Indonesian governor's vasectomy-for-welfare proposal sparks intense debate
West Java Governor Dedi Mulyadi reportedly suggested sterilisation in exchange for access to social welfare, electricity connections, food aid, scholarships and public housing.
In an April 28 speech, Dedi questioned why poor families often have many children, saying, 'Stop having children if you can't provide for them well,' the SCMP reported.
'I don't know why poor families generally have many children, while rich people have difficulty having children, even after paying two billion rupiah (RM517,900) for IVF,' he was quoted as saying.
Religious leaders swiftly condemned the idea, with Cholil Nafis of the Indonesian Ulema Council reportedly saying Islam forbids permanent sterilisation and that poverty should be addressed through employment opportunities.
Indonesia's Social Minister Saifullah Yusuf also rejected the proposal, calling it 'not relevant' and impractical, according to the report.
Rights advocates and academics reportedly described the plan as coercive and discriminatory, with Singapore-based scholar Sulfikar Amir calling it a 'blatant form of body politics' and warning that it wrongly assumes poverty results from large families rather than structural economic inequality.
Public reactions online were mixed, with some supporting the proposal and others labelling it 'fascist,' the SCMP noted.
The debate comes amid new World Bank data showing that 60.3 per cent of Indonesians — or roughly 171 million people — live below the updated poverty threshold of US$6.85 (RM29.23) per person per day.
This figure contrasts sharply with Indonesia's official poverty rate of 8.57 per cent, based on older national standards.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malay Mail
a day ago
- Malay Mail
Anwar urges Asean unity on Myanmar crisis, pledges support for Bangladesh
PUTRAJAYA, Aug 11 — Securing peace in Myanmar and addressing the refugee crisis are among Malaysia's priorities, particularly in supporting Bangladesh, which has been burdened with hosting large numbers of displaced persons, said Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim. He stressed that immediate humanitarian assistance must be extended to refugees and victims of natural disasters, such as earthquakes, while ensuring that efforts to resolve the crisis in Myanmar remain a priority in regional cooperation. 'I commend the Bangladeshi authorities for taking the initiative in multilateral forums in New York, Qatar and here in Malaysia. 'Our Foreign Minister (Datuk Seri Mohamad Hasan) will coordinate a team with Indonesia, the Philippines and Thailand to visit Myanmar in the next few weeks to ensure that peace is attained and that atrocities against some ethnic minorities and the people of Myanmar can be amicably resolved.' Anwar said this during a press conference in conjunction with the three-day official visit of the Chief Adviser of the Government of Bangladesh, Prof Dr Muhammad Yunus, to Malaysia from August 11 to 13. — Bernama
Free Malaysia Today
5 days ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Indonesia cracks down on pirate protest flag
A Jolly Roger skull and bones symbol topped with a straw hat from Japan's anime series 'One Piece' has caused concern among officials in Jakarta. (AFP pic) JAKARTA : Indonesia is cracking down on a viral pirate flag that is spreading as a symbol of political protest ahead of independence day. The Jolly Roger skull and bones with a straw hat – from Japanese anime series 'One Piece' – has been fluttering from a rising number of trucks, cars and homes. Officials warn the 'provocation' – seen by many as a protest against President Prabowo Subianto's policies – should not fly alongside the country's red-and-white flag. The pirate banner was taken up by disgruntled truck drivers earlier this summer, but has recently snowballed into an online and real-life movement. 'I personally raised the One Piece flag because the red and white flag is too sacred to be raised in this corrupt country,' Khariq Anhar, a 24-year-old university student in Sumatra's Riau province, told AFP. 'I believe freedom of speech in Indonesia exists, but it is very limited. 'Voicing your opinion is getting more dangerous,' he said. Government officials say the flag's use is an attempt to divide the nation. They warn it may be banned from flying next to Indonesia's colours, or being raised on Aug 17 – the 80th independence anniversary after Japan's surrender at the end of World War II. 'It is imperative we refrain from creating provocation with symbols that are not relevant to this country's struggle,' chief security minister Budi Gunawan said in a statement last week. Ministers have cited a law that prohibits flying a symbol higher than the national flag as the basis for any punishment. Under that law, intent to desecrate, insult or degrade the flag carries a maximum prison sentence of five years or a fine of nearly US$31,000. State secretary minister Prasetyo Hadi on Tuesday said Prabowo had no issue with the 'expression of creativity', but the two flags 'should not be placed side by side in a way that invites comparison,' local media reported. 