Hershey, Nestle, other cocoa companies defeat appeal of child slavery lawsuit
In a 3-0 decision, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit found no causal connection between the plaintiffs' forced labor and the defendants' alleged venture to obtain "cheap cocoa harvested by enslaved children."
The plaintiffs said they were required to live in squalor and threatened with starvation if they did not work, after being approached by unfamiliar men who falsely promised paying jobs.
They sued under a federal law protecting children and other victims of human trafficking and forced labor.
Circuit Judge Justin Walker, however, said the plaintiffs alleged at most they worked in areas that supplied cocoa to the defendants, which buy an estimated 70% of Ivorian cocoa, rather than specific farms that supplied the cocoa.
"Is there a 'possibility' that at least some of the importers sourced cocoa from those farms? Yes," Walker wrote. "But is it 'plausible'? Not on this complaint."
Other defendants included privately-held Cargill, privately-held Mars, Mondelez International (MDLZ.O), opens new tab, Barry Callebaut (BARN.S), opens new tab and Olam International.
Mali and the Ivory Coast share a border in West Africa. A trial judge ruled for the defendants in June 2022.
Terry Collingsworth, a lawyer representing the plaintiffs, said his clients were "extremely disappointed" and considering their legal options.
"The court rewarded the chocolate multinational defendants ... for concealing their cocoa supply chains, such that former child slaves are unable to link a specific company to the Cote d'Ivoire (Ivory Coast) farms where they were enslaved," he said.
In March 2024, the same court dismissed a similar lawsuit seeking to hold five major technology companies including Apple (AAPL.O), opens new tab and Tesla (TSLA.O), opens new tab liable for child labor in cobalt mining in the Democratic Republic of the Congo.
Collingsworth represented the plaintiffs in the cobalt case.
The case is Coubaly et al v Cargill Inc et al, D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 22-7104.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
7 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Human trafficking suspect filmed 'assaulting' HIMSELF behind bars to evade justice...but stunt backfired badly
A human trafficking suspect was caught on camera slamming himself into a glass wall in his jail cell before he was hospitalized with a brain injury. Randolph Lewis, 33, was arrested at a Michigan hotel as part of a multi-state human trafficking investigation, police said. The Texas resident is allegedly connected to at least 10 victims. Police believe he injured himself after his arrest in order to blame the officers and delay his case, as reported by Click on Detroit. However, officials said Lewis will be taken back to Oakland County jail as soon as he recovers from his injuries, which were said to be 'significant.' Video from inside the jail cell shows Lewis repeatedly hitting his head against the glass wall until he falls back on the floor. Officers arrived at the hotel in the Detroit suburb of Southfield on Monday after they received a report of destruction of property. A Louisiana woman, 21, called police and said Lewis broke her windshield after she brought him the wrong food. The woman added that Lewis had rented multiple rooms and she did not even know she was in Michigan. She also said she and other women were forced to have sex with Lewis and other men across several states. The woman's services were being advertised online, police said on Thursday. Police found sex toys, lubricant and condoms inside the hotel rooms, according to court documents. 'These victims are in a place where they don't know where they are, they don't have a home, they have nothing in their lives to give them support and their basic needs, except this trafficker,' Oakland County Prosecutor Karen McDonald said. Southfield Police Chief Elvin V. Barren said some victims as young as 17 were coerced and threatened into sex-trafficking. Barren added that Lewis 'panicked on the video because he understands the seriousness of this offense, and then wants to injure himself to delay or keep himself in a hospital room and not go to prison. 'And then ultimately, like I said, I guarantee you had I not shown this video, he would say that the Southfield Police Department injured him. So, again, I did him a favor.' Lewis was charged with running a human trafficking enterprise resulting in injury, prostitution, accepting earnings, using computers to commit a crime, two counts of criminal sexual conduct and assault with intent to commit sexual penetration. He was granted a $300,000 cash bond and would have to wear a GPS tracker if released. The alleged human trafficker is scheduled to appear in court on August 4.
Reuters
a day ago
- Reuters
Brazil's biggest conilon coffee cooperative to launch cocoa pilot project in Bahia state
SAO PAULO, July 24 (Reuters) - Brazil's biggest conilon coffee cooperative, Cooabriel, is launching a cocoa pilot project in the country's Bahia state slated for September in collaboration with commodities powerhouse Cargill, it said in an interview this week. Cooabriel hopes the pilot, located in the south of Bahia, will produce around 10,000 60-kilogram bags of cocoa beans, working with farmers who are already producing conilon coffee, part of the same family as Robusta beans. The pilot project is another example of efforts in Brazil, once the world's second-biggest cocoa producer, to rebuild the country's standing in the global industry after its output was devastated by disease in the 1980s. "It's still somewhat of a timid project, but it is a promising project," Cooabriel's President Luiz Carlos Bastianello told Reuters in an interview. The majority of Cooabriel's coffee producers in Bahia are already producing cocoa and the cooperative wants to help them boost their productivity, while also possibly picking up some new farmers along the way, Bastianello said. Cargill is supporting the pilot project, which is financed by Cooabriel, as part of its aim to see major chocolate consumer Brazil become self-sufficient in cocoa production, Cargill's director of cocoa origination, Murilo da Silva Severo, said in an email. "This partnership with Cooabriel has the potential to bring Cargill an annual increase of 1,500 (metric) tons of beans," Severo said, adding the quantity could increase and Cargill has already suggested Cooabriel take the project to the neighboring state of Espirito Santo. Though similarities exist between conilon coffee farming and cocoa production, Cooabriel will have to contend with some challenges around market volatility and storing the cocoa beans, the cooperative's manager of new businesses, Alexandre Costa Ferreira, said. "If we work on this correctly, we have everything we need to gain a lot of volume, a lot of scale, and put Brazil on a different level," Ferreira said.
Leader Live
a day ago
- Leader Live
Nestle sees lower customer demand after hiking coffee and chocolate prices
The KitKat and Nescafe maker revealed that sales growth was almost entirely driven by higher pricing, as it passed inflation in its supply chain on to customers. The Swiss consumer group reported organic growth of 2.9% over the first half of the year, compared with a year earlier. It said this was driven by a 2.7% increase in pricing, while it saw real internal growth of 0.2%. This included a 3.3% increase in prices in the second quarter as sales volumes declined marginally amid pressure on customer finances. The company said this came as it 'took actions to address input cost inflation in coffee and cocoa-related categories'. Confectionery prices increased by 10.6% over the half-year, while coffee prices rose by 6%. Sales volumes were only marginally higher over the quarter as Nestle reported 'lower consumer demand' as shoppers were 'adjusting to price increases'. It came as Nestle also announced a review into the future of the vitamins business its previous boss bought in 2021. The company has indicated it could sell off its mainstream vitamins and supplements division, which includes the Nature's Bounty and Puritan's Pride brands. Laurent Freixe, Nestle chief executive, said: 'We are executing our strategy to accelerate performance and transform for the future. 'We are accelerating our category growth and improving our market share, through better execution and increased investment, funded through a relentless pursuit of efficiency. 'These actions are already delivering results, with broad-based growth and a robust profit performance in the first half.'
