Indian Panthers: NBL team's CEO responds to concerns about pay delays
Indian Panthers CEO Parveen Batish admits players were being short-changed, but said the matter had been resolved ahead of the Rams contest.
'There's some truth in that, I won't deny that – but that's been rectified,' he told Newstalk ZB.
'I had a discussion with three or four of the players, told them what was going to happen.
'Were they OK with what I was planning to do and would they be playing? The answer was yes. And then I heard nothing from them all day.'
Batish said cashflow issues led to payments – which he says amounted to $3,200 – being delayed.
'For a new company, sometimes it's just cashflow. We've come off the back of our largest league in India and so sometimes, that just happens.
'But it wasn't that we didn't communicate what was happening, because we did.
Discover more
'We're not the first company to be in cashflow issues.'
However, a source within the Panthers organisation spoken to by ZB claims that players, coaches and operational staff had yet to be fully paid.
The living conditions were particularly difficult for the team's four overseas players who made the trip to New Zealand, with the source saying the imports were leaning on food banks after being given a credit card that had insufficient funds.
'Everyone is frustrated, everyone is tired and the sad thing is this is the product,' the source told Newstalk ZB.
The source also claimed the team had been without their interim coach Goodman, CEO Batish and their general manager for a fortnight, with the trio based in Melbourne.
'We haven't had practice, there's no training facility and there's no schedule.'
There were also frustrations over the delayed arrival of the team's Indian players.
'Every week we'd ask when the rest of the guys were coming from India and there was no definitive answer.'
The source believes the difficulties faced by Indian players already with the Panthers in New Zealand were putting off their compatriots in India.
Batish acknowledged the issues the new franchise has faced, admitting the team had fallen short of expectations.
'We haven't delivered the product that we promised, so having three Indian players when we should've had eight to 10, that's our fault. So, our overreliance on local players, which has led to this, shouldn't have happened in the first place.'
In a statement, the NBL said they had known about the delayed payments since last Friday and were considering their options regarding the Panthers' future.
Advertise with NZME.
But the Panthers source claims officials from the NBL and Basketball New Zealand had known about the delayed payments for three weeks.
That in turn, led to the planned televised protest against the Rams in an effort to be heard, before the game was canned at the eleventh hour.
It's understood the team's mid-season shift from Takanini to Pukekohe for their home games, was due to the club being unable to afford the operational costs at Pulman Arena.
The source was adamant that there was no future in sight for the Indian Panthers, and that if the franchise continued, the concerns around player payments would heighten.
All 12 clubs – including the Panthers – met league officials, with Batish staking his claim for his franchise to remain.
'I presented to the other clubs and it was a discussion; it was an opportunity for them to ask questions of us and ask questions of the league.
'But there was certainly no consensus out of that meeting to say that our license should be removed. If there was, then there would've been a second meeting that I don't know anything about.'
A source within the NBL confirmed there was only one meeting between the clubs, and that no vote took place.
