'The Sunday Game' : All-Ireland Camogie Final referee decisions 'balanced out'
But RTE's Sunday Game panel felt that the refereeing decisions balanced themselves out by the end of the the Croke Park decider.
Manley was particularly incensed by Hannah Looney's red card, a push in the back of his goalie Amy Lee and a late decision he felt went against Cork in their bid for a three-in-a-row as Galway upset the odds.
Introducing a section on the refereeing decisions in the match, Sunday Game host Jacqui Hurley said:
'In a lot of ways he (the referee) tried to let the game flow and that probably added to it, because there was some decisions that were a little contentious.
'Because of that that maybe it was allowed to fester and maybe it leads to the sending off as well.'
Former Limerick camogie player Aoife Sheehan said: 'I think so and that's probably something when you are on the field and you might feel that you are getting a raw deal.
"And the next thing you might give away a free and someone else does it - and you don't get anything. That can be really difficult.'
On the red card incident, Sheehan continued: 'Hannah Looney got a little dig in the back from Carrie Dolan and makes her feelings known straight away afterwards.
'She gives her I don't know what you would call it, a kind of a punch into the side of the head. I suppose she saw red there for it.
'That was her frustration coming out in that incidence. She gave the referee a decision to make and he made it.'
In the lead up to the red card a Cork player was pushed in the back but no free was given before Looney was dunted in the back.
In the closing stages a number of high tackles by Cork players went unpunished with one on Galway's Aoife Donohue resulting in a Cork free for overcarrying.
Sheehan continued: 'There was funny decisions on both sides. Ger Manley I know was a bit incensed afterwards.
'He was saying it but on the balance I think a lot of them (decisions) just evened out each other.
'That's the way we've been calling for camogie to be refereed for a long time. Look, let it go, let it flow, let the physicality get into it and I think both teams did get into it.'
Waterford player Niamh Rockett was also on the Sunday Game panel. She said: 'I think the refereeing really balanced out at that stage.
'We were talking at half time and we were saying will the sideline officials have a word with the referee over some of the more borderline decisions.
'To be fair to the referee, I think he balanced it out on both sides. He let it play when it needed to be played. No-one wants to be looking at a game that's going into a free taking competition.
'A spread of scorers for Cork and a spread of scorers for Galway. It wasn't just relying on Amy O'Connor and Saoirse McCarthy from Cork and Carrie Dolan to shoot the lights out.
'There were great scores from play. There were penalties. It had all the drama with it and I suppose the referee, they can only see the game and make a decision in a split second.
'Although Ger Manley might feel aggrieved by it I do feel it balanced out in the very end of it.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
9 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Jubilant crowd welcomes Galway camogie heroes – ‘The heart they show is just unbelievable'
Well over 1,000 Galway supporters gathered on the pitch to greet their heroes, who celebrated with the O'Duffy Cup and posed with fans under the Galway evening sunshine. All 39 members of the squad were given a raucous reception from the sea of maroon as they entered the main stage, with signs and flags scattered across the homecoming crowd heightening the festival-like atmosphere. Among those who gathered at Duggan Park were Kai, Lucy, Chloe, Siofra, Mia, Saoirse, Ruairi, who had attended the match in Croke Park with their families and even managed to luckily touch the trophy as it was presented to the players in the Hogan Stand. They added: 'There were more Cork fans but even though there were less people there was more loudness from Galway.' The group were in Ballinasloe to support the team even further as they proudly showed their hand painted sign reading 'Congrats girls, we are so proud!' 'We made [our sign] 15 minutes before we came, the paint just dried,' Mia said. And the young fans are already looking forward to next year as when asked to give the winners a message, they said: 'You got this next year, you're gonna make it and win as well.' Niamh, Ruairi, Rod, Aoife, Niamh, Eanna and Aoibhinn were also at Duggan Park to support the Galway team who, they said, are their local heroes and role models. Rod said: 'We just want to support our local heroes, especially two local girls, Ciara Hickey and Katie Anna Porter. We just want to show our support to the girls and say well done. 'And it's great for the children here to see great heroes and role models to look up to, they might emulate them in the years to come.' Niamh proudly added: 'They did absolutely brilliant yesterday, they brought it to Cork in the first half in particular. They stuck with it in the second half, and then we just got it over the line. So fair play to them, they gave it everything they had to give.' The squad was represented by players from all corners of the county, with each player's name being greeted by a wave of cheers from the crowd. The last player to be presented was Galway captain Carrie Dolan, who received a rapturous cheer from the crowd when her named was announced, having scored seven points in the final. Addressing the spectators, she said it was an 'absolute honour' to captain the side and praised her teammates for their dedication and ability to recover from last year's All-Ireland final defeat to Cork. 'We have two mothers in the team; we have girls that are 18 years of age and the heart they show is just unbelievable. Twelve months ago, we lost the All-Ireland in Croke Park and sometimes you don't get those days back. Only the good teams come back and yesterday we came back. 'I want to thank you all for coming out and supporting this team. I've never seen [such] a crowd to get behind the Galway camogie team since I started playing. We've lost three of the last four finals we've been in, and you stayed coming up that road. I can't tell you how important you were yesterday in that victory. 'To all the young boys and girls down there, yesterday our dream came true and, in the future, that could be your dream too. Never give up on your dream if you want to be a Galway camogie or hurling player.' Last to address the crowd was Galway manager Cathal Murray, who spoke proudly of the group and praised the side for the hard work that ultimately sealed their first O'Duffy Cup since 2021. 'One of my earliest memories as young child is coming to Ballinasloe to see the '87 and '88 teams, and I think it put a love of hurling in me. I hope there's lots of young girls out there that look up to these girls and that they inspire you and I hope you go on and represent your county in Croke Park. 'We're here because of the team here on my left-hand side. I'm unbelievably honoured to have such an unbelievable group of players representing Galway. I think the performances that put up over the last number of years have been exceptional but yesterday topped it all off. 'For me as manager, I'm just unbelievably honoured and privileged to be involved with such a special group of players.'
