Filipinos push back against growing Israeli presence on popular tourist island
Siargao — a resort island off Surigao del Norte province in Mindanao — is the Philippines' premier surfing site and one of the country's top tourist destinations.
It has lately become popular among Israelis, whose arrival over the past few months has resulted in numerous complaints. Siargao-based singer and community organizer Maria Lalaine Tokong went viral last week when she highlighted that many of the tourists were 'disregarding the culture, the customs,' of the place.
'We are feeling less at home in our home,' she wrote. 'I speak up because I refuse to let our identity, our peace, and our safety be erased.'
Tokong's post has since resulted in tens of thousands of interactions, with Filipinos sharing similar concerns.
It came against the backdrop of Israeli plans to open a Chabad house — a Jewish community center and place of worship — on the island. The plans have been opposed by the local community, which met Israeli embassy representatives in May.
'We don't want it,' Tokong told Arab News. 'When we talked about the cultural center with the Israeli embassy, we specifically told them, 'What's the purpose?' We already have an education system. We already have a church here.'
With new officials taking office following recent elections, she is now preparing with other community members to take the case forward with the local administration.
In April, Project Paradise, a Siargao-based non-governmental organization, held a town hall meeting with residents and local business owners to gather their complaints.
'We received reports primarily regarding disrespect for local customs and values — ranging from noise disturbances, reckless driving, disregard for modesty in dress in rural areas, to environmental irresponsibility such as leaving trash on beaches or protected areas,' Sofia Nicole de Asis, president of Project Paradise, told Arab News.
While De Asis said that the incidents 'are not isolated to any one group, and our stance has always been that misconduct is a behavioral issue, not a nationality-based one,' members of the Facebook group Siargao Business Classified 2.0 have been reporting Israeli tourists calling local staff 'slaves,' illegally raising their flags on boats, trashing local homestays, violating the island's no-noise curfew past midnight, and verbally and physically assaulting locals.
'They have no right to put up a cultural center as they have no roots or connection to Filipinos' history. 'Free Palestine' today, so we won't be shouting 'Free Siargao' tomorrow,' one user wrote, as others complained over inaction from the island's administration.
'These people were welcomed into our country and treated with genuine hospitality, yet they choose to disregard our laws and disrespect our people and communities. The local government of Siargao should strictly enforce all local rules and regulations,' another user said.
'For the local government in Siargao, you better act. Remember you're still part of the Philippines, you might one day be surprised that Siargao is now 'the promised land,'' another commented.
Officials in General Luna, one of the main towns on Siargao, did not respond to requests for comment from Arab News.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Arab News
2 days ago
- Arab News
India, Philippines upgrade ties to strategic partnership on Marcos' Delhi visit
New Delhi/Manila: India and the Philippines elevated their ties to a strategic partnership on Tuesday during President Ferdinand Marcos Jr.'s visit to New Delhi, as the two countries also move to boost trade and defense engagements. Marcos is on a five-day visit to India, where he was accorded full ceremonial honors involving a military parade and formal reception before he met with Prime Minister Narendra Modi. The two leaders jointly declared the strategic partnership and agreed to boost cooperation across various areas, including culture, tourism and space. 'India and the Philippines are friends by choice, and partners by destiny. From the Indian Ocean to the Pacific, we are united by shared values. Ours is not just a friendship of the past, it is a promise to the future,' Modi said in a joint press statement. After their navies sailed together for the first time in the South China Sea on Monday, the two countries also agreed on Tuesday to bolster defense collaboration. 'Strengthening defense relations (is) a symbol of deep mutual trust. As maritime nations, maritime cooperation between the two countries is both natural and necessary,' Modi said. India and the Philippines have agreed to establish mechanisms for enhanced maritime cooperation between the Indian and Philippine coast guards and for talks between their militaries. 'We will foster naval and coastguard interoperability via port calls in cooperative activities and capacity building in the maritime domain,' Marcos said. With bilateral trade currently valued at more than $3 billion, Delhi and Manila will start working toward a preferential trade agreement to further strengthen commerce ties, both leaders said. For India, deepening its relations with the Philippines is 'an important step in expanding its presence in East Asia,' said Manoj Kewalramani, a fellow in China studies and chairperson of the Indo-Pacific Studies Programme at the Takshashila Institution. 'The elevation of the relationship to a strategic partnership underscores the growing political proximity between the two nations and the alignment of broader interests,' he told Arab News. Strengthening India-Philippines defense relations is a strategic move for New Delhi to support its interest in the South China Sea region. 