Ten Commandments in Every Classroom: Texas Bill Nearing Law
This article was originally published in The Texas Tribune.
Come September, every public school classroom in Texas could be required to display the Ten Commandments under a requirement that passed the Texas legislature Wednesday — part of a larger push in Texas and beyond to increase the role of religion in schools.
Senate Bill 10 passed the Senate 28-3, despite a federal court ruling that a similar Louisiana law violated a constitutionally required separation of church and state.
Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter
The bill preliminarily passed the House 88-49 on Saturday — the Jewish Sabbath day. The Ten Commandments forbids work on that day, Rep. James Talarico noted in an effort to highlight legislative hypocrisy. The lower chamber's initial approval came after more than two hours of debate and despite last-ditch Democratic efforts to water down the law, including giving school districts the opportunity to vote on the policy, and adding codes of ethics from different faiths into the bill.
On Sunday, the House passed the bill 82-46, but clarified in it that the state would be responsible for any legal fees if a school district were to be sued over the policy. The bill now goes to Gov. Greg Abbott, who is expected to sign it.
Sponsored by Sen. Phil King, a Republican from Weatherford, the bill requires every classroom to visibly display a poster sized at least 16 by 20 inches. The poster can't include any text other than the language laid out in the bill, and no other similar posters may be displayed.
'It is incumbent on all of us to follow God's law and I think we would all be better off if we did,' Rep. Candy Noble, a Republican from Lucas who is carrying the bill in the House, said during the floor debate Saturday.
Supporters argue that the Ten Commandments and teachings of Christianity more generally are core to U.S. history, a message that has resurged in recent years as part of a broader national movement that considers the idea of church-state separation a myth.
That movement fueled Texas' push to require schools display 'In God We Trust' signs if they were donated by a private foundation — signed into law in 2021. In 2024, the State Board of Education approved Bible-infused teaching materials.
This session, lawmakers have advanced bills that allow a prayer or religious study period in school, and one that would require teachers to use the terms 'Anno Domini' (AD) — Latin for 'in the year of the Lord,' and 'Before Christ' (BC) when expressing dates.
Proponents of King's bill also say making the Ten Commandments more prominent in schools will combat what movement leaders see as a generations-long moral decline.
Texas is one of 16 states where lawmakers have pursued the Ten Commandments bills.
Although the Supreme Court ruled against a similar Kentucky law in 1980, supporters in Texas and beyond find support in the current makeup of the court's justices and in the 2019 Supreme Court decision in Kennedy v. Bremerton School District, which found a football coach could lead prayers on the field after games.
But Robert Tuttle, a professor of religion and law at George Washington University, said allowing a private individual to pray — as in the Kennedy case — is different from displaying the Ten Commandments in the classroom.
Last June, a federal court struck down a Louisiana law requiring all public school classrooms display the Ten Commandments — the first state this decade to pass such a law. The state is appealing the decision.
'The constant presence of a sacred text in the room with them is effectively telling them, 'Hey, these are things you should read and obey,'' Tuttle said. 'That's not the state's job — to do religious instruction.'
He also said that despite the Supreme Court trending in a more conservative direction, its decision Thursday that leaves in place a prohibition on the establishment of a religious charter school in Oklahoma could mean that the Court, for now, is not throwing out that principle.
During Texas legislative committee hearings, opponents from free speech and civil rights groups — some of whom waited till 4 a.m. to testify — said the policy could send a message of exclusion to students of other faiths or those who don't practice a religion. They also said the commandments were irrelevant to classes like math, and could prompt questions that were not age-appropriate, such as what adultery means.
The teachers union said it opposes the bill because members believe it violates the principle of separation of church and state.
'Public schools are not supposed to be Sunday school,' said spokesperson Clay Robison.
Talarico — who is studying to become a minister — raised concerns in House floor discussions Wednesday that the First Amendment forbids imposing a state-sponsored religion.
'My faith means more to me than anything, but I don't believe the government should be forcing religion onto any American citizen, especially our children,' the Austin lawmaker told the Tribune. 'I'm a Christian who firmly believes in the separation of church and state.'
