logo
Inquiry accuses French PM of failing to act over school abuse

Inquiry accuses French PM of failing to act over school abuse

Khaleej Times20 hours ago
Physical and sexual violence at a Catholic school in France persisted for years without any action from Prime Minister Francois Bayrou, who served as education minister between 1993 and 1997, a parliamentary inquiry said on Wednesday.
The scathing report issued by several French lawmakers, who have investigated the claims of abuse at the Notre-Dame de Betharram boarding school, also pointed to "persistent violence" in other French schools, accusing the state of failing to act.
Bayrou, 74, has in recent months faced accusations from the opposition that as education minister he knew of widespread physical and sexual abuse over many decades at the Notre-Dame de Betharram school to which he sent some of his children.
"In the absence of action that the former education minister... had the means to take, this physical and sexual violence against the pupils of Betharram continued for years," the two co-rapporteurs of the inquiry, Violette Spillebout and Paul Vannier, said in a 330-page report.
A member of Bayrou's team took issue with the findings that accused the prime minister of inaction.
"It's exactly the opposite," the official told AFP on condition of anonymity. "No minister after Francois Bayrou organised any verification checks or inspections."
The centrist politician has denied any wrongdoing and denounced what he calls a campaign of "destruction" against him.
"Many of the testimonies we received were beyond my imagination," Vannier told broadcaster France Inter on Wednesday.
"I couldn't imagine acts of torture, children being injected with water, children being deprived of sleep, children being deprived of food to punish them in endless sadistic games for years and years, devastating entire lives," he said.
The conclusions of the parliamentary inquiry, which heard from 135 people including survivors of abuse at other schools, add further pressure on Bayrou, who survived a vote of no confidence on Tuesday.
The commission of inquiry is not expected however to refer the matter to courts.
Named by President Emmanuel Macron in December to bring much-needed stability to the French government, Bayrou's minority coalition depends on the far-right to stay in office and risks being ejected in the autumn in a looming standoff over the budget.
'Absolute sadism'
"This commission of inquiry was a thorough investigation into the unthinkable: children, all over France, subjected to monstrous acts," wrote Fatiha Keloua Hachi, who presided over the commission.
Over the past months, lawmakers heard of sexual violence and "physical violence too, sometimes of an unprecedented severity, of absolute sadism," she said.
In mid-May, Bayrou was questioned for five and a half hours by the lawmakers investigating the violence, in one of the most delicate moments of his time in office. He struck a defiant tone at the time and said he only knew of allegations of sexual abuse from media reports.
Centrist Spillebout and Vannier, a lawmaker with the hard-left France Unbowed party (LFI), said that violence at the Betharram school was systemic.
The violence "was - at least in part - institutionalised", they said, with "a community of prominent figures providing unwavering support".
The lawmakers stressed that the abuse at the Notre-Dame de Betharram school was also "far from being a unique case".
Such violence still persists in private schools, particularly Catholic establishments, the authors said, pointing to a "strong code of silence."
The rapporteurs also deplored "a failing state," with "virtually non-existent" controls and an "inadequate" system of prevention and reporting.
They listed a range of proposals to address the violence including creating a compensation fund for victims.
Around 200 legal complaints have been filed since February last year accusing priests and staff at Betharram of physical or sexual abuse from 1957 to 2004.
Some of the boarders said the experience had scarred them for life, recounting how some priests visited boys at night.
Bayrou's eldest daughter, Helene Perlant, accused the clergy running the school of systemic abuse, saying a priest beat her during summer camp when she was 14. She said however her father did not know about the incident.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

South Africa: Select Committee on Education Sends Deepest and Heartfelt Condolences to East London 'Pens Down' Party Victims
South Africa: Select Committee on Education Sends Deepest and Heartfelt Condolences to East London 'Pens Down' Party Victims

Zawya

time11 hours ago

  • Zawya

South Africa: Select Committee on Education Sends Deepest and Heartfelt Condolences to East London 'Pens Down' Party Victims

