Bear hunt backlash: FWC to hear public comment on first proposed bear hunt in 10 years
The Brief
Florida officials are reconsidering bear hunting, nearly a decade after the last hunt was cut short.
Conservationists argue habitat loss, not overpopulation, is the real threat, while proponents say hunting helps manage bear numbers.
A virtual meeting on March 13 will gather public input, with a final decision expected in May.
ORLANDO, Fla. - The controversial topic of bear hunting is back up for discussion in Florida. The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) is hosting a virtual public meeting to gauge the public's interest in hosting their first bear hunt in 10 years.
What we know
The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) is considering hosting the state's first bear hunt in nearly a decade.
A virtual public meeting is scheduled for Thursday, March 13, to gather public input. The last permitted hunt took place in 2015 but was cut short after just two days when more than 300 bears were killed. The commission will not make a final decision until a meeting set for May 21-22.
Proponents of the hunt argue that Florida's bear population has grown significantly and could sustain a limited, regulated hunt. FWC estimates that the bear population, which was once over 11,000, now stands at around 4,000.
What we don't know
It remains unclear whether the FWC has already reached a decision or if public input will significantly influence the outcome. Conservation groups argue that habitat destruction, rather than population growth, is the real issue threatening bears in Florida. Additionally, there is no consensus on whether a hunt would effectively manage bear populations or if alternative, non-lethal methods would be sufficient.
The backstory
Bear hunting in Florida has long been a controversial issue. The state's last hunt in 2015 was met with significant backlash, particularly after it was cut short due to the high number of bears killed in a short period. Since then, bear hunting has remained a contentious topic, with environmental groups advocating for stronger conservation efforts while hunting organizations push for controlled population management.
The renewed discussion follows the passage of Amendment Two in November, which enshrined a constitutional right to hunt and fish in Florida. Some view this amendment as a stepping stone for reinstating bear hunting.
What they're saying
Katrina Shadix, executive director of Bear Warriors United, believes the FWC commission already has their minds made up.
"There's no right way to do a wrong thing, and bear hunting in Florida is a wrong thing," Shadix said. "It would be a very bad look on the FWC if they participate in something like this – again."
The proposed hunt comes on the heels of amendment two passing in November. Amendment Two established a constitutional right to hunt and fish in Florida. Proponents of the hunt argue the bear population is on the rise.
"There is plenty of data," said Mark Barton of Back Country Hunters & Anglers. "It shows that Florida's bear population is thriving, and it could easily support a limited and highly regulated bear hunt."
FWC estimates Florida's bear population was once well over 11,000; it's now estimated to be around a third of that – somewhere closer to 4,000.
"This is not about wiping out bears," said one proponent of the hunt. "It's about maintaining a balanced population and high-density areas where non-lethal methods alone may not be enough."
According to Shadix, the problem is not the bear population, it's the loss of their habitat.
"We have development and roads taking away their homes. That is what is threatening the future of bear survival," Shadix said. "These are obstacles the bears probably will not survive. Maybe in our lifetime they'll go extinct."
What's next
The virtual FWC meeting starts on Thursday at 6 p.m. You can watch it here.
No decisions on a bear hunt will be made until the FWC meeting on May 21-22.
STAY CONNECTED WITH FOX 35 ORLANDO:
Download the FOX Local app for breaking news alerts, the latest news headlines
Download the FOX 35 Storm Team Weather app for weather alerts & radar
Sign up for FOX 35's daily newsletter for the latest morning headlines
FOX Local:Stream FOX 35 newscasts, FOX 35 News+, Central Florida Eats on your smart TV
The Source
This story was written based on information shared by the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, Bear Warriors United, Mark Barton of Back Country Hunters & Anglers, and from previous reporting from FOX 35 News.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
Help curb boating accidents in Florida, Gov. Desantis. Sign the Lucy Law bill.
