
Ministers slammed over ‘jaw-dropping' NHS negligence claims for poor care
The NHS must do more to reduce 'tragic' incidents of patient harm and cut 'jaw-dropping' payouts for poor care, MPs have warned as costs spiral to a record high.
Compensation for clinical negligence claims cost £2.8bn in 2023-24 – up from £2.6bn the year before – with hundreds of millions paid out in legal fees.
The highest number of claims were for failings in emergency medicine, obstetrics, orthopaedic and general surgery, with maternity care payouts costing the most, totalling £1.1bn last year.
The Department of Health and Social Care has set aside an 'astounding' £58.2bn to cover the potential costs of clinical negligence events occurring before April 2024.
The public accounts committee sounded the alarm on the rise, saying ministers needed to get a grip on NHS finances.
Its chair, Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown, said: 'The fact that the government has set aside tens of billions of pounds for clinical negligence payments, its second most costly liability after some of the world's most complex nuclear decommissioning projects, should give our entire society pause.
'It must be a priority of the highest order for the government to reduce tragic incidences of patient harm and lay out a mechanism to reduce legal fees to manage the jaw-dropping costs involved more effectively.'
The most recent NHS data shows 4,076 incidents of severe harm to patients and 4,449 patient deaths were recorded by the NHS in just three months from October to December last year.
And a fifth of last year's record £2.8bn compensation bill – £545m – went to lawyers. That amount is higher than the entire expenditure of the government's legal department, the report found, which totalled £341m in the same year.
In the past five years alone, NHS Resolution, which manages negligence claims, has spent over £12bn on payouts – £2.4bn of which has been spent on claimants' legal fees.
'If we can reduce the leakage of lawyers' fees in the middle, that benefits the whole of the NHS, because there will be more money available for other services,' said Sir Geoffrey,
Hospital chiefs in England warned last week that they have been forced to cut nurse and doctor posts and scale back emergency and maternity care to meet the government 's 'eye watering' savings demands for 2025-26.
The committee challenged the DHSC to set out how it intends to 'reduce tragic incidents of patient harm' and manage the costs of negligence 'more effectively'.
Acknowledging the high cost of payouts for maternity care failings, Sir Geoffrey said the difference between some maternity units and others 'is quite significant'.
He said: 'Obstetrics is an inherently dangerous process, so the line between doing harm and negligence is quite narrow, but the NHS need to look carefully at why some units do get more negligence claims than others.'
MPs on the committee also criticised the DHSC, which they said 'lacks a grip of the financial pressures it faces'.
MPs also raised concerns over the 'uncertainty' surrounding the abolition of NHS England, announced in March, which they said had created 'high levels of uncertainty for patients and for staff'.
They said the DHSC had a 'lack of firm plans' for its closure and reducing its headcount by 50 per cent.
'At the moment, it looks a little bit like shifting the deck chairs on the Titanic. We really want to make sure that this thing is going to work properly,' Sir Geoffrey told The Independent.
'It has been two months since the government's decision to remove what up until now has been seen as a key piece of machinery without articulating a clear plan for what comes next, and the future for patients and staff remains hazy,' he said.
MPs highlighted how some hospitals in England had pushed through unauthorised special exit packages – severance payments which require Treasury sign-off because they are new or contentious, totalling more than £180,000 in 2023/24.
'There remain far too many special severance payments where approval has only been sought after the payment has been made,' they added.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Daily Mail
30 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
The smartwatch that fitness fans swear by and call 'better than an Apple watch' is on sale right now - now £30 off with FREE gifts
We're almost halfway through 2025, and if those well-being resolutions you made at the start of the year have gone out the window, the HUAWEI Watch Fit 4 Pro boasts everything you need to get back on track (and you can now snag it for £30 off). A must-have for fitness fanatics or those looking to enter their fitness era, the smartwatch is at the very forefront of the industry when it comes to vital sign monitoring, and also boasts a wide-range of features designed to make your workout easier. HUAWEI Watch Fit 4 Pro In your fitness era? This gold-standard watch will be your new best friend while working out, boasting over a hundred sports modes, including terrain maps tracking, trail running, diving and gold modes. Plus, get more insights into your health than ever before with heart and respiratory rate monitoring, blood pressure risk monitoring, and comprehensive sleep analysis. Ready to buy? Use code AFIT4PRO30OFF for £30 off your purchase, as well as a pair of FREE Huawei Freebuds SE3, and two premium watch straps. Be quick! £219.99 (£30 off) Shop Not only that, but it's incredibly stylish, too, with a lightweight, comfortable design, sleek frame and multiple colourways available. Finally, there's a smart watch you'll actually want to wear, long after your workout is finished. For a limited-time only, shoppers can get their hands on the sought-after watch for an impressive £30 off, as well as two premium straps and a pair of free HUAWEI Freebuds SE3 using code AFIT4PRO30OFF - though be quick, as this deal is only around until the 29th June (and you don't want to miss out). Whether you're looking to get a better insight into your overall health, or you want to take advantage of the myriad of features tailored specifically to fitness enthusiasts, the HUAWEI Watch Fit 4 Pro is a must-have bit of kit to add to your collection - and users say it's 'better than an Apple watch'. 'I'm honestly blown away!', wrote one user. 