
The poverty line has moved but have basic vulnerabilities in India eased?
According to recent World Bank data, extreme poverty in India fell sharply from 27.1% in 2011–12 to just 5.3% in 2022–23, suggesting that 269 million people have been lifted out of poverty. While this achievement is nominally and statistically significant, the finding prompts a deeper and more structural methodological question: Are we counting fewer people as 'poor' in India, or are we failing to capture the full spectrum of vulnerabilities that persist among people in relative poverty which discussions based on 'poverty line' measurement miss in scope and reality?
Historically, poverty measurement in India relied predominantly on income or consumption. This approach universally classifies individuals as poor or non-poor based solely on monetary criteria, offering a limited view of deprivation. In India, the Tendulkar Committee and later the Rangarajan Committee refined these poverty lines to reflect changing consumption patterns, but still focused primarily on income criteria. However, over the last two decades, the conceptualization of poverty, its measurement and assessment have all evolved significantly.
Also Read: Mint Quick Edit | Poverty isn't widespread but prosperity needs to be
Multidimensional frameworks, including the UNDP's Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI), highlight that poverty encompasses deficits in education, health and living standards.
Much of India's recent poverty discourse has centred on updated metrics, including the World Bank's shift from a poverty line of $2.15 to $3 per day and methodological refinements such as the adoption of thslum e 'modified mixed recall period' (MMRP) in consumption surveys. These changes, while noteworthy, underscore a deeper tension between statistical representation and lived deprivation. As critiques argue, estimates that rely on projected data, especially in the absence of post-pandemic ground surveys, risk portraying a linear trajectory of progress that may not fully account for access-based or structural vulnerabilities.
A victory, but for whom?: While incomes have risen, they have not translated into improved well-being when access to essential public goods such as healthcare, education, transportation and digital infrastructure remains unequal. For multitudes, these access gaps persist,
Uttar Pradesh (UP), Maharashtra, Bihar, West Bengal, and Madhya Pradesh, states that together made up 65% of India's extreme poor in 2011–12, account for two-thirds of India's overall reduction in extreme poverty.
Yet, our Access Inequality Index Report 2025, which ranks Indian states based on access to essentials across five pillars—basic amenities, healthcare, education, socio-economic services and legal recourse—reveals a more uneven picture. While West Bengal and Maharashtra show relatively better rankings as 'achiever' and 'front-runner' states, respectively, UP and Bihar remain in the 'aspirant' category.
This means that despite reductions in poverty as measured by consumption or income, the majority of households in these states continue to lack reliable access to vital public goods. For instance, only 19% of households in UP and 21.5% in Bihar have access to clean cooking fuel. Just 22.4% of households in Maharashtra and 33.7% in West Bengal have at least one member covered by a health insurance or finance scheme.
Also Read: Himanshu: India needs official poverty data for effective policymaking
States such as Kerala, Goa and Tamil Nadu consistently rank high in access to essential public services, with Goa leading overall and topping categories like basic amenities and healthcare. For example, 90% of households in Goa live in pucca houses, compared to 83.4% in Kerala and 87.9% in Tamil Nadu. Also, 91.9% of households in Goa have access to piped water supply within their dwelling or yard, while child immunization rates stand at 84.1% in Goa, 84.5% in Kerala and 85.7% in Tamil Nadu. In contrast, states such as Bihar, UP, Jharkhand and Chhattisgarh lag far behind.
These deprivations are critical to people's well-being and show that income thresholds alone are insufficient markers of progress. A household that marginally exceeds the poverty line but lacks clean water or reliable healthcare remains vulnerable. These forms of deprivation often remain invisible in conventional consumption data, yet they are pivotal in determining a household's ability to recover from shocks, invest in education or participate fully in economic life.
Alternative readings: An analysis of household income data by Azim Premji University's State of Working India 2021 highlights the unequal economic impact of the covid pandemic. The lowest 10 percentiles saw a steep 27% decline in income, compared to 23% among the 40th-50th percentiles and 22% among the top 10 percentiles. Income losses were more pronounced in urban areas. And although the setbacks may appear modest, the absolute income reduction for low-income households has been profound. This financial distress coincided with a sharp increase in non-monetary deprivations.
Also Read: India must redraw its poverty line to reflect economic progress
The Hunger Watch survey reported in 2022 that 80% of respondents experienced some form of food insecurity, with 25% suffering severe distress (like skipped meals and hunger); 41% observed a decline in the nutritional quality of their diets, and 67% were unable to afford cooking gas in the month preceding the survey. A Pew Research Centre report in 2022 also estimated that about 75 million additional people in India fell into poverty due to the pandemic.
