Dorset incinerator opposers 'devastated' over High Court ruling
Campaigners have said they are "devastated" after losing a court case against the decision to build an incinerator near Dorset's Jurassic Coast World Heritage Site.The High Court has dismissed an appeal for a statutory review into Powerfuel Portland's £150m waste incinerator planning application, which was given the go-ahead by the government in September, despite initially being refused by Dorset Council.The decision comes after a two-day hearing in March.The Stop Portland Waste Incinerator (SPWI) group said taking the matter to the Court of Appeal was its "one final chance".
The group's request for a statutory review was upheld on the grounds the Secretary of State's decision "does not satisfy" Dorset Council's Waste Plan.But Debbie Tulett, who heads up the campaign, described news of the latest decision as "devastating"."I am very disappointed that the judge was unable to see that the planned waste incinerator does not comply with our county's waste plan," she said."We do have one final chance left on the legal challenge side of things and that is to try and get our case heard at the Court of Appeal."
Ms Tullett said she believed the majority of those who were opposed to the incinerator "would like us to fight to the bitter end".She said after "nearly six years of full-time fighting against the waste incinerator, I am not ready to throw in the towel yet".Olympic sailor and Portland resident Laura Baldwin, who is also campaigning against the plans, described the decision as "deeply upsetting"."It is clear that it is no longer a financially attractive investment with the upcoming inclusion in the emissions trading scheme making it very much more expensive to burn waste," she said.While Olympic champion Ellie Aldridge said "no-one will want to train" at the National Sailing Academy if an incinerator was built nearby.
'Vital to port'
The Environment Agency (EA) granted Powerfuel Portland an environmental permit for the incinerator in February after concluding it had met all of its necessary criteria.At the time Dorset Council leader Nick Ireland called the announcement "extremely disappointing".He said the incinerator would be "throwing out nitrous dioxide, sulphur dioxide, arsenic, nickel, chromium" into the atmosphere, below the top of the island and opposite the beach, and harm the area's tourism industry.But Powerfuel Portland said the facility would have the capacity to process up to 202,000 tonnes of waste per year and create enough energy to power about 30,000 homes.It said hazardous or clinical waste would not be burned.Portland Port previously said the power plant was "vital to this port's future" by allowing it to offer shore power to docked cruise ships.
You can follow BBC Dorset on Facebook, X, or Instagram.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
Belfast loyalist Winston Irvine's sentence referred to Court of Appeal
A sentence handed to leading Belfast loyalist Winston Irvine has been referred to the Court of Appeal. Irvine was sentenced to two-and-a-half years, with half to be served in jail, at Belfast Crown Court last month following an incident where firearms and ammunition were found in the boot of his car. The 49-year-old avoided a statutory five-year sentence on several of the charges he faced after Judge Gordon Kerr KC ruled that there were 'exceptional circumstances' in his case, namely Irvine's 'work for peace and his charity work in the community'. However, there was criticism by several political figures, including First Minister Michelle O'Neill, that the sentence had been too lenient. On Friday it was announced that Northern Ireland's Director of Public Prosecutions Stephen Herron was referring the sentence to the Court of Appeal. The Public Prosecution Service (PPS) confirmed the referral has been lodged with the Court of Appeal. 'While sentencing is a matter for the independent judiciary, the Director of Public Prosecutions does have the power to refer particular sentences to the Court of Appeal on the grounds that they may be unduly lenient,' a PPS spokesperson said. 'An unduly lenient sentence is one that falls outside the range of sentences that a judge, taking into consideration all relevant factors and having regard to sentencing guidance, could reasonably impose. The sentence must not just be lenient but unduly lenient. 'After careful consideration of the sentence handed down in the case of Winston Irvine, including with the benefit of advices from independent Senior Counsel, we have determined that there is a sufficient legal basis to refer the sentence to the Court of Appeal.' They said consideration was also given to the sentence handed down to Irvine's co-accused Adam Robinson Workman, 54, who was sentenced to five years imprisonment. But they said following careful consideration, it was determined that there was no legal basis on which to refer Workman's sentence to the Court of Appeal as potentially unduly lenient.