That same source expected the league to announce the removal of the Indian Panthers license.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
4 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Media Insider: AM transmissions of up to seven Auckland radio stations – including sport and Pacific broadcasts – threatened under RNZ plans to replace transmission masts
At the heart of the looming showdown are two prominent AM transmission masts on either side of Auckland's Northwestern Motorway, at the Lincoln Rd interchange in Henderson. RNZ's AM transmission towers in West Auckland are used by 15 radio stations. Photo / Michael Craig The red and white masts are well-known landmarks; 15 radio stations rely on them for their AM services. There are eight on the 'northern' mast (Radio Waatea, Humm, BBC World Service, Chinese Voices, Newstalk ZB, Rhema, Radio Tarana and Radio Samoa) and seven on the 'southern' mast (531PI, RNZ National, Parliament, APNA, Ake 1179, Gold Sport AM and Sport Nation). According to RNZ, both masts need replacing. The southern mast on Lincoln Rd is 153m high and 70 years old. The northern Selwood Rd mast is 122m high and 91 years old. 'The masts have a design life of 50 years, which RNZ has managed to extend until now,' says RNZ chief technology officer Mark Bullen. RNZ says it needs to remove both masts and – while it insists no final decision has been made – it has proposed replacing just the northern mast. Scotty Stevenson and Israel Dagg host Sport Nation's breakfast show, which broadcasts on 1476AM in Auckland. Sources say RNZ has been prepared to build a new southern mast but only if every existing tenant agrees to pay increased fees. The radio industry is baulking at the proposed fees and wants to see RNZ's costings. Under the one-mast scenario, RNZ would move RNZ National and Parliament from the southern mast to a new northern mast at the expense of at least one and possibly two of the existing northern mast stations. Up to five other stations on the southern mast would also lose their AM transmissions, including Sport Nation – the Entain channel that has live cricket rights – and NZME's Gold Sport AM, which has live rugby rights. Other AM stations on the southern mast are those that cater to specific communities in Auckland, including 531PI for the Pasifika community, APNA for the Indian, Fijian, Bangladeshi, Pakistani and Punjabi communities, and Ake 1179, the official station of Ngāti Whātua. Many of the 15 stations have a digital presence, but for some of them, AM is the main or only means of transmission. The radio industry says New Zealand still has strong AM audiences because of the country's geography, topography and high percentage of second-hand imported cars from Japan with radios that usually go up to only 90FM. Media Insider understands some in the commercial radio industry are infuriated by RNZ's position, believing its proposed costs are inflated. They are also angry about what they label sky-high, ongoing fees RNZ is proposing for those who are lucky enough to have a spot on the new northern mast. The Radio Broadcasters Association has engaged a lawyer and fired a shot across RNZ's bow, threatening legal action. It is understood that the lawyer has told RNZ that withdrawing transmission services would come at a high cost for the public and broadcasters. And that from a charter, public law and a plurality perspective, this included broadcasting to the Pacific Island, Samoan, Chinese, Indian, Māori, and Christian communities. 531PI hosts specialist Pacific language shows on the AM frequency each week. RNZ's position RNZ would not agree to chief executive Paul Thompson being interviewed for this story, instead providing a statement because it said it was in the middle of consultation with the industry. RNZ chief executive Paul Thompson. Photo / Mark Mitchell RNZ's Mark Bullen said in the statement that 'no legal proceedings have commenced'. 'While RNZ cannot speak to the specific intentions of the co-siters, we are in ongoing conversation with them,' he said. Bullen said RNZ had engaged with the industry about AM transmission at its Henderson sites 'for many years'. 'Based on structural engineers' reports, we have decided to decommission both towers by June 2026 to ensure the health and safety of both sites,' Bullen said. RNZ's transmission towers have been features of the West Auckland skyline for decades. Photo / Michael Craig 'The building of a new mast on the northern site would be sufficient to meet RNZ's transmission needs. 'RNZ is now talking to broadcasters ... about the financial viability of building a new mast on the southern site. Whether there are sufficient clients and ongoing revenue to make it financially prudent for RNZ to invest in the southern site [is] part of RNZ's consideration.' He said if RNZ decided 'not to fund the mast, RNZ is open to ideas from co-siters that would provide other viable, funded plans'. 'RNZ has also had discussions with Government officials on technical options around additional FM services, but were advised this is not viable.' Bullen said replacing both masts would cost in the range of $7 million, with the southern mast estimated to be close to $3m. 