Annie McCarrick case: Cadaver dogs brought in by gardaí searching site
Gardaí investigating the murder of
Annie McCarrick
have brought in a cadaver dog in the search of a house in Clondalkin.
A man, who is in his 60s and originally from Dublin, was arrested on Thursday morning and remains in Garda custody.
The search of a house in Clondalkin, for Ms McCarrick's remains or any other evidence, stepped up on Friday when a cadaver dog was brought onto the site.
The man arrested for questioning on suspicion of the murder was flagged to gardaí as a possible suspect in the case in the immediate aftermath of the New Yorker vanishing from
Sandymount
, South Dublin, in 1993.
READ MORE
Friends of Ms McCarrick were concerned about the man, and the nature of his contacts with the 26-year-old in Dublin.
They outlined those concerns, and the specific reasons for them, in fax messages to the Garda investigation team. However, they have always believed the information they supplied was not properly handled and was not factored into the initial inquiry in any meaningful way.
The suspect, who is in his 60s and originally from Dublin, was arrested on Thursday morning and remained in Garda custody early on Friday. He was detained under Section 4 of the Criminal Justice Act, on suspicion of murder, and can be questioned for up to 24 hours, though questioning has been paused to allow breaks for rest.
[
Annie McCarrick's best friend is 'overwhelmed with emotion, crying over my coffee' after developments in case
Opens in new window
]
Gardaí yesterday extended his period of detention to the maximum 24 hours of interviews permitted under law and must either release him without charge, or charge him with an offence, later on Friday.
The man has become a successful businessman and now lives outside Dublin. As well as being arrested on Thursday morning, his home was searched. And a house in Clondalkin, west Dublin, that he was linked to was sealed off for searching and excavation, in an operation continuing on Friday morning.
Gardaí bring a cadaver dog into the premises, pictured on Friday morning at a house on Monastery Walk, Clondalkin, where gardaí are continueing their search in the investigation into the death of American woman, Annie McCarrick, who disappeared in 1993. Photograph: Colin Keegan, Collins Dublin.
The Clondalkin property has been renovated by the current occupants, who bought the house over a decade ago. Gardaí have stressed the current occupants are completely unconnected to Ms McCarrick or the murder inquiry now under way.
Some of Ms McCarrick's friends in the United States had remained in close and frequent contact with her when she moved back to Ireland in January, 1993, after first studying here. They said she felt pressured and harassed by an Irishman in her social circle in Dublin and that she told them the man struck her when he had been drinking. They flagged those concerns with gardaí in the initial stages of the investigation when she vanished.
[
Annie McCarrick: Gardaí made first arrest in 32-year investigation after receiving new information
Opens in new window
]
However, at the time Ms McCarrick (26) went missing, there was a series of reported sightings of her getting on a bus bound for Enniskerry, Co Wicklow, and also sightings of her in the village. Other reports placed her 6km away in Johnnie Fox's Pub, Glencullen, Co Dublin.
Those sightings, since discounted, all related to Friday, March 26th, the day of the last confirmed sighting of the murdered woman at her flat in Sandymount, South Dublin. Much of the Garda's attention in the first phased of investigation focused on pursuing those sightings in Enniskerry and Glencullen.
Ms McCarrick knew the man arrested on Thursday, and was very close to him for a period. However, while her friends told gardaí about that man in 1993 – including Ms McCarrick saying he had harassed her and struck her – they felt their information was not actioned by detectives at the time.
When none of the claimed sightings of Ms McCarrick in 1993 led to any breakaway, and her remains were never found, the case remained an unsolved missing person's inquiry until it was upgraded to a murder investigation two years ago.
In recent years, after a cold case review and fresh investigation, detectives have come to focus on the arrested man as the main suspect in the case.
They also have a particular interest in a close associate of his, who they went abroad to interview earlier this year. They believe the suspect and his close associate were together on the weekend Ms McCarrick vanished and detectives have sought to recheck their accounts of their movements, comparing statements taken in recent years.
