
Scholasticide in Gaza: History is screaming to the Present
AMMAN — The American Historical Association (AHA), the world's largest body of professional historians, recently ignited a debate after passing a resolution condemning Israel's destruction of Gaza's education system – only to have its elected council veto the measure.
The resolution accused Israel of committing 'scholasticide,' a term coined by Palestinian academic Karma Nabulsi in 2009 to describe the systematic destruction of Palestinian educational institutions. While the resolution gained support at the AHA's annual convention on January 15, the elected council ultimately vetoed it, fuelling an intense ethical and political debate over the role of historians in times of crisis.
AHA's Veto : A controversial silence ?
Founded in 1884, the AHA has long played a central role in shaping historical discourse. Yet, its leadership's rejection of the resolution underscores the tension between academic neutrality and moral accountability.
AHA convention-goers overwhelmingly approved the resolution on January 15, but the association's 16-member elected council vetoed it without allowing a full membership vote. The council could have either accepted the resolution or referred it to AHA's 10,450 members but chose to reject it.
In its written explanation, the council condemned the destruction of Palestinian educational institutions in Gaza but argued the resolution fell outside of AHA's mission, which focuses on promoting historical research, teaching, and preservation rather than political advocacy.
However, this stance was met with backlash from scholars who believe that remaining silent in the face of destruction is itself a political act.
'Historians who opposed the scholasticide resolution insisted that taking a position would harm the AHA, which is supposedly a 'non-political' organisation. The truth is that our tax dollars have funded 15 months of Israeli annihilation: not taking a stance a position will leave a lasting stain on the association and the discipline. Silence is complicity,' said Sherene Seikaly, Associate Professor of History at the University of California, in an interview with The Jordan Times. 'The task of the historian is to ask hard questions and to take difficult positions, not when the dust settles, but as the fire reigns,' she added.
Notably, the AHA's hesitation stands in contrast to its previous actions. In 2022, the association swiftly condemned Russia's invasion of Ukraine, issuing a statement denouncing Vladimir Putin's distortion of history to justify military aggression.
'The opposition to the scholasticide resolution thus deems the question of Palestine as 'political' and Palestinian lives as less valuable,' Seikaly said.
Barbara Weinstein, Professor of History at New York University and former AHA president, emphasised that scholasticide is a recognised phenomenon under international law.
'The right to learn and preserve historical evidence should be included in the broader category of human rights,' Weistein told The Jordan Times. 'And I believe that anyone who is a historian and claims that their work is 'not political' is either a fool or a scoundrel. It is utter nonsense to say that historians should stay out of politics. Every decision we make – what we research, what archives we explore, what histories we choose to amplify, is imbued with a vision of the world that I would describe as political.'
As to whether the AHA, as an organisation, should stay out of politics, Weistein said : 'The very defence of history as a discipline is political, the association is engaged in advocacy by its very nature. During my time as a president, the AHA issued a statement severely criticising a move by the European Union to criminalise Holocaust denial, including in work by historians. Needless to say, no one on the AHA executive council was in favour of Holocaust denial, but we argued that his was the sort of issue that should be 'adjudicated' by other – better – historians, and not be a matter for the criminal justice system. How is that not political ?'
Erasing Palestinian intellectual heritage
While the AHA debates its stance, the reality on the ground in Gaza grows more dire by the day. Since the war broke out in October 2023, Israel's military assault has led to the widespread destruction of Gaza's educational infrastructure.
The destruction extends far beyond physical buildings. 'Armed and abetted by the United States, Israel has destroyed 80% of schools and every single university in the Gaza Strip. Israel has targeted and killed scholars from across the humanities, social sciences, and STEM. Israel has destroyed almost every library, archive, and cultural centre in the Strip,' Seikaly said, adding that centuries of endowments, collections, and documents are now gone forever.
Beyond destruction, evidence has emerged of Israeli forces repurposing Palestinian schools as military outposts and detention centres. The European-Mediterranean Human Rights Monitor has documented such cases as the Salah Al-Din Preparatory School in Gaza City, turned into a detention and interrogation facility in February 2024, and other civilian buildings, including schools, being systematically demolished after being used as military headquarters. The Human Rights organisation stated that such actions violate international humanitarian law, which mandates the protection of civilian infrastructure.
A generation without education
In April 2024, UN experts issued an urgent warning over the pattern of attacks on schools, universities, and the mass killing, arrest, and detention of students and educators.
Ajith Sunghay, head of the UN Human Rights Office in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, also underscored the severity of the situation: 'The education system in Gaza no longer exists. Children can no longer find a place to learn.' The UNICEF echoed this assessment, confirming the complete collapse of the educational system in Gaza.
