logo
Supreme Court signals it may rule on law protecting power of minority voters

Supreme Court signals it may rule on law protecting power of minority voters

Washington Post3 days ago
The Supreme Court has signaled that it may rule on the constitutionality of a key section of the landmark Voting Rights Act that allows states to draw majority-minority voting districts mainly to protect the power of Black and Hispanic voters.
The justices on Friday evening asked opposing parties in a battle over a Louisiana voting map to submit briefs addressing whether the state's creation of a second Black majority congressional district violated constitutional provisions that require all people to be treated equally. The district covers areas stretching from Shreveport to Baton Rouge.
'The stakes here are enormous,' Rick Hasen, a law professor at UCLA and an expert on election law, wrote on his blog.
Black voters and civil rights groups sued Louisiana in 2022 under the Voting Rights Act, saying the state's then new congressional map diluted their voting power. One of six congressional districts consisted of a majority-minority population in a state where roughly a third of voters are Black. That district covers New Orleans and parts of Baton Rouge.
The Voting Rights Act allows states in some circumstances to consider race in drawing districts as a means to redress discriminatory electoral practices, but maps that are explicitly based on race violate the 14th Amendment's Equal Protection Clause. States must carefully thread those competing directives.
Federal courts ruled for the plaintiffs in the Louisiana case, and the state redrew the map in 2024, creating the second majority-Black congressional district. A group of self-described 'non-African American' voters then sued, claiming the map was an unconstitutional racial gerrymander that violated the Equal Protection Clause.
The case made its way to the Supreme Court last term, but the justices put off a decision to allow for additional briefing. The order issued on Friday clarified the legal issues the court wanted to consider more fully. The court is likely to decide the case during its next term, which begins in October.
Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act, which is one of the cornerstones of civil rights era law, prohibits racial discrimination in voting practices. States have long drawn majority-minority districts to meet its provisions and protect minority voters against gerrymandered maps that diminish their power.
'What the Court seems to be asking, without directly saying it, is whether Section 2 of the VRA, at least as to how it has been applied to require the creation of majority-minority districts in some circumstances, violates a colorblind understanding of the Constitution,' Hasen wrote.
A broad ruling by the court striking down the second Black majority district in Louisiana could pare back the use of race-based redistricting. The case could also affect the balance of power in a closely divided Congress. Currently, the newly created second majority Black district is held by a Democrat.
In 2013, a divided Supreme Court invalidated another important part of the Voting Rights Act, which required certain mostly Southern states with a history of discriminatory voting practices to get federal clearance before changing voting rules. The states included Louisiana.
In 2023, the high court prohibited Alabama from using a voting map that the justices found unlawfully diminished the power of Black voters.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Priest's Daughter Told a Friend She Was Nervous Before ‘Routine' Visa Hearing. Then She Was Detained by ICE for 5 Days
Priest's Daughter Told a Friend She Was Nervous Before ‘Routine' Visa Hearing. Then She Was Detained by ICE for 5 Days

Yahoo

time5 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Priest's Daughter Told a Friend She Was Nervous Before ‘Routine' Visa Hearing. Then She Was Detained by ICE for 5 Days