In March 1993 Ms McCarrick, from Long Island, New York, was living in rented accommodation at St Cathryn's Court, Sandymount, with two friends. They last spoke to her at the property on the morning of Friday, March 26th.
.
Amid rising concerns for her safety, Ms McCarrick was reported missing to gardaí that Sunday, more than 48 hours after the last confirmed sighting of her.
Meanwhile, the US lawyer hired by the father of Annie McCarrick to represent the family in the period after her disappearance has said he is 'delighted' there has been arrest and remains hopeful the case will eventually be resolved with a conviction.
Michael Griffith has criticised An Garda Síochána over its reluctance to engage with him and others working for the family in the aftermath of her disappearance in March 1993.
He suggested then Director of Public Prosecutions Eamonn Barnes had been helpful to the team Mr Griffith had assembled to work on the case on behalf of the McCarrick family but that the Garda was reluctant to share information or engage.
'We met with the Garda. We tried to follow up leads at that time but nothing came of it,' he told RTÉ Radio 1's Morning Ireland programme on Friday.
'In the States here, attorneys tend to share evidence with investigations, with the police, but even though Eamonn Barnes wanted the Garda to open up the file to us, the Garda was quite reclusive about it, and we weren't able to get into the file, although there were a couple of persons of interest, one of whom I'm told may now be in custody.'
He said had a meeting with Jean Kennedy Smith, then US ambassador to Ireland, who assured him the Department of State would do everything it could to assist but said this had no impact on the level of co-operation provided by An Garda Síochána.
Mr Griffith said the disappearance of their daughter took a very considerable toll on her parents, John, now deceased, and Nancy.
'Obviously there was a lot of stress that came out of this and the McCarricks got divorced.'
He said he would like to know what prompted an arrest in the case after so long but he remains hopeful the case will be resolved for the family.
An Garda Síochána said they did not respond on individual cases but have a policy of appointing family liaison officers in major cases.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
‘We we're full of hope': Aunt of Annie McCarrick says family disappointed after murder suspect released
Annie McCarrick's mother Nancy is used to waiting. She has been waiting for 32 years to find out where her only daughter's remains may be buried. When she received a 3am phone call on Thursday from the Garda team investigating her daughter's murder, it brought a new level of emotional intensity to the family's wait for answers. A man who knew Annie McCarrick had been arrested on suspicion of her murder . Fortunately, Nancy McCarrick's younger sister, Maureen Covell, was staying with her when the gardaí called. She has supported Ms McCarrick since 1993. READ MORE Annie McCarrick was nine years younger than Ms Covell, who is now 67. Both women were like best friends and spent lots of time together. From early on Thursday morning until the suspect was released without charge on Friday afternoon, an extended Irish-American family living in the Long Island area of New York had their fingers crossed. After all, this was the first arrest in a case whose narrative has changed completely since a new team of Garda investigators were appointed. 'Naturally, we were full of hope,' said Ms Covell. 'At last, it seemed there would be answers. There have been so many attempts over the decades to solve this case but there had never been any conclusive or definitive answers.' It was a case of disappointment once again for the family on Friday, as the man was released without charge . A search and excavation at a house in Clondalkin, Dublin, which was linked to him, is ongoing. Speaking to The Irish Times from her home in Long Island, Ms Covell said: 'All of us are quite disappointed as we were hopeful that some results would come of this arrest and interrogation. It is important to say that we haven't given up all hope as it seems the gardaí are getting close. We cautiously look forward to hearing if there are any findings with regards to the excavation. 'We appreciate the continued efforts of the gardaí as they follow some very recent leads.' She added that the family continues to hope for 'closure and answers along with a possible conviction to this 32-year- old nightmare'. Ms Covell said the family had been left deeply frustrated by elements of the original Garda team's approach to the investigation. 'Unlike my dear sister, who has remained so graceful and stoic throughout this ordeal, I still find it very frustrating that all the faxes our family and friends sent to the gardaí after Annie's disappearance about significant issues in her personal life were ignored at the time,' she said.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Search for remains of Annie McCarrick set to continue after main suspect released without charge
