Karen Read judge cuts off witness who sends 'happy birthday' wish to 10-year-old from stand
"So I was going to say I have three kids, a 9-year-old who's actually turning 10 today – happy birthday Kai – and I have two older ones," said Dr. Andrew John Rentschler, a biomechanical engineer and accident reconstructionist from a firm called ARCCA.
"All right, I'm going to, we're going to stop this – [use] another example," said Judge Beverly Cannone after an objection from special prosecutor Hank Brennan.
Brennan has repeatedly tried to have Rentschler's testimony blocked or limited. The ARCCA scientists dispute the state's version of events – and have also been accused of destroying text messages with the defense they were ordered to give to prosecutors as well as slow-walking discovery disclosures.
Final Defense Witness In Karen Read Trial Pumps Brakes On Lexus Collision Theory
Read is accused of mowing down O'Keefe after a night of drinking and leaving him to die as she went to his house and left him raging voicemails as his niece and nephew slept in the home. He had taken them in after they were orphaned when his sister and brother-in-law died within months of one another.
Read On The Fox News App
"Was it appropriate? I think it's his personality," said David Gelman, a Philadelphia-area defense attorney and former prosecutor who is following the trial. "It may have missed the mark, but it's a breath of fresh air since experts are usually boring."
Grace Edwards, a Massachusetts trial lawyer who is also following the case, said the judge likely cut Rentschler off because narrative answers can distract from the facts of the case.
Karen Read Reveals She Will Not Testify In Her Own Defense
"The story can lead to a long answer that could be potentially off-topic or the jury could take from it something else that was not intended, like 'Happy Birthday,' and only remember that part," she told Fox News Digital. "The judge wanted the witness refocused to specific questions with focused answers rather than potentially rambling about his three kids."
Follow The Fox True Crime Team On X
Rentschler insisted that "details matter" repeatedly as he explained the basics of the scientific method and took issue with another expert report from the firm Aperture, retained by the prosecution.
Aperture labeled the injuries to O'Keefe's arm "lacerations," he said – a term that he testified contradicts the findings of the official autopsy, which described them as "superficial abrasions."
GET REAL-TIME UPDATES DIRECTLY ON THE True Crime Hub
"The superficial abrasions and abrasions occur when there's rubbing or scraping of the skin, and it just rubs away the top layer, the epidermis of the skin," he testified. "Now, a laceration is an actual jagged, ripping or tearing of the skin which gets down through the epidermis into the dermis. So abrasions take much less force. They're less severe than what a laceration actually is."
Sign Up To Get The True Crime Newsletter
Based on his testing, he said that he ruled out an impact with Read's 2021 Lexus LX 570 SUV and O'Keefe's arm as the cause of those injuries.
"They're inconsistent with striking the taillight or being produced as a result of contact with the taillight," he testified.
The prosecution claims that these minor injuries came from an impact with Read's broken taillight after she allegedly drove into O'Keefe on Jan. 29, 2022 and left him to die on the ground in the snow.
The defense denies a collision and has claimed the injuries came from dog teeth and claws.
