What to expect of Trump, Putin summit in Alaska on Ukraine
For example, in the fall of 2022, the high-water mark for Ukraine on the battlefield, U.S. intelligence estimated that there was a 50% chance Russia would reach for nuclear weapons if its forces in southern Ukraine were facing collapse. Were Russia losing today, the risks for Americans would be higher.
Putin's will vs. Trump's way
While Russia's progress has limited the risk of escalation, it has also increased Moscow's willingness to continue fighting. Since beginning his second term, Trump has tried to find a way to end the war, but the Kremlin has not shown much willingness to moderate its demands.
Putin has insisted on Ukraine renouncing aspirations to join NATO or allow NATO forces on its territory; conceding Russian sovereignty over the four provinces it annexed in 2022; the demilitarization of Ukraine; and the "denazification" of the country, by which it means dramatic reforms to how it governs itself domestically.
Putin has also rejected a temporary ceasefire that doesn't engage on these issues.
Opinion alerts: Get columns from your favorite columnists + expert analysis on top issues, delivered straight to your device through the USA TODAY app. Don't have the app? Download it for free from your app store.
The debate over the what to do next often obscures more than it reveals. One hears reference to Ukrainian victory or Russian defeat without defining what those terms mean or what their implications would be.
Does Ukrainian victory or Russian defeat mean Kyiv regaining all territory inside its internationally recognized borders? That isn't going to happen.
Could Ukraine losing territory but keeping its sovereignty and military - without NATO membership - be portrayed as success? Many security scholars believe that such armed neutrality is the best that can be achieved for Ukraine.
Opinion: I was the US ambassador to Ukraine. Here's why I resigned.
Don't forget Zelenskyy's intransigence
This is where Ukraine's intransigence comes in. Even though Ukrainian public support for continuing the war has cratered, President Volodymyr Zelenskyy is using the Ukrainian Constitution as a firewall against concessions.
As amended in 2019, it both prohibits the Ukrainian government from ceding any territory and somewhat clumsily commits it to pursue membership in NATO. In rejecting Trump's suggestion that there be land swaps as part of a settlement, Zelenskyy pointed at the constitution's provision against giving up territory, arguing that "no one will step back from this, nor will anyone be able to."
The Ukrainian president's willingness and ability to end the war probably has less to do with high-minded constitutional principles and more to do with his own political survival. At this point, the war has produced total destruction in Ukraine, the evisceration of its territory, and all the ruinous human and economic costs of the war - but without any U.S. security guarantees. Zelenskyy knows this would be a disastrous legacy, so he has a powerful incentive to obtain something he can portray as a benefit of the war.
Gen. Wesley Clark: Trump needs to push Putin hard to end war in Ukraine - now | Opinion
The question is whether Kyiv's position on the battlefield can sustain Zelenskyy's intransigence on the political issues, with or without more U.S. support. There are worrying signs that it cannot. Ukraine faces an array of manpower issues along the 600-mile front. Key towns seem to be in jeopardy. Time is not on Ukraine's side.
As always, the Europeans are doing everything in their power to keep the United States at the center of the war in Ukraine - and as the central provider of regional security. They called a virtual meeting with Zelenskyy and Trump two days before the Putin summit, and proposed a plan for Ukraine that would involve potential NATO membership in exchange for Kyiv conceding that it lost territory.
After the meeting on Aug. 13, French President Emmanuel Macron and European Council President Antonio Costa indicated Trump committed that the United States would participate in security guarantees for Ukraine.
However, Trump has previously resisted European pleas for U.S. security guarantees to Ukraine, and make no mistake: That is just what NATO membership would be. With two consecutive U.S. administrations revealing that Washington does not perceive an interest in Ukraine worth fighting Russia over, such a commitment would be inherently incredible.
In the coming days, avoiding any traps laid by the Europeans, the Ukrainians or congressional hawks is essential. From a U.S. perspective, patience and low expectations are the right course for talks with Russia.
Above all, Trump must avoid backing into a reboot of the Biden administration's Ukraine policy, which involved an endless flow of weapons and hoping for a miracle.
America's resources for and interests in the war in Ukraine are limited. Trump's policy should reflect that.
