Unease among Labour MPs as government eyes reforms to Send provisions
MPs, parents, families, and teachers all agree the current system is ripe for reform.
Poor state provisions have seen local councils spend billions of pounds educating pupils independently and transporting pupils to and from school.
Meanwhile, parents and families have told ITV News they've had to pull their children out of mainstream state schools for months on end due to inadequate provision.
In autumn this year, the Education Secretary, Bridget Phillipson, will outline her plans for reforming Send (Special Educational Needs and Disabilities) provisions.
In recent weeks, government ministers have refused to rule out scrapping Education, Health and Care Plans (EHCPs) - the legal document outlining support for Send children.
The speculation has fuelled suspicion and anger among campaigners and parent groups, who over the weekend penned an open letter urging the government not to remove the legal rights of Send children.
But there are now growing concerns among Labour MPs about what these changes could look like and how they will sell reforms on the doorstep.
One backbencher told ITV News that ministers needed to frame the changes in the context of improving outcomes for children rather than cost-cutting.
"This is the same issue as with winter fuel and welfare - there's too much of a focus on making the numbers work on a spreadsheet without thinking about the impact on people," they said.
'If people think the government is scrapping EHCPs as another form of penny-pinching – that's going to be a hard sell,' another Labour MP said.
Jen Craft, Labour MP for Thurrock and a Send parent, told ITV News that special educational needs is one of the 'biggest issues' in her inbox. She describes the government's upcoming reforms as an 'opportunity' to reform an "adversarial" and "broken" system.
But she warned that any changes needed to be done in collaboration with families.
'The answer is to listen to parents, listen to families and listen to the children themselves," she said.
Other MPs voiced frustration that the lack of clarity from the government has fuelled suspicion and anxiety among parents.
'They've been caught off guard, again, by the scale of concern on an issue," one added.
'EHCPs aren't a golden solution, and the system does need reform – but we've got to explain what is being done and bring parents on side,' another backbencher said.
Over the summer, ministers will continue discussions with MPs and campaigners before confirming plans in the School's White Paper.
With the dust still settling from last week's welfare rebellion - Downing Street will be keenly aware that the success and failure of Send reform will rely on getting MPs and - more crucially - the public onside.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
a few seconds ago
- Telegraph
Police investigate St George's flag painted on roundabout
Police have launched an investigation after the St George's Cross was painted on a mini-roundabout. A video on social media appeared to show a man daubing stripes of red paint on to the roundabout in Bromsgrove, Worcs. The video has been shared amid a growing movement that has seen members of the public display patriotic flags in towns and cities across England. West Mercia Police confirmed that it was investigating the graffiti as criminal damage. Insp Richard Field, of Bromsgrove Police, said: 'Painting roundabouts is not only dangerous to drivers and pedestrians, but it also amounts to criminal damage. We are working closely with partners, including Worcestershire county council, to tackle this issue and investigate where appropriate.' At least five other roundabouts in the West Midlands have reportedly been painted in a similar way. A West Midlands Police spokesman said: 'We're aware of criminal damage having occurred, and we're carrying out further inquiries.' On Tuesday, it emerged that Reform-led Worcestershire county council had removed the paint from the roundabout in Bromsgrove. Video posted online appeared to show a maintenance truck on the roundabout, with a council worker dressed in hi-vis cleaning off the paint. The council said such markings could be distracting to road users. A spokesman added: 'All road markings on the county's highway network are strictly regulated for safety, including those on roundabouts of any size. Changes to agreed road markings must not be made unless approved by the Highway Authority, in line with these regulations. 'Unofficial actions on the highway network could be distracting or cause confusion to some road users so will therefore be removed.' The council was embroiled in a row earlier this week over the hanging of patriotic flags from lampposts. On Monday, a spokesman said St George and Union flags hung from lamp-posts in Wythall, a village south of Birmingham, risked endangering pedestrians and motorists. But the remarks drew an angry reaction from Cllr Jo Monk, the council's leader, who said: 'I, of course, support flying both flags proudly on lampposts throughout the county. 'Our national flags are a symbol of our national pride, and I will champion any effort that celebrates our nation.' We won't remove flags, says Reform Nigel Farage, the Reform leader, insisted a press officer at the council had issued the statement about the flags without authority, and Reform UK later confirmed its 12 councils would not remove patriotic flags from lamp-posts. The flying of patriotic flags in public has become a contentious issue in recent weeks. Tower Hamlets, run by the pro-Gaza party Aspire, said it would remove any St George's flags from council property, including lampposts, 'as soon as possible'. In Birmingham, the Labour-run council – which declared effective bankruptcy in 2023 and has been grappling with bin strikes for more than five months – claimed the flags put the lives of pedestrians and motorists 'at risk'. The authority removed hundreds of the flags from lamp-posts and other street furniture last week. Critics have accused the two councils of 'two-tier bias' because Palestinian flags were not taken down for months after popping up in the aftermath of the start of the Israel-Hamas war. An online 'patriotism campaign' called Operation Raise the Colours, encouraging people to hang patriotic flags across England, has gathered momentum online. The Government has previously issued guidance saying it wants ' more flags flown, particularly the Union flag', as long as they are erected with 'the permission of the owner of the site'.
