AI regulation does not stifle innovation
Photo credit: Claudenakagawa / Shutterstocl
Ever since co-founding the All-Party Parliamentary Group on AI nine years ago, still ably administered by the Big Innovation Centre, I've been deeply involved in debating and advising on the implications of artificial intelligence. My optimism about AI's potential remains strong – from helping identify new Parkinson's treatments to DeepMind's protein structure predictions that could transform drug discovery and personalised medicine.
Yet this technology is unlike anything we've seen before. It's potentially more autonomous, with greater impact on human creativity and employment, and more opaque in its decision-making processes.
The conventional wisdom that regulation stifles innovation needs turning on its head. As AI becomes more powerful and pervasive, appropriate regulation isn't just about restricting harmful practices – it's key to driving widespread adoption and sustainable growth. Many potential AI adopters are hesitating not due to technological limitations but Tim Clement-Jones Liberal Democrat peer and spokesperson for the digital economy uncertainties about liability, ethical boundaries and public acceptance. Clear regulatory frameworks addressing algorithmic bias, data privacy and decision transparency can actually accelerate adoption by providing clarity and confidence.
Different jurisdictions are adopting varied approaches. The European Union's AI Act, with its risk-based framework, started coming into effect this year. Singapore has established comprehensive AI governance through its model AI governance framework. Even China regulates public-facing generative AI models with fairly heavy inspection regimes.
The UK's approach has been more cautious. The previous government held the AI Safety Summit at Bletchley Park and established the AI Safety Institute (now inexplicably renamed the AI Security Institute), but with no regulatory teeth. The current government has committed to binding regulation for companies developing the most powerful AI models, though progress remains slower than hoped. Notably, 60 countries – including Saudi Arabia and the UAE, but not Britain or the US – signed the Paris AI Action Summit declaration in February this year, committing to ensuring AI is 'open, inclusive, transparent, ethical, safe, secure and trustworthy'.
Several critical issues demand urgent attention. Intellectual property: the use of copyrighted material for training large language models without licensing has sparked substantial litigation and, in the UK, unprecedented parliamentary debate. Governments need to act decisively to ensure creative works aren't ingested into generative AI models without return to rights-holders, with transparency duties on developers.
Digital citizenship: we must equip citizens for the AI age, ensuring they understand how their data is used and AI's ethical implications. Beyond the UAE, Finland and Estonia, few governments are taking this seriously enough.
Subscribe to The New Statesman today from only £8.99 per month Subscribe
International convergence: despite differing regulatory regimes, we need developers to collaborate and commercialise innovations globally while ensuring consumer trust in common international ethical and safety standards.
Well-designed regulation can be a catalyst for AI adoption and innovation. Just as environmental regulations spurred cleaner technologies, AI regulations focusing on explainability and fairness could push developers toward more sophisticated, responsible systems.
The goal isn't whether to regulate AI, but how to regulate it promoting both innovation and responsibility. We need principles-based rather than overly prescriptive regulation, assessing risk and emphasising transparency and accountability without stifling creativity.
Achieving the balance between human potential and machine innovation isn't just possible – it's necessary as we step into an increasingly AI-driven world. That's what we must make a reality.
This article first appeared in our Spotlight on Technology supplement, of 13 June 2025.