Irish Independent
12 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Defending champ Syd aiming for more Classic glory in Irish Sprint Cup Final
The Cork-based greyhound is favourite to win the €20,000 first prize for his syndicate of owners and preserve an unbeaten record in this year's renewal of the two-bend Classic. Indeed, in nine outings at the Co. Louth venue the Johnny Linehan-trained Broadstrand Syd has suffered just one defeat when he finished second behind 2023 winner Carrick Aldo in last year's third round. He is not the only unbeaten finalist. Droopys Patriot completed a five-timer on Saturday, a sequence that goes back to March when he took Tralee's Juvenile Classic over 525 yards. The August pup is handled by Robbie Gleeson who won the Sprint Cup in 2016 with Ballymac Bigmike. It is far from a two-dog affair. Stonepark Browne was successful in the first and second rounds before running up to Broadstrand Syd the last twice. Southwind Wild boasts a similar profile. He has finished second to Droopys Patriot on each of the last two occasions. Ballymac Brandan came into the event unraced. Nevertheless, the January '24 whelp has accumulated two victories so far. The field is completed by Epic Ace, whose trainer Pat Guilfoyle was responsible for the 2020 hero Grangeview Ten. He caught the eye with the manner he came from behind to win his second round heat. The dog is owned by John Kennedy Jnr who took the Sprint Cup with Good Cody (2021). Track record holder Broadstrand Syd (20.57 first time up in 2024) has a best of 20.70 this year and 'only' clocked 20.91 in each of his last two spins which will give his rivals some hope. Droopys Patriot twice went around in 20.88 and has fared best of the four railers in the draw in that he has avoided trap one and will wear the blue jacket, inside Broadstrand Syd and Stonepark Browne. The latter is a value bet as he made Syd work hard in the semis when starting from one. The other three contenders will be outsiders. If there is to be an upset it could be provided by Epic Ace though he will need to be closer at the first bend. Big race line-up 1 Ballymac Brandan, owner-trainer Liam Dowling, Co. Kerry 2 Droopys Patriot, owner Newmarket Racing Syndicate, trainer Robert Gleeson, Co. Kildare 3 Broadstrand Syd, owner Ryan Drake Donovan Syndicate, trainer John Linehan, Co. Cork 4 Stonepark Browne, owner Michael O'Dwyer, trainer Michael O'Donovan, Co. Tipperary 5 Southwind Wild, owner William Wood, trainer Pat Buckley, Co. Limerick 6 Epic Ace, owner John Kennedy Jnr, trainer Pat Guilfoyle, Co. Tipperary The August 15 card boasts five other finals where there is lots of local interest. Corduff, Co. Monaghan handler Laurence Jones has Lockstep and Sling Your Hook in an S2 400. They will be joined by Country Bucks, owned by David Hoey, Knockbridge. Clogherhead's Graham Kelly has Beretta Kadie in an A4 525 and Whiterock Shadow, owned jointly by Tommy McKevitt, Dromiskin, in an A3 525. Togher's Michael Doyle has qualified Coolemount Andy for the A3. Laurence Jones' Rosetta Stone runs in an A2 525 and Farney Charm in an A1 525 where the field includes Graham Kelly's Beretta Brandi.
RTÉ News
12 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Humbling experience for Galway camogie squad at Temple Street Children's Hospital
It's a Monday tradition for the All-Ireland winners and a "special morning" for the Galway camogie squad as they visited the Children's University Hospital in Temple Street. The O'Duffy Cup was there too, all after the Connacht side edged out holders Cork in Sunday's senior decider at Croke Park. There was great excitement among patients and staff as the players were guided through the corridors to meet the children. "It's very special, watching the All-Irelands down through the years, you get to see other teams do it," said Galway defender Dervla Higgins to RTÉ News. "Yesterday we thought the game was the most important thing ever but it humbles you coming here today, you see that there are bigger things in life." For Aoife Donohue, player of the match in this year's final, keeping up the well-established tradition was foremost for the squad. "All the girls wanted to come here," she said. "We are so lucky to go out and do what we are able to but coming here is so special; it really puts things into perspective. It's just a special morning." Ahead of taking the O'Duffy Cup across the Shannon, the victorious Galway senior camogie squad visited the Children's Hospital in Temple Street @GalwayCamogie96 @OfficialCamogie @MartyMofficial #rtenews #rtesport — RTÉ GAA (@RTEgaa) August 11, 2025 Another one of the Galway stalwarts, Róisín Black, also emphasised the importance of meeting the patients and their families in Temple Street. "There's a good gang of us here this morning and we all wanted to come. We met children from all over Ireland and seeing the smiles on their faces has added a bit more happiness to their day. "We met children from Galway as well, in their Galway jerseys, so to brighten up their day is lovely. When we go out on the pitch, if we win or lose that determines our happiness for that day. Seeing the smiles on the faces of the children when we bring in the cup, well that puts everything in perspective." After leaving Dublin, the new All-Ireland champions will first stop off in Athlone stop in Athlone, where the players and the O'Duffy Cup will make that symbolic walk across the Shannon. The team will then head to Ballinasloe and the celebrations will continue at the home club of captain Carrie Dolan in Clarinbridge.