The National
an hour ago
- The National
SNP must not act as bystanders in run-up to next year's election
James Murphy's piece on Saturday was scathingly critical: 'The reality is that Swinney's plan isn't designed to win independence. It's designed to preserve control of the issue inside the SNP. It's self-interest wearing a saltire.' READ MORE: Every plan to achieve indy must be subject to the test of practicality On the same day, I believe Selma Rahman spoke for many thousands of SNP voters when she said: 'I'm beginning to consider myself voting fodder for the SNP, the way Labour took so many of us for granted in the past.' She'd still vote SNP in 2026, 'but the grassroots/Yes movement and civic society need to come together, speaking out with the (very broad) independence movement.' John Swinney, widely admired for personal qualities, has become rather like a coach addressing his sweating team as they collapse on the benches at half-time of a home game down 0-6: 'There's still time. We've missed chances and conceded gift goals but our tactics are sound. Don't despair! There's still time, plenty of time...' READ MORE: Supreme Court's sex ruling 'rolls back progress for all women', SNP members say And there is still time; nine months until the Holyrood election, and nine months, as we all know, is a long time if you're expecting a delivery (though it's nearly always wonderfully worth the wait). But all John is promising to deliver, as we earnestly hope for a rebirth of our nation, is a prolonged extension of expectancy. So the SNP need to stand up and sharpen up, remember their genetic responsibility and join up with other parties and agencies together to declare in their manifestos a common resolve, given the authority of a majority of the sovereign people, to leave the 1707 Travesty of Union and at last take our rightful place at the table of the world's free and independent democracies. Let's see Holyrood 2026 as more than exciting; its potential is epic. John Melrose Peebles IT is certainly correct to say that a vote for independence in a plebiscite election will not sway Starmer. It is probably true to say that dangling him by the ankles from the Forth bridge will not make him accede to a second referendum (not that I'm suggesting we try that – it would probably pollute the water if he fell). Nothing in our lifetime will make Westminster pay anything other than lip service to the democratic right of the Scots to secede from this pseudo union, so it is time to stop wasting our efforts in trying. READ MORE: Holyrood 2026 is the first step in regaining our political mojo A plebiscite election, whilst it will definitely not persuade Starmer or any other 'elected' dictator to accept our rights, will convince the rest of the world that we are being held prisoner in this farcical facsimile of a democracy. We should have withdrawn our MPs from the palace of hypocrisy when we swept the board. No, it wasn't a democratic majority but under Westminster rules it was a victory. Remember a majority of votes in this 'democracy' never happens but the chancers soldier on regardless. We should have told the world that we were open for business then, and not waited for the electorate to be disheartened by failure. I once knew a retired civil engineer who said: 'I have built bridges, roads and dams in every former British colony and they all had one thing in common with Scotland. The Raj only left either when the fighting became too hot or there was eff all left to steal!' You will never get the thief to leave your house by asking nicely. This one is going to stay until there is eff all left to steal and, given their shortage of water and greed for electricity, that could take a very long time. They won't go until we throw them out, especially given the number of 'patriots' who would rather be serfs for a price than freemen for a fortune, so, whatever we do, begging for a referendum without making it obvious that denial is going to hurt, is not going to work! Les Hunter Lanark THERE are many in Scotland who, despite the prevailing fragmentation of the efforts of popular and party political movements to emancipate us from the current multi-faceted dystopia, retain the grace to be willing, if not able yet, to fully forgive Nicola Sturgeon entirely for wasted years and squandered momentum towards a more hopeful legacy for our children. There is no doubt that her attempts at a qualified apology for