'The pain, fear, and uncertainty she and her family endured over the past five days should never have happened,' an official said after Yeonsoo Go's releaseNEED TO KNOW A 20-year-old college student and priest's daughter was detained by immigrant officials following a visa hearing on July 31 Four days later, she was released on her own recognizance after the religious community rallied around her The U.S. Department of Homeland Security claimed that she "overstayed her visa that expired more than two years ago," but an attorney for the Episcopal Diocese of New York denies that, saying her visa was valid through the end of the yearA college student — and daughter of an Episcopal priest — was detained after a standard visa hearing in New York City. Days later, she was reunited with her mom after she was brought back to Manhattan from a Louisiana detention center. 'Everything just feels surreal,' Yeonsoo Go, 20, said after she was allowed to leave Federal Plaza Immigration Court with her mother, Rev. Kyrie Kim, on the evening of Monday, Aug. 4, CW affiliate WPIX reported. 'I always had faith that I would be out soon,' she added, according to CNN affiliate WCBS. Before her arrest, the Purdue University student — who moved to the United States from South Korea with her mom back in 2021 — told a friend she was nervous because of the wave of detainments under the Trump administration, the outlet reported. Then, on Thursday, July 31, Go's fears became reality. Mary Davis, an attorney for the Episcopal Diocese in New York, where Go's mother is a priest, told CNN that the hearing was part of the process to convert her religious worker's dependent visa, known as a R-2 visa, to a student visa. In a separate interview with NBC News, Marissa Joseph, identified as Go's attorney, said the student was renewing her visa because her mother had changed employers. On July 31, Go was told she was due back in court in October, but when she and her mother exited the courthouse, ICE agents were waiting for the young woman, ABC affiliate WABC, FOX affiliate WNYW and CNN reported. 'They thought they had come for a routine hearing, for due process, and they really fell into a black hole of unknown,' Davis told CNN affiliate WCBS, adding that Go was 'absolutely terrified.' Neither attorney immediately responded to PEOPLE's request for comment. In a statement obtained by PEOPLE before her release, U.S. Department of Homeland Security Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin claimed that Go had "overstayed her visa that expired more than two years ago." However, lawyers for the Episcopal Diocese of New York have denied this, saying that her visa wasn't set to expire until December. 'We have no idea why they are alleging this, because we have a piece of paper that says she has a visa till December 2025,' Davis told NBC News. 'This is what lack of due process does. We have evidence on our side. They're making allegations. We are not being given the opportunity to sort it out.' DHS and ICE did not immediately respond to PEOPLE's questions about Go's release. Go's case is one of a number making headlines since President Trump returned to the White House and began cracking down on immigration. While Trump's successful campaign was centered on a law enforcement message to 'seal' the southern border and remove millions of migrants in the country illegally — with a focus on dangerous people and people with criminal backgrounds — some of the deportations have stirred debate. The local religious community was 'heartbroken' by Go's detainment, Rev. Anne Marie Witchger, a priest of St. Mark's Church in-the-Bowery and a colleague of Rev. Kim, tells PEOPLE. 'Soo came to this country legally and is lawfully here,' says Rev. Witchger, adding that both Go, who is gearing up her second year at Purdue University, and her mom are 'important members of the community.' Following the 20-year-old student's arrest, the religious community rallied around her, and a GoFundMe has been created to help with legal fees. "We call for the end of weaponization in our courts," Rt. Rev. Matthew Heyd, Bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of New York, said while advocating for her release over the weekend, according to WNYW. "We stand up for a New York and a country that respects the dignity of every person." Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. Following Go's release, New York Assemblymember Amy Paulin released a statement of support. 'The pain, fear, and uncertainty she and her family endured over the past five days should never have happened,' Paulin wrote. 'But tonight we celebrate her freedom and the strength of a community that refused to stay silent.' Lawyers told WABC that the student's case is ongoing and they are cooperating with government officials. As Davis told CNN, 'We've worked very hard for our voices to be heard and to lift her up, and to convey the message that Soo does not deserve to be in detention and…it's been heard.' Read the original article on People

Purdue University student freed from ICE detention after outcry from faith leaders
Purdue University student freed from ICE detention after outcry from faith leaders

Washington Post

time8 hours ago

  • Washington Post

Purdue University student freed from ICE detention after outcry from faith leaders

A Purdue University student from South Korea has been freed from federal detention, tearfully reuniting with her family and religious community in Manhattan following days of outcry from faith leaders in New York and abroad. Yeonsoo Go, 20, was taken into custody on Thursday during a routine immigration hearing in Manhattan, according to her attorneys and family. She was then transferred to a federal detention facility in Monroe, Louisiana, where she was held for three nights before being released without bail on Monday.

Purdue University student freed from ICE detention after outcry from faith leaders
Purdue University student freed from ICE detention after outcry from faith leaders

Associated Press

time8 hours ago

  • Associated Press

Purdue University student freed from ICE detention after outcry from faith leaders

A Purdue University student from South Korea has been freed from federal detention, tearfully reuniting with her family and religious community in Manhattan following days of outcry from faith leaders in New York and abroad. Yeonsoo Go, 20, was taken into custody on Thursday during a routine immigration hearing in Manhattan, according to her attorneys and family. She was then transferred to a federal detention facility in Monroe, Louisiana, where she was held for three nights before being released without bail on Monday. Mary Rothwell Davis, an attorney for the Episcopal Diocese of New York, where Go's mother works as a priest, said the family had not received an explanation for the arrest or abrupt reversal. 'We don't know why it happened, but we're very happy that it did,' Davis said. 'We were moving heaven and earth to make it known that we thought this was a mistake.' A spokesperson for the Department of Homeland Security said Go had been placed in expedited removal proceedings for overstaying an expired visa. The agency did not respond to questions about what prompted Go's release. 'The fact of the matter is those who are in our country illegally have a choice — they can leave the country voluntarily or be arrested and deported,' agency spokesperson Tricia McLaughlin said in a statement. But Davis disputed the contention that Go was here illegally. She said Go has maintained a valid visa since arriving in the U.S. in 2021, along with her mother, Rev. Kyrie Kim, who leads a Korean congregation in the New York area. A graduate of Scarsdale High School in the suburbs of New York City, Go studies at Purdue's College of Pharmacy and remains active in the Episcopalian church, according to Davis. In recent days, clergy members, including Bishop Matthew Heyd, as well as the church leaders in Korea, have called on the Trump administration to release Go, insisting that her arrest was a mistake. 'Whether it was our outcry or some other factor that persuaded DHS to send her home, we don't know, but we're so grateful,' Davis said, adding that Go's experience in detention was 'unbelievably traumatic.' New York State Assemblymember Amy Paulin, a Democrat, said she had spoken by phone with Go, who she described as 'relieved' to be home. 'She is home, she is safe, and she is so grateful for the outpouring of love and support from this incredible community,' Paulin said.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store