'Gross failures' and 'neglect' played part in death of newborn baby
Her mother Laura Stockwell-Parry was induced and Etta-Lili was born "in poor condition" on July 3, 2023,at Ysbyty Gwynedd, Bangor having suffered oxygen starvation, according to a pathologist.
She was taken to Arrowe Park Hospital on the Wirral but died there four days later on July 7. At a two day inquest in Cernarfon Kate Robertson, senior coroner for north west Wales, found that neglect was a contributory factor in the little baby's death.
READ MORE: Council crews to search bins and hand £70 fines to rule-breakers
READ MORE: Venomous snake bolts into sea from beneath paddleboard at popular Welsh beach
Staff had failed to notice problems early enough and a subsequent investigation wasn't thorough enough, the coroner said. Neither a community midwife before the birth, nor maternity unit staff at Ysbyty Gwynedd noticed the baby had stopped growing at about 40 weeks, the hearing was told. Sign up for our free daily briefing on the biggest issues facing the nation sign up to the Wales Matters newsletter here.
North Wales Live reported that the health board said said "significant steps" had been taken to address the failures in this case, which it said was an "isolated incident".
Mrs Robertson found cause of death was hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy. She recorded a narrative conclusion at this week's inquest. In a Prevention of Futue Deaths report statement, issued after the inquest the coroner said there were "several gross failures" identified in Etta's mother's care.
These failures resulted in opportunities not taken to deliver Etta before she became distressed. There were "many incidences of learning" relating to Etta's resuscitation at Ysbyty Gwynedd, she added.
Mrs Robertson found: "There were several opportunities not taken by those caring for Etta's mother.
"There were opportunities to identify concerns with Etta through her mother on the midwifery led unit on 2 July 2023 including properly conducting holistic assessments, properly completing partogram and manual palpation of maternal pulse which would also likely have resulted in earlier detection of distress and successful delivery. Etta's death was contributed to by neglect."
The coroner also found that Mrs Stockwell-Parry ought to have been referred to the labour ward for close monitoring, but instead, she was induced and received only intermittent monitoring. Her pulse was not always taken and recorded and there was no recognition that Etta Lili's mother's pulse was being recorded as opposed to the fetal heart rate.
Mrs Robertson also found the neonatal investigation was not thorough. The investigator neither obtained nor requested statements from the doctors directly involved in Etta's resuscitation, nor did they meet them to understand what had occurred.
Mrs Robertson said she is concerned that staff not involved in the incident will not learn enough from events where there is inadequate sharing of learning from an incident. She issued the Prevention of Future Deaths report about her concerns.
BCUHB has 56 days to respond with a timetable of how it will act on points raised.
Angela Wood, Executive Director of Nursing and Midwifery Services at Betsi Cadwaladr University Health Board, said "significant steps" have been taken to address the issues in this "isolated incident".
She said: "We would like to extend our deepest sympathies and heartfelt condolences to Mr and Mrs Stockwell-Parry following the tragic death of baby Etta. We recognise the profound impact this has had on the family, and we are truly sorry for the pain and loss they have endured.
"Since this tragic event in July 2023, we have carried out a thorough review of the care provided and taken significant steps to ensure that the issues identified have been addressed. We are committed to learning from this and have implemented a range of measures to strengthen our training and clinical oversight to ensure the safest possible care for mothers and babies."
She added: "We want to reassure expectant mothers and families in our care that this was an isolated incident. Providing safe, compassionate care is our highest priority, and we remain committed to upholding the highest standards of care across our maternity services."