errors of strategic judgement, particularly in the distracting domain of gender recognition and the debilitating 'pacts' it necessitated, have made a good start in rehabilitating her posterity. READ MORE: Nicola Sturgeon is still as strong a voice as ever for those in need I suspect and hope it represents the understandable human tendency to 'own up' in instalments to more extensive and wide-ranging incompetence. In the case of Nicola et al, the acquiescing to long-term devolution and substandard governance latterly are more difficult to hold hands up to, in addition to matters of judicial/political boundaries being compromised. It is counterproductive in the long run to rehash the derelictions of fallible human beings. The epithet of 'humanum est errare' and to forgive divine is apposite and also an urgent matter in Scottish politics if the current parlous state of the NHS, public health, education and mental health and the devastating inequalities that stalk the land are to be meaningfully transformed in the coming decade in an independent Scotland. While I am suspicious of political auto justifications as per Robin McAlpine's article of August 16, I nonetheless provisionally salute Nicola's gesture and wish the remnant SNP party a full return to health and vigour after their period of malaise and lack of clear vision. Andrew Docherty Selkirk
ITV News
an hour ago
- ITV News
'It will be a betrayal': Ukrainians from the Donbas on losing their home in a peace deal
By ITV News Producer Michael Maitland-Jones "If we give up our territory, I think that it will be a disaster not only for Ukraine, but the whole world." Olexandra Suslova, a teacher from Donetsk has spoken to ITV News about the land concessions Ukraine may have to make for a potential peace agreement with Russia. Vladimir Putin is seeking full control over Ukraine's eastern regions of Donetsk and Luhansk, which are known together as the Donbas. Russia already controls almost all of the Luhansk region, but Ukraine is estimated to still hold onto around 30% of Donetsk. The area is of strategic importance to Ukraine, with strongly fortified cities like Sloviansk, Kramatorsk and Kostiantynivka acting as a barrier to Russian forces. Holding on to the area has cost thousands of Ukrainian lives, and giving it up could hand Russia the means to threaten other parts of Ukraine in the future. The view from the Donbas Olexandra left her home in Donetsk in 2019 and now lives in Kyiv - she is among the 1.5 million to have fled the Donbas since Russian aggression began in 2014. The idea of her home being handed to Russia is painful. "I think that we, as Ukrainians, are against it because we still remember how it was in 2014, and we see what it led to," she said. "I personally think that any decision cannot be made without our President and without our opinions. " She is also skeptical about whether the concession would lead to a lasting peace. "I think that for him (Putin), it's just a pause, just a break, to reinforce again, to build up troops and everything and to attack again. So I think that this is the most dangerous thing about it. You cannot give it a chance." In her mind, the only way for Russia to be able to live alongside Ukrainians would be with "really serious guarantees from our partners and from all of the countries who are involved in this war and who want to stop it. Only on these conditions ". "I think that there are a lot of people in occupied regions who are still waiting for Ukraine and they're waiting for their decisions to still be a part of Ukraine... I think that it will be such a betrayal just to neglect their feelings and their desires and their rights to be Ukrainians. " Maria Kolomiyets left Donetsk in 2014 when she was 10. Her memories of it are fond- including of her grandparents. Now, with much of the region under Russian occupation, she cannot visit their graves. "For me it is so hard to see Donetsk in Russian (control)... I remember normal Donetsk with smiling people... with big festivals.. with roses.. now I don't see roses, now I don't see anything like that". As for the possibility of handing the remains of Donetsk to Russia, she says that it would be a tough future for those who may be displaced. "When someone thinks that your home is not your home, you must go to another city. You don't have money. It's not cheap. I remember it's so difficult. You have some plan. But now your plan must be crushed. "