Related
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
4 hours ago
- The Guardian
Out of the shadows: drone-op claims show Israel's Mossad leaning in to its legend
Israelis were celebrating on Friday what many see as a stunning new success by their country's foreign intelligence service, the Mossad. Hours after launching 200 warplanes in a wave of strikes against Iran, Israeli officials released footage they said showed the Mossad agents deep inside Iran assembling missiles and explosive drones aimed at targets near Tehran. According to unnamed security officials who briefed Israeli media, similar precision weapons were launched from trucks smuggled into the country and a 'drone base' hidden somewhere near Tehran. This was established well in advance of Friday's attack and used to destroy Iran's air defences, the officials said. The Mossad, an abbreviation of the Institute for Intelligence and Special Operations in Hebrew, has scored many such victories in almost 80 years of undercover operations, earning a unique reputation for audacious espionage, technological innovation and ruthless violence. The new operation in Iran comes just 10 months after the service managed to sabotage thousands of pagers and walkie-talkies used by Hezbollah operatives in Lebanon, an attack that killed 37 people and injured about 3,000 others while crippling the militant Islamist organisation. The service then contributed to the air offensive that wiped out Hezbollah's leadership in a matter of days. Over decades, the Mossad has built up deep networks of informants, agents and logistics in Iran. This has allowed a series of operations including the assassination with a remote-controlled automatic machine gun of a top Iranian nuclear scientist travelling at speed in a car on a remote road, the infection with malware of computers running key parts of Iran's nuclear programme and the theft of an archive of nuclear documents. Last year, Ismail Haniyeh, the political leader of Hamas, was assassinated with a bomb placed in his favourite room in a government guesthouse in Tehran. 'This most recent operation is impressive, of course, but Iran has been an open book for Israeli intelligence for a decade or more,' said Yossi Melman, a veteran Israeli security reporter and author. Melman said those pictured setting up missile launches in the grainy videos released by the Mossad were likely to be Iranians. 'The boots on the ground inside Iran are not Israeli, so they have to be recruited, trained, equipped, and deployed. Then all the components of the weapons have to be smuggled in. It all needs a lot of professionalism and skill.' Unusually, Israeli officials have highlighted the role of Aman, the military intelligence service, in building up targeting information for the Israeli offensive. Though Aman and the Mossad often work closely, it is the foreign service, much smaller, that gets most of the attention. Even then, most of the Mossad's work is never known outside tightly restricted circles. For decades, few had even heard of the Mossad, which was formally established in 1949. Former agents were ordered not to tell even their family or their previous employment and the service never admitted its involvement in any operation. Yossi Alpher, who took part in some of the service's best-known operations in the 1970s, told the Guardian last year: 'Everything the Mossad did was quiet, no one knew. It was a totally different era. The Mossad was just not mentioned. When I joined, you had to know someone to be brought in. Now, there is a website.' The Mossad's senior officials have long been more likely to spend their time on sensitive diplomatic missions, briefing senior Israeli decision-makers on regional political dynamics or building relationships abroad than recruiting spies or running operations such as that targeting Iran this week. For decades, the Mossad oversaw years-long clandestine efforts to build up 'enemies of Israel's enemies', such as Kurds in Iran, Iraq and Syria, and Christians in what is now South Sudan. As with many of its efforts, this had mixed success. The Mossad is blamed by some for ignoring warnings about the reputation of Maronite Christian militia in Lebanon for brutality and ethnic hatred, and encouraging Israel's disastrous invasion of that country in 1982, in which thousands of civilians were killed. The Mossad also played a significant, though still little-known, role in the covert supply of arms to Ayatollah Khomeini's Iran to help fight Saddam Hussein's Iraq, as part of the Iran-Contra scandal during Ronald Reagan's presidency. The mythical reputation of the Mossad has been bolstered by films and TV series, with screenwriters attracted to some of the service's best-known exploits. One of the most famous is the 1960 capture in Argentina of Adolf Eichmann, a Nazi officer who was a key organiser of the Holocaust. Others include stealing warships from the French navy in 1969, warning of impending attack by Egypt and Syria in 1973 and providing key intelligence for the famous raid on Entebbe, Uganda, in 1976 that freed Jewish and Israeli passengers hijacked by Palestinian and German extremists. In 1980, the service set up and ran a diving resort on Sudan's Red Sea coast as a cover for the clandestine transport of thousands of members of Ethiopia's Jewish community to Israel. The Mossad spies lived among tourists before being forced to close down the operation after five years. After a deadly attack by Palestinian extremists on Israeli athletes at the Munich Olympics in 1972, the Mossad led a campaign to disrupt the networks and groups responsible. The effort ended when a Mossad team shot dead a Moroccan waiter in Norway in the mistaken belief he was a Palestinian Liberation Organization security official, and then made further errors leading to their arrest and trial by local authorities. In 1997, an effort to kill Khaled Meshaal, a powerful Hamas leader, went badly wrong when the Mossad team was caught in Amman by local security forces. Israel was forced to hand over an antidote and relations with Jordan were badly damaged. In 2010, agents were caught on CCTV camera in Dubai during another assassination. Then there is the failure to learn anything that might have warned of the Hamas raids into southern Israel on 7 October that killed 1,200 Israelis, mostly civilians, and led to the abduction of 251. The attack prompted the Israeli offensive in Gaza, the current war with Hezbollah and, indirectly, the new confrontation with Iran. Former Mossad officials say the service only gets noticed when things go wrong. This is not quite true, though – as the release of the Iran videos shows. Melman said one of the Mossad's aims – particularly with the publicity – is to sow fear among Iranians. 'The aim is psychological. The Mossad is telling the Iranian regime: we know everything about you, we can wander into your home when we like, we are an omnipotent force,' said Melman. 'It's also a very good way to boost the morale of the Israeli public.'