Get daily breaking news updates on your phone by joining our WhatsApp community here. We occasionally treat members to special offers, promotions and ads from us and our partners. See our Privacy Notice
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
11 hours ago
- Yahoo
Seaside town's new hospital proposals unveiled - nine years after was supposed to open
Back in 2013 plans for new a £22m hospital in a North Wales seaside town were backed by Welsh Government. Under the proposal the 30 bed facility on the site of the Royal Alexandra Hospital in Rhyl, would have opened in 2016. But nine years after that projected opening date and the scheme for a new hospital alongside a revamp of the existing building has still not started. Planning was secured in 2020 but the Covid pandemic and subsequent spiralling inflation saw it stall. Now a "paired-back" scheme has been put out to consultation by Betsi Cadwaladr health board ahead of a planning application being submitted. READ MORE: North Wales city ranks among five worst seaside resorts in the UK READ MORE: Emirates imposes ban for all flights from October This would see a 14 bed hospital ward alongside a new Minor Injuries and Ailments Unit (MIAU), a dental facility, and new radiology unit. A planning statement said: "Planning permission for a previous design scheme for a new community hospital building at the site was originally granted permission back in 2020. However , progression of the previous redevelopment scheme was hit by implications from the Covid pandemic, and in-turn significant increased development costs. "Consequently, the original proposals were found to be unaffordable, and therefore the proposals have had to be rethought. In the interim period, BCUHB's development and project teams have been working hard to plan a development which will both meet the changing needs of our population and provide value for the public money being spent. "The proposed new building would represent a significant investment for the Royal Alexandra Rhyl campus to complement the retained facilities. Join the North Wales Live Whatsapp community now "Through the updated proposals BCUHB are looking to build a valuable addition to the community services provided in Rhyl, which will help to safeguard the continued use of the Royal Alexandra site for years to come. "Whilst the latest proposals have been paired-back from the previous proposals, the plans aim to incorporate as much of the previously proposed facilities as possible." The development proposals presented are for a new three storey community hospital building. Ground and first floor levels will accommodate the new healthcare facilities, with the second floor limited to accommodating necessary mechanical plant to serve the building. The statement added: "A separate programme of refurbishment and improvement works to the existing grade II listed main Royal Alexandra Hospital building are also planned to go ahead separately to the new building proposals. These refurbishment works will be the subject of a separate application in due course." Leader of the Welsh Conservatives and Clwyd West MS Darren Millar said: "Twelve years ago, the people of North Denbighshire were promised this incredible new hospital which would relieve pressures on Ysbyty Glan Clwyd and greatly improve the patient experience. 'The project has been beset by delays since the estimated costs ballooned and people have been left wondering whether the promised new facility would ever materialise. "Now, we have been insulted with massively scaled back plans, even though pressures at Glan Clwyd are worse than they were twelve years ago. "This is totally unacceptable, and the Welsh Government must now deliver on its many pre-election promises. Anything less will be an insult to people in the locality. "The Welsh Government has spent tens of millions on 20mph speed limits, unnecessary overseas offices, and tree planting in Africa, so money is no excuse for not giving us what we were promised. 'Given the dire state of health services here in North Wales, they should be looking at increasing the number of hospital beds, not slashing them." Sign up for the North Wales Live newsletter sent twice daily to your inbox Find out what's happening near you
Yahoo
18 hours ago
- Yahoo
Patient given chance to perform one final time with choir
A patient was given the chance to perform one final time with her choir as part of a special final wish. Annette 'Nettie' Burtenshaw, a 64-year-old woman from Penarth, was transported from the University Hospital of Wales to Cardiff Castle to perform with her Rock Choir at the City Hospice's Forever Flowers Celebration of Life. The journey was made possible by the Welsh Ambulance Service's Wish Ambulance initiative, which she was the 100th journey made. Ed O'Brian, clinical lead for palliative and end of life care at the Welsh Ambulance Service, said: "Reaching the 100th Wish Ambulance journey is such a special moment for Team Wish. "It's a powerful reminder of what kindness, teamwork and compassion can achieve. "What makes this milestone even more special is that it's entirely driven by the incredible Welsh Ambulance Service volunteers, who are the heart and soul of every Wish journey." The Wish Ambulance initiative, launched in 2019, helps terminally ill patients across Wales take meaningful final trips. Journeys have included visits to concerts, sporting events, birthday parties, the beach and more. In Ms Burtenshaw's case, the Wish Ambulance enabled her to perform one last time with her choir. Ms Burtenshaw, who was diagnosed with uterine cancer in 2021 and later with bone cancer, described the experience as "amazeballs." She said: "I can't put into words how much it meant to perform again with the choir. "There was no way on earth I could have done it without the Wish volunteers, they were angels. "From the bottom of my heart, thank you." The program is supported by more than 500 off-duty ambulance workers who volunteer their time and use non-emergency vehicles. Mark Harris, assistant director of operations (ambulance care) at the Welsh Ambulance Service, said: "We're very grateful and proud of our wonderful team of volunteers."