The Chairperson of the Select Committee on Education, Sciences and the Creative Industries has learnt with shock of the deaths that occurred following a 'pens-down' party in East London. The committee sends its deepest and heartfelt condolences to the families of the deceased and wishes a speedy recovery to the injured. Two people were reported dead and seven others were injured on the weekend following what seems to be a deliberate attack on party revelers in Nompumelelo Township, just outside East London. A group of local young men, suspected to be a gang, gatecrashed a 'pens-down' party and started attacking those at the tavern. Mr Feni said the incident, the second in a short space of time in the same area, calls for parental guidance and serious reflection on situations in which learners have free access to alcohol. 'It is sad that fatal alcohol-related incidents that often involve learners are becoming a common but worrying occurrence in the country. Social gatherings where learners are allowed to use alcohol should be criminalised. The violence that characterises our society is condemned,' the Chairperson said. 'Society must not tire in condemning the pens-down culture. This is so reminiscent of the recent Enyobeni incident, which is subject of an inquiry, that resulted in the deaths of 21 learners in the same vicinity. We condemn these actions, whether learners were involved or not; law enforcement must also leave no stone unturned in this,' Mr Feni said. Mr Feni said the Eastern Cape Department of Education must assist and determine if any learner had been affected by the incident and provide the necessary support. Distributed by APO Group on behalf of Republic of South Africa: The Parliament.

France's Le Pen hands Bayrou a lifeline, but budget will test her patience
France's Le Pen hands Bayrou a lifeline, but budget will test her patience

Khaleej Times

time20 hours ago

  • Khaleej Times

France's Le Pen hands Bayrou a lifeline, but budget will test her patience

French far right leader Marine Le Pen may have decided to let Prime Minister Francois Bayrou survive this time round, but his days might be numbered. Bayrou survived his eighth no-confidence motion on Tuesday, after a truce struck with the Socialists collapsed over his failure to soften France's pensions reform but Le Pen's far-right National Rally (RN) declined to join the mutiny. Together, the RN and left-wing lawmakers have the numbers to topple the government. Although RN lawmakers, the biggest bloc in parliament, allowed Bayrou to fight another day, their benevolence is unlikely to last long. Le Pen's troops have made it clear that budget talks this autumn will be crunch time for Bayrou, who is struggling to push 40 billion euros in savings through a divided parliament to lower the euro zone's largest deficit and appease increasingly alarmed investors and EU beancounters. "Voting a motion of no-confidence would be a very bad signal to ratings agencies and the IMF. It would be extremely damaging for the country," former Prime Minister Elisabeth Borne, now the education minister in Bayrou's government, told Reuters. Boosted by their newfound power over Bayrou's future, the RN is making ever stricter budgetary demands that are virtually impossible for him to meet. During last year's budget, Le Pen orchestrated the ouster of Bayrou's predecessor Michel Barnier after he refused to respect just one of her four budgetary red lines. Boris Vallaud, the lower house Socialists' leader, said Bayrou's chances of making it to year's end were "very small." RN lawmaker Jean-Philippe Tanguy was less emphatic, saying: "It'll depend on the budget." A June 30 Ifop poll showed Bayrou, never popular, now has an 80% disapproval rating, his worst yet. He will present an outline of his 2026 budget by mid-July, with the text unveiled in late-September. A Bayrou aide said it was too soon to write him off: "I wouldn't underestimate Bayrou's ability to find compromises." RN sources told Reuters Le Pen believes it will be less costly to topple Bayrou in the autumn than now, when the geopolitical situation is fraught. The RN itself is also less unified than it was, after Le Pen was convicted of embezzlement in March, knocking her out of the 2027 presidential race. She aims to overturn her ban, but it has raised the profile of her No. 2, Jordan Bardella, the party president, who will run in 2027 if she cannot. Bardella, who is increasingly showing signs of independence from Le Pen, is keen to push the party towards a more fiscally conservative position and shed some of Le Pen's more socially-minded cost-of-living measures, one RN source said. The source said the RN's 2025 red lines will be maintained and even hardened, by refusing any tax rises in the 2026 budget. Previously it had tolerated tax increases for the wealthiest. The party has also hardened its position on French energy policy, turning against renewables and making nuclear energy a symbol of French national pride that it wants to turn into a key plank of its industrial manifesto. The RN could even file a no-confidence motion if Bayrou decides to bypass parliament to pass a multi-year energy plan by decree. "That would be a casus belli," the source said. In private, Le Pen's lawmakers say they would cast a favourable eye on Defence Minister Sébastien Lecornu, who they see as closer to their line on law and order, as a possible successor to Bayrou. From July 8, Macron can dissolve parliament again and call fresh legislative elections. But he may be wary of plunging France back into chaos at a time of multiple global conflicts and economic uncertainty stemming from US President Donald Trump's trade wars. Dissolving parliament would have the benefit of dislodging Le Pen from her parliamentary seat, but many Macron allies think a new election would be ill-advised, with opinion polls showing the RN and Bardella more popular than ever. "The chances of getting a more governable Assembly than the current one are close to zero," Borne warned.