The search for the remains of Annie McCarrick at a house in Dublin was due to continue through the weekend after the man questioned on suspicion of her murder was released from Garda custody without charge on Friday afternoon. The businessman, aged in his 60s, who knew Ms McCarrick well, was interviewed for a total of 24 hours in the period since his arrest on Thursday morning when his home in the east of the country was also searched. He denies any wrongdoing in relation to the disappearance of New Yorker Ms McCarrick (26) from Sandymount, South Dublin, in March, 1993, or her murder. Annie McCarrick, who went missing in 1993. Photograph: An Garda Siochana/PA Wire 'The male aged in his 60s who was arrested on the morning of 12th June, 2025, and detained under the provisions of Section 4 of the Criminal Justice Act 1984 has been released without charge,' the Garda confirmed in a statement. READ MORE On being released from Irishtown Garda station at about 3pm he was met by waiting photographers and TV camera crews before being driven away. Gardaí on Friday afternoon brought a cadaver dog into the search at the house in Clondalkin in the event the dog may respond when checking the rear of the property where excavation had taken place. The Garda search team used diggers, a consaw and a Kango hammer to excavate in an area that includes some built structures. Gardaí remove a skip at a house in Clondalkin, west Dublin. Photograph: Colin Keegan/Collins Dublin Gardaí bring a cadaver dog into a house being searched in connection with the murder of Annie McCarrick. Photograph: Colin Keegan/Collins Dublin Before the search began on Thursday morning, skips with construction waste were seen outside the house as renovation work was under way. However, The Irish Times has established that nothing connected to Ms McCarrick was found during the recent work at the house to prompt the Garda excavation. Instead, the search and excavation, and the arrest of the main suspect, were pre-planned on the part of the Garda investigation team. The house was being searched because the suspect was linked to it. . The current owners of the property, who bought it in 2011, have no connection to the murdered woman or the Garda investigation. The suspect was arrested by detectives from the Garda's Dublin south-central division's serious crime unit based at Irishtown Garda station. He knew Ms McCarrick and was at one time very close to her. [ Annie McCarrick: Cold case murder detectives must overcome poor investigations of 1990s Opens in new window ] He was flagged to gardaí as a possible suspect in the case in the immediate aftermath of the New Yorker's disappearance. Friends of Ms McCarrick were concerned about the man as she had told them she felt pressured and harassed by him and that he had struck her on one occasion. Ms McCarrick's friends outlined those concerns in fax messages to the Garda investigation team. They have always believed the information they supplied was not properly handled and was not factored into the initial inquiry in any meaningful way. However, in recent years – particularly since the case was upgraded from a missing persons inquiry to a murder investigation two years ago – the man arrested and since released became the key suspect. Gardaí are also very interested in a close associate of his and travelled abroad earlier this year to interview him. Detectives believe the two men were together on the weekend Ms McCarrick vanished. Both men were interviewed in 1993 and have been spoken to several times in the years since then. In March 1993, Ms McCarrick, from Long Island, New York, was living in rented accommodation at St Cathryn's Court, Sandymount, with two friends. They last spoke to her at the property on the morning of Friday, March 26th. Amid mounting concerns for her safety, Ms McCarrick was reported missing to gardaí that Sunday, more than 48 hours after her last confirmed sighting.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
American man questioned in Michael Gaine murder inquiry says he made Garda ombudsman complaint