'It's incredibly light and thin. The screen is so bright and clear, too - it really looks and feels premium. What really sold me was promised 10-day battery life. Coming from an Apple Watch, I didn't think that was even possible - but the HUAWEI Fit 4 Pro actually delivers. No more constant charging!'. 'It's like the ninja of smartwatches. Silent. Invisible. Deadly accurate with fitness tracking,' wrote a second customer. 'Now that the sun has decided to show up again, I'm actually motivated to get outside and move. With the Fit 4 Pro, I might just transform into one of those 'morning jog' people!'. 'The battery life is incredible, I'm on my 2nd day now, still with 85 per cent,' noted a third shopper. 'The launch offer is really good at the moment, and when you compare it to the price of other watches, there's no comparison! Forget Apple, forget Samsung, forget Fitbit…buy this awesome watch'. The stylish watch boasts a feather-light weight of only 27 grams, so you'd be forgiven for forgetting you're wearing it. Crafted from premium materials such as sapphire glass and an aviation-grade aluminum body, its been made with durability in mind - no matter how messy your workout gets. Ideal for easy management of everyday life, the 347ppi AMOLED screen brings visuals to life with clarity and detail - so you'll actually want to check your notifications when wearing it. For those who have wanted to invest in a smartwatch for some time but never liked the look of them, the HUAWEI Watch Fit 4 Pro is available in multiple colourways depending on your personal style. Plus, you can personalise your watch home screen, too, so that picture of your smiling pet or that first day of school photo will never be far away. Perhaps the most impressive element of the watch, however, is its industry-leading health and fitness tracking. At the lift of a finger, users will be able to access insights such as heart rate, blood oxygen, respiratory rate, body temperature changes, stress, blood pressure risk and sleep breathing awareness. A recent Mindshare report showed that 66 per cent of the global population is paying more attention to their overall health, and this savvy smartwatch provides a comprehensive look into your wellbeing - meaning you can take actionable steps to improve certain factors, if necessary. The Watch Fit 4 Pro also provides advanced menstrual cycle management features for women, allowing for easy tracking of current, previous and upcoming cycles, as well as symptom monitoring that is seamlessly logged with the HUAWEI Health App for collaborative health management. As well as an impressive seven day battery life in as little as 60 minutes per charge, the waterproof design also boasts impressive GPS accuracy, terrain map tracking and multiple golf modes with access to over 15,000 golf course maps worldwide, showing detailed 3D layouts of each. With over a hundred sports modes to choose from, it's no wonder that hundreds of fitness fanatics are raving about the watch. And now's your chance to get yours for £30 off with code AFIT4PRO30OFF, PLUS two premium bonus straps and FREE HUAWEI Freebuds SE3 (worth £39.99). What are you waiting for? Your journey to better health awaits.


Wales Online
31 minutes ago
- Wales Online
NHS tells Tesco shoppers to 'keep an eye out' in health alert
NHS tells Tesco shoppers to 'keep an eye out' in health alert Tesco shoppers may spot the NHS logo on a common household product The NHS has partnered with Tesco to raise awareness (Image: Getty ) The NHS is asking anyone who shops at Tesco to 'keep an eye out' and to 'contact your GP practice if something doesn't feel right'. The alert comes as customers at the major UK supermarket may spot the NHS logo on the front of Tesco's own-brand Luxury Soft toilet rolls. The partnership aims to raise awareness of bowel cancer and educate shoppers about the red-flag signs to watch out for. In a post on X, NHS said: "Keep an eye out for our logo on @Tesco toilet roll—78.9 million rolls sold and counting!" It added: "It's a reminder for people to look out for possible signs of cancer when going to the loo. Know what's normal for you and contact your GP practice if something doesn't feel right." A message on the toilet roll underneath the NHS logo reads: "Finding cancer earlier makes it more treatable and can save lives." Underneath, it continues: "See back of pack for more information." Shoppers can read through the possible signs of cancer when goingto the toilet on the packaging, which includes changes to your poo and blood in your poo. For more information on the signs of cancer, go to Content cannot be displayed without consent Article continues below Symptoms of bowel cancer may include: changes in your poo, such as having softer poo, diarrhoea or constipation that is not usual for you needing to poo more or less often than usual for you blood in your poo, which may look red or black bleeding from your bottom often feeling like you need to poo, even if you've just been to the toilet tummy pain a lump in your tummy bloating losing weight without trying feeling very tired or short of breath – these are signs of anaemia, which can be caused by bowel cancer Speak to a doctor if you have any symptoms of bowel cancer for three weeks or more. The NHS says: "Try not to be embarrassed. The doctor or nurse will be used to talking about these symptoms." Ask for an urgent GP appointment or get help from NHS 111 if your poo is black or dark red or you have bloody diarrhoea. You can call 111 or get help from 111 online. Over 200 distinct varieties of cancer exist. Cancer has the potential to impact any region of the body, including organs, blood, bone marrow, and the immune system. At times, cancer can spread from one location to another, this is referred to as secondary cancer or metastasis. 'Don't die of embarrassment' - NHS Cancer Clinical Director Professor Peter Johnson urges people to get cancer signs checked The treatment you'll have depends on the type of cancer. The most common treatments for cancer include: surgery to remove the cancer, chemotherapy, which uses medicines to kill cancer cells and radiotherapy, which uses radiation to kill cancer cells. Article continues below Treatment can also involve immunotherapy, where medicines are used to help your immune system kill cancer and hormone therapy to help stop or slow down the growth of cancer. The NHS says: "You'll be looked after by a team of specialists who will work with you to create a treatment plan that is best for you."