Macron seeks breakthrough on Iran in first talks with Putin since 2022
Macron seeks breakthrough on Iran in first talks with Putin since 2022

The National

time20 hours ago

  • The National

Macron seeks breakthrough on Iran in first talks with Putin since 2022

French President Emmanuel Macron and his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin discussed how to re-establish international control over Iran's nuclear programme in their first call in nearly three years. The two-hour discussion between the leaders – who stopped talking after Russia's 2022 invasion of Ukraine – was dictated by the urgency of the situation in Iran. The Kremlin described the call as "very substantive" and said it was France that asked for it to take place. Iran's nuclear facilities are believed to have been heavily damaged by US strikes but western powers now fear that Iran will leave the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT). Mr Putin said he was open to discussing Iran's nuclear programme within the 'P5" framework of the permanent members of the United Nations Security Council – Russia, China, France, the UK and the US, people familiar with the matter said. The Russian leader also said he could hold talks bilaterally or within a separate format involving Germany, the UK and France, known as the E3. France views the Iranian nuclear threat as sufficiently serious to justify the involvement of all five countries. Mr Macron is scheduled to speak soon to Chinese President Xi Jinping. Foreign Minister Jean-Noel Barrot on Wednesday said France was 'broadening discussions to other permanent members of the United Nations Security Council who were also signatories to the 2015 agreement' on Iran's nuclear programme, known as the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action or JCPOA. 'It is in this context that the President spoke to Vladimir Putin yesterday,' Mr Barrot said as he addressed the foreign affairs committee at the National Assembly. France and Russia have diverging views on Iran's nuclear programme. Mr Macron recently sided with US and Israeli demands of zero enrichment, while Mr Putin, an Iranian ally, said during his call with the French President on Tuesday evening that it was necessary to respect Iran's right to the peaceful development of nuclear energy. The Kremlin said Mr Putin also insisted that Iran must continue to comply with its obligations under the nuclear non-proliferation treaty. Strikes 'won't stop Iran' US strikes 'certainly damaged and delayed [Iran's nuclear programme] even though it is difficult to have a comprehensive assessment of those military operations', Mr Barrot said. However the strikes 'will not stop Iran from rebuilding its nuclear programme tomorrow', he added. He argued that a 'negotiated solution' was necessary to stop Iran ending co-operation with the International Atomic Energy Agency or leaving the non-proliferation treaty. Some diplomats hope that Iran will be open to negotiations despite taking a hard line against the IAEA. Iran's Deputy Foreign Minister Majid Takht-e Ravanchi told the BBC on Monday that his country was open to resuming diplomatic talks with the US as long as further US strikes were ruled out. Mr Takht-e Ravanchi also said Iran would 'insist' on being able to enrich uranium for what it says are peaceful purposes. In their phone call, the Russian and French presidents also discussed the war in Ukraine. In a context in which both the US and Ukraine are holding talks with Russia, it was important for France to also open a channel of discussions with Mr Putin, informed sources said. Mr Macron asked Mr Putin to set aside old grievances against Ukraine and focus on the current situation. But Mr Putin reiterated his position to Mr Macron that the war was 'a direct consequence of the West's policy', which he said had 'ignored Russia's security interests'. Any possible peace agreement between Russia and Ukraine should have a 'comprehensive and long-term character' and be based on 'new territorial realities', the Kremlin quoted Mr Putin as saying. The Russian President has previously said Ukraine must accept Russia's annexation of swathes of its territory as part of any peace deal. Mr Macron, who briefed Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy before and after the talks with Mr Putin, has said Ukraine alone should decide whether or not to accept territorial concessions.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store