logo
Scholasticide in Gaza: History is screaming to the Present

Scholasticide in Gaza: History is screaming to the Present

Jordan Times09-02-2025

AMMAN — The American Historical Association (AHA), the world's largest body of professional historians, recently ignited a debate after passing a resolution condemning Israel's destruction of Gaza's education system – only to have its elected council veto the measure.
The resolution accused Israel of committing 'scholasticide,' a term coined by Palestinian academic Karma Nabulsi in 2009 to describe the systematic destruction of Palestinian educational institutions. While the resolution gained support at the AHA's annual convention on January 15, the elected council ultimately vetoed it, fuelling an intense ethical and political debate over the role of historians in times of crisis.
AHA's Veto : A controversial silence ?
Founded in 1884, the AHA has long played a central role in shaping historical discourse. Yet, its leadership's rejection of the resolution underscores the tension between academic neutrality and moral accountability.
AHA convention-goers overwhelmingly approved the resolution on January 15, but the association's 16-member elected council vetoed it without allowing a full membership vote. The council could have either accepted the resolution or referred it to AHA's 10,450 members but chose to reject it.
In its written explanation, the council condemned the destruction of Palestinian educational institutions in Gaza but argued the resolution fell outside of AHA's mission, which focuses on promoting historical research, teaching, and preservation rather than political advocacy.
However, this stance was met with backlash from scholars who believe that remaining silent in the face of destruction is itself a political act.
'Historians who opposed the scholasticide resolution insisted that taking a position would harm the AHA, which is supposedly a 'non-political' organisation. The truth is that our tax dollars have funded 15 months of Israeli annihilation: not taking a stance a position will leave a lasting stain on the association and the discipline. Silence is complicity,' said Sherene Seikaly, Associate Professor of History at the University of California, in an interview with The Jordan Times. 'The task of the historian is to ask hard questions and to take difficult positions, not when the dust settles, but as the fire reigns,' she added.
Notably, the AHA's hesitation stands in contrast to its previous actions. In 2022, the association swiftly condemned Russia's invasion of Ukraine, issuing a statement denouncing Vladimir Putin's distortion of history to justify military aggression.
'The opposition to the scholasticide resolution thus deems the question of Palestine as 'political' and Palestinian lives as less valuable,' Seikaly said.
Barbara Weinstein, Professor of History at New York University and former AHA president, emphasised that scholasticide is a recognised phenomenon under international law.
'The right to learn and preserve historical evidence should be included in the broader category of human rights,' Weistein told The Jordan Times. 'And I believe that anyone who is a historian and claims that their work is 'not political' is either a fool or a scoundrel. It is utter nonsense to say that historians should stay out of politics. Every decision we make – what we research, what archives we explore, what histories we choose to amplify, is imbued with a vision of the world that I would describe as political.'
As to whether the AHA, as an organisation, should stay out of politics, Weistein said : 'The very defence of history as a discipline is political, the association is engaged in advocacy by its very nature. During my time as a president, the AHA issued a statement severely criticising a move by the European Union to criminalise Holocaust denial, including in work by historians. Needless to say, no one on the AHA executive council was in favour of Holocaust denial, but we argued that his was the sort of issue that should be 'adjudicated' by other – better – historians, and not be a matter for the criminal justice system. How is that not political ?'
Erasing Palestinian intellectual heritage
While the AHA debates its stance, the reality on the ground in Gaza grows more dire by the day. Since the war broke out in October 2023, Israel's military assault has led to the widespread destruction of Gaza's educational infrastructure.
The destruction extends far beyond physical buildings. 'Armed and abetted by the United States, Israel has destroyed 80% of schools and every single university in the Gaza Strip. Israel has targeted and killed scholars from across the humanities, social sciences, and STEM. Israel has destroyed almost every library, archive, and cultural centre in the Strip,' Seikaly said, adding that centuries of endowments, collections, and documents are now gone forever.
Beyond destruction, evidence has emerged of Israeli forces repurposing Palestinian schools as military outposts and detention centres. The European-Mediterranean Human Rights Monitor has documented such cases as the Salah Al-Din Preparatory School in Gaza City, turned into a detention and interrogation facility in February 2024, and other civilian buildings, including schools, being systematically demolished after being used as military headquarters. The Human Rights organisation stated that such actions violate international humanitarian law, which mandates the protection of civilian infrastructure.
A generation without education
In April 2024, UN experts issued an urgent warning over the pattern of attacks on schools, universities, and the mass killing, arrest, and detention of students and educators.
Ajith Sunghay, head of the UN Human Rights Office in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, also underscored the severity of the situation: 'The education system in Gaza no longer exists. Children can no longer find a place to learn.' The UNICEF echoed this assessment, confirming the complete collapse of the educational system in Gaza.
The consequences of this annihilation are dire. According to UN figures, more than 5,500 students, 261 teachers, and 95 university professors have been killed during Israeli assaults. More than 7,800 students and 756 teachers have been injured. The United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees (UNRWA) confirmed that 60% of educational institutions, including 13 public libraries, have been damaged or destroyed, including 76 schools that were directly targeted, and at least 625,000 students are now left without access to education.
The destruction of Israa University in January 2024 marked a grim milestone – the last remaining university in Gaza reduced to rubble.
'Even UN-designated 'safe zones' have not been spared, with schools sheltering displaced civilians bombed repeatedly. The persistent attacks are depriving yet another generation of Palestinians of their future,' the UN statement read.
The impact of this devastation extends beyond the present, threatening the very survival of Palestinian culture, history, and intellectual life. 'When schools are destroyed, so too are hopes and dreams,' the experts stated.
Scholasticide: a key feature of genocide
The term 'scholasticide' describes a deliberate genocidal strategy to dismantle an entire society's ability to document its history and build its future, as well as its right to knowledge. The implications go beyond the immediate loss of human lives and infrastructures.
'The concept of 'scholasticide' is significant both as a means to denounce forms of destruction that wreak permanent damage on the society, but also as a way of thinking about 'repairing' that damage (to the extent possible) when the war finally ends,' Weinstein said.
Historically, the destruction of educational institutions has been a hallmark of genocide. From the systematic targeting of schools in Iraq to the mass killing of educators in Gaza, scholars have long documented how obliterating intellectual heritage aims to erase a people's past.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Jordan Strongly Condemns Ben-Gvir's Storming of Al-Aqsa Mosque - Jordan News
Jordan Strongly Condemns Ben-Gvir's Storming of Al-Aqsa Mosque - Jordan News