The Independent
32 minutes ago
- The Independent
More than 1,000 doctors urge MPs to vote down ‘deeply flawed' assisted dying bill
More than 1,000 doctors have urged MPs to vote against the assisted dying bill when it returns to the Commons, claiming it is a 'real threat to both patients and the medical workforce'. The Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill, which would allow terminally ill patients with six months left to live to end their lives, is due to be voted on for a final time on 20 June. Ahead of the vote, in a letter to MPs, doctors from the NHS expressed 'serious concerns', arguing that 'this bill is not the answer". While they acknowledged that there must be a debate on end of life care, they argued too little evidence has been heard from doctors, people with disabilities and other marginalised groups. "This bill will widen inequalities, it provides inadequate safeguards and, in our collective view, is simply not safe,' they wrote, saying the bill is 'deeply flawed'. The letter has been signed by geneticist Sir John Burn, Sir Shakeel Qureshi, who received a knighthood for his work in paediatric cardiology, Professor Aileen Keel, the former deputy chief medical officer for Scotland, and Baroness Finlay, a professor of palliative medicine and member of the House of Lords. In its current form the bill, which applies only to England and Wales, would mean terminally ill adults with only six months left to live could apply for assistance to end their lives, with approval needed from two doctors and the expert panel. Last month, MPs approved a change in the bill to ensure no medics would be obliged to take part in assisted dying. Doctors already had an opt-out, but the new clause extends that to anyone, including pharmacists and social care workers. The letter, seen by Sky News, goes on to say: "Vulnerable patients are at risk of coercion with women, victims of domestic abuse, and the elderly at particular risk. People who struggle to pay for heating or care or wish to preserve their assets for their children are at high risk of choosing to die if the option is available and the alternative is more difficult." Meanwhile, Professor Colin Rees, a member of the Royal College of Physicians working group on assisted dying, said the legislation will 'have very profound consequences for the future and many doctors are really concerned that members of parliament are not hearing the views of the medical profession". "We don't think it's a bill that is safe, that protects patients, protects families, and protects the medical workforce,' he added. But Kim Leadbeater, the bill's sponsor, said assisted dying must be legalised to avoid terminally ill people acting out of desperation or making 'traumatic' trips to Switzerland. Last month, she told the Commons she has heard 'hundreds of stories from people who have lost loved ones in deeply difficult and traumatic circumstances', adding: 'If we do not vote to change the law, we are essentially saying that the status quo is acceptable.' The warning from the doctors came after TV medic Hilary Jones warned that medicine will go 'back to the Dark Ages' if the proposed legislation is voted down. The GP, often seen on ITV's Good Morning Britain and the Lorraine show, said he would help a terminally ill patient to end their life if the law was changed, describing the practice as 'kind and compassionate'. Dr Jones said medics are currently 'looking over their shoulders because of the legal repercussions of the law' as it stands. Encouraging or assisting suicide is currently against the law in England and Wales, with a maximum jail sentence of 14 years. Asked about the potential significance if the law changes, Dr Jones said: 'It will relieve healthcare professionals who deal with terminal illness. 'There are wonderful people who are caring and compassionate, who just live in fear of their actions being misinterpreted, of being accused of wrongdoing, and because of that fear, people at the end of life are often undertreated. 'People are looking over their shoulder because of the medications they're using or the doses they're using, it means that patients aren't getting the best palliative care that they could have.'