'In summary, no final decision has been taken on the southern site and we are awaiting further feedback from co-siters who we have been engaging with regularly.' The industry's position Radio Broadcasters Association chair Jana Rangooni said the association had known for some time that the towers might need to be replaced or relocated. 'Until December last year, we had understood RNZ was looking at a range of options to do this,' Rangooni said. 'Our members and other broadcasters became concerned when a consultation process started in December. It appeared RNZ only intended to rebuild the northern tower. This means all southern tower AM radio stations could be taken off air, along with a number of the northern tower stations RNZ wants to move off that tower to accommodate themselves. 'We believe this raises numerous commercial and public law issues that we have flagged to RNZ on behalf of our members.' Radio Broadcasters Association chairwoman Jana Rangooni says RNZ's plans for the towers raise commercial and public law issues. Photo / Supplied Rangooni said she understood all broadcasters wanted to continue to broadcast on both towers at reasonable fees, similar to current pricing. 'We are aware RNZ is requiring increased fees of 200% to 400% uplift on these. 'We believe the option to provide both towers at current prices is a viable one for RNZ, taking into account that the northern tower needs to be built for them to remain broadcasting. The transmission profits they have made from the commercial broadcasters in the past decade would fund most of the southern tower. 'We would not expect commercial operators to be subsidising RNZ operations. We have expected that profits would be recognised towards tower replacement, given their age and well-known need for replacement.' She said the association was also concerned RNZ would not meet with association members as an industry group 'to discuss all possible options'. This included 'any joint approaches that might need to be made to the minister or relevant ministry'. 'We believe the option to build both towers based on current fees is a viable and indeed sensible one for a public broadcaster. Should they decide not to, we, along with the impacted broadcasters, will look at all avenues open to us to ensure the respective Pacific, Asian, religious, sporting and other audiences do not lose the services they rely on. 'Recognising these audiences fits well with the role of RNZ in the public interest at a time all New Zealand radio organisations are focused on maintaining and growing our local audiences.' NZME chief audio officer Jason Winstanley said the company - which also owns the NZ Herald and Newstalk ZB - was disappointed with RNZ's position. NZME believed it was financially viable for the southern tower to be rebuilt. 'We don't believe the proposed cost increase to accommodate the rebuild of both towers is required, based on the financial modelling we've done,' said Winstanley. 'We have requested Radio NZ's modelling several times, but they have declined to provide it. We believe the millions of dollars all broadcasters have paid to date should be used to maintain and rebuild the towers. 'If the southern tower isn't rebuilt, 1332AM would cease broadcasting in Auckland. At that point, for Gold Sport to continue in Auckland, we'd need to find another frequency for it. We're urging Radio NZ to fully explore all options before a final decision is made by their board.' Brian Kelly hosts Gold AM's The Country Sport Breakfast, which broadcasts on 1332AM in Auckland. Photo / Alex Cairns MediaWorks director of content Leon Wratt told Media Insider: 'MediaWorks is continuing to work through the RBA with RNZ towards both AM towers at Henderson being replaced so all stations, including Humm on 702AM, remain on-air. With Henderson being Auckland's sole AM transmission site, the future of these stations now sits with RNZ.' Entain Australia and New Zealand chief media officer Christopher Haigh said the company was 'actively working through potential distribution challenges with RNZ and are committed to bringing Sport Nation to audiences around the country'. 'We'll keep working on our AM/FM coverage plans, alongside bolstering our digital content offering, that already includes livestreaming of sport like cricket, netball and rugby league amongst others.' While Sport Nation has an AM frequency in Auckland, it does not have an FM frequency. Pacific Media Network Pacific Media Network chief executive Don Mann. Photo / Mike Scott Another impacted station is 531PI, operated by the Pacific Media Network, on the southern mast. It broadcasts 10 specific languages across specialist shows each week. 'If that southern tower goes, there won't be any AM transmission of pan-Pacific languages in Auckland,' said PMN chief executive Don Mann. 'It'll be the end of terrestrial AM transmission of publicly-funded Pacific languages.' 531PI is not part of the GFK radio ratings survey, but Mann said Pacific Media Network, through its various platforms, targeted the 440,000 Pacific Islanders living in New Zealand, about 275,000 of whom were in Auckland. 