document that's been written with an understanding of the needs of young people in Aotearoa, at the moment, or the realities of teaching them.
"And I think ultimately that leads to a third concern; this curriculum would take us backwards."
That was because New Zealand had been making "really great progress" with trying to create a more "level playing field" in education, he said.
"And this is going to be greatly undermined because it reduces that flexibility that we have to meet the different diverse student needs that we have in our communities."
Taylor said the curriculum was very prescriptive in terms of the types and numbers of texts that had to be studied at each year level.
"At the moment there is much greater autonomy and teacher and student choice around that. This is very heavy on detailing what needs to be taught."
In Year 12 and 13 it would be compulsory to teach Shakespeare and a 19th Century novel, he said.
When asked what he would like to see instead, Taylor said New Zealand had very diverse communities with students who had different requirements.
"Really good English teachers understand that and are able to work out what the right text is for each student for them to be able to do the learning they need to do.
"We're not in a homogeneous situation where we are able to just say these texts are going to best for everyone."
He said while he personally loved Shakespeare and 19th Century literature, it was not going to be right for all students.
"We need the ability to be able to know our learners, know our students, know what learning they need and actually pick the right texts for them."
Taylor pointed out Shakespeare and a 19th Century novel were compulsory and would take up a large chunk of the year.
Northcote College in Auckland. Head of English David Taylor says the new English curriculum enables systemic racism.
Photo:
RNZ / Marika Khabazi
Taylor said in his
opinion piece on The Spinoff
, that the proposed new curriculum enabled "systemic racism".
He said such racism could be subtle.
"A big part of that here is what's been taken away."
When compared to previous versions of the curriculum he said there was a loss of explicit reference to Māori authors, or to the stories of tangata whenua or Te Tiriti itself.
"The loss of opportunities for students to tell their own stories. There's a real lack of respect for Māori history and storytellers by not including them.
"And instead what you get is the privileging of these non-Māori texts... by making them compulsory it's at the exclusion of something else.
"You call out what you privilege. So by calling out those texts you are marginalising texts and authors who in previous versions have been far more in the spotlight."
Asked if the government was putting international authors ahead of New Zealand writers, Taylor said that was "very clear".
Taylor said although the
Treaty Principles Bill
had been voted down, "this is kind of it happening by stealth really and I think anybody who objected to the underlying problems with that bill should take a strong interest and make a submission on this as well".
"It's not just something for English teachers. I think it's something for anyone who's interested in education."
He lambasted current and previous governments and the Ministry of Education for "institutional incompetence" and creating an education system which was "lurching from one chaotic mess to another".
He loved his job but said it was incredibly tiring.
The proposed curriculum was currently out for consultation.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Spinoff
4 hours ago
- The Spinoff
All the novels I studied at high school, ranked
Year 13 student Zara Dollie considers all the books she studied from years 9 to 13, and puts them in their place. From Shakespeare's tragic love to S.E. Hinton's street fights, we have all battled with 'novel studies' throughout our NCEA careers. A 'novel study' consists of closely analysing a book chosen by your teacher to write essays about. It's often a dreaded aspect of the year because it requires doing things teenagers don't typically want to do: deep reading, critical thinking, and clear writing under pressure. How often do these stories continue to impact us after the final exam is over? What life lessons did 1984 teach me? How did The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas develop my capacities for empathy? With the new English curriculum incoming, now feels like a good time to revisit the novels I was made to study throughout secondary school – and reflect on the ones that stayed with me. To help me reason with how these books impacted me (or not), I ranked them using the following criteria: How relevant the text was at the time I studied it; Its literary merit; Whether it taught me any lasting life lessons. 5. The Raging Quiet by Sherryl Jordan Studied in Year 11 Marnie's journey to Fernleigh and her catalytic relationship with Raven filled me with an unimaginable amount of disdain – and I wasn't the only one that felt this way. Marnie's relationship with Raven, while clearly intended to be poignant, didn't resonate with me the way other characters in media have. I struggled to invest myself in the progression of their bond, and instead enjoyed the individual personalities of the characters. That said, Jordan's ability to highlight the complexities of empathy was evident and admirable. At age 15 I was reading Sally Rooney, dabbling in Emily Brontë, growing amicable with Murakami. While The Raging Quiet taught independence, standing up to conformity, and breaking away from societal norms, it lacked the mind-bending, evocative depth other authors provided. I do believe that incorporating Aotearoa writers into the curriculum is important, but I would have liked to explore these themes through a more culturally familiar setting – one that reflected our own society. Jordan is a fantastic writer, but this story didn't challenge me in the ways I needed at that stage. At Year 11 we needed something complex, a story to sink our teeth into, and The Raging Quiet was not that novel. I do think, however, that this book would be an amazing novel for students between Year 7 and 8 to read as a class. 