Justin Logan ( @justintlogan ) is director of defense and foreign policy studies at the Cato Institute.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
29 minutes ago
- The Independent
University of Alaska dorms to host up to 750 Russian delegates in town for Trump-Putin summit
The University of Alaska Anchorage is expecting hundreds of Russian delegates who are in the city for the summit between President Trump and President Vladimir Putin to stay in student dorms. 'There may be up to 750 people staying on campus between the U.S. and Russian delegations,' vice chancellor Ryan Buchholdt said in an email to the Alaskan newspaper, Anchorage Daily News. The school can house around 12,000 people. This week marks the start of the school calendar for those returning from the summer break. The summit is going to be held at Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson, about a 10-minute drive from Anchorage, reports Alaska's News Source. The meeting will mark the first time Trump and Putin have met in person since 2018. 'In addition to the dorms, we do have the Alaska Airlines Center [a sports arena that has a 5,000-seat capacity] that has been set up with beds, meeting most of the need, mostly from the Russian delegation side,' Buchholdt also told Alaska's News Source. University police are working closely with state and federal law agencies to monitor security, Buchholdt added. 'Our main concern is making sure anyone who is staying on campus, whether they are from the United States or Russia or any other locality, is safe,' Buchholdt said, 'and is able to do the mission that they're here to do and go back home safely.' On Thursday, some of the delegates had already arrived as of Thursday afternoon, according to university spokesperson Katie Bender. Flight tracking data showed that at least one flight from Moscow had touched down in Anchorage that afternoon. 'The delegations are in separate locations. For security purposes, we are not able to share where the delegations are located,' Bender added. Alyeska resort, located about 40 miles south of Anchorage, informed local press that they were fully booked for the weekend, and the website of the local hotel, Captain Cook, was also fully booked. The hotel site showed one remaining room in a hostel, at a staggeringly raised price of $150 a night on Friday. Town mayor Suzanne LaFrance explained that finding accommodation at the height of the tourist season is hard enough as it is, let alone with a significant political event taking center stage. 'I know that people are looking at creative solutions. I don't have any specific details about that [housing delegations in UOA], but I know that the university is engaged in those conversations, and I'm optimistic that we'll come up with some options for folks,' she said to Alaska's News Source. At the Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson, news and camera crews were seen rolling in on Thursday morning. Locals watched on as officials gathered in the vicinity. 'It's kind of a big deal, I mean, do we all want World War III?' one man told Alaska's News Source. The two leaders will hold peace talks regarding the future of Russia and Ukraine, amid a deadly war that has killed hundreds of thousands of soldiers on both sides. Earlier on Thursday, Putin praised Trump's 'energetic and sincere efforts to stop' the war in Ukraine. More than a million Russian troops have been killed or injured since the full-scale invasion of Ukraine began on 24 February 2022, reports the British Ministry of Defense. Meanwhile, Ukrainian personnel fatalities and casualties have amounted to around 400,000, says the US-based Centre for Strategic and International Studies. Ahead of the summit, Trump vowed that as he hopes to secure a ceasefire deal.
The Guardian
33 minutes ago
- The Guardian
‘An intimidation tactic': Trump's show of force dismays Washington residents
Washington DC's only Home Depot was busy with contractors and customers on Thursday morning – but the Hispanic day laborers who usually gather and wait for work under the parking lot's sparse trees were nowhere to be found. Two days earlier, masked federal agents swarmed the area and made several arrests, which were photographed by bystanders and posted on social media. Juwan Brooks, a store employee who witnessed the raid, said the agents grabbed anyone who appeared Hispanic. 'They don't ask no questions,' Brooks said. People walking across the parking lot, getting out of their cars, or even sleeping in their vehicle – all were grabbed by the agents, leaving behind empty work trucks that were eventually towed away. 'It was cool when Trump was saying it, but to actually see it first hand? I didn't like it,' Brooks said. The day laborers 'are not bad people', and he wondered what happened to the children of the men that were taken away. Four days after Trump ordered federal agents and national guard on to the streets of Washington DC to fight a crime wave that city leaders say is not happening, residents of the capital are becoming used to the presence of groups of armed men in their neighborhoods, and the aggressive tactics they use. Beyond the apparent immigration arrests at Home Depot – which Brooks said was the second raid there he is aware of since Trump took office – federal agents have been spotted setting up roadblocks at busy intersections, and patrolling neighborhoods across the city. Trump, who exercised a never-before-used clause in the law governing the district to take over the Metropolitan police department (MPD) for 30 days, this week said he would seek Congress's approval to keep it under federal control for the 'long term'. It's unclear how much of a difference the deployment has yet made on public safety. Rates of violent crime dropped to 30-year lows last year, but it remains more prevalent in Washington DC than many cities with similar populations. Since Trump made the deployment official on Monday, the city recorded two homicides, bringing its count for the year up to 101. 'I just feel like it's too much federal overreach. I think it's unnecessary, and I think our MPD does a great job,' said Kevin Cataldo, a neighborhood commissioner whose district includes the block just north of downtown where the 100th homicide of the year took place on Monday, hours after Trump announced the federal takeover. The White House says 800 national guard troops will be on the ground in the city, along with hundreds of federal officers from the Drug Enforcement Administration, border patrol, FBI and other agencies. On Thursday afternoon, a half-dozen unarmed troops, who said they had been told not to talk to the press, could be found milling among the tourists visiting the Lincoln Memorial on the National Mall, an area not known for crime. 