'Our roots are in linear terrestrial transmission, but we do use third-party platforms, we do use multimedia. We do use visual content, and we stream. 'But the issue is that target audience. The target audience for 531AM, given that it's a language channel, is the Pacific people [for whom] English is not their first language. 'Their first language is Pacific. It's generally an older audience that's been trained over 35 years to listen by appointment on linear radio.' For example, the Tongan community knew their show was broadcast at 3pm every Wednesday; the Samoan community knew their show was on 3pm every Thursday. While PMN had made strong gains and growth in multimedia, Mann said there were still issues for some in the Pasifika community not having easy access to online connectivity or devices. Mann said the industry accepted there was probably a limited timespan for AM transmission, whether that was 'five years or 10 years, or whatever, I don't know'. It was an issue being grappled with across the world. AM still played a critical role in emergency situations, and for ethnic communities, that timespan tail was likely a bit longer when they relied on specialist languages. 'It will be a critical situation if we just turn off terrestrial broadcasting to an older Pacific audience.' Radio Tarana chief executive Robert Khan said Tarana was offered a position on the new northern tower, but the fees had doubled. 'If we don't accept it, we're out of business, quite frankly. The choice was yay or nay - yay if you want your lifeline, nay if you don't want your lifeline.' Further questions for RNZ Media Insider went back to RNZ with further questions on Friday. 'RNZ has not made a final decision on the southern mast. If we decide not to fund the replacement mast, then RNZ is open to ideas from co-siters that would provide viable plans consistent with our charter,' said a spokesman. RNZ says it has been through a fair and robust process with other broadcasters over future AM transmission options. Photo / Michael Craig 'RNZ has a primary responsibility to prudently use its funding to create public media content for audiences. That means we need to ensure all infrastructure investment is affordable while also providing the best value to New Zealanders. RNZ is not established as an infrastructure provider to other broadcasters who have independently secured AM licences from the Crown. 'To fund a southern mast, RNZ must be able to recover its costs and take into account the risks and uncertainties involved. This means we have proposed an increase in fees. 'The majority of RNZ's infrastructure investment has been in maintaining its AM network, which has never been profit-driven. The goal has been to maintain a resilient national network for our services, given our statutory emergency lifeline role.' RNZ did not directly respond to a question about why it had not met the industry as a group but said it had embarked on a 'fair and robust process' with each broadcaster. Editor-at-Large Shayne Currie is one of New Zealand's most experienced senior journalists and media leaders. He has held executive and senior editorial roles at NZME including Managing Editor, NZ Herald Editor and Herald on Sunday Editor and has a small shareholding in NZME. Watch Media Insider - The Podcast on YouTube, or listen to it on iHeartRadio, Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
RNZ News
4 days ago
- RNZ News
RNZ recognised at Radio and Podcast Awards
Alexa Cook (left) won best journalist, while Kate Green was awarded best new journalist. Photo: RNZ RNZ has won plaudits for its news and podcasts at the annual Radio and Podcast Awards. RNZ's Alexa Cook won best journalist, and reporter Kate Green was awarded best new journalist. RNZ's journalism was also recognised for best team coverage on the sinking of the HMNZS Manawanui . RNZ was also a finalist in the category for its coverage of the Tangi of Kiingi Tuheitia. RNZ won five podcast categories, including best podcast producer or producing team. The Detail , a Newsroom production for RNZ, again picked up best news and current affairs podcast. Nellie's Baby , a hit podcast by RNZ investigative journalist Kirsty Johnston, won best society and culture podcast. In the radio categories, Newstalk ZB's Mike Hosking was awarded best talk presenter, ahead of stablemate Heather du Plessis, RNZ's Lisa Owen for Checkpoint and Morning Report' s Corin Dann and Ingrid Hipkiss. Sunday Morning host Jim Mora was recognised for services to broadcasting. Newstalk ZB won network station of the year and More FM Northland won local station of the year. The Sir Paul Holmes Broadcaster of the Year was Newstalk ZB's Heather du Plessis-Allan. The full list of winners is here . Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
NZ Herald
4 days ago
- NZ Herald
Media Insider: Radio and Podcast Awards - Newstalk ZB wins station of the year, Heather du Plessis-Allan named broadcaster of the year
Newstalk ZB has won station of the year for a record fifth straight year at tonight's NZ Radio and Podcast Awards, and Drive host Heather du Plessis-Allan has been awarded the top individual prize of broadcaster of the year. More FM Northland won best local radio station and Radio Tarana