This article originally appeared in The Texas Tribune at https://www.texastribune.org/2025/05/24/ten-commandments-texas-schools-senate-bill-10/. The Texas Tribune is a member-supported, nonpartisan newsroom informing and engaging Texans on state politics and policy. Learn more at texastribune.org.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
29 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Jamie Dimon says ‘don't put a good foot forward, put the truth forward' and reveals what would get him into public service
CEO Jamie Dimon was asked about leadership lessons at the end of a wide-ranging interview during the Reagan National Economic Forum on Friday. He talked about getting out, listening to people, observing, providing honest assessments, and having humility. He also explained what would lure him from the private sector to the public sector. Wall Street's longest-tenured CEO said it's better to give an honest assessment than to make the boss feel good. At the end of a wide-ranging interview during the Reagan National Economic Forum on Friday, CNBC's Morgan Brennan asked JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon about leadership lessons. The first thing he said was, 'get out, get out, get out, get out, talk to people, talk to clients. I talk to everybody.' Noting that President Dwight Eisenhower, a Republican, regularly met with Democratic leaders, Dimon also discussed the importance of hearing opposing views as well as listening to complaints and learning about rivals. 'Observe, observe, observe, and have all your people do it,' he added. 'And it's a never-ending process. Because we have competitors from around the world, and they're smart, and they're tough, and they're coming.' Then he turned to what makes companies that were once pace-setters in their respective industries fail. Dimon pointed to arrogance, greed, complacency, and bureaucracy. Companies can 'bull—t' themselves about how they're earning money and why, while executives may feel pressure to make the boss feel good and avoid embarrassing someone, he explained. 'When people say to me, put a good foot forward, I always say, don't put a good foot forward, put the truth forward, 100% the truth,' Dimon said. 'Tell us, and we will deal with it. It's OK. So a deep, honest assessment.' He also put humility and curiosity on the list of traits leaders should have, saying 'people don't want to work for jerks' and don't want to work for bosses who blame others. Meanwhile, CEO succession at the world's biggest bank by market cap has been an ongoing parlor game on Wall Street, and Dimon recently reaffirmed that he is stepping down sometime in the next two to four years. But at the still relatively young age of 69, there has been widespread speculation that he might have a second act in the government, either in elected office or an appointed role. Earlier this year, he even admitted that he considered running for president of the United States, but decided against it because didn't want to spend so much time away from his family. And while running for re-election last summer, Donald Trump suggested he might consider Dimon for Treasury secretary, though he later ruled him out. On Friday, Dimon was asked what it would take for him to enter public service. His answer hinted at some humility. 'Alright, ready? I'll tell you: if I thought I could really win, which I don't think I could,' he said. This story was originally featured on Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
Stringer pushes plan 'predict and prevent' antisemitic attacks
Former NYC Comptroller Scott Stringer insists he'll crack down on antisemitism if elected mayor by using tech to help authorities 'predict and prevent' biased attacks before they happen. The longshot mayoral candidate rolled out his plans Saturday to partner with the Anti-Defamation League on the initiative while addressing members of the Congregation Kehilath Jeshurun synagogue on Manhattan's Upper East Side. 'My new initiative would use advanced monitoring tools to scour social media posts following during or after international emergencies,' — especially those involving Israel or Jewish institutions,' claimed Stringer, a devout Jew and vocal Zionist. Advertisement 4 Former NYC Comptroller Scott Stringer is planning to partner with the Anti-Defamation League on an initiative — if elected mayor — that he claims will help authorities crack down on antisemitism by using tech to 'predict and prevent' biased attacks before they happen. Paul Martinka 'It would flag content that incites violence or signals coordinated threats. It would provide the tools for law enforcement, community leaders, and institutions like this one to act before tragedy strikes.' Stringer, soon heading into the June 24 Democratic primary, insisted his initiative — which would be overseen by the NYPD and Office of Emergency Management — is 'not about surveillance of [dissenting] opinions, or about setting up databases or lists of people who don't agree with us.' Advertisement 'It is about surfacing potential danger before it becomes real violence,' he pointed out. 4 Stringer revealed his plan to tackle anti-Israel hate Saturday at the Congregation Kehilath Jeshurun synagogue on Manhattan's Upper East Side. 7.8.96 The ADL oversees what it boasts is a 'first-of-its kind interactive and customizable map' that helps users detail 'specific incidents of hate, extremism, antisemitism and terrorism by state and nationwide.' The 'H.E.A.T Map' allows users to better understand 'tactics extremists use, compare activity by type and/or state and access and download raw data,' according to the ADL. Advertisement Although Jewish New Yorkers make up about 10% of the city's population, they were the target of over 62% of total hate crimes in the first quarter of 2025. 