'What they are doing right now? It's just a show of force. I did that in Iraq,' said Kevin Davis, a 21-year army veteran visiting the capital from El Paso, Texas. 'When people see the uniform, they act differently.' More prevalent have been the federal agents who have appeared in neighborhoods across the overwhelmingly Democratic city. They began arriving over the weekend, and on Sunday night, a justice department employee was arrested for hurling a sandwich at a Customs and Border Protection official, and later charged with felony assault on a federal officer. Recent evenings have seen federal agents and police set up roadblocks and pull drivers over on major roads, as protesters gathered to condemn them. On Tuesday evening on 14th Street in Columbia Heights, a north-west Washington neighborhood that is home to the city's largest Hispanic population, police and federal agents, some with their faces covered, began stopping cars, said a local shop manager who declined to be named. Before long, dozens of people emerged to berate them. '[Residents] were trying to tell them to leave, you know, the people in the street and the neighbors,' he told the Guardian. 'They yelled back 'don't make the people scared, this is a free country', 'why make the community unsafe?',' the manager said. The scene repeated a little over a mile south on 14th Street on Wednesday evening, with police and federal agents pulling over cars, and locals heckling them and trying to warn approaching drivers away, according to videos posted on social media. Owen Simon, an undergraduate government student at Georgetown University, had heard that agents were spotted in the tony neighborhood around campus, and wondered what they were doing there. Muggings happened occasionally in the neighborhood, but Simon said he was less concerned about those than what the agents might do to foreign students – or students who appeared to be foreign. 'No one wants to walk around knowing that anyone could be scooped up out of the street at any moment,' he said. 'I don't think that this move by the Trump administration is a way to crack down on crime. I think it's about optics.' As he smoked a cigarette in the Home Deport parking lot, Brooks had a similar concern about Congress Heights, the south-east Washington neighborhood where he lives. Crime there is undoubtedly a concern, but it was teenagers who were behind it, not his working-class neighbors. 'You got other people catching strays off that, too,' he said. 'You got working people living in the neighborhood, going to the store, getting picked up because of 16-, 17-year-olds. 'I understand targeting the area, but you can't really blame the people in the area who are trying to do better,' he added. Over the weekend, he had seen eight cars full of federal agents driving through his neighborhood like they wanted to be seen, something he had never witnessed the city police do. 'What is this for?' he wondered. 'It's more of an intimidation tactic.' Joseph Gedeon contributed reporting
South Wales Guardian
40 minutes ago
- South Wales Guardian
Lords does not need ‘Putin apologists like Farage', minister says
In a letter to Sir Keir Starmer, the party leader said that a 'democratic disparity' in the Lords needed to be addressed. Reform has four MPs and controls 10 councils in England. Asked about the party leader's demands, Defence Secretary John Healey said: 'I'm not sure that Parliament's going to benefit from more Putin apologists like Nigel Farage, to be honest.' Asked whether that accusation was 'a bit strong', Mr Healey told LBC: 'Look at what he's said about Russia, look at what he's said about Putin in the past. 'At this point, when maximum pressure needs to be put on Putin to support Ukraine in negotiations, when the maximum condemnation of Putin is required from someone who is sitting down with Trump in Alaska but turning up the attacks on Ukraine, it needs all voices. 'And I have to say, the voice of Reform is conspicuously absent in any of our discussions and any of our defence debates about Ukraine and about Russia.' The minister urged Mr Farage, the MP for Clacton, to start 'weighing in alongside us and the other parties in the House of Commons' in condemning the Russian president. Reform's deputy leader Richard Tice accused the Defence Secretary of 'an absurd smear'. 'Is Mr Healey suffering from a touch of August sunstroke?' he said. During the general election campaign last year, the Reform leader was criticised by leaders from across the political spectrum for suggesting the West provoked the Ukraine war. He also said he disliked the Russian president but 'admired' him as a political operator because 'he managed to take control of running Russia', in a BBC interview. Mr Farage has repeatedly denied being an 'apologist' or 'appeaser' and said he is clear that Mr Putin is to blame for the war. The Reform leader has previously called for Lords reform, writing in an article for the Telegraph in February that 'a smaller chamber is needed'. In his letter to the Prime Minister, first reported by the Times, Mr Farage said: 'Reform UK wishes to appoint life peers to the upper house at the earliest possible opportunity.' In what he described as a 'modest request', he said it was time that Reform was represented in the unelected second chamber. 'My party received over 4.1 million votes at the general election in July 2024. We have since won a large number of seats in local government, led in the national opinion polls for many months and won the only by-election of this parliament,' he said. Political appointments to the Lords are made at the discretion of the Prime Minister, who is under no constitutional obligation to elevate opposition figures but will sometimes ask other leaders to nominate individuals. In December, Sir Keir appointed 30 new Labour peers, including his former chief of staff Sue Gray – which Mr Farage said at the time showed the ruling party's 'lofty ambition' to abolish the Lords had 'fallen by the wayside'. The Conservatives appointed six new peers, while the Liberal Democrats appointed two.