BBC News
4 hours ago
- BBC News
Winston Irvine 'unduly lenient' sentence to be appealed
The sentence given to Winston Irvine was unduly lenient and should be extended, according to the Public Prosecution Service (PPS).Irvine, 49, from Ballysillan Road in north Belfast, was given a two-and-a-half year sentence last month after admitting to firearm and ammunition sentence was half the minimum recommended term, with the judge citing "exceptional circumstances".The PPS said it will now appeal the sentence. Irvine's sentence – half of which is to be served on licence – was below the minimum sentence of five years and attracted criticism from some politicians.A spokesperson for the PPS told the BBC's The Nolan Show: "After careful consideration of the sentence handed down in the case of Winston Irvine, including with the benefit of advices from independent Senior Counsel, we have determined that there is a sufficient legal basis to refer the sentence to the Court of Appeal."The PPS referral has now been lodged with the Court of Appeal. Irvine is currently serving his sentence on the segregated UVF wing at Maghaberry high security sentencing Judge Gordon Kerr KC said despite Irvine's guilty plea, he had declined to give any explanation to the police or the court for having the guns and bullets in the boot of his the judge said he did not consider the crimes to be connected to judge cited Irvine's "character and long-term commitment to peace building in Northern Ireland" among exceptional circumstances relating to the court was told he had worked at the highest levels of government and had "devoted most of his adult life to peace".Court documents released to The Nolan Show revealed the extent of the character references provided to the include letters from Loyalist Communities Council chair David Campbell, former Policing Board member and director of Northern Ireland Alternatives Deborah Watters, Gary Mason a Methodist Minister, as well as Dr Harold Good .The PPS said it would not be appealing the five year jail term handed to co-accused Robin Workman.
BBC News
21 hours ago
- BBC News
Families hid in attics during 'race motivated' disorder, says chief constable
Families hid in attics and wardrobes during violent disorder in Ballymena, the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) Chief Constable has comes following three days of violence in Ballymena, and some other towns, in which 41 officers were injured and 13 people disorder began on Monday after a peaceful protest over an alleged sexual assault in the County Antrim Boutcher described the disorder as "wanton, disgraceful, criminal behaviour that is absolutely race motivated". Mr Boutcher said after a peaceful protest was "hijacked" on Monday evening, police and the fire service had to help families "who have done nothing wrong".He added that: "We stand absolutely shoulder to shoulder with the diverse communities in Northern Ireland. "These bigots and racists will not win the day."The first protest was organised hours after two teenage boys appeared before Coleraine Magistrates' spoke through an interpreter in Romanian to confirm their names and ages. Their solicitor said they would be denying the Boutcher said the family of the young girl wanted the violence to stop."She's been further traumatised by what has happened over the last three nights," he said. The worst of the disorder took place in Ballymena, mainly in the Clonavon Terrace have described the disorder as "racist thuggery, pure and simple" and targeted at ethnic minorities and law the three days in Ballymena, police officers came under sustained attack with petrol bombs, heavy masonry, bricks and fireworks thrown in their Boutcher called on those involved to stop and warned that there will be prosecutions. "Don't come out onto the streets tonight. If you do we will police you, and we will deal with you through the criminal justice system.""We'll be releasing images of those responsible. We will be going after them." On Wednesday, the PSNI confirmed that a significant number of extra police officers were being deployed into areas Scotland has agreed to send officers, after police in Northern Ireland requested extra support under mutual aid deployment will involve an undisclosed number of public order officers trained to police civil Larne, masked youths attacked a leisure centre and set it on fire on Wednesday. The centre had been providing emergency shelter for families following the clashes earlier in the week, the council have also been incidents in Larne, Carrickfergus, Coleraine, north Belfast and Newtownabbey. Olympic swimmer Danielle Hill, who competed in both the Paris and Tokyo Games, has condemned the attack on Larne Leisure Hill, who swims for team Ireland, was at the facility when the attacks took place. She said: "I went to move my car, and four masked men walked around the corner, and I thought, okay, this is time to go."The 25-year-old said: "This isn't what we want. There are kids involved. And it's my duty to care and protect those guys so I made the decision then to cancel my session."As I went back inside to clear my stuff and clear all the kids and make sure they were picked up, I came back outside and there were people in balaclavas standing around the corner. "I got a phone call from a family friend to say that if I hadn't already, I should leave. I instantly rang our duty manager and spoke to a child protection officer inside and told them to evacuate." Ms Hill said: "I mean, it's sad. It's awful. I lay awake last night. When there's kids involved it's upsetting. It shouldn't be happening. There was no need for the violence."As a club, we're deeply saddened that It got to that stage and that those kids had the witness what they did."We can only hope that one day they will come back and that this isn't a place of fear for them and that it is that safe place where they can go and be kids."In a statement, a council spokesperson said they're "assessing the significant damage" and that "the centre remains closed". A housing association has warned its residents to leave their homes and take measures to protect their properties ahead of a planned protest in County Housing in Portadown sent a letter to its residents stating Thursday's demonstration in the town is "directed towards migrants, foreign nationals, and what are perceived as deviant behaviour".The letter added that the demonstration could lead to an "unsafe situation" and advised them to "stay with family or friends during the protest".The police have said they are aware of social media posts calling for protests across Northern Ireland on Thursday evening and in the week Chief Constable Ryan Henderson said: "We urge anyone who plans to attend these protests to engage with us as we will be doing our part to ensure the safety of participants and to facilitate the lawful exercise of freedom of expression."Police will not tolerate a repeat of the scenes we saw last night in Ballymena and other parts of Northern Ireland," he added. "We will continue to diligently monitor the situation."