4 New York University students and pro-Israeli supporters rally in April 2024 across the street from where pro-Palestinian students and supporters rally outside the NYU Stern School of Business building. AP 4 Stringer insisted his initiative — which would be overseen by the NYPD and Office of Emergency Management — is 'not about surveillance of [dissenting] opinions, or about setting up databases or lists of people who don't agree with us.' Robert Miller 'The pattern, by now, is painfully familiar,' added Stringer. Advertisement 'Major incidents in and around Israel set off a torrent of online hatred,' he said, referring to Hamas' October 7, 2023 terror attack on Israel that set off the ongoing war in Gaza. 'Jewish schools, synagogues, and cultural centers face waves of threats. Our families – whether it's young children at school or elders walking in or out of shul, are in the crosshairs. 'The hate might start online, but it doesn't stay there,' he said.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Texas Legislature approves $338 billion two-year spending plan with a focus on property tax relief
Texas lawmakers signed off Saturday on a $338 billion two-year spending plan that directs billions toward hiking teacher pay, cutting property taxes and shoring up the state's water infrastructure, after House and Senate budget writers ironed out their differences and won approval from both chambers on their final draft. The budget now heads to Comptroller Glenn Hegar, who is expected to verify there is enough revenue to cover the Legislature's planned spending — the last step before the 1,056-page bill reaches Gov. Greg Abbott's desk. The spending plan doles out the money to run the state's business for the next two years, from September through the end of August 2027. It includes the underlying funding for some of the biggest bills passed this session, much of it paid for with general revenue, Texas' main source of taxpayer funds used to cover core services. Lawmakers approved $149 billion in general revenue spending, with the rest drawn from federal funds and other state revenue earmarked for specific uses. The budget's $338 billion price tag is nearly $17 billion more than what lawmakers budgeted two years ago, about a 5% increase. However, the Legislature is expected to approve additional spending for the current cycle — which runs through the end of August — in what is known as the supplemental budget, lessening the year-to-year increase. A large chunk of the budget — more than one out of every seven dollars — is devoted to maintaining and providing new property tax cuts, a tab that has grown to $51 billion. For the last several years, lawmakers have tried to rein in Texans' property tax bills by sending billions of dollars to school districts to reduce how much in property taxes they collect from homeowners and businesses. The state does not collect property taxes; its coffers are filled through a combination of sources that include sales tax, taxes on oil and gas production, and franchise taxes on businesses. With the help of a projected $24 billion budget surplus, the Legislature is spending some $45 billion to maintain existing cuts lawmakers have enacted since 2019, with the rest going toward a mix of 'compression' — sending money to school districts to replace funds they otherwise would have collected in property taxes, thus lowering tax rates — and raising the state's homestead exemption, or the amount of a home's value that can't be taxed to pay for public schools. A chunk of the money will also go toward tax cuts for businesses. About $3 billion of the property tax relief will come from money lawmakers had originally planned to spend on border security. The team of five senators and five House members who hammered out the final budget draft diverted nearly half of the $6.5 billion set aside for the state's border clampdown in earlier versions, marking one of the biggest eleventh-hour budget changes. It was a reflection of a monthslong decrease in illegal border crossings and the billions that could be coming to Texas under a tentative federal plan to reimburse states for their immigration enforcement efforts under the Biden administration. Sen. Joan Huffman, a Houston Republican who chairs the Senate Finance Committee, said the spending plan is a 'responsible, balanced budget that falls within all constitutional and statutory spending limits and meets the needs of our rapidly growing state.' 'The Texas economy is the envy of the nation, and the budget will secure our state's prosperity for generations to come,' Huffman, the Senate's lead budget writer, said on the floor Saturday. 