4. The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas by John Boyne Studied in Year 9 The story of Shmuel and Bruno is heavy enough to make any adult eyes well with tears, so as an impressionable 13-year-old, I found this book profoundly sad. This story was so impactful because of its simplicity. Boyne didn't write descriptive, gruesome scenes, but instead used the innocence of childhood as a tool to convey the weight of tragedy. The contrast between a child's curiosity and the bleak reality of the holocaust struck a chord in all of us. Boyne's storytelling sparked conversations not just about history, but about empathy, injustice, and just how easily innocence can be lost. Boyne's writing contained the perfect level of mature language for our age group. We were taught valuable lessons through this book, such as the dangers of prejudice – a relevant lesson during the rise of bullying online and offline. The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas was the first in-depth exposure to just how gruesome the holocaust was for most students in our class. Many students later revisited the holocaust through social science and history, which made this novel a formative first step — one that shaped our emotional understanding before the facts arrived. 3. One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest by Ken Kesey Studied in Year 13 The themes within One Flew Over the Cuckoos Nest were eye-opening, fresh and fitting for a Year 13 class. Its structure and characters were unlike anything I'd studied in school before — a welcome shift. At its core, the novel taught the importance of human connection – an appropriate lesson at this age. In the novel, the main character McMurphy fosters connections between patients in a psychiatric hospital, despite their different struggles, and creates a web of camaraderie. His ability to unite people showed students that authentic leadership sometimes lies in rebellion against injustice, and in empathy, and in the capacity of human connection to repel oppressive systems. This made us question authority and institutions, raising conversations about how those in power can misuse their authority under the guise of order or care (for example, the ward's use of electroshock therapy and lobotomy as tools for control, rather than healing.) These weren't just literary concepts. They were life lessons. And they stayed with me. 2. 1984 by George Orwell Studied in Year 12 Studying dystopia in Year 12 was one of my favourite units throughout my school years. 1984 hooked my class from the beginning — probably because dystopian fiction is already so familiar to teens through popular novels such as The Hunger Games, The Maze Runner, and Shatter Me. The novel offered countless lessons: the metaphors were rich, it's structured well and contains a diversity of sentence types, all of which made it interesting to read. Orwell's use of auditory imagery, specifically during the Two Minutes Hate (a daily ritual in which citizens are forced to express hatred for the Party's enemies), revealed to us how writing can unsettle a reader on a visceral level — and taught us how to do the same. 1984 was timely. The totalitarian environment reflected what was happening in 2024 — from surveillance control to political spin. Through Orwell we discovered how impactful propaganda can be: ringing bells of war time propaganda, the Russian revolution, and other periods we knew about because of school and other forums. This sparked questions about life itself, such as the implications of totalitarianism and what it means for the future. Orwell helped shape our perception of worldly events as well as taught us lessons about literature and what it can do. 1. The Outsiders by S.E. Hinton Studied in Year 10 'Stay gold, Ponyboy, stay gold,' still echoes through my mind whenever I see a fiery sunset burn orange. That line — and the book it comes from — was hands down the most important novel I was taught at school. Not because it was easy. Not because it got me a good grade. But because it stuck. Hinton framed the chaos of adolescence like the films Mid90s, Eighth Grade, and Normal People would later. The ongoing relevance of the ideas in The Outsiders shows that its lessons are impactful — they move beyond the time the novel was written. I was 14 when I studied this novel – just old enough to begin questioning things like loyalty, family, class – but too young to know where to look for answers. That's why this novel landed. Considering Hinton was 16 when she wrote it, I felt like she understood exactly how I was feeling. She wrote teenagers like they were real people, rather than just mere characters waiting to be analysed. The depth of each character added to the book's literary strength and made them more relatable for our age group. Reading the novel felt like having someone articulate the inner workings of teenagehood. While the plot of the novel hit hard, the quiet moments that Hinton described resonated too. Like the way Ponyboy describes sunsets, or his deep thoughts about poetry and loss. This novel showed me that vulnerability isn't weakness, being sensitive doesn't mean you're soft, and being observant is a gift. The Outsiders showed us that real strength can come from empathy. During Year 10, I thought I was far too complicated and far too alternative for others to relate to. But Ponyboy, the 'greasers' and their utter disdain for the 'socs' made me feel like I was part of something. The main concept I took away from this book was: 'Sometimes, you have to make poor decisions for the better outcome.' Those are words I pulled straight from the essay I wrote back then in Year 10. Consider Johnny's decision to kill Bob – on the surface, this is entirely wrong, both morally and legally. But he makes this decision to protect Ponyboy. Their strong sense of companionship taught me that morality isn't always black and white. It made me realise that sometimes, the hardest choices are the ones that teach us the most. And that kind of insight? It lasts. If books we study in school are meant to shape our thinking, then let them be books that challenge us, comfort us, and — like Ponyboy's story — stay with us beyond the final bell.