Spectator
5 hours ago
- Spectator
The impossible politics of ‘ancestral remains'
In 2002 the remains of Sarah Baartman were buried in her South African homeland. She was among thousands of people around the world from whom body parts were collected in recent centuries and stored or displayed in museums. You might think, as tastes and norms change, returning these remains to their communities a simple thing. But a recent report from an All-Party Parliamentary Group on Afrikan Reparations urging such action has proved controversial among archaeologists. The APPG, chaired by Bell Ribeiro-Addy MP, sets out its recommendations in a policy brief called Laying Ancestors to Rest. It calls for the outlawing of the sale of human remains, an inquiry into the use of 'ancestral remains' in British museums, and museums and 'educational institutions' to stop displaying 'ancestral remains'.
Scottish Sun
13 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Brit & US spy planes high-tail it out of Gulf amid fears of Iran reprisals over Israel's missile and drone blitz
All three planes left Qatar between 4am and 5am local time – as Israel announced it had attacked Iran SPY PLANES QUIT GULF Brit & US spy planes high-tail it out of Gulf amid fears of Iran reprisals over Israel's missile and drone blitz Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A TRIO of British and US spy planes high-tailed it out of the Gulf amid fears of Iran reprisals over Israel's missile and drone blitz. An RAF Rivet Joint plane and two US Rivet Joints scrambled at dawn from Al Udeid airbase in Qatar. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up They all flew back to Europe. The planes are packed with spy sensors for hoovering up signals intelligence and the can monitor air defence radars – providing valuable battlefield intelligence. All three planes left Qatar between 4am and 5am local time – as Israel announced it had attacked Iran. Flight records show the US planes had spent weeks taking turns, on alternate days, to patrol Iran's coast. The RAF jet spent three and a half weeks at the same US Air Base but the UK crew switched off their transponder so there is no publicly available flight data. An RAF source claimed the plane was there support the Royal Navy's aircraft carrier strike group, which is sailing through the region. UK defen The UK's Rivet Joint jets are flown by RAF pilots but mostly crewed by government code-breakers from the GCHQ listening post. The RAF source said the UK spy plane was not involved in Iran operations. They claimed return to base yesterday was 'a coincidence'. Any intelligence collected by the RAF's three Rivet Joints is automatically shared with America. Iran launches wave of missiles at Israel & smoke billows over Tel Aviv after Ayatollah vow to avenge blitz on nuke sites A source said Britain would have been unable to stop America sharing intelligence from British flights with Israel if the Pentagon chose to do so. One of the RAF's three Rivet Joints was nearly shot down by Russia over the Black Sea three years ago. The planes, based at RAF Waddington, Lincs, have been spying on Russia's defences in southern Ukraine and occupied Crimea. The RAF Rivet Joint based in Qatar returned to RAF Waddington yesterday. The US jets flew to Crete. 2 An RAF Rivet Joint plane (stock image) and two US Rivet Joints scrambled at dawn from Al Udeid airbase in Qatar Credit: PA:Press Association