'We have leveraged our state surplus over several sessions to make targeted, one-time investments without burdening future budgets.' Rep. Greg Bonnen, R-Friendswood and Huffman's counterpart in the House, said the budget 'prioritizes public education, tax relief, public safety, infrastructure and improving taxpayer services for individuals and businesses.' The House and Senate have been largely aligned on budget matters this session. Each chamber approved plans earlier this year that spent similar amounts overall and lined up on big-ticket items including how much money to put toward school vouchers, property tax cuts and water infrastructure. Much of the fine print — outlining how that money would be used — was worked out in separate bills. Among the marquee items is an $8.5 billion boost for Texas' public schools, the product of weeks of negotiations between the chambers. The funding package, known as House Bill 2, provides extra money for teacher and staff pay raises, educator preparation, special education, safety requirements and early childhood learning. Another $1 billion in the budget is set aside for a school voucher program that will allow families to use public money to fund their children's private school tuition or pay for a range of school-related expenses. Abbott has already signed the voucher bill into law and has said he will approve the school funding bill. 'We passed historic policies for the nearly 6 million students across Texas, but this is where we bring those policies to life,' Sen. Brandon Creighton, R-Conroe and chair of the Senate Education Committee, said of the state budget, known as Senate Bill 1. 'Without SB 1, those reforms are just words on paper. This budget turns our promises into action and gives lasting weight to our priorities.' Shannon Halbrook, a fiscal policy expert at the left-leaning think tank Every Texan, said the budget contains 'some things that we consider wins with an asterisk.' 'We're definitely happy that they're investing more into public education,' Halbrook said. 'It's not quite the way we would have preferred for them to do it. For example, we've consistently advocated for increasing the basic allotment, because it's a really simple way to provide additional funding for schools across the board. Instead, HB 2 chooses to kind of do it in a much more complicated, convoluted way.' More than 70% of the budget is reserved for education and health and human services, the latter of which includes Medicaid and the Children's Health Insurance Program, which provides health coverage for children from low-income households that make too much to qualify for Medicaid. One lingering uncertainty was how much the state would hike pay for personal care 'community attendants,' who are paid through the Medicaid program to help patients with tasks such as laundry, errands, grooming, eating and medication. The House had proposed increasing their base wage to more than $14 an hour, nearly $2 more than the Senate's proposal. Sen. Lois Kolkhorst, a Brenham Republican and the chamber's lead health care budget writer, said the issue amounted to 'one of the most contentious parts' of her section of the budget. In the end, the chambers agreed to meet in the middle, spending nearly $1 billion in general revenue to hike the attendants' base pay to $13 an hour. Rep. Donna Howard, D-Austin, said the attendants fulfill a critical function caring for vulnerable Texans, and even with the pay raises, 'we have not gotten anywhere near where we need to be.' But, she acknowledged, 'we did get something.' 'This is the Legislature's budget. It doesn't have everything in it we want,' said Howard, a longtime member of the House Appropriations Committee. 'That's the whole point of why we're here. It's a compromise with the Senate … And any compromise doesn't include everything we fought for in the House.' The budget also puts some $10 billion toward the state's energy, water and broadband infrastructure. That includes $5 billion to double the Texas Energy Fund, a low-interest taxpayer-funded loan program meant to incentivize the development of gas-fueled power plants. Lawmakers are also putting $2.5 billion into the Texas Water Fund as part of the supplemental budget for the current spending cycle. The fund is used to pay for new water supply projects — such as desalination — repairing old water infrastructure, conservation and flood mitigation projects. In November, voters will be asked to approve a proposal to allot $1 billion a year starting in 2027— $20 billion in total — until 2047 to secure the state's water supply. Disclosure: Every Texan has been a financial supporter of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan news organization that is funded in part by donations from members, foundations and corporate sponsors. Financial supporters play no role in the Tribune's journalism. Find a complete list of them here. First round of TribFest speakers announced! Pulitzer Prize-winning columnist Maureen Dowd; U.S. Rep. Tony Gonzales, R-San Antonio; Fort Worth Mayor Mattie Parker; U.S. Sen. Adam Schiff, D-California; and U.S. Rep. Jasmine Crockett, D-Dallas are taking the stage Nov. 13–15 in Austin. Get your tickets today!
