A former top Meta exec says AI is doomed if artists want tech firms to ask for permission to train models on their work
Former Meta executive Nick Clegg says the UK's AI industry will be killed if tech companies must ask artists for permission to use their work when training models.
Clegg was promoting his upcoming book "How to Save the Internet" at the Charleston Festival on Thursday when he was asked about artists' demands for tighter AI copyright laws.
Clegg said it would be reasonable to let artists "opt out of having their creativity, their products, what they've worked on indefinitely modeled."
However, he said it would be "somewhat implausible" if they expect companies to get permission before training models.
Clegg said this is because "these systems train on vast amounts of data."
"I just don't know how you go around, asking everyone first. I just don't see how that would work. And by the way, if you did it in Britain and no one else did it, you would basically kill the AI industry in this country overnight," Clegg continued.
Clegg was the UK's deputy prime minister from 2010 to 2015. He joined Meta in 2018 as its vice president for global affairs and communications and was promoted to president of global affairs in 2022. He announced his departure from Meta in January.
Clegg and representatives for Meta did not respond to requests for comment from Business Insider.
In October, the UK government introduced the Data (Use and Access) Bill. The bill will allow companies to train AI on creative works such as books and music, unless the copyright holder opts out.
Earlier this month, the House of Lords voted to amend the bill to require tech companies to disclose and seek consent before using copyrighted material to train their models. The House of Commons rejected the change.
Singer Elton John said in an interview with the BBC on May 18 that he was " very angry" with the bill, as it would allow tech companies to engage in "theft, thievery on a high scale." He said he was prepared to take the government to court and "fight it all the way."
"It's criminal, in that I feel incredibly betrayed," John said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Energy Deal Creates Technical Bullish Signal for Meta Platforms Stock (META)
From a fundamental perspective, social media and technology juggernaut Meta Platforms (META) recently made a compelling case for long-term investment. Meta recently entered into a 20-year power purchase agreement with Constellation Energy's (CEG) Clinton nuclear plant in Illinois. Primarily, the deal will help Meta manage its energy costs, a core component of its forward growth strategies. Easily unpack a company's performance with TipRanks' new KPI Data for smart investment decisions Receive undervalued, market resilient stocks right to your inbox with TipRanks' Smart Value Newsletter Indeed, artificial intelligence has emerged as one of the top priorities in the tech ecosystem. However, generative AI comes at a significant cost: substantial power consumption. In 2023, the power required to support AI deployment was estimated at 1 gigawatt. Experts believe that this rate will increase sevenfold to tenfold in the next two years, thus underscoring the criticality of Meta's energy deal. I too am bullish on META, but for different reasons. Market narratives aren't always reliable indicators of future valuations. Even as sentiment around Meta remains largely optimistic, analysts are actively revising their forecasts. While the majority maintain a bullish stance, the consensus price target suggests a degree of caution. For traders focused on near-term gains, compelling narratives alone don't offer enough concrete data for decision-making. In these cases, speculators often rely more on empirical, quantitative indicators to inform their strategies. When investors turn to financial publications, they're not simply looking for recycled narratives—they're in search of opportunities, specifically cases where the market may have mispriced certain stocks. To uncover these discrepancies, investors often turn to fundamental and technical analysis. While these methods can provide helpful context and short-term guidance—helping frame potential entry and exit points—they fall short of offering true empirical precision. The core issue lies in the problem of non-stationarity: over time, the metrics and benchmarks used for analysis can shift significantly due to changing market conditions and sentiment cycles, undermining their long-term reliability. For example, META stock recently closed near the $700 level. Five years ago, the equity could be bought for around $230. And a decade ago, META was priced at around $117. Attempting to conduct meaningful statistical analyses, such as price clustering, would be impossible given the significant disparity in share prices. Similarly, it's challenging to make valuation assessments on META stock. One could note that the equity trades at over 27x earnings. However, there's no first-order principle that this metric means anything. Furthermore, a range of catalysts — including business expansion, industry transitions, share dilution, and buybacks — can alter this ratio. Subsequently, comparisons across time aren't meaningful due to the shifting framework. To conduct an empirically sensible analysis, one must impose stationarity on the dataset, and that's where market breadth comes into play. At its core, market breadth is the pattern of accumulation and distribution. Another way of looking at market breadth is that it represents demand, and demand is a binary concept — it's either happening or it's not. Plus, from a statistical standpoint, demand is a discrete event that is easily categorizable and quantifiable across time. Stated differently, a market breadth profile that occurred several years ago remains relevant to the same profile that is currently in effect. That's the benefit of compressing — or abstracting to use the proper lexicon — price discovery into a binary code: analysts can develop probability matrices, focusing on how one demand profile (or behavioral state) transitions to another. With META stock, in the past two months, the security printed a '7-3-U' sequence: seven up weeks, three down weeks, with a net positive trajectory across the 10-week period. Notably, in 58.25% of cases, the following week's price action results in upside, with a median return of 2.59%. If the implications of the 7-3-U sequence materialize as projected, META stock could potentially reach $715.78 in short order, possibly within a month. Should the bulls maintain control of the market, the optimists could attempt to drive the share price to $723 over the next three weeks. Primarily, the