The consequences of this annihilation are dire. According to UN figures, more than 5,500 students, 261 teachers, and 95 university professors have been killed during Israeli assaults. More than 7,800 students and 756 teachers have been injured. The United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees (UNRWA) confirmed that 60% of educational institutions, including 13 public libraries, have been damaged or destroyed, including 76 schools that were directly targeted, and at least 625,000 students are now left without access to education.
The destruction of Israa University in January 2024 marked a grim milestone – the last remaining university in Gaza reduced to rubble.
'Even UN-designated 'safe zones' have not been spared, with schools sheltering displaced civilians bombed repeatedly. The persistent attacks are depriving yet another generation of Palestinians of their future,' the UN statement read.
The impact of this devastation extends beyond the present, threatening the very survival of Palestinian culture, history, and intellectual life. 'When schools are destroyed, so too are hopes and dreams,' the experts stated.
Scholasticide: a key feature of genocide
The term 'scholasticide' describes a deliberate genocidal strategy to dismantle an entire society's ability to document its history and build its future, as well as its right to knowledge. The implications go beyond the immediate loss of human lives and infrastructures.
'The concept of 'scholasticide' is significant both as a means to denounce forms of destruction that wreak permanent damage on the society, but also as a way of thinking about 'repairing' that damage (to the extent possible) when the war finally ends,' Weinstein said.
Historically, the destruction of educational institutions has been a hallmark of genocide. From the systematic targeting of schools in Iraq to the mass killing of educators in Gaza, scholars have long documented how obliterating intellectual heritage aims to erase a people's past.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Roya News
3 hours ago
- Roya News
"Israeli" navy targets Yemen's Hodeidah port
"Israeli" naval forces launched missile strikes on Yemen's Hodeidah port Tuesday, marking the first time "Israel" has directly attacked the Houthis from the sea, according to the Associated Press (AP). The Israeli Occupation Forces (IOF) confirmed that its navy conducted the assault, targeting what it described as Houthi-controlled docks used to transport weapons. 'The port is used to transfer weapons and is a further example of the Houthi terrorist regime's cynical exploitation of civilian infrastructure in order to advance terrorist activities,' the IOF said in a statement. The Houthis acknowledged the attack through their Al-Masirah TV channel but did not provide further details. The strike appears to have hit the port infrastructure crucial for humanitarian aid in Hodeidah, the main lifeline for millions of Yemenis reliant on food and supplies amid years of conflict and famine.

Ammon
6 hours ago
- Ammon
16,382 students killed since Israel began aggression
Ammon News - The Palestinian Ministry of Education and Higher Education stated that 16,382 students have been killed and 23,532 injured since the start of the Israeli aggression on the Gaza Strip and the West Bank on October 7, 2023. In a statement issued on Tuesday, the Ministry of Education clarified that the number of students killed in the Gaza Strip since the beginning of the aggression has reached more than 16,245, and 25,959 injured. In the West Bank, 137 students were killed, 897 others were injured, and 749 were detained. The Ministry indicated that 917 teachers and administrators were killed, 4,347 were injured in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, and more than 196 were detained in the West Bank. It noted that 443 government schools, universities, and their affiliated buildings, as well as 91 schools affiliated with the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA), were bombed and vandalized in the Gaza Strip. Sixty university buildings were completely destroyed, and 20 educational institutions sustained severe damage. In the West Bank, 152 schools and eight universities were raided and vandalized. It is worth noting that for the second year in a row, high school students in Gaza have been prevented from taking their exams. She noted that schools in Nablus were closed due to the ongoing incursion by Israeli forces since the morning hours. The Ministry noted that six UNRWA schools in Jerusalem have remained closed since May 8, 2025. WAFA

Ammon
7 hours ago
- Ammon
King concludes working visit to Europe
Ammon News - His Majesty King Abdullah II concluded his working visit to Europe that included Spain, the United Kingdom, and France. In Spain, His Majesty met with King Felipe VI of Spain in Madrid on Thursday. The meeting covered the importance of continued coordination between Jordan and Spain on issues of mutual concern, as well as keenness to elevate bilateral relations to the level of strategic partnership. His Majesty commended Spain's support for the rights of Palestinians, as well as its support of creating a political horizon to achieve peace on the basis of the two-state solution, and the need to stop the war on Gaza and resume the flow of sufficient humanitarian aid to all areas of the Strip. Also, His Majesty King Abdullah II and President of the Government of Spain Pedro Sánchez witnessed the signing of a joint declaration on the strategic partnership between Jordan and Spain on Thursday. The declaration aims to elevate bilateral relations between Jordan and