Award judges resign after Queensland state library strips writer's prize over Hamas tweet
The 2022 Stella award winning poet Evelyn Araluen, Wiradjuri academic and writer Dr Jeanine Leane, writer and reviewer Nigel Featherstone and Gamilaroi poet Luke Patterson all confirmed to Guardian Australia on Friday they have resigned from the awards' judging panels. It is believed several other judges have also resigned, but wish to remain anonymous.
Wyld, who now writes under the name K A Ren Wyld, first learned her black&write! fellowship for her manuscript on the Stolen Generations had been withdrawn from a News Corp journalist on Tuesday morning, just hours before she was due to accept the award in Brisbane. Wyld said at a meeting called shortly after the journalist made contact, the library chief executive, Vicki McDonald, referred to a tweet Wyld had posted about the death of the Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar in October, which referred to him as a martyr. Wyld deleted the tweet shortly after posting it.
On Friday, the State Library of Queensland confirmed it had received a written direction from the state arts minister, John-Paul Langbroek, on Monday stating: 'It is my firm view and direction under Section 23 of the Libraries Act 1988 and I am sure the view of most Queenslanders, that Ms Wyld should not receive the award in a Queensland Government or State Library of Queensland venue.'
A spokesperson for Langbroek told the Guardian the minister supported the library's decision to postpone the awards, and stood by the comments he made in parliament where he said that taxpayer-funded awards should not be granted 'to individuals who justify terrorism'.
Earlier this week, a statement by a spokesperson for McDonald said the library's decision to 'postpone the black&write! ceremony' had been made after Langbroek's comments in parliament, in which he said he had 'taken the decision that this award should not be presented' at the state library.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
In Araluen's letter of resignation to the library, the Dropbear author told McDonald she was 'disgusted' by the library's decision to rescind Wyld's fellowship and the Queensland government's 'flagrant ministerial overreach', and was withdrawing as a judge in the Queensland literary awards' Judith Wright Calanthe award.
'I will not participate in a system that values thought-policing and the silencing of anti-genocidal sentiments over the integrity of artists,' she wrote.
'By conceding to this flagrant weaponisation of the mere perception of a bad-faith assumption of anti-Semitism, wielded against a First Nations author who has been so central to the Blak literary community, the State Library have made themselves liable for the consequences of this decision.
'The reputational harm of this choice will not be ignored by the literary and First Nations community.'
Featherstone, a judge in the awards' fiction category, said he was unwilling to participate in a process where a panel's recommendations could be overruled by the arts minister, 'in effect, imposing further political silencing'.
He told the Guardian there were two 'eminently competitive' books nominated in the category he was judging that dealt directly with the conflict in Gaza.
'Should the panel decide that those titles and their authors be shortlisted, or if one is recommended as the winner, will the minister be overturning those decisions too?' he asked.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
Fellow fiction prize judge Leane said after careful thought she decided she had no other option than to resign.
'I cannot be complicit in this discourse that denies genocide and that tries to shut down any artist, not just First Nations, any artist or writer who wants to speak out against what is happening in Palestine,' she said.
'Ren's manuscript was not about Palestine, it was actually about the cultural genocide here … they're shutting down two discussions here … they're shutting down two truths.'
The Australian Society of Authors said it intended to write to the Queensland premier and the arts minister to 'call for a strong stance on freedom of expression and independent arts funding processes'.
'This represents yet another alarming instance of the undermining of freedom of expression and arms-length arts funding,' the ASA said in a statement.
'It sets a dangerous precedent for creators – irrespective of their political views – that opportunities awarded on the basis of literary merit can be retracted if the creator is subject to complaints about their political ideas and expressions. It is vital that arts funding opportunities are independent from government interference.'