setup incentivizes a bullish posture because of the baseline probability. On any given week, the chance that META stock will rise is 55.51%, which is a decent upward bias. However, the 7-3-U sequence adds a couple of percentage points to the odds in favor of the bullish speculator. In the open market, a 3% gain or so isn't really going to move the needle. However, with the leverage of multi-leg options strategies, relatively incremental gains can turn into significant payouts. For those who want to take a more aggressive approach while staying within the realm of rationality, the 710/715 bull call spread, expiring June 27, is offering value. This transaction involves buying the $710 call and simultaneously selling the $715 call, for a net debit paid of $210. Should META stock rise through the short strike price at expiration, the maximum reward is $290, which translates to a payout of over 138%. What makes this trade so enticing? As specified earlier, the statistical response to the 7-3-U is generally to the upside. Should META stock rise, the median return is 2.59%. Of course, the actual result could be higher or lower. If the median performance materializes, META could soon be priced near $716. Therefore, a $710 price target provides a certain level of 'safety' margin. Notably, the market makers are offering a 138% payout, which suggests that they don't expect META stock to rise significantly from here. Most likely, they believe that the good news is priced in. Among professional market analysts, META stock carries a Strong Buy consensus rating based on 42 Buys, three Holds, and one Sell rating. The average META stock price target is $698.07, implying a marginal upside potential of less than 1% over the coming 12 months. If you're looking to invest in Meta Platforms, the company's recent energy deal offers a strong long-term narrative. However, if your goal is to trade META stock for shorter-term gains, you'll need more actionable, data-driven insights. In that case, statistical analysis may be a better approach, providing the required empirical rigor to identify high-probability opportunities. Disclaimer & DisclosureReport an Issue Sign in to access your portfolio
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
NC, SC attorneys general among those urging Meta to crack down on deceptive ‘pump and dump' Facebook ads
RALEIGH, N.C. (QUEEN CITY NEWS) – North Carolina Attorney General Jeff Jackson is among 42 across the country urging Meta to crack down on deceptive ads. The joint letter claims the social media giant is allowing these so-called 'pump and dump' schemes on Facebook, conning users out of hundreds of millions of dollars. 'Scammers are using fake Facebook ads to trick people into losing millions in scam investments,' said Jackson in a statement. 'It's Meta's job to take these ads down and make sure their platform is as safe as possible for users everywhere. Meta needs to act now.' Consultant behind AI-generated robocalls mimicking Biden goes on trial in New Hampshire Jackson's office says these ads frequently use images of well-known financial figures like Warren Buffet, Cathie Wood and Elon Musk to make users think they're legitimate. They'll advertise stocks with outrageous returns, free consultations, or offer to give investment advice. The AGs claim that clicking on the ads directs users to join a WhatsApp group, where the scammers allegedly urge victims to buy penny stocks to rapidly inflate the share prices. After 'pumping up' the price of the stock, the scammers will 'dump' their shares, causing the prices to fall and leaving victims unable to get their money back. South Carolina AG Alan Wilson is among the co-signers. The letter cites several examples of victims, including a 65-year-old woman who lost her 401(k) to this scheme after clicking on a Facebook ad for what seemed to be a reputable investment management company. And three victims in South Florida spoke to a news outlet reporting direct losses of more than $85,000 and pointing to two-dozen other victims who lost millions more. The attorneys general are asking Meta to either strengthen its advertisement review practices to prevent these ads from being shown to Facebook users or remove all investment ads from the platform. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Brazil's top court votes to hold social media platforms accountable for user posts
By Ricardo Brito BRASILIA (Reuters) -Brazil's Supreme Court on Wednesday ruled that social media companies must be held accountable for some types of content published by users on their platforms in the country, but details on the decision have yet to be resolved. Six of the 11 Supreme Court judges voted to hold platforms responsible for third-party content seen as illegal, in a decision that could result in fines against social media companies for not removing some users' posts in the country. The decision could impact the business of platforms including Meta's Facebook and Instagram, as well as TikTok, Elon Musk's X and other internet giants, such as Alphabet's Google, in a market of more than 200 million people. Only one justice so far voted to not change the current law on the matter, which says that the companies can only be found responsible for third-party content on their platforms if the firms do not comply with a legal decision ordering the content removal. Writing for the majority, Justice Gilmar Mendes said current Brazilian law represents "a veil of irresponsibility for digital platforms." "Even if they are informed of the occurrence of crimes on their platforms, they (currently) cannot be held responsible for damages caused by keeping this content online, except in the case of a court order," he said. Asked to comment, Meta sent a 2024 statement where it had said that a decision holding platforms responsible could make them "liable for virtually all types of content even without having been notified." In a statement sent before the vote which gave the court a majority, Google said the current Brazilian law regarding social media can and should be improved, "as long as procedure guarantees and criteria are set to prevent legal uncertainty and the indiscriminate content removal." TikTok and a representative of X in Brazil did not immediately respond to requests for comment. The court did not agree on the scope of the decision, such as what types of content would be considered illegal. The court's head, Luis Roberto Barroso, said he will work with the court members to find a consensus. Four judges still need to vote in the trial, which has been rolling over for months. Votes previously cast can still be changed, although that is not common. The trial is set to resume on Thursday.