Spain to a strategic level in the development-related, economic, commercial, social, cultural and defence fields, with the aim of achieving goals of mutual interest, and enhancing security and stability. In addition, a memorandum of understanding for cooperation in the agriculture sector, and an extradition agreement were signed. During expanded talks with Prime Minister Sánchez, His Majesty emphasised the significance of these agreements, which will serve to enhance cooperation between the two countries across all fields, and noted the importance of maintaining coordination, and building on the two countries' long history of mutual respect and commitment to the pursuit of peace and stability around the world. The King expressed appreciation for Spain's support to Jordan's services to refugees, as well as its economic and administrative modernisation efforts, noting readiness to deepen cooperation in the economic and tourism fields. Speaking about regional developments, His Majesty praised Spain's position calling for an end to the war on Gaza, and ensuring that delivery of humanitarian aid reaches all areas of the Strip. The King highlighted the importance of Spain's decision to recognise the Palestinian state, a step that will lead to more support for the Palestinian people. His Majesty said work is underway to gain more European support for the Arab plan to rebuild Gaza without displacing its residents, commending Spain as the voice of reason and wisdom. The King warned of the dangers of unilateral measures targeting Palestinians in the West Bank, and Muslim and Christian holy sites in Jerusalem. His Majesty reiterated the need to step up international efforts to support Palestinians in gaining their legitimate rights to establish their independent state on the basis of the two-state solution. For his part, Prime Minister Sánchez praised Jordan's important efforts, under the leadership of His Majesty, to promote security and stability in the region and the world, noting Jordan's vital role in supporting Palestinians. Sánchez added that the war on Gaza, which has claimed the lives of tens of thousands of innocent civilians, must be brought to an end. In the United Kingdom, the King met with Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer, and they discussed bilateral relations and regional developments during their meeting in London on Thursday. During a bilateral meeting followed by an expanded one at 10 Downing Street, His Majesty affirmed Jordan's commitment to continuing to build on the deep-rooted ties and historic friendship between Jordan and the UK. His Majesty commended the joint efforts by Jordan and the UK to address developments in the region, emphasising the need for coordination at the bilateral and Arab-European levels. Regarding regional developments, the King stressed the need to step up international efforts to immediately end the war on Gaza, and ensure the flow of humanitarian aid. His Majesty praised the UK's support to the humanitarian response in Gaza, highlighting the importance of its efforts to achieve stability in the region, and just and comprehensive peace on the basis of the two-state solution. The King also warned of the dangers of recent escalations in the West Bank, as well as the attacks on Muslim and Christian holy sites in Jerusalem, reiterating Jordan's position that rejects the displacement of Palestinians from their land. His Majesty also highlighted Jordan's readiness to maintain coordination with the UK in service of the two countries' mutual goals and interests, as well as on regional issues. For his part, Prime Minister Starmer thanked His Majesty for his leadership and efforts, particularly in the region, in relation to the conflicts taking place, noting that their meeting was an important opportunity to discuss and exchange views on regional issues and bilateral relations. Starmer pointed out the importance of the two countries continuing to work together, including efforts to immediately reach a ceasefire in Gaza, and ensure the delivery of urgent humanitarian aid as quickly as possible. He agreed that the only long-term solution is the two-state solution. His Majesty met in London on Friday with current and former British officials, and members of the House of Commons and House of Lords to discuss key developments in the Middle East. The meeting covered the situation in Gaza, with His Majesty emphasising the need to immediately end the war on Gaza, and ensure the entry of sufficient aid to alleviate the dire humanitarian situation in the Strip. The King highlighted the importance of the UK's role in bringing stability to the region, and creating a political horizon to achieve just and comprehensive peace on the basis of the two-state solution. Discussions also touched on current developments in the West Bank, Jerusalem, and Syria. In France, His Majesty met with number of officials, heads of state, and Prime Ministers. The King also met with France President Emmanuel Macron in Nice, where His Majesty stressed Jordan's readiness to strengthen ties with France across various sectors, which will contribute to enhancing stability in the Middle East. The two leaders highlighted the importance of maintaining coordination on regional issues, stepping up international efforts to reach comprehensive calm in the region, immediately reinstating the ceasefire in Gaza, and resuming the entry of humanitarian aid. His Majesty warned of the serious consequences of continued escalations in the West Bank and Jerusalem, reiterating that granting Palestinians their full legitimate rights is the only way to stabilise the region.