The library declined to comment on the judges' resignations.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Writers festival requires ‘complete self-censorship' over Gaza war, academic says, as speakers withdraw in protest
A number of authors and academics have withdrawn from this weekend's Bendigo Writers festival over a speaker code that one says requires 'complete self-censorship' over Israel's war in Gaza. Academic and author Dr Randa Abdel-Fattah, First Nations poet Dr Evelyn Araluen and Wiradjuri writer and poet Jeanine Leane are among those who have withdrawn from the festival over the code. Prof Clare Wright, a guest curator at the festival and Latrobe University academic, has also withdrawn for personal and professional reasons which include the code, a source told Guardian Australia. Author Kate Mildenhall, who was due to moderate a festival session, said she was not sent the code of conduct but has since become aware of it. 'In solidarity with the other writers who are withdrawing and also because of my own personal beliefs about the ideas of censorship I felt I was unable to continue with my participation in the writers festival,' she said. The festival's code, viewed by Guardian Australia, says speakers should uphold respectful engagements which involves avoiding language or topics that 'could be considered inflammatory, divisive, or disrespectful'. A source told Guardian Australia Bendigo Writers festival (BWF) sent some speakers the code of conduct on Wednesday – two days before the opening day. The code says that for 'La Trobe Presents panels', speakers must comply with the principles espoused in La Trobe University's Anti-Racism Plan, including the plan's definitions of antisemitism and Islamophobia. Dr Abdel-Fattah, a Macquarie University academic, said she could not appear at the festival 'as a Palestinian'. 'The actual wording of [the speaker code and La Trobe policy] requires me to engage in complete self-censorship, so, such as a profound act of gaslighting,' she said. La Trobe's 2025-2030 plan adopts University Australia's antisemitism definition. The adoption of a sector-wide definition earlier this year emerged as a key recommendation of a report on antisemitism on Australian university campuses, which found there was an 'urgent need for reform' to ensure the safety of Jewish students and staff. The definition states that antisemitism is: 'discrimination, prejudice, harassment, exclusion, vilification, intimidation or violence that impedes Jews' ability to participate as equals in educational, political, religious, cultural, economic or social life'. It states that criticism of the policies and practices of the Israeli government or state is 'not in and of itself antisemitic' but further reads: 'Criticism of Israel can be antisemitic when it is grounded in harmful tropes, stereotypes or assumptions and when it calls for the elimination of the State of Israel or all Jews or when it holds Jewish individuals or communities responsible for Israel's actions …' Some academics at Australian universities have warned the definition could have a 'chilling' effect and limit the scope of what can be taught on the Middle East. Abdel-Fattah said La Trobe's anti-racism plan makes no mention of anti-Palestinian racism. It includes a definition of Islamophobia – discrimination that may be racial, religious or cultural in nature and is defined as an irrational fear, hatred or prejudice of Islam, Muslims, Islamic traditions and practices, and those who appear to be Muslim. Abdel-Fattah said her new novel, Discipline, is centred on the story of a Palestinian author and journalist. 'The book is all about how their voices are repressed and censored and how their voices are managed through the language of policies, through the language of civility and politeness and not offending others,' she said. La Trobe University is one of the festival's partners. Wright was a guest curator of the festival's 'La Trobe Presents panels'. Araluen, a Goorie and Koori poet, said she hoped audiences would reconsider whether they wanted to attend a festival that has made it impossible for people to speak openly about their work, experiences or perspectives. 'It's really important to make sure that the art sector is not divorced from law and from policy and from morality,' she said. 'You can't place this form of censorship on artists and writers when we're being told to discuss things like First Nations, languages and the history of political representation of Aboriginal people, as is the event that I was programmed to speak on.' The programme of the two-day festival in regional Victoria says it includes events featuring 80 writers and speakers. The Bendigo Writers festival and La Trobe University have been contacted for comment.
The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
Albanese says ‘Hamas will engage in propaganda' amid confusion over statements on Palestinian statehood
Anthony Albanese has warned media about Hamas propaganda, amid confusion regarding statements reportedly made by the terrorist group in relation to Australia's pledge to recognise a Palestinian state. Nine newspapers reported on Wednesday that the Hamas co-founder and senior official Sheikh Hassan Yousef had welcomed the decision, praising Australia's 'political courage' and calling on other countries to follow its example. But the group later said Yousef was in jail and not able to communicate with media outlets. Nine clarified on Thursday that the statement was from Yousef's office not the man himself. Australian Associated Press reported that Hamas's foreign relations chief, Istanbul-based Dr Basem Naim, had poured cold water on the veracity of the Yousef statement. 'Sheikh Yousef is in an Israeli jail for years now. I'm very surprised ... I doubt it's true,' he said referring to the statement attributed to Yousef. Guardian Australia reported the government's response to Nine's Wednesday report and the quotes attributed to Yousef. Critics of the Albanese government, including the federal Coalition and conservative media commentators, seized on the statement attributed to Yousef when attacking Labor's decision to recognise Palestine. The opposition's foreign affairs spokesperson, Michaelia Cash, claimed Albanese should 'hang his head in shame after being praised today by the terrorist group Hamas'. The opposition leader, Sussan Ley, pointed to 'the Hamas co-founder praising our prime minister for this decision'. Nine clarified on Thursday the statement had been issued by Yousef's political office in the West Bank, which it said 'issues statements on his behalf', and that Yousef was in prison. A statement on an English-language Telegram channel, purportedly run by Hamas, stated that Yousef was 'being held in poor conditions and is cut off from the outside world, with no means of communication with local or international press outlets'. It denied he had made any statement on Australia's recognition of a Palestinian state. AAP reported Naim referred to the Telegram statement, confirming its veracity. Albanese on Thursday said: 'Hamas do not want a two-state solution.' 