'Just a cartoon' A presidency spokesman did not respond to an AFP question about its position on the pirate flag, which was put two days earlier. Experts say unhappy Indonesians are using the flag as a way to express anti-government feeling indirectly, with some of Prabowo's economic and defence policies causing concern about democratic backsliding. 'Symbols like the pirate flag let people channel frustration without spelling it out,' said Dedi Dinarto, lead Indonesia analyst at advisory firm Global Counsel. 'It reflects a public sentiment that parts of the country have been 'hijacked',' Dinarto said. Others, like food seller Andri Saputra, who has flown the pirate ensign below an Indonesian flag at his home for a week, say they want to be able to decide what symbols they display. 'I want to be free to express my opinion and express myself,' the 38-year-old said in Boyolali regency in Central Java. 'This is just a cartoon flag from Japan,' Saputra said. Online culture has been a popular channel for Indonesian dissatisfaction against perceived government corruption and nepotism. Japanese anime is popular in Indonesia, and in the best-selling 'One Piece' manga series created in 1997, the flag represents opposition to an authoritarian world government. In February, protests known as 'Dark Indonesia' began against Prabowo's widespread budget cuts, sparked by a logo posted on social media showing a black Indonesian mythical Garuda bird alongside the words 'Emergency Warning'. Other rallies in 2016 and 2019 were also sparked online, and Dedi says the government may be worried that 'this follows the same digital playbook'. There is also a generational divide, with older locals viewing the Indonesian flag as hard-won after centuries of colonial rule, while younger Indonesians see the new movement as an expression of disappointment. Police raid 'They just want Indonesia to get better, but… they can only express it through the 'One Piece' flag,' said Ismail Fahmi, founder of Indonesian social media monitor Drone Emprit. Police in Banten Province neighbouring capital Jakarta and West Java Province, Indonesia's most populous, have threatened action if the flag is flown next to the nation's colours. One printing business owner in Central Java told AFP on condition of anonymity that his facility was raided by plain-clothes police on Wednesday evening to halt its production of the pirate emblem. Rights groups have called the response excessive and say Indonesians are allowed to wave the flag by law. 'Raising the 'One Piece' flag as a critic is a part of the freedom of speech and it is guaranteed by the constitution,' said Amnesty International Indonesia executive director Usman Hamid. Despite the government's threats, some young Indonesians are still willing to risk walking the plank of protest. 'Last night my friend and I went around the town while raising a One Piece flag,' said Khariq on Wednesday. 'If the government has no fear of repressing its own people, we shouldn't be scared to fight bad policies.'
Free Malaysia Today
6 days ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Indonesia readies island medical facility for 2,000 wounded Gazans
Israel's offensive in Gaza has killed more than 60,000 Palestinians. (AP pic) JAKARTA : Indonesia will convert a medical facility on its currently uninhabited island of Galang to treat about 2,000 wounded residents of Gaza, who will return home after recovery, a presidential spokesman said today. Muslim-majority Indonesia has sent humanitarian aid to Gaza after Israel started an offensive in October 2023 that Gaza health officials say has killed more than 60,000 Palestinians, whether fighters or non-combatants. 'Indonesia will give medical help for about 2,000 Gaza residents who became victims of war, those who are wounded, buried under debris,' the spokesman, Hasan Nasbi, told reporters, adding that the exercise was not an evacuation. Indonesia plans to allocate the facility on Galang island, off its island of Sumatra and south of Singapore, to treat wounded Gaza residents and temporarily shelter their families, he said, adding that nobody lived around it now. The patients would be taken back to Gaza after they had healed, he said. Hasan did not give a timeframe or further details, referring questions to Indonesia's foreign and defence ministries, which did not immediately respond to Reuters' requests for comment. The plan comes months after president Prabowo Subianto's offer to shelter wounded Palestinians drew criticism from Indonesia's top clerics for seeming too close to US President Donald Trump's suggestion of permanently moving Palestinians out of Gaza. In response to Trump's suggestion, the foreign ministry of Indonesia, which backs a two-state solution to resolve the Middle East crisis, said at the time it 'strongly rejects any attempt to forcibly displace Palestinians'. A hospital to treat victims of the Covid-19 pandemic opened in 2020 on Galang, which had been until 1996 a sprawling refugee camp run by the United Nations, housing 250,000 of those who fled the Vietnam War.