The American questioned and arrested in the investigation into the murder of Kerry farmer Michael Gaine has confirmed that he complained to Fiosrú, the Office of the Police Ombudsman, about his treatment by gardaí. In an extensive interview with The Irish Times, Mr Kelley (53) refused to be drawn on the exact nature of the complaint he lodged against the Garda team investigating the murder of the Kenmare man. Speaking in Tralee , where he is now living, Mr Kelley said the matter was confidential. However, he said the complaint did not relate to his arrest on May 18th but to a previous interaction with gardaí. Mr Kelley, who helped Mr Gaine with work on his farm, made a voluntary witness statement to gardaí as part of their missing person's investigation after Mr Gaine (56) was reported missing on March 21st by his wife, Janice when he failed to return to their home at Carhoomengar East, Kenmare, on March 20th. READ MORE 'I made the complaint in late March, so, yes, it was before I was arrested and, yes, it related to the gardaí bringing me to Sneem Garda station to make a voluntary witness statement,' said Mr Kelley. He has yet to receive a reply from Fiosrú, he said. In response to queries, Fiosrú said it 'does not confirm or deny the existence of complaints made by or against individuals. This is to protect the investigative process, and the rights, both of complainants, and those complained against.' The funeral of murdered Co Kerry farmer Michael Gaine at Holy Cross Church, Kenmare, on June 7th. Photograph: Niall Carson/PA Gardaí upgraded their investigation into Mr Gaine's disappearance to a murder inquiry on April 29th. On May 16th, a family member found body parts, later identified as belonging to Mr Gaine, while spreading slurry at Mr Gaine's farm at Carrig East, just off the Ring of Kerry near Moll's Gap. Mr Kelley confirmed last month to The Irish Daily Mirror – and later to The Irish Times – that he had been arrested by gardaí and questioned about Mr Gaine's murder, but he denied any involvement in the killing which shocked people in Kenmare where Mr Gaine was a well-liked member of the community. [ Michael Gaine funeral hears of 'idyllic' community struck by 'something terrible' Opens in new window ] Mr Kelley has said he may be being framed by 'people who are involved in organised crime'. Mr Kelley had been living alone, rent free, for more than two years at the old Gaine family farmhouse at Carrig East in return for carrying out farm work for Mr Gaine, who kept around 40 cows and 500 sheep at his 400-hectare (1,000-acre) hillside landholding. Gardaí search the farm of Michael Gaine (56) near Kenmare. Photograph: Domnick Walsh Approached this week by The Irish Times, Mr Kelley declined to answer questions about the murder investigation, but he agreed to talk about his own life to date and how he came to Ireland from the United States, where he grew up. A native of Maine in the northeastern US, Mr Kelley said he came to Ireland seeking political asylum, alleging that he had been threatened by the Ku Klux Klan – the racist group that originated in the southern states of the US at the end of the American Civil War – in Maine because he was a Catholic and the Ku Klux Klan was anti-Catholic. [ Who is Michael Kelley, the man questioned over the murder of Michael Gaine? Opens in new window ] He alleged they had poisoned and killed his dog, Lyra, a German Shepherd, and that they had shot at him while he was in the woods near his home outside Swanville in Waldo County. Fearing for his life, he said, he made the decision to come to Ireland and seek asylum. 'I arrived in Ireland in 2017, into Dublin Airport and asked for asylum when I came up to immigration desk,' said Mr Kelley. He said he was subsequently put in contact with an immigration lawyer who in turn consulted a barrister who was an expert in this area. 'The barrister told me that I stood no chance of getting asylum, so I decided then to go underground here in Ireland,' said Mr Kelley. Michael Gaine farmed 400 hectares near Kenmare where he was a well-liked member of the community. Photograph: He also revealed new details about his US military service. Mr Kelley said he was awarded top grades when he graduated from Belfast High School in Waldo County, Maine, and applied to join the US Rangers, given his interest in strategy and war games as a teenager. He said he was accepted into US Rangers due to his high grades and passing the physical examination. He entered the Rangers training camp at Fort Benning in Georgia where he completed courses at the infantry and airborne schools. However, he left the Rangers training centre after he claimed he was asked to sign a document that gave the Rangers indemnity to deploy him on clandestine operations such as covert assassinations. I just put down my weapon and I took off my uniform and told them I was a conscientious objector — Michael Kelley He said he then joined a regular US army unit in around 1990 and was transferred to Germany and the US Air Defence Artillery Unit at Ansbach, some 60 kms from Nuremberg, where he carried out sentry duties on US patriot missiles. 