The subsequent State of Working India 2023 study reaffirmed these patterns, documenting a 22% drop in cumulative household income from March to October 2020, with the poorest households disproportionately affected, driving a notable surge in poverty rates.
While welfare programmes such as the PM Awas Yojana, Ujjwala Yojana, Jan Dhan Yojana and Ayushman Bharat have expanded coverage, and direct benefit transfers have improved matters, challenges persist. Access to resources does not always translate to adequacy; owning a gas cylinder does not guarantee regular refills. Many essential services remain underfunded, unevenly implemented or inaccessible, particularly in rural and remote areas. All this makes access inequality the emerging face of poverty in India.
Ultimately, despite significant improvements in headline poverty metrics, a closer examination reveals a more complex reality. The persistence of access disparities, relative poverty and regional inequalities underscores the need for clarity on poverty today. We must pay attention to institutional capacity, political will and the equitable distribution of public goods.
The authors are, respectively, dean and research analyst, O.P. Jindal Global University.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
38 minutes ago
- Time of India
RCB to be sold after historic IPL 2025 win? Owner Diageo breaks silence
Image credit: BCCI/IPL Diageo India, the Indian branch of UK-based Diageo Plc and owner of the Royal Challengers Bengaluru (RCB) IPL franchise, has firmly rejected rumors of selling the team. In a letter addressed to the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE) and its Surveillance Department on Tuesday, June 10, a Diageo India representative stated that the media reports suggesting a potential sale are purely speculative. "The company would like to clarify that the aforesaid media reports are speculative in nature and it is not pursuing any such discussion," Mital Sanghvi, the company secretary, informed the regulating body of the Indian Stock Market. "This is for your information and records." Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel. SUBSCRIBE NOW! According to a Cricbuzz report, Diageo's statement was in response to a query from the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE), where the company is publicly listed. Since speculation about a possible sale of the RCB franchise began circulating, shares of United Spirits — the Diageo-owned company that holds RCB — have seen a notable uptick. On Tuesday, Bloomberg reported that Diageo is considering selling the RCB franchise. The report surfaced shortly after RCB's maiden IPL title win on June 3 — a milestone achieved after 17 years — followed tragically by an incident in Bengaluru on June 4, where celebrations turned fatal, leaving 11 dead and many injured. Virat Kohli's love for 'dhaba' food, priority for family & more | RCB bus driver shares stories Though Diageo officially dismissed the sale reports as "speculative," the ambiguity of their statement has sparked deeper speculation. A seasoned voice in India's sports business ecosystem suggested that 'being a public company, there will be a lot of pressure on reputational damage,' hinting that Diageo could be weighing its options more seriously than publicly admitted. There are also murmurs about Diageo valuing the RCB franchise at around USD 2 billion. While some industry insiders view that figure as inflated — especially when compared to Torrent's acquisition of Gujarat Titans at approximately INR 7500 crore (around USD 1 billion) — others disagree. Lalit Modi , the architect of the IPL, told Cricbuzz that a USD 2 billion valuation for RCB is quite realistic. 'A particularly special feeling': Andy Flower hails Virat Kohli, RCB after historic title win "I will not be surprised if it is sold for a higher price," he remarked, adding that comparing the RCB valuation to that of the newer Gujarat franchise isn't an apples-to-apples comparison. "I will not be surprised if it is sold for a higher price," he said , stating that the valuation of GT cannot be compared here since it was a one-year-old deal. The sale report remains speculative, as clarified by the Diageo official in the response to the BSE. "No decision is final and they may decide against selling the team, the people said, asking not to be named as the details are private," the Bloomberg report says.