On Thanksgiving Day 2019, my life changed forever. A speeding boat struck me while I was snorkeling. My right arm was severed on impact, and I caught a glimpse of it sinking onto the reef below. Both of my legs were severely damaged by the propellers, and my left wrist was badly broken. After miraculously surviving this, one of the first things I said after waking up from my medically-induced coma was, "I can make a bigger difference now than I ever could before this happened." As a marine biologist who worked at Loggerhead Marinelife Center at the time of my accident, I frequently saw the devastating effects of boat strikes on sea turtles, not knowing that I would soon endure the same fate. I often snorkeled off the coast of Palm Beach County, enjoying the beauty of the area's diverse marine life. On that fateful day, I was snorkeling off of the coast when a 36-foot speedboat directly hit me. The driver did not see my divers-down flag, a required safety device that was floating just a few feet away from me. GPS data from the boat recorded their speed at about 45 miles per hour at the time of impact. I firmly believe that my faith was what saved me and that God had given me an opportunity to help others through this incident. When I heard about Lucy's Law, I knew I had to support it. The bill is comprehensive boater safety legislation named in honor of Lucy Fernandez, a Miami teenager who was killed in a tragic boating accident. She was just a few years younger than me at the time of my accident; she deserved to live a long, full, and joyful life. The legislation, which currently awaits the governor's signature, has three main components. It requires the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) to establish standards for online boating safety education courses. It also aligns boating under-the-influence with driving-under-the-influence penalties and creates harsher penalties for operators who leave the scene of an accident. Gov. DeSantis, we're counting on you to help prevent more of these life-changing accidents. I urge you to sign Lucy's Law. This legislation may not change what happened to me, but it can help protect others and potentially save lives. Florida is the boating capital of the world. We have pristine, blue waters filled with marine life, which my career is dedicated to preserving. Every resident and visitor has the opportunity to explore all that our coastal waters have to offer. But with that opportunity comes responsibility. According to the FWC, there were 659 boating accidents in 2023 alone and 59 of those were deadly. Education and training saves lives. Lucy's Law will save lives. Carter Viss founded the Carter Viss Foundation, a boating safety nonprofit based in Jupiter. This article originally appeared on Palm Beach Post: Florida bill could improve boat safety. Desantis must sign. | Opinion
Yahoo
4 days ago
- Yahoo
Maxwell: Florida fights efforts to save manatees. Insurance costs rise again
Today we're looking at new developments in stories featured in two previous columns. And fair warning: Both are pretty depressing. In one case, Florida has decided to fight a court ruling that ordered the state to stop allowing the water pollution that has led to record manatee deaths. (Yes, the state's environmental protection agency is fighting an order to protect the environment.) In the other, a new report shows that home insurance rates are continuing to rise in Florida, despite Tallahassee lawmakers repeatedly telling you they delivered relief. (In other words, the politicians hope you'll listen to their words and not look at your own bills.) Let's start with the manatees. A few weeks ago, I wrote about the record number of manatees starving to death due to water pollution that has killed off the seagrass they eat to survive. Stories from both the Orlando Sentinel and Tampa Bay Times described nightmarish demises of the state's official marine mammal with the docile creatures literally rotting from the inside due to empty bellies. In one case, biologists found a calf still trying to nuzzle its mother's corpse. Other sea cows were found so starved that their bones had pierced their thinned skin. Maxwell: Manatee corpses — the price of the 'freedom' to pollute in Florida The in-depth reporting by the two newspapers detailed how water pollution in the Indian River Lagoon had killed off much of seagrass, contributing to the deaths of around 1,900 manatees over the past three years. I wrote at the time: 'To stop that pollution, lawmakers would have to stand up to development interests, agribusiness and influential utility companies, something they rarely do.' Well, an animal-rights group called Bear Warriors United filed a lawsuit saying the state had a legal obligation to do just that. And a federal judge agreed, ruling that Florida had violated the federal Endangered Species Act in allowing the wastewater discharges to pollute the habitat of the threatened species. But instead of agreeing to belatedly fight to save the sea cows, Gov. Ron DeSantis' administration decided to fight the ruling — and made some eye-popping arguments in a court filing