1News
5 hours ago
- 1News
Watch: Bridgerton actor fights off phone thief
An English actor has been captured on CCTV taking on a man who attempted to steal her phone. Genevieve Chenneour, who stars in the Netflix series Bridgerton as Clara Livingston, was waiting for a coffee in a London cafe in February this year when the incident unfolded. In the video, the man could be seen grabbing Chenneour's phone from a bench where it was sitting behind her. When Chenneour realised what was occurring, she turned around and confronted the man, who was sliding the phone into his pocket. She snatched it back before the 18-year-old thief, later identified as Zacariah Boulares, was tackled by Chenneour's friend. ADVERTISEMENT The video then showed her hitting Boulares with the phone multiple times. On May 29, Boulares pleaded guilty to theft and assaulting another customer.
Scoop
11 hours ago
- Scoop
Tenzing Norgay Movie To Be Filmed At Aoraki/Mount Cook
Press Release – Department of Conservation Filming in New Zealand is scheduled to begin next month. The production, which has already completed scenes in Kathmandu, Nepal, will feature Tom Hiddleston as Sir Edmund Hillary, Genden Phuntsok as Tenzing Norgay, and Willem Dafoe as English expedition … Alpine landscapes within the Aoraki/Mount Cook National Park will serve as the backdrop for a new biopic about Sherpa Tenzing Norgay's 1953 epic climb to the summit of Mount Everest alongside Sir Edmund Hillary. The Department of Conservation (DOC) has approved filming on Malte Brun Pass near the Tasman Glacier and near the Hochstetter Icefall on the eastern side of Aoraki/Mount Cook, which will 'double' as Everest base camp and the famous Hillary Step on the world's highest peak. 'These sites have been used for filming Everest-related documentaries and films before,' says DOC Ranger Ray Bellringer. 'All filming activities are subject to strict environmental conditions to ensure the protection of the natural landscape. DOC staff will be onsite daily to monitor compliance. This is an incredibly special place and it's our role to protect it,' he says. Bellringer also noted the long-standing relationship between New Zealand and Nepal through the Himalayan Trust, and the involvement of Nepalese students in conservation and education programs, including through Lincoln University's Parks and Recreation degree. Since 1953 around 70 Nepalese including many from the Sherpa community have come to Lincoln for study in nature-based tourism and community conservation. 'Sir Edmund Hillary dedicated much of his life after 1953 to supporting Nepalese communities,' Bellringer added. 'It is fitting that this project recognises the life and contributions of Tenzing Norgay, and we are proud to provide a setting that supports this storytelling. It's an iconic setting for an incredible story.' Filming in New Zealand is scheduled to begin next month. The production, which has already completed scenes in Kathmandu, Nepal, will feature Tom Hiddleston as Sir Edmund Hillary, Genden Phuntsok as Tenzing Norgay, and Willem Dafoe as English expedition leader John Hunt. The production is expected to bring a significant economic boost to the local area with a large production crew and cast staying in the village and surrounding area. Set construction and logistical preparations are currently underway. DOC staff will continue to work closely with the production team to ensure minimal environmental impact. Ray Bellringer says he happy Tenzing Norgay's story is getting recognition. 'We're pleased to support this movie project and help showcase it to the world. For Aoraki and the staff here to play a small part in helping to make that happen is special,' he says.