Aperture's Dr. Judson Welcher testified earlier, based on digital forensics of phone and vehicle data, that Read's SUV reversed at 75% throttle right before O'Keefe's last conscious interaction with his cellphone.Original article source: Karen Read judge cuts off witness who sends 'happy birthday' wish to 10-year-old from stand
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
11 hours ago
- Boston Globe
Boston man, 85, killed in multi-vehicle highway crash near Nashua, police say
An investigation showed that an Audi rear-ended Casper's Lexus, causing Casper to strike a Ram 1500 pickup truck , which rolled onto its side, police said. The driver of the Audi, Candice Maple, of Dunstable, Mass., was taken to the hospital with 'minor injuries,' authorities said. The driver of the car that rolled over, Brian Roberts, 50, of Churchill, Tenn., did not require medical treatment, authorities said. Advertisement So far, no charges have been filed in the case. Police are investigating 'all aspects' of the crash, authorities said. Truman Dickerson can be reached at
Boston Globe
a day ago
- Boston Globe
Karen Read seeking dismissal of most counts pending against her in wrongful death lawsuit
Her attorneys stressed that Advertisement Lawyers for the O'Keefe family fired back in a filing opposing the dismissal motion, noting that discovery in the high-profile lawsuit Advertisement The family's emotional distress claims 'require a fact-intensive analysis which is not ripe for deciding at this early stage of the lawsuit and without adequate discovery,' the lawyers said. They added that 'traditional' emotional distress damages are 'expressly disallowed as a component of wrongful death damages,' hence the additional counts. The plaintiffs' attorneys said the O'Keefe family has 'suffered and continues to suffer immense emotional trauma from this wrongful death, which has been further intensified by the unyielding barrage of harassment and ridicule by Read and her supporters targeting the grieving family.' A Norfolk Superior Court jury Prosecutors had alleged that Read backed her Lexus SUV in a drunken rage into a Boston police officer, early on Jan. 29, 2022, after dropping him off outside a Canton home following a night of bar-hopping. Read's criminal attorneys said she was framed and that O'Keefe entered the property, owned at the time by a fellow Boston officer, where he was fatally beaten and possibly mauled by a German Shepherd before his body was planted on the front lawn. The allegations in the lawsuit track with the government's case in the criminal trial, and the O'Keefe family's attorneys said in court papers last week that Read, when she initially returned to O'Keefe's residence in the predawn hours of Jan. 29, 2022, woke up and traumatized his niece, then 14. Advertisement Read woke up O'Keefe's niece 'in a panic stating that something had happened to JJ and that [the niece's] surrogate father was dead,' the plaintiffs' lawyers wrote. In the niece's presence, Read chose not to call 911 but instead called " various acquaintances proclaiming, among other things, that JJ never came home and that he may have been hit by a snowplow,' the plaintiffs said. 'Thereafter, at or about 5 a.m., Read departed JJ's residence leaving [the niece]frightened, traumatized, and alone.' In the dismissal motion, Read's lawyers said the civil complaint includes no allegation that O'Keefe's niece 'directly observed' the alleged collision, nor did she 'observe the Decedent at any point thereafter.' The niece's 'alleged perception of death, as alleged, was based on conversations with the Defendant and there is no precedent for one to claim emotional distress as a bystander merely by learning via conversation that a loved one has been injured or passed away.' The parties are requesting a hearing in Plymouth Superior Court on the motion to dismiss the civil counts, records show. The next hearing currently scheduled in the case is a status conference on Sept. 22, according to court documents. Material from prior Globe stories was used in this report. Travis Andersen can be reached at
CBS News
7 days ago
- CBS News
Karen Read asks judge to dismiss emotional distress claim in O'Keefe family lawsuit
Lawyers for Karen Read are asking a Massachusetts judge to dismiss part of the civil lawsuit that was filed against her by the family of Boston police officer John O'Keefe. O'Keefe's family filed a wrongful death suit in August 2024. The suit was filed against Read and two Canton bars. According to new court documents filed Tuesday, Read's attorneys want the family's claims of "emotional distress" tossed out. They say family members were not present at the time of the alleged crash, which her attorneys argue undermines the family's claims. She is not seeking to dismiss the suit entirely. The civil suit is being heard in Plymouth Superior Court. Read was accused of hitting and killing O'Keefe, who she was dating, outside a Canton home after a night of heavy drinking. Her first criminal trial ended in a mistrial in 2024. During the retrial in 2025, a jury acquitted Read of second-degree murder, manslaughter while operating under the influence of alcohol, and leaving the scene of bodily injury and death. The jury found Read guilty only of operating under the influence of alcohol. She received a year of probation. When O'Keefe's family filed the civil suit, they said they were seeking monetary damages of $50,000 for "conscious pain and suffering, fear of impending death, wrongful death, lost value to next of kin, severe and profound emotional distress manifesting in bodily symptoms, and other compensable damages." Read's criminal defense attorney Alan Jackson joined her legal team earlier this month for the civil suit.