last week. In its appeal, the state's laughably named Department of Environmental Protection agreed that there is an indeed existential threat afoot. But it isn't manatees that the state is worried about. It's developers. As the News Service of Florida reported, the state argued that the judge's ruling 'threatens to impede commercial and residential development in the state.' Yeah, forget the dying sea creatures. Florida is rallying to protect the state's development interests, whom the state said 'have no ready means to challenge this moratorium.' You know who else has no ability to show up in court and file a brief? The dying manatees. Admittedly, the judge's order is severe in calling for a temporary pause on all new development with the septic systems that have created much of the pollution. But the state ignored one warning after another to do the right thing on its own. So now the state's acting like a whiny kid who was warned time and again to stop misbehaving and then complained when Mom and Dad finally laid down the law. The bottom line: You know things are bad when the state not only allowed the manatee die-off to happen, but is now fighting for the right to let the deaths continue. In the insurance arena, the South Florida Sun-Sentinel's intrepid insurance reporter, Ron Hurtibise, just reported that home insurance rates are rising again in Florida. The latest quarterly report from the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation showed an average premium increase of less than 1%. That's small. But it comes on the heels of increases in nine of the previous 10 quarters. All told, the average premium price in Florida is now 30% higher than it was in 2022 — when lawmakers claimed to have 'reformed' the market. In other words: you got conned. Lawmakers in Tallahassee definitely made reforms, but most of them benefited the insurance companies, not consumers. Insurance costs edge higher for Florida homeowners and condo owners Yes, there are more insurance companies now in Florida, which is good. But most homeowners aren't seeing financial benefits. The insurance companies are. So Florida's politicians and insurance officials carefully choose words like 'stabilization' to refer to the relief they delivered and hope you won't notice your costs keep going up. The reality is that Florida has a complicated and risky insurance market, thanks to frequent storms and rising floodwaters. The only way to provide meaningful relief to consumers — meaning lower rates — would be for lawmakers to either beef up the state-run Citizens Insurance program, so that more people can access it, or use tax dollars to subsidize the market even more than it already does by investing even more in underwriting of reinsurance or through direct subsidies. Because it's clear that the state's version of 'reform' — which mainly involved making it harder for homeowners to sue their insurance company, even when they're denied benefits they're owed — didn't bring down costs. The state's own numbers say as much. smaxwell@
Yahoo
4 days ago
- Yahoo
Can you catch iguanas in Florida then sell them? You can, here's how
While many who live in south Florida see iguanas as vermin, nuisance animals or even a tasty meal, others are interested in keeping them as pets or selling them. Catching and selling iguanas caught in the wild in Florida was illegal until recently. But last month, the Florida Fish and Wildlife Commission (FWC) walked back a 2021 vote that prohibited capturing and selling the huge, invasive green lizards. Here's what to know about catching and selling iguanas in Florida… And what to know if you just want to catch and kill one legally. Yes, you can now catch and sell iguanas in Florida. But it wasn't always allowed. In 2021, the FWC implemented Prohibited Species rules, which heavily restricted people's ability to buy, sell or keep iguanas as pets. The rules were intended to reduce invasive iguana populations and protect native species, but it ended up having the opposite effect. Since then, the United States Association of Reptile Keepers (USARK) and some other special interest groups have been trying to reverse the Prohibited Species rules, which they successfully accomplished on May 21, when the FWC voted to change the rules it implemented in 2021 and allow Floridians to capture iguanas from the wild and sell them out-of-state. 'We have worked very hard with FWC to create rule changes which will allow more people to remove nonnative species,' USARK Florida President Elizabeth Wisneski said in a release. 'This will benefit Florida's environment and our small businesses.' USARK told the Fort Myers News-Press that while the rule change is a great start, there's still more work to be done and the FWC hasn't taken action on allowing the collection of eggs. 'FWC must reform caging regulations to make it economically feasible for businesses to be able to house iguanas,' Wisneski said. 'Addressing the threats of invasive species in Florida is a priority for the FWC, but we can't do it alone,' FWC Chair Rodney Barreto said. 