Jordan News

time3 hours ago

  • Jordan News

Jordan Strongly Condemns Ben-Gvir's Storming of Al-Aqsa Mosque - Jordan News

The Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Expatriates of Jordan strongly condemned the storming of Al-Aqsa Mosque/Al-Haram Al-Sharif by Israel's extremist National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir, under the protection of the Israeli occupation police. The ministry labeled the act as a blatant violation of international law and international humanitarian law, describing it as an unacceptable provocation and escalation that must be stopped immediately by Israel, as the occupying power. اضافة اعلان Ministry spokesperson Ambassador Dr. Sufian Qudah affirmed the Kingdom's firm rejection and strong condemnation of the repeated and provocative incursions by Minister Ben-Gvir, and the facilitation by Israeli police of such actions. He emphasized that these incursions coincide with restrictions imposed on Muslim worshippers, which constitute a flagrant violation of the legal and historical status quo of Al-Aqsa Mosque/Al-Haram Al-Sharif. These acts are seen as attempts to impose a temporal and spatial division of the site and a desecration of its sanctity. Ambassador Qudah stressed that such practices do not change the reality that East Jerusalem is an occupied territory, and Israel has no sovereignty over it. He further warned of the grave consequences of the continued illegal and provocative violations of Islamic and Christian holy sites in Jerusalem, urging Israel, as the occupying power, to immediately halt all such provocative actions by Ben-Gvir. These actions, Qudah said, are part of the extremist Israeli government's policy aimed at escalating tensions in the occupied West Bank, conducting raids on Palestinian cities, and violating the sanctity of religious sites in occupied Jerusalem. He reiterated that Al-Aqsa Mosque, in its entirety of 144 dunums, is a solely Islamic holy site, and that the Jerusalem Awqaf Department, affiliated with Jordan's Ministry of Awqaf and Islamic Affairs, is the sole legal authority responsible for managing and overseeing all affairs of the mosque and regulating entry to it.

"Israeli" MPs to vote on bid to dissolve Knesset
"Israeli" MPs to vote on bid to dissolve Knesset