'The good thing about joining the military was that it gave me the opportunity to see Europe because I hadn't been to Europe before,' he said. 'I joined because I wanted to fight against totalitarianism and Stalinism in the USSR and East Germany.' He said he later decided to become a conscientious objector when he learned of the US attack on Iraqi troops retreating from Kuwait City on what became known as the 'Highway of Death' in the spring of 1991 when US Marine, US Air Force and US Navy aircraft bombed the convoy. 'These guys had been given a promise of safe passage out of Kuwait back to Iraqi, they had their tanks loaded up on low loaders and do you know what happened? US aeroplanes attacked them with cluster bombs and hundreds of Iraqis were just incinerated,' said Mr Kelley. 'I just put down my weapon and I took off my uniform and told them I was a conscientious objector.' He said he remained in the US Army for several months afterwards and was assigned to desk duties before he left the military and returned to civilian life. A US Army spokesman said the army had no record of Mr Kelley serving with it but noted that soldiers' records are automatically moved to the National Archives and Records Administration when they have left the army for more than 15 years. This agency has been contacted by The Irish Times for details of his military service. [ Garda starts reviews of Tina Satchwell and Michael Gaine murder inquiries Opens in new window ] During the interview, Mr Kelley spoke about his upbringing in Maine with his mother, Janice Kelley, who had attended Martin Luther King's Jobs and Freedom March to Washington in 1963 when he made his famous 'I have a dream' speech. Mr Kelley, a musician who busks regularly on the streets of Tralee, also spoke about how his mother had lived in the East Village in New York in the early 1960s and once played guitar with Joan Baez. He also saw Bob Dylan and other prominent figures of the US folk boom of the time in the coffee shops of Greenwich Village, he said. Michael Kelley busking on the street in Tralee, Co Kerry. Photograph: Domnick Walsh Among the many figures from the counterculture that his mother knew was Walter Bowart, editor of the East Village Other, a radical underground newspaper. In the interview, Mr Kelley spoke in detail about the writing of Bowart on mind control programmes developed by the Central Intelligence Agency, the US spy agency, and who alleged that it was the CIA that developed the drug LSD and introduced it in the counterculture movement as a means of trying to control people. On his eight years in Ireland, Mr Kelley said that when he could not secure asylum, he moved to Kerry and began living in the Killarney National Park where he built himself a hut. They found my camp and told me I had to leave, that I couldn't live in the national park – they were out shooting deer, and they had guns – so I wasn't going to argue with them — Michael Kelley 'I made it from logs and tarpaulin – it was deep in the woods, the other side of the lake and I lived there. I used to go into Killarney every three or four days in the middle of the night to search in dumpsters. You get a lot of food thrown way in a tourist town like Killarney,' he said. Mr Kelley said he was always conscious of his Irish heritage – 'we were an Irish-American family', he said. He taught himself the tin whistle and later the flute, and began playing Irish airs. He busked around Killarney to make money to support himself. . 'I also started doing wood carvings at my camp, from fallen trees; I used to carve a lot from rhododendron,' he said, referring to the woody plant that grows extensively in the Killarney park. 'It's got a good grain for carving, so I used to sell those wood carvings around town to supplement what I made from busking.' Michael Kelley and his mother Janice in a 2018 photograph posted on Facebook While he couldn't give an exact timeline for how long he lived in the park, Mr Kelley said his time there came to an abrupt end when rangers from the National Parks and Wildlife Service happened upon his camp. 'They found my camp and told me I had to leave, that I couldn't live in the national park – they were out shooting deer, and they had guns – so I wasn't going to argue with them,' he said. A National Parks and Wildlife Service source confirmed that park rangers came across Mr Kelley at his camp in the park some years ago and asked him to leave the area, as camping was prohibited in the park, and that he subsequently left. After an hour-long interview, Mr Kelley politely told The Irish Times he had to leave, abruptly ended the conversation and departed, disappearing into the Tralee streets.