'What they want is one state,' the prime minister said. 'And I noticed in the [Telegram] statement that's made today, they say that the alleged statement from the person yesterday is someone who's been in prison in Israel since October 2023 and has no means of communication. 'What that should be is a warning to the media, of being very careful about the fact that Hamas will engage in propaganda. Because what is happening is the international community is united about isolating Hamas, about supporting a peaceful way forward.' Ley on Thursday again claimed the terrorist group had given 'full-throated praise of the prime minister'. The government on Wednesday cautioned against legitimising the statement attributed to Yousef, with a spokesperson claiming Hamas 'always tries to manipulate facts for their own propaganda'. 'Media have a responsibility to make professional judgments to not promote propaganda of terrorist organisations to get cynical headlines,' they said. Nine on Thursday said the earlier statement attributed to Yousef had been provided by his political office in the occupied West Bank 'which issues statements on his behalf'. Nine said Yousef's office 'confirmed it had released the statement and that Youssef was still in jail'. Nine on Wednesday initially reported: 'Yousef, one of Hamas' most senior leaders in the occupied West Bank, said in a statement to this masthead.' Nine later added a clarification noting 'this story has been updated to clarify the statement was issued by Sheikh Hassan Yousef's office and that he is held in prison. A subsequent statement issued via a Telegram channel in Hamas's name has also been added to the story'. Nine declined to comment further. The ABC on Wednesday reported on a statement attributed to the Hamas media director, Ismail Al-Thawabta, that Australia's move to recognise a Palestinian state 'reflects a growing global awareness of the necessity to end the injustice suffered by our people for decades'. 'We call on the Australian government to translate this recognition into concrete actions — by exerting diplomatic pressure to end the Israeli occupation,' the ABC reported Al-Thawabta as saying. Guardian Australia sought comment from Al-Thawabta and the Hamas-run Ministry of Information in Gaza. – Additional reporting Australian Associated Press
Daily Mail
4 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Bombshell twist in Hamas statement praising Anthony Albanese's Palestine move
Hamas has distanced itself from comments reportedly made by one of its co-founders praising Anthony Albanese's decision to recognise Palestinian statehood. Sheikh Hassan Yousef, a co-founder of Hamas and one of its most senior figures in the West Bank, purportedly told Nine Newspapers on Wednesday he welcomed the 'political courage' of the Labor government. He also claimed the decision to recognise Palestine vindicated Hamas' s October 7 attack - the worst massacre of Jews since the Holocaust. But now a statement published on Hamas's English-language Telegram channel on Thursday has 'denie(d) the issuance of any statement by Sheikh Hassan Yousef, detained in occupation jails since October 19, 2023, on the Australian position regarding the recognition of the Palestinian state'. 'Hamas affirms that Sheikh Hassan is held in poor detention conditions, cut off from the outside world, and has no means of communication with any local or international press outlets,' the statement added. This was echoed by Albanese, who told reporters he would 'not be a cheer squad for Hamas'. 'What that should be is a warning to the media to be very careful about the fact that Hamas will engage in propaganda, because what is happening is that the international community are united about isolating Hamas, about supporting a peaceful way forward,' Albanese added. He urged the media not to 'repeat Hamas's propaganda'. Nine Newspapers, who broke the original statement said to be from Yousef, reported on Thursday that the comments had been provided by the former Hamas leader's 'office in Beitunia, a town near Ramallah in the occupied West Bank, which issues statements on his behalf'. Despite the apparent disconnect, Hamas still issued a statement applauding the Labor government's decision to recognise Palestine. 'Such a move reflects a growing global awareness of the necessity to end the injustice suffered by our people for decades,' Hamas media director Ismail Al-Thawabta told the ABC. 'We call on the Australian government to translate this recognition into concrete actions — by exerting diplomatic pressure to end the Israeli occupation.' The Opposition has predictably seized on the decision to recognise Palestinian statehood, with Liberal deputy leader Sussan Ley accusing the Prime Minister of 'making a real mess of this.' 'On the same day, a listed terror organisation calls our prime minister a hero, while our closest ally, the US, says that these actions are going to make peace in the region less likely,' she told Nine on Thursday morning. 'So, it's really quite extraordinary, because remember, the Prime Minister used justification for this decision by saying Hamas would not be involved. 'And I saw the Treasurer yesterday saying, 'Oh, Hamas will have no role in a future Palestinian state.' Really? As if we can control these things?' In response, an Australian government spokesperson stuck to the line that their decision was designed to 'isolate Hamas' - before tacitly criticising the media for airing Hamas's position Shadow Foreign Minister Michaelia Cash said the decision was a gift to the proscribed terrorist group. 'All Australians should be appalled at the massive propaganda victory Mr Albanese has handed Hamas on a platter,' Cash said on Wednesday. The decision also provoked the ire of Israel, with the country's Foreign Minister Gideon Sa'ar reposting a news article about Hamas praising Albanese. 'Hamas loves Anthony Albanese,' Sa'ar wrote, using a heart emoji for 'loves'. On Monday, the Prime Minister announced that Australia would recognise Palestinian statehood at the United Nations next month, following similar commitments from other Western allies, including the UK, France, and Canada.