Roya News

time7 hours ago

  • Roya News

"Israeli" MPs to vote on bid to dissolve Knesset

Israeli Occupation Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's fragile governing coalition is under serious strain ahead of a parliamentary vote on Wednesday that could set the stage for its collapse. The vote, initiated by the opposition, proposes dissolving the Knesset, a move that hinges on whether Netanyahu's ultra-Orthodox allies will continue backing him, the Associated Press (AP) reported. The vote comes amid deepening tensions within Netanyahu's right-wing coalition, triggered by the failure to pass a long-promised law exempting ultra-Orthodox men from military service. The issue has sparked intense public debate, especially as the war in Gaza stretches into its ninth month and military manpower is under unprecedented pressure. Despite the turmoil, many analysts believe Netanyahu may still strike a deal to keep his government afloat. But the vote remains the most significant threat to his leadership since the war on Gaza began on Oct. 7, 2023. 'We transported at least 31 martyrs and about 200 wounded as a result of Israeli tank and drone fire on thousands of citizens... on their way to receive food from the American aid centre,' civil defence spokesman Mahmud Bassal told Agence France-Presse (AFP). While the Israeli Occupation Forces (IOF) have yet to comment on the vote or the allegations from Gaza, tensions across "Israeli" society remain high, especially concerning mandatory military service. In "Israel", most Jewish men must serve nearly three years in the army, followed by regular reserve duty. Jewish women serve for two years. But ultra-Orthodox men, who make up about 13 percent of the population, have historically received exemptions if they are enrolled in religious seminaries. These exemptions have long stirred resentment among the broader public, particularly because seminary students often receive government stipends until the age of 26. The backlash intensified following October 7, which led to the call-up of 360,000 reservists, the country's largest mobilization since 1973. The war's duration and intensity have stretched "Israel's" military thin, and enthusiasm for continued reserve service is waning. The military has increasingly relied on social media to encourage enlistment, as growing numbers of reservists are reportedly refusing additional tours. Meanwhile, ultra-Orthodox enlistment remains extremely low, despite early signs of increased interest following the October attack. The longstanding exemption policy originated in 1948, meant to preserve the small number of Torah scholars who survived the Holocaust. But over time, the system has ballooned, now covering tens of thousands. The Supreme Court declared the arrangement unlawful in 2017, but successive governments have avoided enacting a permanent alternative. Some ultra-Orthodox leaders fiercely oppose any form of military conscription. Rabbi Ephraim Luft from Bnei Brak said, 'It mixes together people with very different backgrounds, very different ideas, some people with very immoral ideas.' He emphasized the community's belief that religious devotion protects the state as much as armed service. 'There's no difference between the Spanish Inquisition or the Israeli draft law,' he said. Two ultra-Orthodox parties, Shas and Degel HaTorah, are critical to Netanyahu's ruling coalition. Both have hinted at withdrawing support if the draft exemption law is not passed. A Shas spokesperson warned on Monday that they may back the vote to dissolve the government unless a resolution is reached. Degel HaTorah has voiced similar concerns for over a week. Critics argue that the religious parties are placing narrow interests above national unity. 'Basically, they don't really care about the war and the economic situation of the state and anything else but their communal interest,' said Shuki Friedman, vice president of the Jewish People Policy Institute (JPPI). According to a parliamentary committee, roughly 13,000 ultra-Orthodox men reach the draft age of 18 each year, yet less than 10 percent enlist. With the ultra-Orthodox population growing at about 4 percent annually, many experts, including Friedman, believe the current model is unsustainable. Even if the vote passes on Wednesday, it is just the first step. It would still require additional votes and procedural hurdles, potentially delaying any actual government dissolution for weeks or months, said political science professor Gayil Talshir from Hebrew University. 'It will be like a gun that's been put into position, but that doesn't mean the coalition is over,' she explained. "Israel's" next scheduled elections are not until fall 2026. Still, pressure is mounting. Top ultra-Orthodox rabbis issued a religious decree Tuesday reinforcing opposition to military service, making it politically harder for their parties to compromise. Thousands of draft notices have already been sent to ultra-Orthodox men, and although only a small number have been arrested, the fear is palpable, according to Friedman. With the Gaza war continuing and captive negotiations in flux, Netanyahu insists "Israel" must remain unified. However, his ultra-Orthodox allies are eager for the war to end, believing that only then can they safely secure a lasting exemption law.

Ben Gvir Storms Al-Aqsa Mosque Compound Again Amid International Condemnation - Jordan News
Ben Gvir Storms Al-Aqsa Mosque Compound Again Amid International Condemnation - Jordan News

Jordan News

time9 hours ago

  • Jordan News

Ben Gvir Storms Al-Aqsa Mosque Compound Again Amid International Condemnation - Jordan News

Ben Gvir Storms Al-Aqsa Mosque Compound Again Amid International Condemnation Israeli National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir stormed the Al-Aqsa Mosque compound once again on Wednesday, under heavy police protection and without prior public announcement, according to a statement by the Islamic Waqf Department in Jerusalem. اضافة اعلان The Waqf confirmed that Ben Gvir entered the mosque courtyards accompanied by Israeli police officers. This marks yet another of his repeated incursions into the sacred site, despite widespread condemnation from Arab and Islamic countries. Such visits by senior Israeli officials are typically pre-approved by the office of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Since taking office at the end of 2022, Ben Gvir has carried out multiple high-profile visits to the site, which is considered the third holiest in Islam and a flashpoint in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. His most recent prior incursion was on May 27, when he entered the compound alongside government officials, Knesset members, and over 2,000 Israeli settlers, coinciding with Jerusalem Day—the anniversary of Israel's 1967 occupation of East Jerusalem, as marked on the Hebrew calendar. That event drew strong Palestinian and Arab denunciations. Ben Gvir's latest action comes just one day after the UK, Australia, Canada, New Zealand, and Norway imposed sanctions on him and Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich, in response to their repeated incitement to violence against Palestinians. The sanctions include asset freezes and entry bans in the respective countries, further escalating international criticism of the Israeli government's far-right ministers. Notably, Israel began allowing settler incursions into the Al-Aqsa compound in 2003, despite ongoing opposition from the Islamic Waqf, which administers the site. – (Anadolu Agency)

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store