Time of India
41 minutes ago
- Time of India
Tier-III cities drive 62% of new insurance premiums: Report
HighlightsA recent report from Probus, an InsurTech and insurance broking firm, reveals that Tier-III cities and smaller towns are now responsible for approximately 62 per cent of new insurance premiums in India for the current fiscal year. The motor insurance segment experienced significant growth of 25.6 per cent in fiscal year 2024-25, driven by increased awareness, digital access, and an expanded Point-of-Sale Person network. Fresh life insurance policies saw a growth exceeding 60 percent in fiscal year 2024-25 compared to the previous year, while Small and Medium Enterprise insurance emerged as the fastest-growing segment with 112 percent increase. A new report from Probus, an InsurTech and insurance broking firm, indicates that Tier-III cities and smaller towns are now significant contributors to India's new insurance business. The report states that these regions account for approximately 62 per cent of total new insurance premiums in the current fiscal year. This trend suggests a shift in how new insurance business is generated in India. Smaller towns, aided by digital payment infrastructure like UPI and increased internet access, are showing higher rates of digital adoption. Probus highlights that this is a consistent pattern, with the contribution from these regions rising from 58 per cent to 62 per cent over the past three fiscal years. For the fiscal year 2024-25, the motor insurance segment saw notable growth at 25.6 per cent. This was attributed to increased awareness, digital access, and an expanded Point-of-Sale Person (PoSP) network. The report also observes that local distribution methods, including app-based onboarding and regional language interfaces, have facilitated wider access to insurance products. What may have been a compliance-driven purchase is increasingly being viewed as a financial planning tool in these areas. Across insurance verticals, fresh life insurance policies showed growth exceeding 60 per cent in FY 2024-25 compared to FY 2023-24. Non-life insurance, encompassing motor, health, and SME segments, also experienced growth. SME insurance emerged as the fastest-growing segment in FY 2024-25, with a 112 per cent increase. Rakesh Goyal, director, Probus, commented on the findings, noting the resilience of the Indian economy and the role of Tier-II and Tier-III cities in this. He stated that Probus's approach aligns with the goal of 'Insuring India by 2047,' by providing digital tools and strengthening PoSP models to offer insurance solutions to consumers in these emerging markets.


Business Standard
44 minutes ago
- Business Standard
DAEWOO India appoints EBG group as Strategic Partner for Home Appliances and Electronics Retail Expansion
EBG Group has partnered with DAEWOO a globally recognized Korean brand to exclusively extend their premium home appliances, electronics, and consumer goods to Indian market. This strategic alliance combines DAEWOO's cutting-edge technology and innovation with EBG's extensive marketing expertise and distribution networks. The association aims to disrupt India's home appliance and electronics retail by introducing high-quality, energy-efficient, and sustainable solutions tailored to modern Indian consumers. DAEWOO brings decades of technological innovation and high manufacturing standards, while EBG Group's deep understanding of Indian consumer preferences and retail operations positions it to successfully introduce and expand DAEWOO's products in India. According to Dr. Irfan Khan, Founder and CEO of EBG Group, 'the partnership aligns with EBG's long-term strategy to strengthen its market footprint, bringing premium appliances that meet the increasing demand for energy-efficient solutions. EBG Group will lead the retail and distribution expansion for DAEWOO Consumer Products across India, ensuring seamless access to products through a robust retail network and strong after-sales support. The focus is on creating a hassle-free shopping experience while providing consumers with reliable service infrastructure nationwide'. 'The partnership will introduce a range of high-performance, stylish and energy-efficient home appliances, including whole range of Home & Kitchen appliances as well as Smart home solutions, Mr. H. S. Bhatia, Managing Director, DAEWOO India said. With IoT-enabled devices and advanced energy-saving features, DAEWOO's products are designed to meet the needs of India's growing tech-savvy consumer base, who seek innovation, convenience, and sustainability. By combining technological advancements with deep market insights, both companies aim to bring premium, affordable, and high-tech solutions to Indian households, setting the stage for the next evolution in consumer electronics. 'EBG plans to create business opportunities for Indian entrepreneurs through an innovative franchise model. This initiative is expected to further strengthen DAEWOO's retail presence and empower local partners, with details to be announced soon', Mr. Hari Kiran, COO and Co-Founder of EBG Group said. 'We are excited to collaborate with Daewoo in bringing innovative, high-quality home appliances and electronics to India'. With DAEWOO brand EBG aim to develop a holistic ecosystem that enhances customer experience through reliable service, easy accessibility, and a nationwide after-sales network. About DAEWOO India DAEWOO is a global leader in the design and manufacturing of home appliances, electronics, and consumer goods. Known for its cutting-edge technology and commitment to quality, DAEWOO products are trusted by consumers around the world with presence in more than 70 countries. DAEWOO brand operates in India through their manufacturing and marketing partner M/s. Kelwon Electronics & Appliances Pvt. Ltd. With a focus on innovation and sustainability, DAEWOO continues to lead the way in creating products that make life easier, more comfortable, and more sustainable. About EBG Group EBG Group is a premier name in the Indian market, known for launching and managing premium tech and lifestyle brands. With an in-depth understanding of Indian consumer behaviour and a strong retail presence, EBG has built a reputation for providing innovative solutions and excellent customer experiences. Through this strategic partnership with DAEWOO, EBG aims to redefine the home appliances and electronics market in India.