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Millions of people ‘could be denied weight-loss jabs due to flawed NHS guidance'
Millions of people could be denied access to treatments such as weight-loss jabs because of flawed NHS guidance, a major think tank has warned. King's Fund senior analyst Danielle Jefferies said Body Mass Index (BMI) measures, which are used to determine obesity levels, are primarily based on research for white European or American people. That means they do not account for the inherited ethnic differences of people from Black, Asian, brown, dual heritage or indigenous ethnicities – differences that can mean some groups are more likely to develop some health conditions. The 2021 census for England and Wales showed 1.3 million people listed themselves as 'other' for their ethnic group, while 1.7 million people listed themselves in 'mixed or multiple' categories. Ms Jefferies said that meant the current BMI thresholds 'potentially do not fully work for up to 3 million people in the UK', meaning they could miss out on treatments because they have a lower BMI than is required for some treatments. The warning comes as the NHS prepares to roll out access to weight-loss jab Mounjaro, to 250,000 patients a year over the next 12 years. Access to Mounjaro is based on strict measures, including the stipulation that a person has a BMI of over 40. Other NHS treatments, such as IVF, bariatric surgery, and joint replacement surgery, are also managed based on a person's BMI. Currently, BMI guidelines for people from black, Asian and Middle Eastern backgrounds are lowered to account for health risks that occur at a lower BMI than for white people. But the same is not done for those in these mixed heritage groups. Ms Jeffries said: 'The current NICE guidelines take a broad-brush approach by recommending lower BMI thresholds for anyone of Black, Asian or Middle Eastern background, which effectively includes almost everyone who is not white. 'This creates some knotty issues. First, because it leaves some people wondering if they are 'white enough' to use the old thresholds, which is a subjective and problematic way to categorise people from global majority ethnic backgrounds.' 'For example, does this include people who identify as Latino, white Middle Eastern, or Hispanic? Or does this include someone who is mixed and has one grandparent who is Black or Asian and the rest white?' Ms Jefferies said the NHS BMI calculator automatically gives patients who identify as 'other white ethnic group' – for example, someone who could identify as Latino – a higher threshold as if they were white. She said this can have 'real-world consequences' and including or excluding an ethnic group from the threshold adjustment could 'significantly impact national obesity figures and change how we measure health inequalities between different ethnicities'. 'For individuals, lower BMI thresholds could be life-changing. For the average-height adult, the cut-off point for being obese for people from a white ethnicity is more than a stone heavier than for people from a Black, Asian or Middle Eastern background. That could be significant if that person was sat in a GP appointment asking whether they qualify for bariatric surgery or weight-loss drugs, or if they are healthy enough to receive NHS-funded IVF,' she added. On Thursday, it was revealed that the price of Mounjaro will nearly triple for private patients in the UK, after the US-owned company equalised costs in markets across the globe. A month's supply of the highest doses of the 'King Kong' of weight-loss medicine will rise from £122 to £330 – an increase of 170 per cent. However, drug manufacturer Lilly said it would not raise the price paid by the NHS, and it was working with private healthcare providers to maintain access to the jab. NICE and the Department for Health and Social Care have been approached for comment.
