Fiery exchange over ‘harshest' reforms
NSW's nominal insurer is 'plunging further into insolvency' by more than $6m a day the state's Treasurer has revealed, as Labor's controversial workers compensation reforms face another round of public inquiry.
Treasurer Daniel Mookhey revealed during an heated parliamentary inquiry on Tuesday that icare was tipped to rise from a deficit of $4.9bn at the end of 2024 to $6bn on July 1 absent reform.
'The nominal insurer is likely to hold $0.78 in assets for every dollar of future liability, meaning it is plunging further into insolvency at a faster rate,' Mr Mookhey said.
'Or, to put it even more simply, the scheme is no longer going backwards by $5m per day, it is going backwards by more than $6m every day.'
The state government's plan to reform workers compensation in NSW hit a major hurdle earlier this month when a strange coalition of the Liberals, Greens and the independents joined together to force another public inquiry.
The Liberals have proposed a number of amendments to the Bill, namely staying the lifting of the threshold of permanent whole person impairment (WPI) for psychological injury, and have called on the government to provide costings.
After hours of hearings, sparks immediately flew over modelling for the amendments between opposition treasury spokesman Damien Tudehope and Mr Mookhey who said 'the government is co-operating with this inquiry'.
Mr Mookhey and Mr Tudehope clashed again over the WPI, which Labor proposes lifting to 30 per cent. The Opposition claims doing so would harm workers injured psychologically to such an extent they may never work again. Treasurer Daniel Mookhey defended the Bill in a heated exchange. NCA Newswire/ Gaye Gerard Credit: News Corp Australia
NSW Treasury Secretary Michael Coutts-Trotter earlier told the committee there was a 'well developed pathway' for those people who, once completing their 130 weeks of payments, would instead transition to the NDIS scheme.
Labor claims the changes would not only help reduce the burden on the beleaguered state self-insurer, but would also allow injured workers access to lump sum payments should they wish, instead of remaining on compensation.
It was over the WPI that Mr Mookhey faced his second heated argument, this time with Greens MLC Abigail Boyd who asked if he knew the change 'would make us the harshest jurisdiction in Australia and one of the harshest in the world'.
Mr Mookhey said he didn't 'accept the characterisation'.
He claimed that at 130 weeks, 88 per cent of psychologically injured workers were back at work and accused Ms Boyd of being 'deliberately misleading' in claiming it would cut off '90 something per cent of people' currently on the scheme.
Consultant psychiatrist Dr Michael Epstein told the committee earlier on Tuesday afternoon that in comparison with other states, NSW's lifting of the WPI to 30 per cent would make it the 'harshest' in the country.
'NSW is going to take the crown,' Dr Epstein said.
Ms Boyd went on to summarise the evidence presented to the committee in three ways: she disputed the projected $2.5bn cost to the self-insurer, said there was 'no imminent danger of scheme collapse', and that the proposed WPI threshold was 'unbearably cruel'.
'I'll just make the point, you're entitled to vote against the legislation,' Mr Mookhey said in reply. Opposition treasury spokesman Damien Tudehope (centre) with Opposition Leader Mark Speakman, left. NewsWire/ Gaye Gerard Credit: News Corp Australia
Ms Boyd went on to accused Mr Mookhey of using 'misleading language' in referring to payments made by the state government to the self-insurer as a 'bail out', and asked him to 'admit you were wrong'. In response, Mr Mookhey said: 'No'.
Following the heated exchange, Ms Boyd said: 'I think we need a bit of a lie down now'.
A range of practising psychiatrists, insurance industry representatives and leaders from NSW Treasury and the nominal insurer, icare, gave evidence during the hours-long hearing on Tuesday.
Mr Mookhey has warned the state self-insurer is tipped to cost the budget $2.6bn over the next five years, while premiums for the nominal insurer have already been set for eight-per-cent for the next financial year.
Exactly how the state government will deliver savings through the scheme was under the spotlight during the hearing, with leaders from NSW Treasury and the nominal insurer grilled over costings for the proposed amendments.
Largely, though, the numbers were not available.