'Approving these rule changes further empowers our stakeholders to get directly involved in removing green iguanas from the state, a win for Floridians and our native plants and wildlife.' Want to catch an iguana to sell? Florida's wildlife agency now says you can, what to know While some people are interested in capturing and selling iguanas or keeping them as pets, a lot of Floridians see iguanas as vermin that need to be "taken care of," or even as a tasty meal (see below). Iguanas are an invasive species in Florida, meaning they're not native to the state, and are only protected by anti-cruelty laws. They can be humanely killed on private property year-round with landowner permission, according to the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC). Before you shoot at an iguana, though, check your local ordinances. There are some areas in Florida where you can't shoot a firearm unless you're at a licensed facility. And there is no place in the state where you can shoot a firearm in any public place or on the right-of-way of any paved public road, highway, or street, according to state laws. In other words, if you see an iguana on the sidewalk, you can't shoot it there, unless you want to be charged with a first-degree misdemeanor. , this applies to: 'Any person who knowingly discharges a firearm in any public place or on the right-of-way of any paved public road, highway, or street, who knowingly discharges any firearm over the right-of-way of any paved public road, highway, or street or over any occupied premises, or who recklessly or negligently discharges a firearm outdoors on any property used primarily as the site of a dwelling…' It doesn't apply to: 'A person lawfully defending life or property or performing official duties requiring the discharge of a firearm or to a person discharging a firearm on public roads or properties expressly approved for hunting by the Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission or Florida Forest Service.' It's legal to kill and eat iguanas, but it's illegal to import iguanas or iguana meat. What to know about wildlife, gun laws: Can you shoot a wild animal on your property in Florida? There are 32 FWC-managed public lands in south Florida, where you don't need a hunting license to kill iguanas, since they're highly invasive to that portion of the state. The public lands where you can kill as many iguanas as you'd like are the same areas where residents and hunters are encouraged to kill any pythons they see. 'If you are not capable of safely removing iguanas from your property, please seek assistance from a professional nuisance wildlife trapper,' the FWC's website says. 'A permit is required to possess live captured green iguanas for eradication and control purposes.' If you want to hunt iguanas for their meat or to just help out with controlling their presence in South Florida but don't know where to go, you can book a guided iguana hunt. There are only two rules to consider when hunting or killing iguanas: You must either have permission from the owner of the property where you found the iguana or be on one of the 32 FWC-managed public lands where eliminating iguanas is encouraged. You must kill the iguana or iguanas humanely. Regardless of the method you use, you must ensure the following two steps are completed to humanely kill a reptile: Step 1: Your method should result in the animal losing consciousness immediately. Step 2: You should then destroy the animal's brain by 'pithing' which prevents the animal from regaining consciousness. For more information visit the 2020 AVMA Guidelines for the Euthanasia of Animals. If you've gone out and killed an iguana without intent to eat it, don't toss the body in a road or waterway. You could be charged with a littering fine. Tossing a dead iguana in the trash could also cost you, depending on where you live. Some cities' waste management systems allow you to throw it in the trash if it is double-bagged, while others require residents to hire a private pickup service to get rid of the dead animal. Check what the rules are for your city before you toss a huge, dead lizard in the trash can. Yes! The iguana has been eaten in other countries for centuries. "People have been eating iguanas since at least 10,000 years ago, when humans reached the New World tropics. It was a readily available, not-too-dangerous food source. It's always been part of the diet," William Kern, a professor at the University of Florida, told USA TODAY back in 2020. Its meat is high in protein and low in fat. It's well-suited for tacos, burritos, curries, soups, stews, gumbo and more, according to the University of Florida Institute of Food and Agricultural Sciences. 'The solution? Iguana stew,' the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service wrote on its list. 'Their meat is often called 'chicken of the trees' for its mild flavor.' The FWC allows for the humane killing and consumption of iguanas in Florida, as they are considered an invasive species. Contributing: Amy Bennett Williams, Fort Myers News-Press This article originally appeared on Fort Myers News-Press: Invasive iguanas caught in Florida can now be sold out-of-state