'From a strategic perspective, I think it is important for India to work with like-minded countries on shared security concerns and shaping the strategic environment around China's periphery,' Manoj said. 'It is also worth remembering that the South China Sea is a critical route for a substantial amount of Indian merchandise trade. So India has significant interests in the region.' Tensions have continued to run high between the Philippines and China over territorial disputes in the South China Sea, a strategic waterway through which billions of dollars of goods pass each year. Manila and Beijing have been involved in frequent maritime confrontations in recent years, with China maintaining its expansive claims to the area, despite a 2016 international tribunal ruling that its historical assertion had no basis. Upgrading India-Philippines ties to a strategic partnership is indicative of 'the trust that Manila has put in place on India as an important factor in its security calculations,' said Don McLain Gill, a geopolitical analyst and international studies lecturer at De La Salle University in Manila. 'Similarly, India being part of the strategic partnership illustrates its willingness to play a more active role … as an alternative security partner and provider, along with a capacity builder,' Gill told Arab News. He expects India to tailor its defense cooperation with the Philippines based on what Manila needs, adding that there are also possibilities for joint production. 'It indicates that the sky is the limit for what both countries can achieve in the realm of defense and security cooperation, but also other strategic areas such as infrastructure and critical minerals,' he said. 'Elevating strategic partnerships isn't something that the Philippines just freely tosses around. It is earned, and the Philippines, I believe, recognizes the importance of forging closer ties with India and deepening them based on emerging realities and threats and challenges.'
Al Arabiya
3 days ago
- Al Arabiya
Philippines, India hold first joint sail in South China Sea
The Philippine and Indian navies have sailed together for the first time in the South China Sea, officials said on Monday, as President Ferdinand Marcos left Manila for New Delhi for a state visit. The Philippines has conducted 'maritime cooperative activities' with foreign navies since late 2023 as part of its push to counter China's expansive claims in the waterway, including joint sails with treaty ally the United States, as well as Japan, Australia, France and Canada. Philippine military chief Romeo Brawner said the idea for the two-day joint sail, which started on Sunday and was inside the Philippines' exclusive economic zone, came about when he met his counterpart in India in March. 'We did not experience any untoward incidents, but there are still those shadowing us - as we had already expected,' Brawner told reporters, without naming China. China's foreign ministry said in a statement that territorial and maritime disputes should be resolved between the countries directly involved and no third party should intervene. Indian navy ships that took part in the first joint sail of the two countries included guided missile destroyer INS Delhi, tanker INS Shakti and corvette INS Kiltan. The Philippines deployed two frigates, BRP Miguel Malvar and BRP Jose Rizal. The exercise coincided with Marcos' departure for a five-day trip to India, where he said he will look to deepen maritime ties and seek cooperation on sectors including defense, pharmaceuticals and agriculture. China claims nearly the entire South China Sea, overlapping with maritime zones of Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines and Vietnam. The waterway is a strategic shipping route where $3 trillion of annual ship-borne commerce takes place. A 2016 ruling of an international arbitral tribunal found Beijing's sweeping claims have no basis under international law, a decision China rejects.
Arab News
3 days ago
- Arab News
Philippine, Indian navies begin first joint South China Sea patrols
MANILA: Indian Navy warships have begun patrolling areas of the disputed South China Sea with their Philippine counterparts for the first time, Manila's military said Monday. The two-day sail includes three Indian vessels and started Sunday, a day ahead of Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos' scheduled trip to New Delhi for talks with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi. The Philippines has heightened defense cooperation with a range of allies over the past year after a series of clashes in the contested waterway. Beijing claims nearly the entirety of the South China Sea despite an international ruling that its assertion has no legal basis. India's naval vessels arrived in Manila for a port visit late last week. The patrol 'started yesterday afternoon, then it's ongoing up to this moment... the activity at the moment is replenishment at sea,' Lt. Col. John Paul Salgado told AFP. While in India, Marcos is expected to sign pacts in such fields as law, culture and technology, according to Foreign Affairs Assistant Secretary Evangeline Ong Jimenez-Ducrocq, but all eyes will be on any potential defense agreements. The Philippines has previously purchased BrahMos supersonic cruise missiles from India, a weapon which has a top speed of 3,450 kilometers (2,140 miles) per hour. India, which has engaged in border clashes with China in the Himalayas, is a member of the so-called Quad, a group that includes fellow democracies the United States, Japan and Australia. Beijing has repeatedly alleged that the four-way partnership, first conceived by late Japanese prime minister Shinzo Abe, was created as a way of containing China.