Asked about the government's return to work strategy, Mr Coutts-Trotter said some 3500 people were on the scheme with a $60m saving, with Mr Tudehope asking: 'Wouldn't you give this program a chance to operate before you actually embarked upon removing benefits?'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
West Australian
11 minutes ago
- West Australian
Energy minister plugs in for power price cap reforms
Caps designed to protect power users from excessive price hikes are not working as intended and need refining, the federal energy minister will concede in his first major speech since the election. A convincing Labor win also has Chris Bowen hopeful Australia can triumph in its bid to co-host global climate talks and muscle out competitor Turkey, with a decision expected soon. In a wide-ranging address to the Australian Energy Week conference in Melbourne, Mr Bowen will promise changes to the so-called Default Market Offer rules to force retailers to compete harder for customer dollars. "The DMO was intended to act as a benchmark price to stop the worst forms of price gouging, while leaving the job of putting downward pressure on prices to competition between energy companies," he will say on Wednesday. "However, I'll be frank. I don't think it's working that way and reform is needed." In several states, regulators enforce caps on what retailers can charge households and businesses to protect the hundreds of thousands of customers unable or uninterested in chasing a better deal. Caps are reviewed annually to reflect the costs of generation and moving electricity around through poles and wires. In NSW, South Australia, southeast Queensland, it's the independent Australian Energy Regulator's job, while in Victoria, the Essential Services Commission sets benchmark prices. Changes to AER's price cap mechanism have not yet been locked in, but could include clamping down on what retailers can claim back from customers on their bills. Mr Bowen said it was hard to defend price caps when 80 per cent of billpayers could be getting a better deal. "That's why we have work underway to deliver a better regulated pricing mechanism which will put downward pressure on electricity bills and also ensure the energy market better utilises the huge uptake of rooftop solar and batteries," he will say. Mr Bowen will declare Labor's thumping election win as a vote of confidence in its energy and decarbonisation policies. He says it puts Australia in a strong position to secure the rights to co-host the COP31 climate talks alongside Pacific nations. An announcement is possible at the UN climate meetings underway in Bonn, Germany. The bid has come under pressure following the federal government's proposed decision to grant an extension on the North West Shelf gas plant's operating life. The project was singled out by Oil Change International in a report showing the United States, Canada, Norway, and Australia are responsible for nearly 70 per cent of projected new oil and gas from 2025 to 2035.
Perth Now
12 minutes ago
- Perth Now
Treasurer unveils top priorities for second Labor term
Treasurer Jim Chalmers is set to lay out his key priorities for reform as he confronts "intensifying pressures" on the economy. Fixing the nation's stagnating productivity and turning around the budget's outlook amid forecast deficits as far as the eye can see are topping his list. As the economy records anaemic growth, Dr Chalmers on Wednesday will push for the nation to recognise "three blunt truths" standing in the way of higher living standards. "Our budget is stronger, but not yet sustainable enough," he will tell the National Press Club in Canberra. "Our economy is growing, but not productive enough. "It's resilient, but not resilient enough - in the face of all this global economic volatility." Dr Chalmers is vowing to ensure Labor's second term is consistent with those priorities. And despite the progress made on getting inflation back within the Reserve Bank's target band, the treasurer will say there's still more to do. Dr Chalmers will identify productivity as the government's primary focus. "Our economy is not dynamic or innovative enough," he will say. "Private investment has picked up, but not by enough to make our capital deep enough. "Skills aren't abundant enough or matched well enough to business needs." On the government's productivity roundtable in August, the treasurer will say it won't be a move to "retract or retrace" the steps taken in the first term, but an effort to renew and refresh. Weak productivity growth is a major problem for advanced economies around the world. "Too often it's seen as a cold, almost soulless concept when it's really the best way of making people better off over time, creating more opportunities, making our economy and our society more dynamic," the treasurer will say. In Australia, labour productivity has stagnated since the COVID-19 pandemic. The latest GDP figures released earlier in June showed a fall in the year to March. The 2022 election coincided with the largest quarterly fall in productivity growth in almost half a century, the treasurer will say.
Perth Now
25 minutes ago
- Perth Now
Energy minister plugs in for power price cap reforms
Caps designed to protect power users from excessive price hikes are not working as intended and need refining, the federal energy minister will concede in his first major speech since the election. A convincing Labor win also has Chris Bowen hopeful Australia can triumph in its bid to co-host global climate talks and muscle out competitor Turkey, with a decision expected soon. In a wide-ranging address to the Australian Energy Week conference in Melbourne, Mr Bowen will promise changes to the so-called Default Market Offer rules to force retailers to compete harder for customer dollars. "The DMO was intended to act as a benchmark price to stop the worst forms of price gouging, while leaving the job of putting downward pressure on prices to competition between energy companies," he will say on Wednesday. "However, I'll be frank. I don't think it's working that way and reform is needed." In several states, regulators enforce caps on what retailers can charge households and businesses to protect the hundreds of thousands of customers unable or uninterested in chasing a better deal. Caps are reviewed annually to reflect the costs of generation and moving electricity around through poles and wires. In NSW, South Australia, southeast Queensland, it's the independent Australian Energy Regulator's job, while in Victoria, the Essential Services Commission sets benchmark prices. Changes to AER's price cap mechanism have not yet been locked in, but could include clamping down on what retailers can claim back from customers on their bills. Mr Bowen said it was hard to defend price caps when 80 per cent of billpayers could be getting a better deal. "That's why we have work underway to deliver a better regulated pricing mechanism which will put downward pressure on electricity bills and also ensure the energy market better utilises the huge uptake of rooftop solar and batteries," he will say. Mr Bowen will declare Labor's thumping election win as a vote of confidence in its energy and decarbonisation policies. He says it puts Australia in a strong position to secure the rights to co-host the COP31 climate talks alongside Pacific nations. An announcement is possible at the UN climate meetings underway in Bonn, Germany. The bid has come under pressure following the federal government's proposed decision to grant an extension on the North West Shelf gas plant's operating life. The project was singled out by Oil Change International in a report showing the United States, Canada, Norway, and Australia are responsible for nearly 70 per cent of projected new oil and gas from 2025 to 2035.
